Regulation of the Minister of Forestry of the Republic of Indonesia No. P.4/Menhut-II/2011 on forest reclamation guidelines

FOREST RECLAMATION GUIDELINES (The Regulation of The Minister of Forestry of Republic of Indonesia Number P. 4/Menhut-II/20 11, 14 January 201 J) 40 DY THE GRACE OF ONE AND ALMIGHTY GOD THE MINISTER OF FORESTRY OF THE REPUBLIC OF INDONESIA, Considering: That to implement the law of Article 51 num ber 6 Government Regulation Number /6 Year Z008 on Forest Rehabilitation and Reclamation, it is neces sary to stipulate Regulation of the Minister of Forestry on Forest Reclamation Guidelines. In view of: 1. Law Number 5 Year 1990 (BN No. 5000 page 1B-1 2B) on Natural Resou rces and Their Ecosys tem (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Year 1990 Number 49, Supplementary State Ga zette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 3419); 2. Law Number 41 Year 1999 (BN No. 7140 page 31 B-32B) on Forestry (State Gazette of The Re public of Indonesia Year 1999 Number 167, Sup plernantarv State Gazette of the Republic of In donesia Number 3888), which has been changed with the Law Number 19 Year 2004 on the En actment of Government Regulation in Lieu of Law Number 1 Year 2004 on the Amendment of Law Number 41 Year 1999 on Forestry to become Law; 3. l.aw Numher 37 Year 7004 nn RegionClI Govern ment (State Gazette of The Republic of Indo nesia Year 2004 Number 125, Supplementrlry State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Num ber 4437), which has bcen changed for several times, the last one with the Law Number 12 Year 2008 (Slate Gazert e of the Republic of Indonesia Year 2008 Number 59, Supplementary State Ga zette of the RepUblic of Indonesia Number 4844); 4. Law Number 26 Year 2007 (BN No. 7556 page 138-228 and so on) on ~patlal Order (State Ga zette of the Republic of Indonesia Year 2007 Number 68, Supplementary State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 4725); 5. Law Number 4 Year 2009 (BN No. 7865 page 9B 10B) on Mineral and Coal Mining (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Year 2009 Number 4, Supplementary State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 4959); 6. Law Number 32 Year 2009 on Environment Pro tection and Management (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Year 2009 Number 140, Supplementary State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 5059); 7. Government Regulation Number 27 Year 1999 (BN No. 6436 page 1B-9B) on Analysis on Envi ronmental Impact (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Year 1999 Number 132, Supple mentary State Gazette of the Republic of Indone sia Number 3174); 8. Government Regulation Number 6 Year 2007 GOVERNMENT REGULATIONS (BN No. 7487 11<Jge 12B-16B and so on) on For est Arrangement and Forest Management Plan Organization as well as Forest Utilization (State Gazette of The Republic of Indonesia Year 2007 Number 22, Supplementary State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 46961, which has becn changed with the Law Number 3 Year 2008 (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Year 2008 Number 1G, Supplementary State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 4814); 9. Governmem Regulation Number 38 Year 2007 (BN No. 7576 page 18-6Bl on Division of Gov ernmental Arratrs among Government, Province Government and District/City Government (State Gazette of the Hepubho ot tndonesia Year 2007 Number 82, Supplementary State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 4737); 10. Government Regulation Number 2 Year 2008 (BN No. 7629 page 11 B-15B and so on) on Tar iff Type Upon Non-Tax Revenue Comes From Forest Area Utilization For Development Interest of Non-Forestry Activities Occurred in Ministry of Forestry(State Gazette of the Republic of In donesia Year 2008 Number 15, Supplementary State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Num ber 4813); 11. Government Regulation Number 26 Year 2008 on Spatial Planning of National Region (RTRWN) (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Year 2008 Number 48, Supplementary State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 4833); 12. Government Regulation Number 76 Year 2008 (BN No. 7781 page 18B-22B) on Forest Heha hilitation arid Rer:lrlmrltion (Sta ta G<J7ette of the Republic of Indonesia Year 2008 Number 201, Supplementary State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 4947); 13. Law Number 24 Year 2010 on Forest I\rea Utili zation (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Year 2010 Number 201, Supplementary State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 5112); 14. Presidential Regulation Number 5 Year 2006 on National Energy Policy; 15. Presidential Decree Number 41 Year 2004 on Li censing or Agreement on Mining Sector Available in Forest Area; 16. Presidential Instruction Number 1 Year 1976 on Synchronization on the Implementation of Duties in Agrarian Sector with Forestry, Mining, Trans migration, and Public Work; 17. Regulation of the Minister of Forestry Number PA3/Menhut-II/2008 on Guidelines for Forestry Area Borrow-Use; 18. Regulation of the Minister of Forestry Number PAO/ Menhut-ll/Zu lOon Organization and Management of Ministry of Forestry (State Gazette of the Repub lic of Indonesia Year 2010 Number 405); 19. Regulation of Minister of Energy and Mineral Re sources Number 18 Year 2008 on Mine Reclama tion and Closure; DECIDED: To stipulate: REGULATION OF THE MINISTER OF FORESTRY ON FOREST RECLAMATION GUIDELINES. 41 GOVERNMENT REGULATIONS 42 CHAPTER I GENERAL First Part Definition Article 1 In this Regulation there are definitions as fol lows: 1. Acid-forming material is material that can create acid when reacted with ai r. 2. Waste rock is rockery unearthed in mining pro cess, but not processed due to the absence or lack of wanted minerals. 3. Cover crop is dense plant grew especially to pro tect and to repair soil between periods of staple crops or between trees and creepers. 4. Holding Dam is a permeable small dam with rocks in concertina wire cage construction, twigs net ting, or bamboo/wood made at ravine's line with 4 meters maximum height. 5. Control Dam is a non-permeable small dam that can holds water with land fill construction with waterproof layer or concrete/arc type for erosion control and surface runoff made at a stream/riv erine with 8 meters maximum height. 6. Numeric data is data in the form of number or number system. 7. Spatial data is data with geo-reference in which many attribute data put in spatial units. 8. Drop structure is a structure built at every certain length at Water Disposal Line (WDL) depends on land inclination, made of stone, wood/bamboo. 9. Erosion is a process of exfoliation or transfer of soil or stone particles due to kinetic energy of water, snow, wind. 10. Environmental damage is direct or indirect change towards physical nature and/or biological of environment that exceeds standard criteria of environmental damage. 11. Measurable means can be measured, in quantity as well as in quality. 12. Reportable means the result that can be reported or informed. 13. Verifiable means the fact that can be proved. 14. Minister is the minister appointed for duties and liabilities in forestry field. 15. Technical Minister is the minister appointed for rluties and liahilitias in energy and mineral re sources field. 16. Mining is a part of mini no business ctr.tivities. to produce mineral, coal, and lor accessory miner al s , 17. Environmental pollution is living things, sub stance, energy, und/o r other components that enter or entered the environment by human ac tivities that exceeds decided environmental qual ity standard. 18. Mining is partly of or whole or activrne s staqe s for research, management, and exertion of min erai or coal concerning general research, exploi tation, feasibility study, construction, mining, processing and purification. transportation and selling as well as post-mining activities. 19, Environmental damage is action that causes di rect or indirect change towards physical nature and/or biological of environment to exceed stan dard criteria of environmental damage. 20. Forest and Land Rehabilitation is effort to recov GOVERNMENT REGULATIONS er, to maintain, and to increase functions of for est and land so that carrying capacity, productiv ity, and roles in keeping life support system to last. 21. Land rehabilitation and soil conservation, next abridged as LRSC is effort to repair/recover, to increase. and to keep land condition to function at optimum as production element, water man aqernent control media. as well as element of en vironmental protection. 22. Forest reclamation is effort to reJlCiir or to rer-over damaged land and vegetation to function at opti mum accordingly to its allocation. 23. Revegatation is effort to repair and to recover damaged vegetation through planting and main tenance activities on the land former used for for est area utilization. 24. Baseline is early/basic situation or condition at location plan acreage for activities of forest area utilization. 25. Closure condition is the condition alter the activi ties of forest area utilization that caused change to baseline. 26. Water Disposal Line, next abridged as WDL, is water line made perpendicular contour direction with specific measure in accordance to rainfall condition, inclination, and hydraulic conductivity/ type of soil, strengthen with soddi ng. 27. Sedimentation is amount of soil materials in form of mud content in water by river water flow com ing from erosion process at headstream, settled at some area at downstream in which settlement speed of suspension material grains has become less than the travel speed. 28. Tailing is soft grained compact substance as waste of processing result of mineral dressing extraction that contains minerals without eco nomic value. 29. Surface mining is activities on mining and exca vation of mining material done with direct con tact to open air. Second Part Principles, Purposes, and Objectives Article 2 Basic principle of reclamation activities concerns: a. a holistic mining activities; and b. done as early as possible without waiting for whole mining process to finish. Article 3 (1) Forest reclamation guidelines is meant to provide reference for the performers in doing forest rec lcrnation activities at the land former used as for est area utilization. (2) rarest reclamation guidelines has objectives for the ca rrying out of forest reclamation to be done ill accordance tu yeflt:ldl pat terrrs , 5tandard5 and criteria in orde r to recove r the forest to re-tune tion at optimum accordingly to its allocation. I hird Part Scope Article 4 The scope of Forest Reclamation Guidelines includes: 43 GOVERNMENT REGULATIONS a. location inventory; b. decision on location; c. planning; d. execution; e. institution; 1. technical monitoring and assistance, g. reporting mechanism of forest reclamation imple mentation; and h. sanctinn CHAPTf:::R II LOCATION INVENTORY Article 5 (1) Location inventory as meant in Article 4 point a is activity of do to ond information collection on condition of whole forest area to get disturbed as effect of forest area utiJizati on. (2) Data and information as meant at paragraph (1) cunsists of prilllary and secondar v-date that con earns: a. Physical Condition of Borrow-Use Acreage; and b. Economic Social condition. (3) Physical Condition of Borrow-Use Acreage as meant at paraqraph Z point d involves: a. forest area function; b. land closure; c. flora and fauna; d. types of land; e. solum thickness; 1. topography; g. climate; h. water management; i. erosion or sedimentation; j. location altitude; and k. types of vegetation. (4) Economic social condition as meant at paragraph (21 point b involves: a. demography; b. income level; c. livelihood; d. education: e. community institution; f l!'Inn nwnf'Tshir: Clnrl g. community's culture; (5) Area scope for economic social data as meant paragraph (1) includes surrounding villages of the m'ming area influenced intentionally/unintention ally by mining activities. Article 6 (1) Based on location inventory result- as meant in Article 5, obtained: a. numeric data and spatial data of whole rarest area to get disturbed; and b. numenc data and spatial data of whole forest area disturbed. (:!l Numeric data and spatial data of area to get dis turbed as meant at paragraph (1) point a are used as baseline data for forest area utilization. (3) Numeric data and spatial data of whole forest area disturbed are used as base to decide on lo cation. (4) Numeric data and spatial data as meant at para graph (1) is main data originated from Feasibil ity Study documents, AEI, Environmental Man 44 aqernent Effort (UKLl, Environmental Monitoring Effort (UPLj, plan on forest area utilization, and Mine Closure Plan. CHAPTER 111 DECISION ON LOCATION Artir.lp. 7 (1) Location is decided based on location inventory result as meant in Article 6; (2) Decision on location is activities of selecting and pointing forest o re a disturbed as effect of forest area utilization ready to get reclamation. Article 8 Decision on location as meant in Article 7 is carried out by doing analysis and evaluation on spatial and numeric data of disturbed rurest ar ee , Article 9 (1) Reclamation wide and location are decided based on the result of analysis and evaluation on spatial and numeric data as meant in Article 8. (2) Result of analysis as meant at paragraph (1) is mapped on reclamation plan map using the small est scale 1 :25.000 as material for 5 (five) year or annual reclamation plan. CHAPTER IV PLANNING First Part General Article 10 11) Reclamation planning is done to produce forest reclamation plan that consist of: a. 5 (five) year plan; and b. annual plan. (2) In case the mine lasts less than 5 (five) years, reclamation plan is arranged accordingly to the life of mine. Second Part Five-Year Reclamation Plan Article 11 (1) Five year raclamatinn ricin is arranged by the holder of license for forest area borrow-use based on the result of location inventory and decision on location. (2) Five-Yeor Rcclomotion Plan consists as follows: a. forest area condition, pre- and post-activities; b. forest area opening plan; c. forest reclamation program; d. rectarnauon tedlllit;i:Il !-,Idll (T-O); e. implementation time frame; f. cost plan; and g. Location map and reclamation activities plan map. Article 12 (1) In case the mine lasts less than 5 (five) years, 5 (five) year plan is arranged accordingly to the life of mine; (2) Plan contents adjusted to life of mine refers to 5 (five) year plan. Article 13 (1) Forest area condition pre- and post-activities as 45 GOVERNMENT REGULATIONS 46 meant in Article 11 paragraph 12} point a, consists information on quantitative and qualitative con dition of baseline and closure. (2) Qualitative and quantitative condition as meant at paragraph (1) concerns stand density, types of plant, topography, inclination, land closure, and flora & fauna. Article 14 Forest area opening plan as meant in Article 11 paragraph (2) point b. consists information on wirlp. anrl locat inn of fmp.st arp.a utilization tn hp. p.x ecuted. Article 15 (1) Forest reclamation program as meant In Article 11 paragraph (2) point c consists of: a , forest orca preparation; b. land form arrangement/land management; c. erosion and sedimentation control, d. management of top soil layer; e. reveqe rariun: and f. effort for security; (2) Forest area preparation as meant at paragraph 11} includes activities of: a. relocation or clearance ot all instruments and infrastructure that no longer in use; b. disposal of toxic/hazardous waste/garbage; c. scrap disposal or burial; and d. opening management and installation of pro hibition, signs, or closing entrance to mine location. Article 16 Implementation time frame as meant in Ar ticle 11 paragraph (2) point e concerns time frame for implementation and completion of forest reclamation activities. Article 17 (1) Cost plan as meant in Article 11 paragraph (2) point f concerns whole cost, direct or indirect cost paid in the implementation of forest recla mation activities. (2) Direct cost consists of: a foras t l'lrp.a prp.paratinn cost: b. land form arrangement/land management cost; c. erosion and sedimentation control cost; d. management of top soil layer cost; e. revegetation cost; and f. maintenerice and security cost; (3) Indirect cost consists of mobilization and demo b ilizatior i cost, rcclame tion plan c ost. reclarna tion administration cost, and monitoring cost. Article 18 Location map and torest reclamation activities plan as meant in Article 11 paragraph (2) point g is made using smallest scale 1:25.000. Third Part Annual Reclamation Plan Arrangement Article 19 (1) Five yea r plan as meant in Article 11 is described further in annual plan. GOVERNMENT REGULATIONS (2) Annual plan consists: a. forest reclamation site/location; b. Tvpce of reclamation activities include: 1. Land management; 2. Ex-mine hole refilling; a) Land surface arrangement; and b) Top su!l uissemination/rnanagement, 3. Erosion and sedimentation control; a) Erection of soil conservation buildlnq (check dam, holding dam, ravine control, drop structure, water disposal line, etc.) b) Planting of cover crops to lessen run off and to increase infiltration. 4. Revegatation (planting acreage width, number of plant per hectare and plant type composition) ; c. Width/volume of every type of reclamation ac tivities; d. Schedule for reclamation activities implementa tion; e. cost needed for every reclamation activity; f. Annual Reclamation Plan Map smallest scale 1: 10.000, consists: 1. width of borrow-use are/ width of total con cession; 2. width plan for mine opening; 3. width plan of reclamation/revegetation acre age. Article 20 (1) From annual reclamation plan as meant in Article 19 for every location there is technical design arranged to be used as detail reference on site location. (2) Site location is site to be used for reclamation activities by applying reclamation technique ac cordingly to technical design. Article 21 (1) Technical design as meant in Article 20 para graph (1) is a detail design of every activity to be done in reclamation act lvities , whe ther il is land management design, plan design, or soil conser vation building design. (2l Technical design as meant at paragraph (1) con SiStS: a. forest reclamation site/location; b. Types of reclamation activities; c. Width or volume of every type of reclamation activities; d. Planting pattern (planting stages, planting range, types of plants, etc.); e. Needs for materials and tools; f. Needs for worker; g. Needs for cost; h. Time frame; I. Planting layout; and j. Design picture of soil conservation building. Article 22 (1) Technical Design is arranged based on analysis result: a. biophysical condition; and b. economic social condition. (2) Biophysical condition as meant at paragraph (1) point a includes: 47 48 a. topojjraphv or IClnrl form; b. climate; c. hydrology; d. soil fertility; e. condition of early vegetation; and f. native vegetation. (3) Economic social condition as meant at paragraph (1) point h involves: a. Demography; b. facility and infrastructure; and c. accessibility. Article 23 (1} Biophysical condition as meant in Article 22 para graph (2) as first step to decide planting activities stages; (2) On certain location, planting activities must be i preceded by pre-condition by planting pioneer plants or fast growing species before enrichment done by planting permanent vegetation types that is local plant type with long cycle. (3} For other locations, can be done direct planting with long cycle local plant types; (4} Selected plant types is focused on native plant planting that local plant types suitable to local soil and climate condition. Article 24 (1} Selected plant types/species also depend on the land utilization/forest function in the future. (2) Fur fJluteGliufl forest, plant types must meet the requirements as follows: a. possesses long cycle; b. deep-rooted; c. low evapotranspiration; d. produce wood, latex, skin, or fruit; and e. heterogeneous. (3) For production forest, plant types must meet the requirements as follows: a. fast growth; b. high commercial value; c. its silviculture has been mastered; d. easy to get quality seed; and e. adjusted to market's needs/demand. Article 25 . to be continued (A) FOREST RECLAMATION GUIDELINES (The Regulation of The Minister of Forestry of Republic of Indonesia Number P. 4/Menhut-II/2011, 14 January 2011) [Continued from Business News No. 8109 page 40-48J 36 Article 25 Besides referring to Article 24, in selecting species it is necessary to pay attention to the follow ing: a. Identification of classification and growth of plant species grow naturally at raclarnation loca tion. h. Soil and drainage condition in which different 10 cal species can adapt to ex-mine location. c. Plant type that can produce seeds and has ability to multiply. d. Plant type with economic value/commercial· can be used by considering land allocation accord ingly to Gerie rel Spa.tia.l Planning (G3PI or Forest Function Management. e. Consideration on habitat requirements, the pos sibility of wild animal to return to that area is an important element of post mining land use. f. Consideration on cutting plant (trubus) because this plan most nf the time is goor! plant groLlr and will repair soil fertility. Fourth Part Plan Ratification Article 26 (, l Arranged 5 (five) year and annual forest reel arna tion plan are analyzed by Minister of Te chriicel , Governor, or Regent/Major accordingly to their authul it\{ O\{ invulvi\\~ Minister. GOVERNMENT RfGULATION<; a. information on policy, plan, and program for space layout existing and/or to be provided and/ or has been stipulated; b. information of space layout as stipulated; c. information on direction on space utilization con taining five year medium-term main program; and d. information on direction on space utilization con taining direction/provision in regulation of zoning, direction, provision for permits, incentive nd dis incentive and direction on penalty Article 25 (1) Development of information system and com munication of national space layout shalt be the responsibility of the minister/management of government or non-government institution which duty relates to space layout according to their respective authoirty. (2) Development of information system and commu nication on space layout in province shall be re sponsibility of the Governor. (3) Development of information system and commu nication on space layout shall be responsibility of the Regency/Mayor. (4l The Minister/management of government FInn non-government institution which duty relates to SpRCA laynut may provide facilities for develop ment of information system and communication system in the region. l51 Development of information system and com munication referred to in paragraph (2) and para graph l3l shall be adjusted to the objective condi tion in the respective region. CHAPTER V FINANCE Article 26 Alia costs required in the context of imple menting obligations of the Government and regional government based on this Government Regulation shall be charged to the State Revenue and Expendi ture Budget, Regional Revenue and Expenditure Bud get and other lawful source in accordance with the provision in the statutory reg ulation. CHAPTER VI TRANSITIONAL PROVISION Article 27 By the time this Government Regulation takes effect, all implementing regulation governing the ria ture and procedure on society's role in space layout existing and survives to the extent it does not contra vene or not replaced yet based on this Government Regulation. CHAPTER VII CLOSING PROVISION Article 28 By the time this Government Regulation comes to force, Government Regulation Number 69 Year 1996 (BN No. 59'19 pages 9B-1 7Bl concerning implementation of Rights and Obligations, as well as tho Naturc Procedure of Society':> role in Space Lay out (Statute BookOf the Republic of Indonesia Year 1996 Number 104, Suppleruer u LO S LCllU le Book of the Republic of Indonesia Number 3660) is revoked and declared nul\ and void. 35 (2) In certain case, the assessment of reclamation plan can involve the Minister who works in the field of environmental management. Article 27 11l The assessment of 5 (five) year and annual forest reclamation plan is done by the Director General of Management Guidance for River Flow Area and Social Forestry on behalf of Minister. (2) In case assessment is stCltP.rl fLllfilling rertuire ments, Director General Of Management Guid ance for RFA and Social Forestry on the behalf of Minister gives recommendation. Article 28 (1) Next, assessed and recommended 5 (five) year forest reclamation and annual plan are ratified by Minister of Technical, Governor, or Regent/Major accordingly to their authority. (2) In case the mine lasts less than 5 (five) years, reclamation plan is arranged accordingly to the life of mine, next the process of arrangement, recommendation, and ratification refers to b (five) years forest reclamation plan. CHAPTER V IMPLEMENTATiON First Part General Article 29 (1) Reclamation activities are started accordingly to agreed plan and must be finished on decided time. (2) In case of reclamation activities implementation, license holder of forest area utilization is holding accountability until end/closure condition accord ingly to ratified plan. Article 30 (1) Implementation of reclamation includes these fol lowinq types of activities: a. civil technique; and b. vegetation technique. (2) Civil technique activities as meant at paragraph (1) point a , involves: a. ex-mine hole refilling; b. land form arrangement; c. top soil management; d. terrace making; e. water disposal line lWDL); f. ravine control buildings; g. check dam making; and/or II. was te oi I catchinq (3) Activities as meant at paragraph (2) are adjusted to local condition. (4) Vegetation technique activities as meant at para graph (1) POint b involves selection of: a. planting pattern, b. planting stages {pre-condition and perma nent vegetation planting); c. planting system (monoculture, multiple crop ping); d. types of plant are adjusted to local condition; and e. cover crop. 37 (jOY~NMENT REGULATIONS 38 Article 31 Implementation of reclamation includes activ ity stages as follows: a. Land management; b. Erosion and sedimentation control. c. Revegetation (re-planting); and d. . Maintenance. Second Part Land management Article 32 Land management as meant In Article 31 point a consists of: a. Ex-mine hole refilling; b. Land form arrangement; and c. Top soil management; Paragraph 1 Ex-mine hole refilling Article 33 (1) Ex-mine hole refilling as meant in Article 32 point a, in open mining activities, the ex-mine hole must be closed or adjusted to its AEI. (Ll The activities for mine hole closure are done pro gressively accordingly to mining implementation progress. Paragraph 2 Land form arrangement Article 34 (1) Land form arrangement as meant in Article 32 point b is adjusted to condition of topography, type of soil, and local climate. (2) Activities in land form arrangement includes: a. Slope form arrangement; b. Water line arrangement; and c. Low Grade ArrangementlPlacement. Article 35 (1) Slope form arrangement as meant in Article 34 paragraph (2) point a is meant to reduce the run off, erosion, and sedimentation as well as landslide. (2) Slope form as meant at paragraph (1) is not too high or steep and formed with terraces, height and inclination of the slope depend on texture and soil structure nature as well as rain fall. (3) Types of treatment for terrace making and soil conservation activities in slope form arrangement are as stated on attachment 1 . Article 36 (ll Water line arrangement as meant in Article 34 paragraph {21 point b is meant to manage water to flow to specific places and can reduce land damage. (2) Amount and density as well as form of water line depend on land form/topog raphy, types of soil, rain fall, and wide of acreage for reclamation. Article 37 (1) Low grade arrangement/placement In the form of mining material with low economic value as meant in Article 34 paragraph (2) point c is meant for the mining rna ter ial not Lu yeL erosion/ lost if buried in long time because it is not yet utilized. (2) Arrangement In the form of low grade pile is as stated on attachment 2. Paragraph 3 Top soil management Article 38 (1) Top soil management as meant in Article 32 point c is meant to reg ulate and to separate top soil trom other soil layers. (2) Top soil as meant at paragraph (1) is a growth medium for plant and one of the deciding factors for plant growth success of reclamation activi ties. Article 39 (1) Top soil management must consider: a. Soil profile observation and to identify the <:nil Irlyf'rs 1.If' to mining material deposit. b. Soil stripping is based on soil layers and placed on suitable place accordingly to the layer level and top soil pile is not more than 2 meters. c. Land formation is according to origin soil lay er structure, top soil is placed On the very top with at least 0.15 meter thickness. d. Thickriess of top soil pile aL soil that cur rtuins toxic is suggested thicker than the non-toxic one or applied with special treatment by do ing isolation and separate it. e. Soil stripping should not be done in wet con dition to avoid condensation and damage on soil structure. (2) In case top soil layer is thin, limited, or a little, it is necessary to consider: a. Decision on priority area that is highly sensi tive area towards erosion needs to get soil conservation handling treatment and plant ing. b. Top soil placement is on planting line or with potting system. c. The mixing of top soil with other soil that is if amount of top soil is very limited/very thin can be mixed with sub soil, things to avoid in top soil utilization are: 1) contains much of sand (> 70% of sand or gravel); 2) contains much of clay [> 60% of clay); 3) has pH of < 5,00 or >8,00; 4) contains chlorine 3 %; ann 5) has electrical conductivity (ec) 400 milisiemen s/meter; d. Direct planting is done using cover crop that grows fast and covers the soil surface. (3) Management of top soil at acreage for reclama tion is as stated on Attachment 3. Third Pdrt Erosion and Sedimentation Control Article 40 Erosion can be caused by: a. wind; b. water. Paragraph 1 Wind erosion Article 41 (1) Sensitive areas towards wind erosion are such as sandy beach, semi-dry/dry area (Nusa Tenegara) or on very wide opened mining land. 39 I!l.WiqJftt ' ;I,' a8\iJp;1,t·)';1 40 (2) Main impacts of wind erosion are: a. Land productivity decrement; b. Dust disturbance; and c. Formation of dust deposit in the gutter, at left and right side of road, fence, and build ings. (3) Annual plant or cover crop is used to control ero sion in long term. (4) There are actions done before plant can play its role, as follows: a. Using mulch as land cover; b. Making soil condition resistance towards ero sion by letting soil in lump form. wetting soil surface, and making curves on soil; and e. Rf'dueina wind vf'lncity hy rnak inq wind breaker. (5) This wind breaker can be line of wild trees or bushes or planted ones planted perpendicular to wards wind, planted trees or bushes are better originated from fast grow and strong ones or can be mode as fence. (6) In placing and selecting wind breaker, there are factors to consider: a. Erosive wind direction. b. Plant heigtn and distance. c. Wind permeability (40% the highest). d. Wind breaker continuity and length as well as turbulence at area for reclamation. Paragraph 2 Water erosion Article 42 (1) Factors that cause erosion are rain fall, slope inclination (topography), type of soil, land use (treatment on land), and soil cover plants. (2) Some methods to control water erosion are: a. Minimizing disturbed acreage. 1) By making details of activities of forest area utilization and reclamation; 2) By making obvious borders of develop ment stages acreage; 3) By cutting trees only in acreage where for est area utilization takes place; 4) By monitoring closely the trees cutting ex ecution. b. Limiting/reducing run off speed with by: 1) Making terrace as stated on Attachment 4; 2) Making diversion/dodaer r.hannel (lparal lei to contour line); 3) Making Water Disposal Line (WDL) as stated on Attachment 5; c. lnc rcoairiq water infiltrotion 1) Making channel terrace in the form of holes or blocked channels made between staple crops to hold water and engrain it into soil (illust ra riun at taulu ueru 18). 2) Soil harrowing in line with contour. Due to harrowing, soil becomes loose and its volume increases as medium for plant's root. d. Storing sediment 1) To store sediment from erosion, a hold ing dam or control dam can be made as stated on Attachment 6. GOVERNMENT REGULATIONS es: 2) If sediment has reached half of dam body, it is better to dredge and used as top soil layer. e. Reducing erosion 1) Cover crop planting can be done to reduce erosion, especially when land manage ment has just done. 2) On relatively flat land, cover crop plant ing can be done manually, while on a little steep land can be done by using hydro seeding. f. Management for water coming out from for est area util ization 1) Water distribution from mining location to public must be according to regulation in effect. ?) If rain f811 is hiOh. it j<: nec e s s arv to make strong and permanent dam completed with dodger cha nnel. 3) Dam location is placed in such way that run off watcr is ccav to rotainand rcdi rected and also water channel inclination is made not too steep. 4) In making permanent dam, it is better to complete it wittl spillvvav s , dispus al pipet out let, and other things considered nec essary. l-ourth I-'art Revegetation Article 43 Revegeta tion is done through activities stag a. field preparation; b. seed nursery and/or provision; c. planting execution; and d. plant maintenance. Paragraph 1 Field preparation Article 44 The field preparation activities as meant in Ar ticle 43 point a covers: a. land clearing; b. soil treatment; and c. soil improvement. Article 45 Clearing the land from weeds (coarse grass, climber, and so on) as meant in Article 44 point a is done so that staple plant can grow well without com petition with weeds in getting nutrient, sunlight. Article 46 Soil Treatment as meant in Article 44 point b is done so that soil becomes loose to make infiltra tion of plant's root easy into soil and to get necessary nutrient easily, so that plant can grow as expected. Article 47 Soil improvement as meant III Article 44 point c is meant so that soil quality that less good for plant's growt h can get special attention throug h soil improvement, such as: a. Gypsum usage. Gypsum is used to improve soil condition that contains much clay and to reduce crusting for mation on hard-setting soil. 41 42 b. Lime usage. Lime is used especially to regulate pH, but also can be used to improve soil structure. c. Mulch, straw, and other organic materials. Mulch is material spread on soil surface as an ef fort to improve soil condition for seed adjustment at early stage of plant, to control erosion, and to maintain soil humidity, and to settle soi I surface angle. Short-term cover crop can also be used as mulch. rL Fertilizer. Even though native plant can adapt low nutri tion level, hut enouah fertilizer tr eatmenr ca n in crease its growth. Treatment with basic fertilizer using correct com position and dosage and accordingly to needs will be very influential to plants' growth level. Organic fertilizer can be used due to its function as converter for nature of soil. Treatment with grained or tablet fertilizer can be applied as long as there is no direct contact be tween root with fertilizer. Paragraph 2 seed nursery and/or provision; Article 48 (1) Seeds needed for revegetation must be obtained through seed nursery and/or provision; (2) For that sake, every forest area utilizer must have nursery. (3) In case seeds available in nursery do not fulfill requirement to plant and/or the amount does not suffice needs of seed provision, direct provision can be done. (4) Law for seed nursery and/or provision implemen tation is regulated accordingly to the law and reg ulation. Paragraph 3 Planting Implementation Article 49 (1) Stages of planting implementation involves: a. arrangement of plant row direction; b. stake planting. c. seeds distribution; d. plant hole creation; and P. 1l1,mting (2) The arrangement for row direction must be par allel to contour or to the area that relatively flat following east-west direction. (3) Stake planting is following plant row direction and planting distance decided on technical de sign. (4) Seed distribution is done after planting hole cre ation activity or done after stakes have been planted. (5) Planting hole is made 30 x 30 x 30 crn or ad justed to seeds size to be planted with distance between plant hole as decided on technical de· sign. (6) Before planting, soil that will be used to cover the plant hole will be mixed with basic fertilizer (N, P, and K) accordingly to needs or types of plant to be planted. Article 50 (1) Planting is done under condition as tollows: GOVERNMENT REGULATIONS a. The plastic (pot/polly bag) is removed from the seeds before planting. b. Plant the seed perpendicularly and compact enough and make sure by pressing surround inq area of the plant usinq feet. c. Amount of final plants is minimum 625 per hactare or with maximum 4 x 4 m planting distance adjusted to land form, area function and plant form/canopy. d. Planting stages are done as follows: 1) For erosion and sedimentation control, first stage is cover crop. 2) After cover crop grow, at certain loca tions must be preceded with pre-condition by planting pioneer plants or fost growing species so that land covering and nutrient enrichment can be obtained quickly. 3) After pioneer plant aged between 2 up [0 3 years, then enrichment is done by planting of long-cycle local species that have high economic value, which gener ally need shade at early planting stage. 4) t-or other locations with possible condi tion, can be done direct planting with Jong cycle local plant types with plant typed adjusted to forest function. Paragraph 4 Plant Maintenance Article 51 (1) Plant maintenance is meant to trigger plant growth in such a way to have optimum condition for plant growth. (2) Plant maintenance activities are: a. Inter planting. Inter planting is done to dead or damaged, unhealthy or wilted plant, and done on run ninq year maintenance, year J and year II until plants can grow well and naturally. b. Weed control. Weed control is done to reduce/lessen com l1f'titinn betwaan st<ll1lp plants with weeds. Weed control can be done manually such as weeding and removing weeds to loosen the soil or chemically Iike chemical agent/herbi cide spraying, depends on fiold condition, soil condition, plant types, and weed types. c. Fertilizing. 1) Fertilizing is meant to pace up plant growth and to increase iricr e rnerrt. 21 In deciding type, dosage, and time for fer tilizing, it is necessary to consider plant species and soi I fertility as well as to per torm soil analyze before hand. d. Pest and disease control. 1) Plant pest and disease control chemically can only be done on a very critical condi tion that tends to fail whole forest recla mation. 2) Control is done by following guidelines for usage/treatment precisely and correctly. e. Prevention of forest fire and illegal grazing. 1) Forest fire can be a serious threat for crop growth, plant productivity and quality. 2) Some of prevention efforts towards fire are: land clearing from flammable 43 44 materials, selecting plant types that re sistance towards fire and providing P.dllr.:Hion on fire prevention to local society. 3) Prevention towards illegal grazina is donp. through education, provision of livestock feed seed, and if necessary building safety fence. f. Trimming. 1) Trimming can be done to provide enough \:Jruwin\:J s pur.e fur plants. 2) Trimming is also meant to provide grow ing space for ermchrnem plant Of relav cr op planted after pioneer or fast grow crop planting. g. Thinning. 1) At early planting that usually done With fast grow species, land covering occurs quickly that cause plant growing competition. 2) Thinning is done to reduce plant growing competition, to remove plant with pressed growth, and to provide enough growing space for relay or enrichment plants. 3) Thinning activity is done at half cycle of pioneer crop age with amount/percentage of available crop amount depends on crop density condition and plant species or plan for long cycle local species planting. 4) Felling management for thinning refers to the law and regulation. h. Enrichment. 1) Enrichment planting can be done by doing relay planting after pioneer crops aged 2 (two) up to 3 (three) years or after thinning. 2) Plant enrichment is done by planting long cycle local plant species that have high eco nomic value accordingly to analysis result in AEI study. Fifth Part Financing I\rticle 52 (1) Cost for forest reclamation implementation is born by the license holder of forest o ro a utiliza tion. (2) To guarantee the success of forest reclamation implementation, license holder is obliged to pay Reclamation Guarantee Funu (RGF). (3) Law on quantity, form, placement procedure, liq uidatton of Reclamation Guarantee Fund is done accordingly to the law and regulation. Sixth Part Forest Reclamation Period of Time Article 53 (1) Due date for forest reclamation completion is 1 {one) year at maximum before the due date of license for forest area utilization. (2) In case the company will return borrowed forest area before the due d ate of forest borrow-use license, then the due date for forest reclamation completion is 1 (one) year at the latest before the due date to return the forest. (3) Assessment is done on forest reclamation suc cess before it is returned as meant at paragraph (1) and (21. CHAPTER VI INSTITUTION Article 54 Institution includes: a. Executive Organization of Forest Reclamation; and b. Human Resources (HR). Article 55 (1) For the license holder of forest area utilization it is obliged to have special organization that han dles forest reclamation. (2) Organization as meant at parauranh (1) c arries out duties as follows: A Tn irlentify reoion space allocation plan and utilization to be mined; b. To identify the baseline; c. To plan forest reclamation efforts; c. To execute pions and efforts for forest rcela marion: e. To establish maintenance, research, monitor ing, and reporting all execution of plans and ef f ort s for forest rcclamatlou. Article 56 Human resources, as meant in Article 54 point b, are obliged to possess expertise in the field of forestry, ag ricult ure , mining, sou. and other tiel ds related to forest reclamation. Article 57 The license holder of forest area utilization is obliged to improve quality and capability of human resources expertise In implementing forest reclama tion activities, through activities such as training, on the job training (apprenticeship), comparative study, and workshop. Article 58 In order to increase quality and capability of human resources in forestry field, there are traininqs as follows: a. GIS mapping and mastering tenurial information on forest area, the license holder can work to oethp.r with Fore sr Arp.A Fs tnblishrnerrr Office (FAEO/BPKH) as Technical Executor Unit (TEUI UPT} of Directorate General of Forestry Plano] ogy. b. Monitoring and evaluation of River Flow Area that go along with environmental surveillance, management, and control, the utilization license holder can work together with Management Of fice for Hi ve r Fluw Art:C1 (MORFA/6PDAS) as the Technical Executor Unit (TEUl of Directorate General of Management Guidance for River Flow Area and Social Forestry. c. Forest plant nursery technique, the utilization li cense holder can work together with The Office tor Forest Plant Seed (OFPS/BPTH) as TEU of Di rectorate General of Management Guidance for River Flow Area and Social Forestry. d. Forest development policy in the region and sus tainable forest management, the utilization li cense holder can work together with Provincial Forestry Office. 45 GOVERNMENT REGULATIONS CHAPTER VII TECHNICAL MONITORING AND ASSISTANCE First Part General Article 59 (1) Activities of technical monitoring and assistance on forest reclamation implementation is done at least once a year. (2) Activities of technical monitoring and assistance is carried out by: a. central level; and b. regional level. Article 60 (1) Monitoring activities of forest reclamation imple mentation as meant in Article 59 paragraph (1) is done to observe the implementation develop rnerit nf fore st rerilarna tio n activities , tn idantifv. as well as to anticipate occurring and/or to occur problems to be able to take action as early as possible. (2) Monitoring activities are done to obtain data and information, policy and implementation of forest reclamation, Article 61 Activities of technical assistance as meant in Article 59 paragraph (1) is meant to provide sugges tion and input for improvement of forest reclamation implementation that is less/not suitable with current law. Second Part Technical Monitoring and Assistance at Central Level Article 62 (1) Technical monitoring and assistance at central level as meant in Article 59 paragraph (2) point a is carried out by the Directorate General of Man agement Guidance for River Flow Area and Social Forestry cq. Directorate for Forest and Land Reha bilitation Guidance. (2) In the implementation of technical monitoring and assistance as meant at paragraph (1) can involve related instances such as Directorate General of Mineral, Coal, and Geothermal, the Ministry of En erqy and Mineral Resources, Directorate General for Forestry Planology of Ministry of Forestry, Third Part Tanhnical Monitoring and Assist:'lncp. CIt Regional Level Article 63 (1) Technical monitoring and assistance at regional level as meant in Article 59 paragraph (2) point b is carried out by Governor, Regent/Major accord ingly to their authority. (2) In the implementation of technical monitoring and as sis tauue, Guver nur , Reyent/Major assign tech nical instance to handle forestry matters and can involve related instance. Article 64 Technical monitoring and assistance is done by technical office as meant in Article 63 appointed 46 by Regent/Major to monitor the development of recla mation implementation, such as: a. Fulfilling payment obligation to Provision of Forest Resources-Reforestation Safety Fund (PFR-RSF/ PSDH-DR); b. Crop inventory from reclamation result; c. Progress/improvement of forest area utilization; and d. Reclamation/revegetation. Article 65 Technical monitoring and assistance as meant in Article 63 is done by technical office appointed by Governor to monitor: a. development of border management implementa tion; b. forest area safety implementation; c. development of forest area utilization implementa tion; and d. reclamation/revegetation. Article 66 (1) Directorate for Forest and Land Rehabilitation Guidance on the behalf of Directorate General of Management Guidance for River Flow Area and Social History assigns Management office of RFA to implement technical rnonrtormq and assistance on reclamation especially related to water man agement condition at concerned RFA aside from monitoring on the progress of forest reclamation implementation; (2) In carrying out water management condition mon itoring as meant at paragraph (1) can be done with SPAS installation. Article 67 Dec; sion for the time to carry out technical monitoring and assistance is done by respective tech nical instance and coordinated with related parties. Article 68 (1) Result of monitoring is used to: a. Know development/progress of reclamation implementation; b. Provide data and information as control func tion toward the implementation of forest recla mation accordingly to the law and regulation. (2) Result of monitoring is reported by technical in stance that handles forestry affairs at District/City level to Gove rnor cq . Head of Provincial Fore strv Office with copy to Directorate General of Man <=lgement Guid aric a for River Flovv Aro a and Social Forestry. (3) Rc ault of monitoring by tcchnicnl inatono o thnt handles forestry affairs at Provincial level is re ported to Governor with c opv to Duectora te Gen eral of Management Guidance for River Flow Area dflU Social Fures uv. (4) Result of technical monitoring and assistance by Management Office of RFA is reported directly to Directorate General of Management Guidance for RIver How Area and Social rorestry. Fourth Part Forest Reclamation Success Assessment Article 69 (1) Assessment on forest reclamation success is done through evaluation activities towards forest 47 48 reclamation implementation. (2) Assessment on success for central level is done by Team coordinated by Directorate General of Management Guidance for River Flow Area and Souial Fort:stry arid a ssessrrierrt on s uc c e ss at re gional level is done by Tearn coordinated by Pro vincial Technical Office that handles forestry. (3) Assessment on forest reclamation success is done once every 5 (five) years or a year before due of license borrow-use of forest area; (4) Law on the implementation of forest reclamation success is regulated accordingly to the law and regulation. Article 70 (1) Building/installation of SPAS as meant in Article 66 paragraph (2) is meant to find out about water management condition and erosion/sedimentation occurred. (2) SPAS as rneam at paraqr aph (1) is t o measure or to know; a. Water rnanaqernent condition, indicated from River Regime Coefficient (RRC), comparison between maximum discharge (Ornaxj and mini mum discharge (Orninl in an RFA. (how to cal culate RRC can be seen on attachment table) b. Occurred erosion is indicated from the amount of mud/sediment content in water carried away by river flow or the amount of sediment on wa ter bodies. The bigger sediment content car ried by water flows means RRA condition is unhealthier. Article 71 (1) srAs set is installed at outlet small watershed (catchment area). (2) In case in mining acreage available more than one catchment urea, then the biggest one or the most influenced one is chosen to build and install SPAS. (3) In order to complete SPAS building, it is necessary to in st all rain gauge, the manual one Ombrometer or the automatic one Automatic Rainfall Recorder/ AKH). (4) In installing the SPAS set, the license holder can coordinate/consult with local Management Office of River Flow Area. (5) Processed/analyzed data of observation result in form of water discharge and mud content is re ported periodicallv and is part of reclamation re port. Fifth Part.. ....... to be continued (A) GOVERNMENT REGULATIONS FOREST RECLAMATION GUIDELINES (The Regulation of The Minister of Forestry of Republic of Indonesia Number P. 4/Menhut-II/2011, 14 January 2011) [Continued from Business News No. 8110 page 36-48] Fifth Part Observation Based on Spatial Data (Measurable, Reportable, and Verifiable/MRV) Article 72 (1) System of control, observation on forest reclarna tion activities must be rnee sureble , re po rteble , and verifiable (MRVl. and must fulfill the principles of: a. Combination of remote sensing and gruund based inventory; b. Calculation result: transparent and open for re view; (Ll The Implementation system of control. morutor ing as meant at parag rap h (1) has to be sup ported by: a. sufficient mapping/spatial data (aiming accu racy of activities loca ti on); b. availability of database system of process doc umentation and activities output; c. availability of monitoring result system (out como). impact and benefit from reclamation program. Article 73 (1) All data and information as result from forest rec lamation observation/monitoring is provided in nu meric/textual, spatial, and visual. (Ll For visual data, company IS obliged to prepare photo image/documentation that can describe the development of image appearance from the base line until completion of mining, before activities and after revegetation is done. 39 GOVERNMENT REGULATIONS 40 (3) Forest reclamation as part of Forest and Land Re habilitation (t-LR) as development prog ram with multiyear process, the input, output, outcome, and impact of the program can be identified and measured. (4) Forest reclamation observation/monitoring is very important to make sure the input, output, out come, and impact of the forest reclamation runs accordingly to plan/aim of the program. Article 74 The implementation of observation with MRV system as meant in Article 72 and Article 73 must meet stages as follows: a. Output observation/monitoring that involves di rect output observation/monitoring of Forest Reclamation activities such as trees plant/crop as direct result of input, in MRV context, this output observation/monitoring will be used more. b. Outcome observation/monitoring that involves re sult 0 bservation/monitoring that indicates the out put of Forest Reclamation has come to function. Indicators that can be observed at on-site/location such as decreasing erosion and sedimentation and so on are part of this outcome indicator. c. Impact observation/monitoring of Forest Reclama tion activities that involves indicators at offsite/ outside or surrounding location that shows the impact/influence of activities, indication of water management irnprovernerit , sucietv ecuuurnv and social are impact indicators of Forest Reclamation that nf'f'rl<:; to bf' measured. d. Benefit observation/monitoring is observation to examine how much benefit from the program. Article 75 (1) in order to support fotest reclarnat ion ubservatiun to get clear image since the early process of for est area utilization until the reclamation implemen tation, the license holder or forest area utilization is obliged to prepare satellite image with sufficient resolution since before forest area utilization takes place until the transfer of forest area, (2) Satellite image provision is part of observation with MRV method that necessary to carry out for certain period of rime accordingly to validity of license for forest area utilization, (3) For the license holder of forest area utilization with 5 (five) years validity or less, satellite image provision is done at the beginning and completion of forest area utilization activities, (4) For the license holder of forest area utilization with validity above 5 (five) years, satellite im age provision is done every 5 (five) years pe riod. CHAPTER VIII REPORTING MECHANISM OF FOREST RECLAMATION IMPLEMENTATION Article 16 The license holder of forest area utilization as the executor of forest recle me tion is obliged to submit report of reclamation implementation periodi cally to Director General of M;ln<'lgf'mf'nt Guidanne for River Flow Area and Social Forestry of Ministry of Forestry with copies to: a. Directorate General for Forestry Planology of Min istry of Forestry; b. Directorate General of Mineral, Coal, and Geother mal, the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resourc es; c. Provincial Technical Office that handles forestry; cllld GOVERNMENT REGULATIONS c. District/City Technical Office that handles forest ry. Article 77 (1) Forest reclamation report consists of: a. Quarterly Report; LJ. Annual Report. (2) Forest reclamation report format for quarterly and annual report is accordino to report format as stated on attachment 7. (3) Aside from data on report format, it should be • completed with: •• 'Cl. SPAS data (water discharge, sedimentation); b. Documentation photos of reclamation activities implementation; and c. Map and coordinate of reclamation acreage (scale 1 : 10,000). Article 78 The license holder of forest area utilization is also obliged to make condition pictures/images of for est area borrow-use acreage since a year up to the transfer/returning of it. CHAPTER IX SANCTION Article 79 For the license holders who do not implement forest reclamation activities accordingly to the law or do not carry out forest recla mati on activities, are ap plied with sanctions, as follows: a. Administration sanction, accordingly to the law and regulation preceded with 3 (three) times writ ten warning with 3 months interval for each warn rnq. b. Sanction in the form of license cancellation for forest area utilization after assessment of forest reclamation done accordingly to the law and regu lation. Article 80 (1) Administration sanction is given by Directorate General of Management Guidance for River Flow Area (Directorate General of MGRFA) and Sociell Forestry after observation has been done by Pro vincial Office th at hanrlles fnrestry fielr:l or hy local MGRFA. (2) In case after the third warning period has over and the license holder of forest area borrow-use does not do forest reclamation, then Directorate Gen eral of Management Guidance for River Flow Area and Social Forestry forms verification/assessment team to perform assessment on reclamation im plementation as base for cancellation of license fur torest area borrow-use by Minister. (3) Member of verification/assessment team consists of related instance as regulated in the Regulation of Minister of Forestry Number: P.60/Menhut 11/2009 concerning Guidelines for Assessment on Forest Reclamation Success. CHAPTER X FINAL PROVISIONS Article 81 By the enactment of the Regulation of the Minster of Forcstry, Decrec of thc Minister of Forestry and Plantation Number: 146/Kpts-II/1999 concerning Guidance for Reclamation of Ex-Mine in Forest Area, is annulled and stated not in effect anymore. Article 82 This Regulation of Minister of Forestry starts to take effect since the prornurqanon date. 41 GOVERNMENT REGULATIONS 42 For everybody to acknowledge this regulation, this Regulation of Minister of Forestry is promulgated by placing it in the State Gazette of the Republic of lnuonesia. Stinulatari in Jakarta on 14 January 2011 THE MINISTER OF FORESTRY THE REPUBLIC OF INDONESIA Sgnd. ZULKIFLI HASAN Promulgated in Jakarta On 18 January 2011 THE MINISTER OF LAW AND HUMAN RIGHTS THE REPUBLIC OF INDONESIA Synd. PATRIALIS AKBAR THE STATE GAZETTE OF THE REBULIC OF INDONE SiA YEAR 2011 NUMBER 23 Editorial note: For technical reason, Attachment is not included. (Al