Antigua and Barbuda National Adaptation Plan
صدر في 2024-12 · النص بتاريخ 2026-10-01
القانون العام والإرشادات الرسمية منشورة بوصفها أبحاثاً. ليست مشورة قانونية أو ضريبية أو مالية.
البحث نفسه مكتوب بالإنجليزية. العناوين والوسوم مترجمة؛ أما النتائج والاقتباسات فغير مترجمة.
عن هذا القانون
- اللغة
- English
- النوع
- policy
- الدولة
- أنتيغوا وبربودا
- الموضوعات
- Agricultural and rural development, Air and atmosphere, Environment, Fisheries and aquaculture, Forestry, Land and soil, Water, Wild species and ecosystems, General
- الكلمات المفتاحية
- tourism, equity, gender, agricultural land, capacity building, data collection/reporting, food security, access-to-information, climate change, coastal zone management, environmental impact assessment (EIA), environmental planning, governance, hazards, monitoring, protection of environment, policy/planning, fishery management and conservation, marine fisheries, forest management/forest conservation, land-use planning, public land, soil conservation/soil improvement, urban land, zoning, land tenure, rainwater, water desalination, water shortage/drought, waterworks, wetlands, water resources management, biodiversity, ecosystem conservation, air quality/air pollution, early warning system, meteorology, pollution control
أين تقرؤه
لا يوجد رابط مصدر مسجل لهذا القانون.
النص
نص القانون نفسه، مادةً مادة، كما هو محفوظ. لكل مادة رابطها.
1.1. Historical and Present Climate Trends ................................................................................................... 15
1.2. Future Climate Scenarios .............................................................................................................................. 17
1.3. Climate Risks and Hazards ............................................................................................................................ 20
1.4. Climate Change Risk Modelling .................................................................................................................... 24 CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITY ............................................................................ 28 2. Future Climate Vulnerabilities and Impacts............................................................... 29
2.1. Agriculture and Food Security ................................................................................................................ 29
2.2. Health...................................................................................................................................................... 31
2.3. Education ................................................................................................................................................ 32
2.4. Cultural and Historical Sites ................................................................................................................... 33
2.5. Tourism ................................................................................................................................................... 34
2.6. Wholesale and Retail .................................................................................................................................... 35
2.7. Finance Sector......................................................................................................................................... 36
2.8. Infrastructure and Housing .................................................................................................................... 37
2.9. Water Sector ................................................................................................................................................. 39
2.10. Biodiversity and the Natural Environment ........................................................................................ 41
2.11. Women, Youth, Persons with Disabilities, the Elderly, Ethnic Communities, and other Marginalized Groups ........................................................................................................................................... 42
2.12. Local Areas.......................................................................................................................................... 53 CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION ............................................................................. 59 3. Adaptation Priorities for Combatting Adversities of Climate Change ......................... 60
3.1. Lessons Learned from Past Initiatives .......................................................................................................... 60
3.2. Adaptation Needs for Antigua and Barbuda ......................................................................................... 61
3.3. Adaptation Strategy, Pathways, and Barriers........................................................................................ 62
3.4. National Commitments Alignment ........................................................................................................ 65
3.5. Policies and regulations.......................................................................................................................... 67
3.6. Institutional Arrangements and Coordination ...................................................................................... 68
3.7. Sectoral Adaptation ................................................................................................................................ 71
3.8. Communications Plan ........................................................................................................................... 113
3.9. Incorporation of Climate Change into Development Policies and Strategy (i.e., Mainstreaming Guidelines) ......................................................................................................................................................... 114 CHAPTER 4: FINANCING STRATEGY ....................................................................................... 120
4.1. Stakeholder Engagement ........................................................................................................................... 122
4.2. Sustainable Financing Mechanisms ........................................................................................................... 123
4.3. Key National Stakeholders ......................................................................................................................... 124
4.4. NAP Synergies with NDC Implementation ................................................................................................. 126
4.5. NAP Costs and Prioritisation ...................................................................................................................... 127
4.6. NAP Prioritization of SAPs and LAPs .......................................................................................................... 132 CHAPTER 5: MONITORING, EVALUATION AND LEARNING FOR ADAPTATION ........................ 138 5. Overview of Monitoring & Evaluation ........................................................................... 139 5.1. National Adaptation Plan Monitoring, Evaluation and Learning Framework .......................................... 140
5.2. Norms and Standards of the NAP M&E System......................................................................................... 142
5.3. Data, Information, and Knowledge Management ..................................................................................... 144
5.4. National Monitoring, Reporting and Verification System ......................................................................... 146 5.5. Measuring Progress on Implementation of Adaptation Actions............................................................... 148
5.6. NAP Theory of Change ................................................................................................................................ 149
5.7. Evaluation of Adaptation Actions .............................................................................................................. 150
5.8. Framing of the Evaluation Scope................................................................................................................ 150
5.9. Reporting on Climate Change Adaptation ................................................................................................. 153
5.10. Feedback and Learning on Adaptation .................................................................................................... 156
5.12. Conclusion ................................................................................................................................................. 156 Appendix .............................................................................................................................. 158 Appendix 1: National Adaptation Plan Project Results Tracker .......................................... 158 Appendix 2: Preliminary Stakeholder Consultation Stakeholder List .................................. 161 Annex A – Prioritisation scores for each output................................................................. 162 Appendix 3: Snapshots from Stakeholder Engagement Activities ...................................... 164 ......................................................................................................................................... 164 Appendix 4: Implementation Plans for the three (3) Local Area Plans................................ 165 References............................................................................................................................ 193 List of Figures FIGURE 1: THE NATIONAL ADAPTATION PLAN PROCESS FOR THE NATIONAL ADAPTATION PLAN DEVELOPMENT FOR ANTIGUA AND BARBUDA (UNFCCC, 2012) ............................................................................................................ 4 FIGURE 2: PREDICTED RISE IN SEA LEVEL IN ANTIGUA AREA ........................................................................................ 19 FIGURE 3: ANTIGUA’S COASTLINE CHANGES UNDER 0.13 M SEA LEVEL RISE (SLR) SCENARIO (A), AND 1.45 M SEA LEVEL RISE (SLR) SCENARIO (B) ............................................................................................................................ 19 FIGURE 4 & 5: CORAL DAMAGE RISK FROM HURRICANES FOR DIFFERENT CLIMATE SCENARIOS (RCP 4.5 & 8.5) AND EVENTS (MCE, HISTORICAL, 100-YEAR)FIGURE 5: CORAL DAMAGE RISK FROM HURRICANES FOR DIFFERENT CLIMATE SCENARIOS (RCP 4.5 & 8.5) AND EVENTS (MCE, HISTORICAL, 100-YEAR) ............................................ 24 FIGURE 6: TOTAL LOSSES (MILLIONS USD) FOR THE MAXIMUM CREDIBLE EVENT (MCE) FOR THE STABILIZATION CLIMATE SCENARIO (RCP4.5) .............................................................................................................................. 26 FIGURE 7: FUTURE ANTICIPATED PROBABLE LOSSES FROM BUILDING DAMAGE FOR STORM WIND (LEFT) AND SURGE (RIGHT) IN A MAXIMUM CREDIBLE EVENT (MCE) ............................................................................................... 26 FIGURE 8: CLIMATE CHANGE IMPACTS ON SECTORS (SOURCE: ADAPTATION COMMUNICATION FOR ANTIGUA & BARBUDA, 2022) .................................................................................................................................................. 29 FIGURE 9: STRATEGY OVERVIEW OF THE YES-CA .......................................................................................................... 46 FIGURE 10: INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS TO SUPPORT CLIMATE CHANGE ADAPTATION (ADCOM, 2022) .......... 69 FIGURE 11: INDICATIVE PROCESS FLOW FOR ANTIGUA AND BARBUDA’S NATIONAL ADAPTATION PLANNING PROCESS (SOURCE: ADCOM, 2022) ..................................................................................................................... 70 FIGURE 12: THE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENT’S IMPLEMENTATION ARRANGEMENTS FOR PROJECT MANAGEMENT IN ANTIGUA AND BARBUDA ...................................................................................................... 71 FIGURE 13: STAKEHOLDER PERCEPTION MAP OF KEY CLIMATIC AND NON-CLIMATIC HAZARDS AFFECTING THE ST. JOHN’S CITY LOCAL AREA .................................................................................................................................. 106 FIGURE 14: COASTAL INUNDATION SCENARIOS FOR JOLLY HARBOUR ...................................................................... 108 FIGURE 15: COASTAL INUNDATION SCENARIOS FOR FFRYES BEACH TO JOHNSONS POINT ...................................... 108 FIGURE 16 : SEA LEVEL RISE PERCEPTION FOR JOLLY HARBOUR ................................................................................ 110 FIGURE 17: SEA LEVEL RISE PERCEPTIONS FOR JOLLY HARBOUR ............................................................................... 110 FIGURE 18: CONCEPTUAL MODEL OF THE ENVIRONMENT REGISTRY ........................................................................ 146 FIGURE 19: NAP THEORY OF CHANGE......................................................................................................................... 149 List of Tables TABLE 1:PROJECTED CHANGE IN FREQUENCY OF DROUGHT, EXPRESSED AS THE NUMBER OF DROUGHT YEARS WITHIN THE 30-YEAR MID-CENTURY (2040-2069) AND END-CENTURY (2070-2099) INTERVALS. RESULTS ARE PRESENTED BY RCM TO SHOWCASE THE EXTREME VARIABILITY IN PRECIPITATION PROJECTS AMONG CLIMATE MODELS. .............................................................................................................................................................. 19 TABLE 2: PROJECTED CHANGE IN MAGNITUDE OF DROUGHT, EXPRESSED AS A PERCENTAGE CHANGE WITHIN THE 30-YEAR MID-CENTURY (2040 – 2069) AND END-CENTURY (2070-2099) INTERVALS. RESULTS ARE PRESENTED BY RCP TO SHOWCASE THE EXTREME VARIABILITY IN PRECIPITATION PROJECTIONS AMONG CLIMATE MODELS. .............................................................................................................................................................. 20 TABLE 3 : RECENT HURRICANES THAT AFFECTED ANTIGUA AND BARBUDA. DIRECT HIT INDICATES THE CYCLONE’S CENTER PASSED OVER LAND OR AT THE MOST 15 NAUTICAL MILES FROM LAND; HIT INDICATES THE CYCLONE CENTRE PASSED BETWEEN 15 & 65 NAUTICAL MILES FROM LAND; BRUSHED INDICATED THE CENTRE PASSED BETWEEN 65 & 105 NAUTICAL MILES FROM LAND. ............................................................................................ 22 TABLE 4: DIRECT BUILDING LOSSES ($M USD) BY DECADE FOR THE HIGH EMISSIONS (RCP8.5) AND STABILIZATION (RCP4.5) CLIMATE SCENARIOS) ........................................................................................................................... 25 TABLE 5: BUILDING STOCK ($M USD) EXPOSED TO SEA LEVEL RISE AND NUISANCE FLOODING BY DECADE FOR THE HIGH EMISSIONS (RCP8.5) AND STABILIZATION (RCP4.5) CLIMATE SCENARIOS. ................................................ 25 TABLE 6: CLIMATE CHANGE IMPACTS (SOURCE: MURPHY, 2023). ............................................................................... 33 TABLE 7: CLIMATE CHANGE IMPACTS ON FOUR (4) THEMATIC AREAS (IMAGECAT, 2023).......................................... 36 TABLE 8: NATIONAL YOUTH POLICY'S STRATEGIES ON CLIMATE CHANGE MITIGATION AND ADAPTATION ............... 48 TABLE 9: INVESTMENT PROGRAMMES (IPS) AND ACTIVITIES FOR ACHIEVING A RESILIENT FOOD SYSTEM. ............... 77 TABLE 10: KEY GOALS FOR I&H SUBSECTORS BASED ON KEY CLIMATE RISKS THAT POSE A THREAT TO THEIR RESILIENCE. .......................................................................................................................................................... 80 TABLE 11: HOUSING: SUMMARY OF PRIORITIZED ADAPTATION MEASURES ............................................................... 82 TABLE 12: ROADS: SUMMARY OF PRIORITIZED ADAPTATION MEASURES ................................................................... 86 TABLE 13: WASTEWATER: SUMMARY OF PRIORITIZED ADAPTATION MEASURES ....................................................... 88 TABLE 14: ENERGY: SUMMARY OF PRIORITIZED ADAPTATION MEASURES.................................................................. 90 TABLE 15: PRIORITY AREAS FOR THE TOURISM SECTOR AND THEIR STRATEGIC OBJECTIVE, OUTCOMES, AND OUTPUTS. ............................................................................................................................................................ 93 TABLE 16: EIA PROCESS AND RESPONSIBLE PARTIES. ................................................................................................. 116 TABLE 17: SUMMARY OF RISKS ASSOCIATED WITH CLIMATE CHANGE IMPACTS AND MITIGATION MEASURES ...... 118 TABLE 18: COSTING ESTIMATES FOR SAPS AND LAPS (IN USD MILLION) ................................................................... 128 TABLE 19: SAPS AND LAPS PRIORITIZATION OF OUTPUTS .......................................................................................... 133 TABLE 20: KEY COMPONENTS OF A NATIONAL MRV SYSTEM FOR ANTIGUA AND BARBUDA AND THEIR RELEVANCE TO NDC IMPLEMENTATION. ADAPTED FROM GGGIB, 2020.............................................................................. 147 TABLE 21: THE TEN (10) OUTCOMES AND ASSOCIATED OUTPUTS FOR THE ST. JOHN’S CITY LAAP 2023-2033 ......... 165 TABLE 22: THE ELEVEN (11) OUTCOMES AND ASSOCIATED OUTPUTS FOR THE DARKWOOD BEACH LAAP 2023-2033 ........................................................................................................................................................................... 175 TABLE 23: THE TWELVE (12) OUTCOMES AND ASSOCIATED OUTPUTS FOR THE ST. JOHN’S CITY LAAP 2023-2033 .. 184 List of Acronyms NDC - Nationally Determined Contributions AC - Adaption Communication NGO – Non-Governmental Organization A&B - Antigua and Barbuda OECS – Organization of Eastern Caribbean APUA – Antigua Public Utilities Authority States BEPAMU – Biodiversity, Ecosystems, and PAHO – Pan American Health Organization Protected Areas Management Unit PDNA – Post-Disaster Needs Assessment CARICOM – Caribbean Community PMC – Project Management Committee CCA – Climate Change Adaptation PMU – Project Management Unit CCORAL – Caribbean Climate Online Risk and PPA – Physical Planning Act Adaptation Tool PV – Photovoltaic COVID – Coronavirus Disease RCP - Representative Concentration CAN – Competent National Authority Pathway CO2 – Carbon Dioxide RO – Reverse Osmosis DOE - Department of Environment SAP - Sectoral Adaptation Plan EIA – Environmental Impact Assessment SLR – Sea Level Rise EIMAS – Environmental Impact Monitoring SIDS – Small Island Developing States and Assessment System SIRF – Sustainable Island Resources EPMA - Environmental Protection and Framework Management Act SIRMM – Sustainable Island Resource GCF - Green Climate Fund Management Mechanism GDP – Gross Domestic Product TAC - Technical Advisory Committee GEF – Global Environment Facility UNDP – United Nations Development GHG - Greenhouse Gases Programme GoAB - Government of Antigua and Barbuda UNESCO – United Nations Educational, GGA – Global Goal on Adaptation Scientific and Cultural Organization Ha – Hectare UNFCCC - United Nations Framework I&H – Infrastructure and Housing Convention on Climate Change IPCC – Intergovernmental Panel on Climate UNICEF – United Nations Children’s Fund Change VSLA – Village Savings and Loans IP – Investment Programme Associations LAAP - Local Area Adaptation Plan NRDC – Natural Resources Defense Council M&E - Monitoring and Evaluation USD – United States Dollar MCA – multi-criteria Analysis UNFAO – United Nations Food and MW – Megawatt Agriculture Organization MOF – Ministry of Finance W&R – Wholesale and Retail MTDS – Medium Term Development WRI – World Resources Institute Strategy XCD – Eastern Caribbean Dollar NAP - National Adaptation Plan Foreword Climate change poses an existential threat to Small Island Developing States like Antigua and Barbuda. Rising sea levels, more frequent and intense hurricanes, and changes in rainfall patterns are already impacting our communities, our economy, and our environment. This National Adaptation Plan (NAP) represents a crucial step in our efforts to address these challenges and build a more resilient future for our nation. This plan is the result of extensive research, stakeholder consultations, and expert analysis. It outlines a comprehensive framework for climate action, addressing key vulnerabilities and outlining concrete adaptation measures across various sectors. From strengthening our early warning systems to investing in climate-resilient infrastructure and promoting sustainable development practices, this NAP provides a roadmap for building a more resilient and sustainable future for Antigua and Barbuda. The successful implementation of this plan will require the concerted efforts of government agencies, civil society organizations, the private sector, and the international community. I urge all stakeholders to work together to ensure the effective and timely implementation of the actions outlined in this NAP. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY I am confident that through collective action and unwavering commitment, we can overcome the challenges posed by climate change and build a more prosperous and sustainable future for generations to come. Sincerely, __________________ Hon. Molwyn Joseph Minister of Health, Wellness and Environment Executive Summary This National Adaptation Plan (NAP) outlines Antigua and Barbuda's comprehensive strategy to address the escalating challenges posed by climate change. As a Small Island Developing State (SIDS), we are acutely vulnerable to the impacts of climate change, including rising sea levels, extreme weather events, and increased temperatures. This plan aims to enhance our resilience by identifying and prioritizing adaptation actions across key sectors, including agriculture, tourism, infrastructure and housing, finance, wholesale and retail, as well as for cultural and historical resources. The NAP is informed by extensive stakeholder consultations, scientific assessments, and climate projections. It outlines a vision for a climate-resilient future, where our communities, ecosystems, and economy can thrive despite the challenges posed by climate change. Key strategies include: • Strengthening Early Warning Systems: Enhancing our capacity to predict and respond to extreme weather events through improved data collection, advanced forecasting models, and effective communication systems. • Investing in Climate-Smart Infrastructure: Developing and implementing resilient infrastructure, such as seawalls, coastal defenses, and climate-proof buildings, to minimize the impacts of sea-level rise and extreme weather events. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY • Promoting Sustainable Land Use Practices: Implementing sustainable land use planning strategies to protect critical ecosystems, such as mangroves and coral reefs, and reduce vulnerability to coastal erosion. • Diversifying the Economy: Promoting economic diversification to reduce reliance on climate-sensitive sectors and enhance economic resilience. • Building Human and Institutional Capacity: Strengthening the capacity of government agencies, communities, and individuals to plan for, adapt to, and respond to climate change. The successful implementation of this NAP will require strong political will, inter-sectoral collaboration, and continued support from the international community. By working together, we can build a more resilient and sustainable future for Antigua and Barbuda. Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan I. Introduc=on I.1. Scope The formulation phase of the national adaptation planning process commenced in 20171 and was completed in 2024, supported by a budget of USD 3,000,000 from the Green Climate Fund (GCF) Readiness Grant. This project assumes a critical role in providing an evidence-based adaptation planning approach to mainstream climate change adaptation into Antigua and Barbuda's public and private sector operations to support the country's capacity to withstand the effects of climate change and promote enduring sustainable development. The plan is also set to address critical gaps that hinder effective adaptation efforts, and it will be implemented through a sector- driven and area-specific approach. These gaps are related to: 1. Data collec_on: to collect and store high resolucon topographical data in Geographic Informacon System (GIS) format for Ancgua and Barbuda; improve the quality of downscaled climacc projeccons; and engage in data exchange among agencies. While there is a large amount of baseline data, there are significant errors that expose the Government to liability issues if adaptacon planning decisions are legislated. The NAP will fill these gaps. INTRODUCTION 2. Planning mandates: to establish sectoral plans that build on the accons idencfied in the Medium-Term Development Strategy (2015) and are prioriczed based on financial and technical criteria; high-level (Cabinet) endorsement and buy-in; and proof of concepts for innovacve financing models. 3. Monitoring and Evalua_on: adaptacon indicators exist but need to be aligned with the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) and naconal development frameworks to manage requirements for meecng M&E obligacons. Ultimately, the National Adaptation Plan (NAP) focuses on the development of climate adaptation strategies, guidelines, and action plans. Activities involve comprehensive vulnerability assessments across key sectors, the translation of findings into practical adaptation measures, and the creation of guidelines to seamlessly integrate climate resilience into development and sectoral endeavours. Furthermore, this NAP will be implemented in collaboration with Government ministries, local authorities, non-governmental organisations (NGOs), international development partners, and community representatives. 1 GCF National Adaptation Planning and Process Readiness Proposal with Ministry of Health and the Environment for Antigua and Barbuda. https://www.greenclimate.fund/sites/default/files/document/readiness-proposals-antigua-and-barbuda-ministry-health-and-environment-adaptation- planning.pdf 1 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan This plan also focuses on public awareness and capacity building, public awareness campaigns and capacity-building workshops/ training, which are integral to promoting understanding of climate change adaptation and resilience and is quite critical in the development of the NAP. However, the NAP does not encompass the direct implementation of physical adaptation measures. I.2. Methodology for NAP FormulaDon (Principle and Approach) The formulation of a NAP for Antigua and Barbuda involves a meticulous methodology grounded in principles and approaches tailored to the unique environmental and socio-economic context of these twin island state. In keeping in alignment with the vision of the NAP to enhance adaptive capacity, strengthen resilience, and reduce vulnerability to the adverse effects of climate change, the core of this process is a commitment to integrate climate change adaptation into national policies and development planning. The principle of inclusivity guides the formulation, ensuring that diverse stakeholders, including government agencies, local communities, and non- governmental organizations, actively participate in identifying vulnerabilities and proposing adaptive strategies. Furthermore, the approach is multifaceted, encompassing comprehensive vulnerability assessments, rigorous climate science, and an understanding of the islands' socio- economic dynamics. By aligning the NAP with existing national development frameworks, the methodology seeks to create a seamless integration of climate adaptation measures into broader policy agendas. INTRODUCTION The Adaptation Communication (ADCOM) of Antigua and Barbuda played a crucial role in the formulation of the NAP for the twin-island nation. This milestone achievement marked the initiation of a strategic and comprehensive approach to address the impacts of climate change. The ADCOM serves as a foundational document, established to adhere to the reporting requirements outlined in the Paris Agreement and its Enhanced Transparency Framework (ETF). By aligning with these international standards, Antigua and Barbuda demonstrated its commitment to transparent and accountable climate action. One of the key contributions of the ADCOM was its role as a repository of information. It systematically introduced and outlined the primary climatic drivers affecting Antigua and Barbuda, providing a comprehensive understanding of the environmental challenges the nation faces. This knowledge base was essential for informed decision-making and prioritization in the development of the NAP. Furthermore, the ADCOM went beyond merely identifying challenges; it delved into the consequences of these climatic drivers. The document also demonstrated the nation's commitment to addressing climate change by presenting a detailed overview of both ongoing and planned initiatives. Importantly, the ADCOM contributed to the understanding of the adaptation framework within the context of Antigua and Barbuda. By elucidating the intricacies of the nation's responses to climate change, it offered valuable insights into the overall landscape in which these adaptation measures were situated. This contextual understanding was crucial for the formulation of the 2 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan NAP as it ensured that the strategies proposed were not only effective but also tailored to the specific needs and challenges of Antigua and Barbuda. Furthermore, the execucng of the NAP process for Ancgua and Barbuda epitomized a dedicated commitment to a consultacve and cooperacve approach, marked by comprehensive stakeholder engagement. This process was characterized by the accve parccipacon of an expansive array of stakeholders, comprising both local and internaconal actors from the public and private sectors. At the core of this inicacve was a purposeful drive to bring together representacves from various sectors, including government agencies, private enterprises, non-governmental organizacons, and community leaders. This comprehensive engagement approach aimed to capture a wide range of perspeccves and insights, fostering a deep understanding of the unique challenges and opportunices, and priorices associated with climate adaptacon in the context of Ancgua and Barbuda. Furthermore, inclusion of internaconal stakeholders also played a pivotal role in facilitacng the exchange of best praccces, the infusion of specialized expercse, and the potencal for financial support. INTRODUCTION 3 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan INTRODUCTION Figure 1: The National Adaptation Plan Process for the National Adaptation Plan Development for Antigua and Barbuda (UNFCCC, 2012) 4 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan INTRODUCTION Table 1: Steps under each of the Elements of the Formulation of the National Adaptation Plans (Source: UNFCCC, 2012) I.3. Legal Basis The 2015 version of the Environmental Protection and Management Act2 (EPMA) brought about a significant transformation by transitioning the Division of Environment into the Department of Environment (DOE) while also expanding its role. This expansion included the incorporation of the Sustainable Island Resources Framework Fund3 (SIRF Fund) within its mandate. Subsequently, the 2019 version of the EPMA replaced the previous Act, entrusting the DOE with vital responsibilities such as overseeing the coordination and execution of cross-border environmental agreements, establishment, and administration of a viable financial mechanism 2 An Act to provide for long-term environmental protection and management, to establish effective administrative responsibilities for environmental management, to undertake and coordinate environmental management and related activities, and to incorporate international environmental treaty obligations into national and legal matters. 3 A national environmental funding facility initially set up as a Special Fund through the Finance Administration Act of 2006, Section 42 (1) (a) to support environmental management and climate adaptation and mitigation. 5 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan to support environmental stewardship, and management of governmental initiatives pertaining to climate change, sustainable development, as well as environment and natural resource management. Building upon this foundation, the year 2021 saw the introduction of the Paris Agreement Regulations4, designed to complement, and reinforce the provisions of the 2019 version of the EPMA. These regulations exhibit a specific focus on enhancing adaptability in the face of climate change. This focus is especially evident in sections that pertain to the proficient management of greenhouse gases5 (GHGs) and other pollutants that impact both human and ecosystem resilience. Moreover, the regulations extend their purview to encompass climate change risk management and adaptation, emphasizing a comprehensive approach to addressing the challenges posed by a changing climate. Additionally, vital to the development of the NAP, were various key policies, regulations, and plans. These include the 2015 Government of Antigua and Barbuda (GoAB) Medium Term Development Strategy (MTDS)6, the National Physical Development Plan of 2015, the draft Building Code for the Organization of Eastern Caribbean States (OECS), the Coastal Management Plan of 2016, the Policy Framework for Integrated Adaptation Planning and Management of 2002, the National Comprehensive Disaster Management Policy and Strategy, and nonetheless, the EPMA of 2015. INTRODUCTION 4 A legally binding international treaty on climate change. It was adopted by 196 Parties at the UN Climate Change Conference (COP21) in Paris, France, on 12 December 2015. 5 A type of gas, such as carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), and nitrous oxide (N2O), that can trap heat in the Earth's atmosphere. 6 Ministry of Finance and Corporate Governance. 2015. Medium-Term Development Strategy 2016 to 2020. https://www.oneplanetnetwork.org/sites/default/files/antigua_barbuda_medium_term_development_strategy.pdf 6 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan I.4. National Circumstances Geographic Context The nacon of Ancgua and Barbuda, consists of two islands with a combined area of 170 square miles (108 mi² for Ancgua and 62 mi² for Barbuda), is highly suscepcble to the effects of climate change due to its geographical locacon at 17.1 degrees North and 61.5 degrees West, which causes the nacon to be prone to the effects of climate change that can adversely impact the public and private sectors. The climate of these islands is moderately arid and tropical maricme, characterized by a dry season spanning from January to June and a wet season from July to December. Over the period from 1995 to 2021, the region has encountered 15 hurricanes and 14 tropical storms, making these weather events the INTRODUCTION primary climacc risks. Following closely are droughts, with 14 instances occurring between 2000 and 2020, categorized as severe, serious, moderate, and slight. The Small Island Developing State (SIDS) of Ancgua and Barbuda has also suffered from the adverse impacts of rising sea levels and elevated land and sea surface temperatures. Historical data shows an average annual temperature of 25.3°C from 1901 to 2016, along with an average annual precipitacon of 2,468.2 mm. Due to the islands' low-lying topography, it is projected that by 2060, approximately 20 km² of land in Ancgua and 15 km² of land in Barbuda will be lost due to rising sea levels, according to the Representacve Concentracon Pathway (RCP) 4.5 scenario outlined by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). Under various RCP scenarios, sea surface temperatures are anccipated to increase by a maximum of 2.7°C. Furthermore, General Circulacon Models (GCMs) predict an 18% rise in the intensity of category 4 and 5 hurricanes for Ancgua and Barbuda, compared to the intensity observed over the past three decades. Specifically considering the RCP 4.5 scenario, it is forecasted that between 2040 and 2069, there will be nine years of drought, signifying an 8% escalacon7 in the severity of droughts. However, a mulc-model scenario indicates a potencal increase of up to 23% in drought severity. 7 DOE. 2022. Adaptation Communication for Antigua and Barbuda. https://unfccc.int/sites/default/files/ACR/2022-07/ATG%20- %20UNFCCC%20Adaptation%20Communication%20-%202022-06-29%20-%20Final.pdf 7 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Addiconally, Ancgua's terrain is a combinacon of coral and ancient volcanic formacons, characterized by its relacvely flat landscape, except for the hilly southwest region, which includes the Shekerley mountains. The highest point on the island is known as Boggy Peak. Along its coastline, one can observe a jagged shoreline punctuated by numerous bays and rocky headlands, surrounded by vibrant coral reefs. Geologically, Ancgua can be divided into three discnct zones, running in a northwest to southeast direccon. These zones encompass the southwest volcanic region, which coincides with the island's only significant topographical feature—the central alluvial plain—and the northeast limestone area. In contrast, Barbuda, located 40 kilometers due north of Ancgua, is a low-lying limestone island. The Barbuda highlands present a discnccve landscape, marked by cavernous formacons and sinkholes that add to the island's unique geological character. The Barbuda highlands present a discnccve landscape, marked by cavernous formacons and sinkholes that add to the island's unique geological character. Notably, the island hosts the Codrington Lagoon on its western edge, which is surrounded by coral, shelly, and semi-crystalline limestone formacons. Although, it has been affected by breaches due to events like hurricane Irma, it remains the largest lagoon in the Eastern Caribbean and holds the status of a Ramsar Wetland of Internaconal Importance. It is also home to the largest frigate bird sanctuary in the encre Eastern Caribbean region. Ancgua, Barbuda, and the nearby Redonda Island are interconnected by the Barbuda bank, an INTRODUCTION extensive underwater plasorm spanning an area of approximately 3,500 square kilometers. This geographical linkage further contributes to the rich natural diversity and ecological significance of the region. Economic Context Ancgua and Barbuda have a dynamic and diversified economy with tourism and financial services at its core. The nacon's economic landscape centers on tourism, a vital contributor to both its GDP and employment. With its priscne beaches, cultural atraccons, and favourable climate year- round, the country draws tourists from around the globe, parccularly through cruise ship arrivals and upscale resorts. With tourism, Ancgua and Barbuda has developed a financial services sector, encompassing offshore banking and internaconal business corporacons, which generates substancal revenue through fees, licenses, and taxes. However, the economy faces vulnerabilices, including suscepcbility to external shocks such as hurricanes and its reliance on internaconal tourism, making it sensicve to global economic fluctuacons. Social Context Ancgua and Barbuda is characterized by a unique social context shaped by its historical, cultural, and economic influences. The country, with a populacon of approximately 97,000 as of 2021 has made significant strides in various social aspects, including gender issues. However, like many nacons, it concnues to grapple with certain social challenges. 8 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Gender issues and context in Ancgua and Barbuda are mulcfaceted. The nacon has witnessed substancal progress in promocng gender equality, with women accvely parccipacng in various spheres of life, including policcs, educacon, and the workforce. This progress can be atributed to legal frameworks and policies that promote gender equity. For instance, the 2015 Gender Equality Act seeks to eliminate discriminacon on the grounds of gender in both the public and private sectors. Despite these advancements, gender disparices persist, parccularly in the economic sphere. Women concnue to face challenges in accessing equal opportunices for leadership posicons and equal pay for equal work. The tradiconal gender roles that have shaped Ancguan and Barbudan society for generacons are scll prevalent in some segments, affeccng women's empowerment and economic independence. Furthermore, issues related to gender-based violence remain a concern in the country. Inicacves have been undertaken to combat this problem, including the establishment of the Directorate of Gender Affairs, which aims to address gender-based violence, promote women's rights, and engage men and boys in gender equality efforts. However, challenges in enforcing exiscng legislacon and providing adequate support services for survivors persist. In the broader social context, Ancgua and Barbuda are known for their rich cultural heritage and INTRODUCTION vibrant tradicons. The country celebrates its African, European, and indigenous Amerindian roots through music, dance, and various cultural fescvals. Tourism is a major economic driver, and the hospitality industry plays a crucial role in shaping the social fabric of the nacon, bringing together people from diverse backgrounds. Addiconally, the country's history of Bricsh colonialism has leu an imprint on its social dynamics. English remains the official language, and elements of Bricsh culture are evident in governance, educacon, and the legal system. However, the nacon has also forged its own idencty, blending these influences with its Afro-Caribbean heritage. I.5. Vision and Goals The vision of the NAP for the twin-island nation of Antigua and Barbuda is to support the global efforts on adaptation described in the Paris Agreement by enhancing adaptive capacity, strengthening resilience, and reducing vulnerability to the adverse effects of climate change, specifically among both the local public and private sectors, and areas. To achieve this, four (4) key outcomes were formulated, each tailored to meet the critical requirements of climate adaptation for the twin-island nation. These outcomes and their associated deliverables have been substantiated through a validation process involving rigorous stakeholder consultations and thorough desk reviews. 9 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Outcome 1: Adaptation baselines are established through data collection, compilation, and comprehensive climate change risk mapping. Outcome 2: Stakeholders are engaged in the consultative adaptation planning process. Outcome 3: Vulnerability Risk Assessment and Adaptation Plans are developed for the Public Sector and Private Sectors using a learning-doing capacity-building approach. Outcome 4: Sustainable financing and workforce training strategies are developed to facilitate NAP implementation in the Public, NGO, and Private sectors. Upon the fulfilment of these key outcomes, there will be: Data Mapping for Adaptation The Environmental Impact Monitoring and Assessment System (EIMAS) will undertake an extensive mapping of the data collected throughout the National Adaptation Plan (NAP) Process. This data mapping initiative will cater to the needs of various stakeholders, including planning agencies and financial institutions. By providing a detailed overview of climate-related data, this effort will permit key sectors to gain further understanding of climate risks. They will be equipped to identify and implement suitable measures for adaptation planning. INTRODUCTION Enhanced Recognition of Adaptation Requirements The private sector and non-governmental organizations (NGOs) will be enabled to recognize the adaptation requirements outlined in the Antigua and Barbuda Paris Agreement Regulations. This recognition will facilitate the development of skills necessary for conceptualizing and executing projects. It will also result in tangible proof of concepts that exemplify the successful implementation of NAPs, thus resulting in the growth of adaptation initiatives. Updated Workforce Training for Climate Change Antigua and Barbuda will make important changes to how they train their workforce about dealing with climate change. This transformation will involve the integration of training modules tailored for adaptation. Knowledge Sharing and Supportive Mentorship Antigua and Barbuda will provide mentorship and support to other small islands within the Organization of Eastern Caribbean States (OECS) sub-region. These mentoring efforts will be particularly valuable as these islands embark on their respective National Adaptation Plan (NAP) journeys. Adherence to Reporting Obligations under the Paris Agreement: 10 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan The approved NAP will be communicated to the UNFCCC as Antigua and Barbuda’s Adaptation Communication per the Paris Agreement Article 7.10. I.6. Defining Sectoral Boundaries Through the process to develop the Antigua and Barbuda NAP, the activities were surrounded around addressing the adaptation needs of Antigua and Barbuda, which are centered around: i.) coastal areas strengthening; ii.) water conservation; ii.) food, water, and energy security; iv.) populating baseline data; and v.) financial resources, and to ultimately contribute to the Global Goal on Adaptation (GGA)8. In alignment with these needs, the NAP was strategically designed to focus on those needs and engage in adaptation planning processes and supporting implementation by developing national climate assessments with climate resilient sector plans for six (6) sectors, along with critical cross-cutting issues, such as women, youth, persons with disabilities, the elderly, ethnic communities, and other marginalized groups – to identify appropriate strategies, incorporating priority actions into the NAP, and conducting technical studies in preparation for implementation of new climate regulations, along three (3) local area adaptation plans tailored to specific areas within Antigua and Barbuda. These plans specifically targeted key sectors and local areas that have been identified as particularly vulnerable to the adverse impacts of climate change and were used to support the development of the NAP. The sectors and areas are as follows: INTRODUCTION The Culture and Historical Sites Sector This sector is responsible for preserving, promoting, and celebrating the rich cultural heritage and historical landmarks of the country. This includes maintaining and showcasing traditional practices, art, music, and festivals, as well as managing and conserving important historical sites, monuments, and artifacts that hold significance to the nation's history and identity. Food Security The food security sector focuses on ensuring a consistent and reliable supply of safe, nutritious, and affordable food for the population. This involves promoting sustainable agriculture, improving distribution networks, enhancing local food production, and implementing policies to reduce food vulnerabilities and ensure access to food for all residents. Infrastructure and Housing The infrastructure and housing sector covers the developing and maintaining essential public facilities, transportation systems, utilities, and housing infrastructure. This includes constructing 8 UNFCC.2021. The Adaptation Committee Considers Methods to Review the Global Goal on Adaptation. https://unfccc.int/news/the-adaptation-committee- considers-methods-to-review-the-global-goal-on-adaptation?gclid=CjwKCAjwo9unBhBTEiwAipC117ZJTD_qf2d9_ev4OolfGuw8xoxE1dwkNA7-qoQA0IXE3nMu- ezP_hoCwAgQAvD_BwE 11 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan and improving roads, bridges and/ or culverts, water supply systems, energy networks, and ensuring the availability of adequate and quality housing for the population. Water The water sector in Antigua and Barbuda encompasses the management, distribution, and conservation of water resources, including both freshwater and wastewater systems. This sector involves collaboration among government agencies, utility providers, and stakeholders to ensure reliable access to clean water for domestic, agricultural, and industrial purposes. However, the country faces challenges such as water scarcity, infrastructure maintenance, and the impact of climate change on water availability. To address these issues, the country is implementing strategies to enhance resilience, such as those posited within the Sectoral Adaptation Plan (SAP) for the water sector. This includes improved water resource management, the development of infrastructure for storage and distribution, and the adoption of sustainable practices. By taking proactive measures to adapt to climate-related changes, Antigua and Barbuda aims to ensure the long-term sustainability and reliability of its water sector. Tourism INTRODUCTION The tourism sector addresses the promotion and management of the country's tourism industry. This includes marketing the destination, maintaining tourism infrastructure, managing accommodations, organizing events, and creating experiences that showcase the natural beauty and cultural heritage of the islands. The sector plays a crucial role in the economy by generating revenue, creating jobs, and contributing to development. Finance The finance sector prioritizes the managing financial services, institutions, and activities within the country. This includes banking, insurance, investment, asset management, and other financial services. The finance sector plays a vital role in facilitating economic growth, supporting businesses and individuals with financial needs, and contributing to the overall stability of the economy. Wholesale and Retail The wholesale and retail sector emphasizes the sustainable distribution, sale, and trade of goods to consumers. This sector involves purchasing products from manufacturers or suppliers in bulk (wholesale) and then selling them to individual customers (retail) through various outlets such as shops, supermarkets, markets, and online platforms. The sector plays a crucial role in ensuring 12 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan the availability of a wide range of goods to meet consumer needs and preferences, contributing to economic activity and employment within the country. Local Area Adaptation Plans Local Area Adaptation Plans in Antigua and Barbuda are responsible for outlining strategies and actions to address climate change impacts at the community level. These plans focus on enhancing resilience, managing risks, and promoting sustainable development within specific local areas of the country. The areas of interest are i.) Airport and Fitches Creek, ii.) Jolly Harbour to Johnsons Point, iii.) St. John’s City. INTRODUCTION 13 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan CHAPTER 1: CLIMATE HAZARDS, RISK AND VULNERABILITIES CHAPTER 1: CLIMATE HAZARDS, RISKS AND VULNERABILITIES 14 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan 1. Climate Hazards, Risks, and Vulnerabili=es
1.1. Historical and Present Climate Trends Historic Climate Trends Throughout the 20th century, increase in mean surface temperatures in the Caribbean approached 1°C, largely driven by an increase in daily minimum (night-time) temperatures and a decrease in the range of mean daily temperature.9,10 The rate of change of 20th century surface temperatures in the Caribbean reached a maximum of 0.3°C per decade in the 1990s. In the first CHAPTER 1: CLIMATE HAZARDS, RISK AND VULNERABILITIES decade of the 21st century, temperature increase in the Caribbean accelerated to 0.7°C per decade. Over the same period, sea level rise in the Caribbean ranged from 10 to 20 cm, contrasted with the global average of 10 cm. Increased evaporation from the ocean surface was also observed in the global tropical regions and parts of the tropical north Atlantic.11 During the latter part of the 20th century, there was notable increase in the total annual precipitation. Consequently, this led to higher daily rainfall intensity, an increase in the maximum number of consecutive dry days, and a rise in the frequency of heavy rainfall events. Given the inherent vulnerability to climate change, it often becomes challenging to detect significant changes until well after they occur. Nevertheless, examining historical changes can provide valuable insights into what may be expected in the future. Present Climate Trends The average daily atmospheric temperature in Antigua is 26.9°C. There is little variation in daily temperatures between summer and winter months; the warmest and coolest months are August and February, with average daily temperatures of 28.3°C and 25.2°C, respectively. Daytime temperatures above 33°C and below 22°C are seldom recorded.12 The average sea surface temperatures in Antigua and Barbuda’s coastal waters is 27.6°C. Like air temperature, there is little yearly variation; the months with warmest and coolest sea surface temperatures are September and February, with average sea surface temperatures of 28.9°C and 26.2°C, respectively. SST in the Caribbean spanning the years from 1982 to 2016 reveals a consistent warming trend, with SST increasing at an annual rate ranging from 0.01°C to 0.04°C. Notably, the warming trend is more pronounced in specific areas, particularly in the eastern Caribbean, extending into the eastern tropical Atlantic. This information underscores the region's 9 Climate changes in the greater and southern Caribbean by B. Singh, 1992 10 Observed climate variability and change by Folland, 1992 (IPCC) 12 http://www.antiguamet.com/Climate/Our_Climate.html and https://www.weather-atlas.com/en/antigua-and-barbuda-climate#climate_text_1 15 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan vulnerability to rising temperatures and highlights the need for climate resilience strategies and adaptation measures.13 Rainfall in Antigua and Barbuda follows a unimodal distribution pattern in line with the general patterns observed across the Caribbean region. The wet season, which correlates with the Atlantic Hurricane Season, spans June to December and accounts for approximately 2/3 of the total yearly precipitation. Antigua receives approximately 1100 mm of rainfall in the low-lying areas each year, and up to 1300 mm in the hilly south-west. Average yearly rainfall in Barbuda is slightly less, at approximately 900 mm. The wettest and driest months are typically October and March, respectively. CHAPTER 1: CLIMATE HAZARDS, RISK AND VULNERABILITIES Drought is a recurring circumstance in Antigua and Barbuda; at least one serious or severe drought has a 28.9% probability of occurrence in one year, an 81.8% probability of occurrence over 5 years, and is a near certainty (96.7% probability of occurrence) in a 10-year period.14 The nation’s depleted groundwater reserves and the absence of naturally occurring surface water creates critical water shortages when compounded by consecutive low-rainfall years. The trade winds blow from the east/northeast with varying strength and consistency throughout the year. The trade winds are steadiest and slowest in the summer months and have an average surface speed of 8 to 10 kph. In the winter months the trade winds are stronger but intermittent, with variable speeds reaching up to 25 kph. Strong trade winds are associated with a lack of precipitation while weak trade winds can transport moisture and rain and develop into tropical storms under the right conditions. Trade winds also carry particles of dust and sand long distances. Tropical dust storms during the Atlantic Hurricane Season are often associated with dry, low-pressure areas and an absence of tropical storms.15 Throughout the year, average wind speeds in Antigua and Barbuda are approximately 20 kph. The interannual variation in the trade winds is strongly influenced by the North Atlantic Oscillation and the El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO). Since the 1950s, Antigua and Barbuda have experienced a gradual sea-level rise of 1.6 to 2.0 millimeters (approximately 0.06 to 0.08 inches). It is important to note that this phenomenon is part of a broader global trend. Over the last two decades, the pace of global sea-level rise has quickened significantly, averaging approximately 3.3 millimeters (about 0.13 inches) annually from 1993 to 2008.16 Hurricane Season and Ocean Warming In the Atlantic Basin, the past two decades have witnessed a notable increase in hurricane activity, resulting in a higher frequency of named storms and hurricanes impacting countries across the 13 https://repositorio.cepal.org/server/api/core/bitstreams/c94d4b38-7867-4049-b500-e2ca09f21e1e/content 14 http://antiguamet.com/Climate/STATS/anu_drought.html 15 https://www.nationalgeographic.org/encyclopedia/wind/ 16 https://www.climatehotmap.org/global-warming-locations/antigua-and-barbuda.html 16 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan region, including Antigua and Barbuda. These hurricane seasons have displayed variability in terms of both intensity and the number of storms. Some seasons have seen more powerful hurricanes, while others have witnessed fewer or weaker storms. Notably, the 2021 Atlantic hurricane season stood out as the third most active on record, ranking behind only the seasons of 2017 and 2005. Remarkably, this marked the sixth consecutive year of above-average hurricane activity in the Atlantic. The 2021 season even commenced ahead of schedule in May, marking the seventh consecutive year in which a storm formed before the official start date of the season on June 1st. Such heightened activity led to the unique occurrence of two consecutive hurricane seasons fully exhausting the list of 21 storm names designated for the year. CHAPTER 1: CLIMATE HAZARDS, RISK AND VULNERABILITIES
1.2. Future Climate Scenarios Global Climate Models (GCMs) serve as fundamental tools for assessing the impact of greenhouse gases on the Earth’s climate, which were chosen from the 5th Phase of the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CIMP5). Global climate change projections from the CIMP5 unanimously predict that climates will continue to change through to the end of the current century. While valuable for broad-scale analyses, the inherent coarse spatial resolution of GCMs limits their ability to accurately depict regional climate conditions on smaller landmasses, such as Antigua and Barbuda. Consequently, GCMs are less suitable for informing localized adaptation strategies and conducting precise risk assessments at a regional level. Regional Climate Models (RCMs) can offer improvements over GCMs by applying similar methodologies as GCMs but over a limited region of the Earth. Based on these models, it is unanimously suggested that mean global surface temperature will increase anywhere between 1.1°C to 2.6°C under RCP4.5 and 2.6°C to 4.8°C under RCP8.5. It is “virtually certain” that there will be more frequent hot extremes and fewer cold extremes, and that heat waves will occur at a higher frequency and longer duration. These temperature increases will likely be accompanied by an increase of intensity and frequency of extreme precipitation events over tropical regions, and significant changes to seasonal precipitation patterns. Sea levels are expected to continue rising due to melting polar ice and seawater thermal expansion. Ocean warming through the end of the century is a near certainty. It is suggested that ocean acidification will increase anywhere between 38 to 41% in an RCP4.5 future, and 100 to 109% for an RCP8.5 future. These impacts are expected to disproportionately impact tropical regions. Downscaling High resolution RCM simulations, at approximately 12km, were modelled from three (3) GCMs in the CIMP5 experiment, over the Caribbean, and were procured to inform the National Adaptation Planning Process. The HadGEM-ES (Hadley Centre Global Environmental Model – Earth System), 17 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan MPI-ESM-LR (Max Planck Institute Earth System Model – Low Resolution) and MRI-CGCM3 (Meteorological Research Institute Climate Global Climate Model version 3) models were selected for their ability to capture the full range of future responses, including low and high temperature responses and wet and dry precipitation biases. Thus, enabling the stakeholders of Antigua and Barbuda to prepare for a multitude of future climates at all possible futures. The models were produced under two Representative Concentration Pathways (RCPs) scenarios, RCP4.5 and RCP8.5. Downscaled projections for Antigua and Barbuda predict increases of 1.4°C to 2.0°C to the average daily minimum temperature by the end of the century under RCP4.5 and increases of 2.9°C to 3.4°C by the end of the century in an RCP8.5 scenario. Heat wave days are projected to increase CHAPTER 1: CLIMATE HAZARDS, RISK AND VULNERABILITIES from the historical average of 18 per year to 100 to 135 by mid-century and 120 to 200 nearing the end of century in an RCP4.5 future. An RCP8.5 future projects that more than 2/3 of the year will qualify as heat wave days nearing the end of the century.17 Daily temperatures could rise an additional 3°C to 4°C during heat spells in an RPC8.5 future. In all downscaled models, up to 10% fewer heatwave days are predicted in Antigua’s hilly southwest region. The three downscaled models differ in their precipitation response under future climate. The HadGEM2-ES and MPI-ESM-LR RCMs both forecast overall reductions in precipitation of up to 2mm/day by the end of the century in an RCP 8.5 future. The MRI-CGCM3 RCM indicates a slight increase in overall precipitation under future climate, driven by increases in wet-season precipitation. Independent of their individual biases, all three regional models predict an increase in the number of consecutive dry days and a shift in the seasonality patterns of precipitation across the region under future climates.18 Sea levels are expected to continue rising due to melting polar ice and seawater thermal expansion. Ocean warming through the end of the century is a near certainty. It is suggested that ocean acidification will increase anywhere between 38 to 41% in an RCP4.5 future, and 100 to 109% for an RCP8.5 future. These impacts are expected to disproportionately impact tropical regions. 17 ImageCat Heat Waves netCDF 18 CEFAS Final Report V1_1 18 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan 180 160 140 120 Rise in cm 100 80 60 40 20 CHAPTER 1: CLIMATE HAZARDS, RISK AND VULNERABILITIES 0 2020 2040 2060 2080 2100 RCP 4.5 RCP 8.5 Figure 2: Predicted rise in sea level in Antigua area (a) (b) Figure 3: Antigua’s coastline changes under 0.13 m Sea Level Rise (SLR) scenario (a), and 1.45 m Sea Level Rise (SLR) scenario (b) The HadGEM2-ES and MPI-ESM-LR RCMs suggest a decrease in the number of consecutive wet days, and an increase in frequency of future droughts in both modelled futures. The HadGEM2-ES model predicts drought years will be 28% (RCP4.5) or 42% (RCP8.5) drier by the end of the century, whereas the MPI-ESM-LR model predicts drought years to be 4 to 6% wetter over the mid-century before drying by up to 20% approaching the end of the century. In contrast, the MRI-CGCM3 RCM shows little change in precipitation totals but an increase in year-to-year variability. Drought frequency and magnitude projections from each of the downscaled models are summarized in Tables 1 and 2, respectively. Table 1:Projected change in frequency of drought, expressed as the number of drought years within the 30-year mid-century (2040-2069) and end-century (2070-2099) intervals. Results are presented by RCM to showcase the extreme variability in precipitation projects among climate models. 19 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan MODEL RCM MID CENTURY END OF CENTURY 4.5 +7 +7 HadGEM2-ES 8.5 +6 +17 4.5 +3 +2 MPI-ESM-LR 8.5 +2 +16 4.5 0 +10 MRI-CGCM3 8.5 +6 +2 Table 2: Projected change in magnitude of drought, expressed as a percentage change within the 30-year mid-century (2040 – 2069) and end-century (2070-2099) intervals. Results are presented by RCP to showcase the extreme variability in precipitation projections among climate models. CHAPTER 1: CLIMATE HAZARDS, RISK AND VULNERABILITIES MODEL RCM MID CENTURY END OF CENTURY 4.5 +29% +28% HadGEM2-ES 8.5 +11% +42% 4.5 -4% +20% MPI-ESM-LR 8.5 -6% +10% 4.5 +15% +2% MRI-CGCM3 8.5 +3% 0 The intensity of hurricanes in the categories 4 and 5 range for Antigua and Barbuda is projected to rise by 18%, according to General Circulation Models (GCMs), when compared to the intensity observed over the past 30 years. This forecast is linked to an anticipated increase in sea surface temperatures, with a maximum rise of 2.7oC under various Representative Concentration Pathway (RCP) scenarios. Higher sea surface temperatures directly contribute to the escalation of hurricane intensity. The heightened temperatures in the sea play a crucial role in amplifying hurricanes, especially those classified as more severe. This occurrence is attributed to the augmented energy input from warmer waters, facilitating the formation and persistence of potent storms.
1.3. Climate Risks and Hazards Climate change poses a significant threat to countries of varying sizes, with Small Island Developing States (SIDS) being particularly vulnerable. It is therefore crucial to understand the potential climate-related risks and hazards affecting their habitats, populations, critical infrastructure, and economies. Decisions related to adaptation, mitigation, and infrastructural development depend on assumptions about the future under the influence of climate change. Extreme Temperatures 20 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Antigua and Barbuda generally experience a warm tropical climate, but extreme temperatures can lead to prolonged periods of excessive heat, increasing the risk of heat-related illnesses. These temperature extremes can have far-reaching consequences, affecting agriculture by reducing crop yields and causing food shortages due to disrupted growing seasons. Additionally, extreme heatwaves pose health risks, particularly for vulnerable populations. Moreover, extended periods of extreme heat, combined with reduced rainfall, can contribute to drought conditions. The heightened demand for electricity during extreme heat can strain the power grid, leading to potential power outages during peak periods. Drought CHAPTER 1: CLIMATE HAZARDS, RISK AND VULNERABILITIES Antigua and Barbuda face ongoing challenges related to drought, primarily driven by decreased precipitation and rising temperatures. The risk of drought is notably higher during El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO) events. The islands rely on small reservoirs and surface water resources, but overextraction has led to saltwater intrusion in groundwater sources. The impact of drought has been historically significant, with events like the 1983 – 1985 drought prompting the purchase of the Crabbs desalination plant in 1987. Another severe drought occurred in 1993 – 1994. Notably, the pan-Caribbean drought from 2013 – 2016, as documented by Dale Destin’s Blog, was the worst drought on record for Antigua and Barbuda, with 2015 standing out as the driest year ever recorded. The probability of experiencing at least one moderate, serious, or severe drought each year is 45.1%, increasing to 95.0% over a five-year period. For severe droughts alone, the probability is 15.1% in a single year and 56.0% over five years. Rainfall Variability Inter-annual variability in Caribbean climate is influenced strongly by the El Nino Southern Oscillation. El Nino episodes usher in warmer and drier conditions during the late wet season, while La Nina episodes bring colder and wetter conditions. These patterns align with the islands' distinct wet and dry seasons, with the wet season spanning from June to November, coinciding with the Atlantic hurricane season. During this period, frequent rainfall is often intensified by tropical storms and hurricanes, which can result in flooding and landslides. Additionally, non- tropical cyclone rainfall events, characterized by their extremity, can exacerbate flood impacts, especially in areas with development choices favouring impervious surfaces and inadequate drainage infrastructure. These challenges highlight the importance of climate adaptation measures in the face of global concerns about changing temperatures and their potential to disrupt rainfall patterns and intensify precipitation events. Sea Level Rise 21 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Antigua and Barbuda, like many Caribbean SIDS, confront yet another pressing threat in the form of sea level rise. Numerous coastal areas have been reclaimed to accommodate essential infrastructure, seaports, hotels, and road networks. The escalation of sea levels amplifies the vulnerability of these vital installations, heightening the risk of damage and disruption. In the past, Barbuda residents primarily depended on shallow groundwater as their main source of drinking water. However, in recent times, a significant shift has occurred, with many residents now allocating a substantial portion of their monthly income to purchasing bottled water. This transition is largely driven by diminishing trust in the quality of the groundwater supply. CHAPTER 1: CLIMATE HAZARDS, RISK AND VULNERABILITIES Storm Surge and Hurricane Season Like many Caribbean countries, Antigua and Barbuda is prone to hurricanes, especially during the Atlantic hurricane season, which spans from July 1st to November 30th. This vulnerability stems from the country’s location within the heart of the Atlantic hurricane belt, where cyclones and hurricanes mostly occur throughout August and September. Historically, these months have seen approximately 79% of the storms. From 1851 to 2011, the nation has experienced 93 storm systems, with 44 of them intensifying into hurricanes.19 The occurrence of hurricanes is strongly linked to the ENSO, with more frequent hurricane activity associated with La Nina events and less frequent events in El Nino years. In recent years, Antigua and Barbuda have experienced the impact of several notable storms, resulting in heavy rainfall, flooding, and substantial damage to buildings, infrastructure, and the natural landscape. Among these storms, Hurricane Irma stands out as one of the most formidable Atlantic hurricanes ever recorded. In September 2017, it passed just north of Barbuda as a devastating Category 5 hurricane, causing catastrophic destruction on the island and significant damage to Antigua. Additionally, a particularly unusual event occurred just before the turn of the century when Hurricane Lenny, a late-season phenomenon in November 1999, made a lasting impact as it traversed westward across the Caribbean, leaving a trail of significant consequences for the islands.20 Table 3 : Recent Hurricanes that affected Antigua and Barbuda. Direct hit indicates the cyclone’s center passed over land or at the most 15 nautical miles from land; Hit indicates the cyclone centre passed between 15 & 65 nautical miles from land; Brushed indicated the centre passed between 65 & 105 nautical miles from land. Year Hurricane names Wind Speed (mph) Status 2017 Maria 161 Brushed 2017 Jose 150 Hit 19 http://country-profiles.geog.ox.ac.uk 20 Antigua and Barbuda Health and Climate Change Profile 2020.pdf 22 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan 2017 Irma 178 Hit 2014 Gonzalo 77 Direct Hit 2010 Earl 104 Hit 2000 Debby 80 Hit 1999 Lenny 127 Direct hit 1999 Jose 96 Direct hit 1998 Georges 115 Direct Hit The impact of climate change on tropical cyclone characteristics is uncertain and varies by basin. However, there is a consensus that future climate changes could modify the nature of tropical cyclones, potentially leading to increased intensity and altered behaviours such as stalling over CHAPTER 1: CLIMATE HAZARDS, RISK AND VULNERABILITIES land21. Based on global climate models, there is a predicted shift in hurricane characteristics, with a potential decrease in the overall number of hurricanes but an increase in their intensity. This suggests a higher likelihood of encountering category 4 and category 5 hurricanes in the future. Over time, the impact of these storms has been notable, leading to significant loss of coastal mangroves, particularly following the events of the 1980s. This loss of mangroves has resulted in reduced storm surge protection. Ocean Acidification and Sea Surface Temperature The oceans play a crucial role as vast carbon sinks, absorbing approximately one-third of the carbon dioxide emissions generated by anthropogenic activities. Ocean acidification, a consequence of increased carbon dioxide levels, poses a significant threat to marine life. It directly impairs the ability of calcifying organisms to construct their shells and skeletons, impacting crucial species like corals and shellfish. Over the past two decades, the Caribbean region has witnessed a troubling trend of decreasing pH levels in its waters, exacerbating the challenges faced by these vital marine organisms in building and maintaining their skeletal structures. Antigua and Barbuda are characterized by an impressive variety of ecosystems including terrestrial forests, scrublands and grasslands, mangrove forests, herbaceous swamps, and salt ponds, sandy. These ecosystems are increasingly at risk from chronic pressures, such as ocean warming. The projected rise in ocean temperatures is expected to amplify the scale, duration, and frequency of ocean heatwave events in the future 22. The Caribbean is identified as one of the regions likely to experience the consequences of a rising heatwave hazard, posing risks to coral reef ecosystems, including those around Antigua and Barbuda. According to ecosystem impact modelling, the nation is projected to witness a notable shift in the annual likelihood of severe bleaching events, moving from the current approximately 10% to around 60% over the 2020-2055 period under a moderate emissions scenario23. Under a high emissions scenario, the latter half of the of the 2020-2055 period is expected to have nearly a 100% likelihood of annual severe bleaching, with an average probability of around 65% across the entire period. 21 https://news.sciencebrief.org/cyclones-mar2021/ 22 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-01142-4 23 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Ecosystem impact modelling indicates that coral damage rates could potentially rise by 47% to 84% by the close of the century under a moderate emissions scenario. In a high emissions scenario, the increase could be even more substantial, engaging between 136% and 270% (Figure 1).23 CHAPTER 1: CLIMATE HAZARDS, RISK AND VULNERABILITIES Figure 4 & 5: Coral damage risk from hurricanes for different climate scenarios (RCP 4.5 & 8.5) and events (MCE, Historical, 100- year)Figure 5: Coral damage risk from hurricanes for different climate scenarios (RCP 4.5 & 8.5) and events (MCE, Historical, 100- year)
1.4. Climate Change Risk Modelling Five hazards; hurricane wind, storm surge, sea level rise, extreme temperatures, and extreme rainfall; can be considered when estimating losses and assessing various impacts related to climate change. These hazards contribute to four types of losses associated with specific events: the Maximum Credible Event (MCE), a “1% chance event”, a historic event, and the Average Annualized Loss (AAL)23. The MCE is the largest event in the Kinetic Analysis Corporation (KAC) event set to affect Antigua and Barbuda, the “1% event” is a 1% probability of occurrence in a year or a 100-year Return Period event (which means that it is expected to occur on average once in 100 years), the historic event was modelled after Hurricane Irma and the AAL represents averages from 930 events that affected the islands, or overall, the average loss per year from the Kinetic library of 14,204 events, over 1,500 years23. Each loss was calculated on a decadal basis from 2020 to 2100, and for the period of 2030 to 2100, the value of the building exposure data has been 23 National Adaptation Plan Climate Change Risk Modelling Project, 2021 24 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan modified to account for the rising sea and frequent (10-year) coastal flooding, which can be considered a fifth type of loss. These were modelled under two climate scenarios, Representative Concentration Pathways (RCPs) 4.5 (Stabilize) and 8.5 (High Emissions). Table 4 summarizes the results of the modelled losses by decade for the high emissions (RCP 8.5) and stabilization (RCP 4.5) climate scenarios for the general building stock. The values indicate physical damage to buildings (direct losses) and are expresses in millions of U.S. dollars. Table 5 provides the value of buildings modelled to be exposed to sea level rise and frequent (10% annual probability, 10-year event) coastal flooding. Table 4: Direct Building Losses ($M USD) by decade for the high emissions (RCP8.5) and stabilization (RCP4.5) climate scenarios) Event Climate Hazard 2020 2030 2040 2050 2060 2070 2080 2090 2100 CHAPTER 1: CLIMATE HAZARDS, RISK AND VULNERABILITIES Type Surge $292 $292 $292 $292 $292 $292 $292 $292 $292 High Emissions Wind $182 $205 $247 $287 $376 $498 $662 $791 $976 Historic TOTAL $473 $451 $516 $573 $710 $909 $1,160 $1,342 $1,626 Surge $292 $245 $257 $276 $286 $312 $313 $328 $336 Stabilize Wind $182 $205 $226 $257 $277 $313 $315 $313 $297 TOTAL $473 $451 $483 $534 $563 $624 $628 $642 $633 Surge $466 $461 $550 $628 $752 $900 $1,107 $1,228 $1,351 High 1 in 100 Year Emissions Wind $3,335 $3,571 $3,939 $4,203 $4,614 $4,984 $5,314 $5,493 $5,711 TOTAL $3,801 $4,032 $4,490 $4,831 $5,366 $5,885 $6,420 $6,721 $7,062 Surge $466 $449 $498 $571 $616 $687 $717 $759 $796 Stabilize Wind $3,335 $3,566 $3,771 $4,029 $4,167 $4,360 $4,367 $4,358 $4,263 TOTAL $3,801 $4,015 $4,269 $4,600 $4,783 $5,047 $5,084 $5,117 $5,059 Surge $1,278 $1,306 $1,442 $1,547 $1,712 $1,897 $2,094 $2,180 $2,276 High Wind $8,090 $8,116 $8,183 $8,203 $8,225 $8,196 $8,088 $7,963 $7,846 Emissions TOTAL $9,368 $9,422 $9,626 $9,750 $9,936 $10,093 $10,182 $10,143 $10,12 MCE 2 Surge $1,278 $1,290 $1,367 $1,472 $1,533 $1,624 $1,659 $1,700 $1,729 Stabilize Wind $8,090 $8,132 $8,166 $8,200 $8,196 $8,194 $8,131 $8,057 $7,974 TOTAL $9,368 $9,422 $9,534 $9,672 $9,728 $9,818 $9,790 $9,756 $9,703 Surge $34 $27 $34 $40 $51 $68 $91 $102 $129 High Emissions Wind $104 $113 $126 $136 $155 $176 $200 $216 $236 TOTAL $138 $139 $160 $176 $206 $244 $291 $317 $365 AAL Surge $34 $26 $30 $36 $39 $47 $47 $51 $55 Stabilize Wind $104 $112 $120 $129 $135 $143 $143 $143 $139 TOTAL $138 $138 $149 $165 $174 $190 $190 $194 $194 Table 5: Building stock ($M USD) exposed to Sea Level Rise and nuisance flooding by decade for the high emissions (RCP8.5) and stabilization (RCP4.5) climate scenarios. Event Climate Hazard 2020 2030 2040 2050 2060 2070 2080 2090 2100 Type High Sea level rise - $108 $128 $184 $251 $320 $415 $561 $689 SLR Emissions and frequent Stabilize flooding - $95 $108 $129 $165 $203 $262 $314 $366 To represent each loss type in Table 4, a series of charts were created to depict the modelled changes in losses overtime. Additionally, a series of maps were developed to visualize how the modelled losses, across the islands, vary spatially. Figure 3 and Figure 4 present examples of these results for which are provided in a website hosted at http://climateriskmap.environment.gov.ag. 25 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan CHAPTER 1: CLIMATE HAZARDS, RISK AND VULNERABILITIES Figure 6: Total losses (Millions USD) for the Maximum Credible Event (MCE) for the stabilization climate scenario (RCP4.5) Figure 7: Future anticipated probable losses from building damage for storm wind (left) and surge (right) in a Maximum Credible Event (MCE) Various maps and charts illustrate anticipated losses throughout the region due to storm surge, hurricane wind, and frequent coastal flooding from sea level rise. The findings reveal that, despite wind damage expected to surpass surge damage in average annualized losses, surge exposure is projected to increase with climate change.23 Additionally, the value of buildings exposed to 26 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan frequent flooding, as outlined in Table 5, is expected to significantly rise and will be concentrated in low-elevation coastal areas. In the Caribbean, the coastal building infrastructure exhibits a dual nature, combining high value with increased vulnerability to climate change compared to internal island regions affected by high winds. The predominant exposure and risk factors lie within the islands, indicating that stringent code enforcement measures could prove highly cost-effective. Exploring potential solutions, such as the construction of buildings at elevated locations, the development of elevated structures, and the implementation of strategic land use, holds significant promise in substantially diminishing future losses. CHAPTER 1: CLIMATE HAZARDS, RISK AND VULNERABILITIES 27 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITY 28 2. Future Climate Vulnerabilities and Impacts Antigua and Barbuda face an increasingly precarious future due to climate change, with profound vulnerabilities and impacts anticipated across the twin-island nation. Rising sea levels pose a significant threat to the low-lying coastal areas, exacerbating the risk of saltwater intrusion into freshwater sources; extreme weather events, including hurricanes and tropical storms, are likely to become more intense and frequent, leading to heightened risks of flooding, landslides, and infrastructure damage impacting a number of key sectors; warming climate conditions may disrupt ecosystems, and may exacerbate water scarcity issues. CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES Figure 8: Climate change impacts on sectors (Source: Adaptation Communication for Antigua & Barbuda, 2022) .
2.1. Agriculture and Food Security The Agricultural sector in Antigua and Barbuda is small, contributing ~3% to the national GDP and ~1.8% of the total employed labour force24. Resultingly, the national food system is heavily reliant on imports, with ~80% of food products being imported25 26. The trade and planning sectors, in addition to the agricultural and fishing sectors, therefore, play a large role in the national food system and food security. 24 Government of Antigua and Barbuda. 2021. Voluntary National Review of Antigua and Barbuda 25 United States Department of Agriculture. 2015. Caribbean Basin. Retail foods. Eastern Caribbean Regional Report CB1526. Global Agricultural Information Network. 26 Government of Antigua and Barbuda. 2021. Voluntary National Review of Antigua and Barbuda. 29 Agricultural production in Antigua is challenged by labour shortages and high material costs, limited freshwater availability, and the legacy impacts of colonization on soil quality and land degradation. Continued expansion of residential and tourism developments reduces the availability of suitable farming land, further stunting growth within the sector. In Barbuda, shallow sandy soil coupled with limited water availability have inhibited agricultural expansion. Limited agriculture has been practiced outside of Codrington, mostly as backyard farming and grazing livestock on open ranges. Climate models predict that Antigua and Barbuda will experience rising air and sea surface temperatures, sea level rise, changes to rainfall patterns, and increasingly intense hurricanes, each of which will likely have significant implications for the agriculture and fisheries sectors, and overall food security. Increased temperatures will threaten food security by reducing crop performance and restricting the types of species of fruits and vegetables that can be grown locally. Rises in ocean temperature are expected to weaken the resilience of fish stocks and marine ecosystems. The projection of CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES increasing drought conditions will place further demand on freshwater production, leading to increased costs associated with local food production. Rises in ocean temperature are expected to weaken the resilience of fish stocks and marine ecosystems. Recent evidence has demonstrated that fishes in warmer water have a smaller maximum body size and smaller size at first maturity27. These fish are also likely to suffer higher natural mortality rates. Shifts in fish stock distribution are also expected with rising sea temperatures and ocean acidity as climate change pushes surface temperatures beyond temperature and salinity limits. Drought is prevalent in Antigua and Barbuda, and agricultural production is already strained by freshwater access. Increased drought conditions will place further demand on freshwater production, leading to increased costs associated with local food production. Correspondingly, it is expected that sea levels will rise in coming decades, leading to saltwater intrusion in low-lying land and aquifers, and high levels of salt in agricultural soil and groundwater resources. High salt content in soil and irrigation water can cause significant reduction in crop yields. Hurricanes represent the largest risk to food security in Antigua and Barbuda. A storm can cause direct damage to crop through high winds, waterlogging, and flooding. Livestock can be at risk of drowning in high-water or injury by projectiles and collapsing infrastructure. Damaged power infrastructure can also create electrocution hazards. A single strong event has the potential to cause the loss of entire fields of produce, and damage to equipment and infrastructure that persists beyond the hurricane season. Hurricane events can also contribute significant disruptions to the fishing sector through damage incurred to supplies and materials, and disruptions to marine 27 Cheung, William & Lam, Vicky & Pauly, Daniel & Herrick, Samuel & Sumaila, Rashid. (2011). Climate Change Impacts on the Biophysics and Economics of World Fisheries. Nature Climate Change. 1. 10.1038/nclimate1301 30 ecosystems. Turbulent weather can destroy coral reef habitats, redistribute sediments, and cause fish to seek refuge in deeper water, reducing the available catch. Damage to transportation infrastructure incurred during a hurricane can result in substantial disruptions to the local and international supply chain by preventing the importation and distribution of food products and essential supplies, decreasing food availability and in turn increasing local food prices.
2.2. Health Human health in the country is seriously threatened by climate change, which is also expected to exacerbate biological and health-related problems. Climate change is predicted to raise the average annual temperature as well as the severity and frequency of heat waves, putting more people at risk for heat-related illnesses. Heat waves can be a serious threat to the health of people, animals, and even plants. They can cause fatalities, destroy livelihoods, reduce labour productivity, CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES increase demand for and the cost of cooling options, and worsen environmental health indicators. The health sector is strongly impacted by climate change, which increases the risk of respiratory and vector-borne diseases, leaving Antigua and Barbuda susceptible to outbreaks of disease. The chikungunya epidemic started in Antigua and Barbuda in 2014, reaching a peak in 2015 with 1005.5 cases per 100,000 people (PAHO, 2020). In 2015 and 2016, the Zika epidemic had a significant impact on the countries of Latin America and the Caribbean. By the end of 2016, there were 509.6 Zika cases per 100,000 people in Antigua & Barbuda (PAHO, 2020). Following the chikungunya and Zika epidemics, dengue fever, which is endemic to Antigua and Barbuda, reclaimed its position as the most common mosquito-borne disease. Antigua and Barbuda had 396.1 cases per 100,000 people in January 2020 (PAHO, 2020). The Covid-19 Pandemic's effects have shown how sensitive and exposed the sector is to medical and biological challenges. According to UNDP, UNICEF, and UN Women (2020), the pandemic led to an increase in health sector spending that is projected to be 0.5% of GDP, including the hiring of foreign disease specialists and the execution of a comprehensive quarantine and testing program. As hospitals operate around the clock, the health sector also uses a lot of energy and water, putting a strain on economic resources. 31
2.3. Education Climate change has a direct impact on the educational sector in Antigua and Barbuda. The primary impacts of climate change on education arise from the effects of extreme weather events, such as heavy rains accompanied by flash floods, strong winds by storms, and increased temperatures with short to long-term consequences. Storm intensity in the Caribbean has increased due to warming conditions over the Atlantic Ocean, with Antigua and Barbuda witnessing its first Category 5 storm on record in 2017. Hurricanes are known to seriously harm infrastructure and homes, notably having a significant effect on the education sector, displacing students from the classroom for long periods at times. Schools are also used for shelter by the public during these high-intensity storms. Recovery from such disruptions frequently takes several months, if not much longer. As a result, economic output, quality of life, and opportunities for students to attend regular school are all significantly reduced. In the past, many storms that hit the country were of modest intensity, usually tropical storms, or categories 1–3 hurricanes. Schools are not constructed to resist the effects of category 4 and 5 CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES storms, which are anticipated to increase by 80% in the Atlantic Ocean in the next 80 years (NRDC, 2019) Flooding from heavy rainfall tends to disrupt school operations around the island. These disruptions, albeit short-term, have a negative impact on students’ development, as classes are postponed until regular activities resume. Increase temperatures have forced schools around Antigua and Barbuda to explore ways to adapt to the changing climate by introducing cooling technologies to maintain a comfortable and healthy environment for its students. 32
2.4. Cultural and Historical Sites Climate change is one of the most pressing global challenges of the 21st century. Its impacts are felt in various sectors, including culture and heritage sites, which play a crucial role in preserving the historical, social, and cultural identity of nations. Antigua and Barbuda, a twin-island nation in the eastern Caribbean, boasts a diverse cultural and historical heritage that spans indigenous traditions, colonial influences, and a unique Afro-Caribbean heritage. The country's culture and heritage sites encompass historic buildings, ruins, archaeological sites, museums, and cultural festivals. These sites not only attract tourists but also foster a sense of identity, pride, and social cohesion among the local population. The compact size of our islands significantly heightens the risk posed to cultural and heritage sites by severe winds, excessive precipitation, and storm surges resulting from tropical storms and hurricanes, with Barbuda being particularly susceptible. Such extreme weather events can cause severe damage to heritage sites, including structural collapse, flooding, and landslides. The historic forts, such as Fort James and Fort Barrington, for example, are at risk of deterioration and CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES destruction due to these hazards. Moreover, there are other significant perils that possess the potential to cause devastating consequences to the people, economy, infrastructure, and environment. Antigua and Barbuda's culture and heritage sites, many of which are located along the coast, are particularly vulnerable to sea-level rise and coastal erosion28. Rising sea levels can cause permanent inundation of low-lying sites and lead to the erosion and destruction of coastal structures, including historic buildings and archaeological remains. For example, Betty's Hope, a significant historic sugar plantation, and the Nelson's Dockyard, a UNESCO World Heritage site, are at risk of being submerged or damaged due to these climate impacts. While some of these threats may be deemed infrequent phenomena, historical records highlight their past impacts and ongoing menace. Such calamities have profoundly hindered the islands' progress, as evidenced by the recent havoc wreaked by Hurricanes Irma and Maria in 2017. The unprecedented devastation caused by these superstorms surpassed normal expectations and had a severe impact on the fragile cultural sectors. Table 6: Climate Change Impacts (Source: Murphy, 2023). Climate indicator Climate Change Risk Impacts on Cultural Heritage Sites Moisture Intense rainfall; Flooding; Groundwater Damage to water systems; changes; Changes in soil chemistry; Physical changes to porous build Changes in humidity cycles materials and structures due to rising dampness; Mould 28 Murphy, Reginald. 2023. Sectoral Adaptation Plan Culture. https://environment.gov.ag/assets/uploads/attachments/a012b-cultural-sector-sap.pdf 33 Temperature Extreme events; Heat waves; Thermal stress to building Hurricanes; Storms; Agro-industry materials; Productivity decline; issues Conservation issues Sea-level rise Coastal flooding; Sea water intrusion Inundation of coastal heritage sites and archaeological sites; Coastal erosion; Population shift and disruption of communities; Loss of coastal infrastructure Wind Wind driven rain with salt and sand Moisture penetration of porous walls of historical sites; Loss of unsupported walls of historical structures Desertification Drought; Heatwaves; Fall in water Erosion of sites and structures; table; Loss of surface water Settlement issues on older unreinforced buildings; Loss of topsoil; Increase in free ranging CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES livestock; Abandonment of arable land; Loss of cultural memory.
2.5. Tourism The tourism industry is also negatively impacted by hurricanes/tropical storms, extreme rainfall, sea level rise, and higher temperatures. The sector, being the main economic sector, is very vulnerable to hurricanes because many accommodations and attractions are located on the coast, with risks associated with strong winds and surges usually impacting these infrastructures. Most tourist amenities are dependent on international travellers, but hurricanes and tropical storms can limit or stop international travel. This causes cancellations which can negatively impact on the financial capabilities of the sector. Rainfall is projected to decrease. This will add pressure on water resources which is necessary to ensure the comfort of tourists. At the other extreme, flooding events may cause cancellations which can, again, limit the economic capabilities and viability of the tourism sector. Sea level rise makes the sector vulnerable because rises in sea level cause beach loss and coastal flooding. Many locations and activities on and along the coastline become susceptible to losses and damage, particularly accommodations and restaurants. High temperatures because the demand for cooling is projected to increase, creating increased energy demand. 34
2.6. Wholesale and Retail In recent times, the international community has increasingly recognized the significant implications of climate change on global economies, ecosystems, and societal structures. Within this context of heightened climate consciousness, Antigua and Barbuda, a small island state located in the Caribbean, faces unique challenges and vulnerabilities resulting from the adverse effects of climate change. These challenges permeate various sectors of the economy, including the crucial wholesale and retail industry, which plays a vital role in promoting the country's socio- economic progress. The country's economy is predominantly composed of small businesses, and much of the population is employed in the private sector (The Inter-American Development Bank, 2013). The wholesale and retail trade sector, which contributed approximately 12% of the GDP in 2021, holds significant importance in the supply chain. This sector involves a two-tier distribution system, where goods manufactured are sold in large quantities (wholesale) to wholesalers, who then sell them to retailers, ultimately reaching the end customers. The wholesale and retail sector, CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES therefore, represents a critical link between production and consumption. Antigua and Barbuda's critical infrastructure is concentrated in the vicinity of St. John's, Antigua, including facilities for power generation, drinking water, and air and sea transport. However, these systems lack alternatives or redundancies, making them highly vulnerable. The main seaport for the islands is in St. John's, while Antigua has one international airport and two smaller airfields on Barbuda. The deep-water harbour in the capital serves as the primary transit point for trade and handles all imported cargo. The commercial buildings within the St. John's Central Business District (CBD) are typically low-rise structures, with occasional mid-rise buildings present. Industrial regions in Antigua and Barbuda mainly consist of large warehouse storage and distribution centers, accompanied by supporting structures such as offices. The heights of these structures are typically limited to one or two stories. The wholesale and retail sectors in Antigua and Barbuda can be significantly impacted by various climate-related factors, including hurricane winds and surges, sea-level rise, extreme heat, and drought29. The small island’s status, economic reliance on limited sectors, and exposure to climate change effects underscore the pressing need for proactive measures to address vulnerabilities, enhance resilience, and promote sustainable development in the face of these challenges. 29 ImageCat & Sustainable Managers. Antigua and Barbuda’s Adaptation Plan for the Wholesale and Retail Sector. https://environment.gov.ag/assets/uploads/attachments/7b725-wholesale-and-retail-sap.pdf 35 Table 7: Climate Change Impacts on four (4) thematic areas (ImageCat, 2023) Thematic Areas Climate Change Impacts Buildings Physical damage to W&R commercial buildings and warehouses due to hurricane storm surge Physical damage to W&R commercial buildings and warehouses due to hurricane wind Physical damage to W&R assets (other than buildings) due to storm surge Physical damage to W&R assets (other than buildings) due to wind Cleaning costs Risk of employee injury/death (assessed while in the workplace) W&R Business Interruption (BI) due to damaged buildings and other assets Lifelines / Critical Infrastructure W&R BI due to accessibility issues caused by storm surge W&R BI due to accessibility issues caused by wind CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES W&R BI due to loss of power W&R BI due to outages to water utilities W&R BI due to outages to telecommunication systems Supply Chain Disruptions to supply chains due to impacts on airport operations Disruptions to supply chains due to ships bypassing the islands during storms Disruptions to supply chains when hurricanes affect overseas suppliers Disruptions to supply chains due to impacts on port operations Economic Businesses impacted indirectly through customers being affected Reduction of consumer discretionary spending impacting sales Lost revenue when hotels are closed Forced closure Costly energy expenses during droughts and hurricanes
2.7. Finance Sector As a SIDS, Antigua and Barbuda had strong resilience to storms and droughts; nevertheless, as of 2023, the country is very vulnerable to climate change and natural disasters. 10% of middle-class and low-income families are spending more money because of the effects of climate change. Moreover, the increased frequency of hurricanes from 15-20 years to now, 1 in 5 years has now 36 caused an increase in insurance by over 300% since 1990 and our budling code has since been revised to include climate-friendly solutions which also comes as additional cost to homeowners. The topic of climate finance is important due to the nature of the small, undiversified, and usually heavily dependent on a single sector such as tourism, and due to the magnitude of their structural issues, Antigua and Barbuda and other SIDS's existing resources and capacities are insufficient to meet such economic and climate challenges. In Antigua and Barbuda, 88% of financial institutions lack a vision or management statement that addresses climate change. 50% of organizations do not consider the impact of climate change in their annual plans, priorities, or actions. Effective partnerships and collaboration among stakeholders, including government agencies, private sector entities, civil society organizations, and international development partners, are vital for mobilizing sustainable finance and leveraging additional resources. CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES
2.8. Infrastructure and Housing The building stock in Antigua and Barbuda is projected to suffer losses of up to US $451 million (EC $1218.9 million) by 2030 due to the impacts of tropical cyclones (storm surge and high winds), sea level rise (SLR), and flooding, which could result in additional losses of US $108 million (EC $291.9 million) under a worst-case emissions scenario using the Representative Concentration Pathway (RCP) 8.5. The deterioration of energy infrastructure and road networks will be accelerated by gradual changes in precipitation and rising temperatures, driving up the cost of ordinary maintenance and repairs and disrupting daily life for residents. Housing Housing in low-income regions often sustains the most damage, especially if they are in a floodplain (e.g., St. John's City, York's, Cashew Hill, McKinnon's, and Jolly Harbour). Exposure of building materials to moisture, excessive salinity, and sunlight may accelerate deterioration and compromise the structural integrity of Antigua and Barbuda's housing sector. The lack of regulation or licensing for contractors and builders in Antigua and Barbuda as a profession makes compliance with the building code even more problematic for the housing industry. 68% of households in Antigua rely on APUA water as their main water supply that is piped into their homes. Desalination supplies the majority of Antigua's APUA water, with surface water catchments providing water when and if catchments are supplied by rainy season rainfall. When water levels fall below permissible extraction levels, catchments like Potworks Dam frequently go offline, especially during the dry season. 37 Barbuda has limited groundwater reserves with groundwater supplies being extremely sensitive to saline intrusion, surface contamination, storm surge, and sea level rise. At least 13% of homes are covered by insurance in Antigua. Low insurance uptake in Barbuda may be a result of choice or limited accessibility. Additionally, there seems to be a widespread lack of information and awareness of policyholder responsibilities on both islands. The high cost of premiums, especially for homes made of materials other than concrete (premiums are higher for homes made of wood), and the long wait times for pay-outs after disasters because they are based on an in-person damage assessment is another reason why this may be low. Public perceptions of insurance are also influenced by a lack of confidence in insurance providers, as well as incidents of fraud and financial disasters. Due to the significant risk to lenders, there are few funding options available for homeowners to improve resilience, particularly if their homes are in flood-prone areas or made of poor-quality materials. Wastewater Due to a near total reliance on septic tanks and soak-aways, many of which are shoddily built and CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES neglected, the water table and downstream coastal waters have been contaminated in both Antigua and Barbuda due to the lack of centralized wastewater treatment infrastructure. Localized flooding occurs in St. John's City due to the results of both rainfall and improperly treated sewage effluent that overflows from septic tank systems and into roads before draining into St. John Harbour and flowing into the ocean. Sewage treatment in Barbuda involves a traditional septic tank plus a deep soak-away system to contain huge quantities of effluent to accommodate the sluggish percolation rates typical of limestone soils. Roads The flat geography of Barbuda slows down the natural water drainage of roads, and there are no storm-water drainage facilities or culverts on the island. Antigua’s high soil moisture content and inadequate drainage present a challenge for major arteries, leading to foundation and sub-base structural failures and pavement distress in the form of potholes, patching, alligator cracking, edge cracking, ravelling, rutting, and settlement. The recently resurfaced Sir George Walter Highway and Friars Hill Road sustained significant damage because of a big rainfall event in November 2020, including the production of large potholes and asphalt stripping that revealed underlying pipes. Some sections of the roads in Antigua just have open drains close to highways that empty into bodies of water, while other areas have stormwater drainage systems. Some roadways are not properly drained, which allows water to spill off onto the adjacent property. Due to the huge volume of trash in places with dense populations, much of which ends up in drains and culverts, 38 drainage systems are unable to function efficiently during periods of heavy rainfall, which results in localized floods. SLR and coastal erosion are especially prone to affect roads in Antigua that are located near the coast. Sea wall protection for roads and the entire coastline is being destroyed by SLR and coastal erosion. Barbuda's roadways along the lagoon, including those in Codrington village, are particularly vulnerable because of their low elevations. Codrington also lacks the full level of coastline protection that it once had because of the sandbar break caused by Hurricane Irma in 2017. Energy Antigua and Barbuda depend on conventional fossil fuels for its energy supply, and imports around 96% of the petroleum products (diesel and oil) required to meet the nation's energy demands. Two power plants in Antigua, APC and Blackpine, generate 60.3 MW and 30.4 MW of energy, respectively. CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES Due to deteriorating infrastructure, inadequate maintenance, and unauthorized grid connections, the electricity system experiences significant inefficiencies and high system losses (24% relative to net generation). The grid encounters difficulties in its ability to recover from extreme events in addition to ongoing operational difficulties. Grid supplies were disrupted after Hurricane Luis (1994) for three months and again after Hurricane Gonzalo (2014) for two weeks. Some houses have backup diesel generators, particularly in Barbuda, because they were provided in the aftermath of Hurricane Irma. Solar PVs are susceptible to damage from hurricanes because flying debris and wind pressure can cause the panels to break. Minimizing gaps between panels can lower the risk to solar installations, and quick dismount devices can be built on smaller installations so that panels can be taken down and stored before a hurricane.
2.9. Water Sector Water resources and water supplies are highly exposed to variability and change in weather and climate conditions. Climate hazards including extreme weather events and episodic droughts disrupt both the quantity and quality of water available for supply, as well as impacting on the water provision infrastructure and operations. Climate change will result in changing hazards, weather patterns, and climate conditions, compounding existing risks. Underlying vulnerabilities in the water sector, for example, competition over resources, leakage, pollution, and poor land use management, act to exacerbate the impacts of climate hazards. The key social and economic sectors of tourism and agriculture, as well as key public services, are highly exposed to risks relating to water and suffer when supplies are interrupted or affected by 39 extreme climatic hazards. These hazards already exist and will worsen as the effects of climate change arise. Surface and groundwater sources are highly vulnerable to drought as evidenced in the 2013-2016 drought in which surface water source output dropped to zero, and groundwater production halved. This resulted in an almost total reliance on desalination. APUA estimated that additional fuel costs incurred for every month without surface water availability are EC$1 million/month. Lack of surface water also impacts food security and, during the 2013-2016 drought, a decrease of 40% in meat production was observed. Climate change projections indicate that although there is likely to be a decrease in average precipitation, extreme weather events that lead to intense rainfall events may become more frequent. Sea level rise may also exacerbate existing saline intrusion in coastal aquifers. Barbuda is extremely prone to drought, which also worsens the level of salinity of groundwater due to unsustainable abstraction. Barbuda is also highly exposed to storms and hurricanes, which bring heavy rainfall, flooding, storm surge, strong waves, and high winds. The extensive sand- mining activities on the island have also reduced natural flood protection. CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES Due to the flat topography of the island, storm surges can cause saltwater contamination of the aquifer. Storm surges and high winds can also damage water production and distribution infrastructure and cause loss of power at RO plants and pumping stations, thereby resulting in further delays with respect to restoring services. While desalination is relatively invulnerable to drought conditions, the desalination process is dependent on a consistent supply of electricity and the ability to abstract sea water from the nearshore environment – both of which are susceptible to the impacts of extreme weather events. Case Example: Category 5 Hurricane Irma in 2017 devastated infrastructure across Barbuda, resulting in a complete evacuation of the island. The main desalination plant at the ferry port (100,000 US gallon/day production) was damaged by Irma. The plant is located on the coast and was flooded internally to a depth of around 1.5 m. The plant’s motors were flooded and required rebuilding, and the electrics were damaged. The building roof was damaged, but the main structure remained intact. The roof has been replaced using similar construction (wooden and galvanized steel). Water supply from the RO plant was restored to Codrington within two months. The pump house was destroyed, and the electricity was damaged. It is understood that it was a wooden structure, which has now been replaced with a concrete structure, including a concrete roof, in the same location. The water transmission mains, which are buried, were generally unaffected by Irma, but damage was incurred to secondary pipes and connections, which typically run over the surface. Currently, the plant is fully operational again, but the backup generator has not been repaired. 40 2.10.Biodiversity and the Natural Environment While the decline in biodiversity is primarily attributed to invasive alien species and human interference in Antigua and Barbuda, climate change also plays a major role. Antigua and Barbuda are highly susceptible to chronic climate pressures, such as rising sea levels, fluctuations in ocean temperatures, extreme climate events like hurricanes, ocean acidification, sea level rise, heat waves and shifting rainfall patterns (Health & Climate Change Country Profile, 2020). These pressures disrupt the delicate balance within ecosystems, endangering both biodiversity and food security. According to the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization (U.N. FAO), 22.7% or about 10,000 hectares (ha) of Antigua and Barbuda is forested. Antigua and Barbuda's forests contain million metric tons of carbon in living forest biomass. The forest ecosystems are susceptible to the influences of changing temperature and precipitation patterns. Recurrent drought periods experienced have resulted in diminished vegetation cover, consequently heightening the risk of CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES soil erosion and the sedimentation of coastal waters when rainfall resumes. Terrestrial habitats become more prone to forest fires, particularly in areas impacted by the invasive lemongrass species. Native seagrasses are susceptible to sediment runoff, human-induced destruction, and the impact of storms. Rising sea levels pose a threat, and a potential decrease in light availability within the seagrass beds and coral reefs (Department of Environment, 2020; Antigua and Barbuda Coral Reef Report Card, 2015), while also entailing the intrusion of saline water into freshwater reserves, coastal erosion, and the destruction of wildlife habitats While temperature increases are not expected to significantly harm mangroves and wetlands, they can cause damage to coral reefs, leaving mangroves vulnerable to greater wave action. Sea level rise poses the most substantial threat to mangroves, while coastal systems in general (e.g., seagrass beds and coral reefs) are projected to experience submergence, coastal flooding, and erosion. Coastal erosion endangers the nesting of marine turtles on beaches, jeopardizing their survival. Projections estimate annual reductions in tourism's contribution to Antigua and Barbuda's GDP ranging from US $102 million in 2050 to over US $340 million in 2080, based on a mid-range sea-level rise scenario (Convention on Biological Diversity, n.d.). Ocean acidification, resulting from the escalating concentrations of atmospheric CO2, engenders supplementary hazards for coral reefs. Projections indicate that oceanic pH levels may decline by 0.3-0.4 units below pre-industrial levels within the next century (Wood et al., 2008) 41 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan 2.11.Women, Youth, Persons with Disabilities, the Elderly, Ethnic Communities, and other Marginalized Groups Women Antigua and Barbuda experience a disproportionate number of women facing poverty and destitution. In the context of climate change, this imbalance exacerbates inequalities for women, leading to heightened vulnerability to gender-based violence, restricted mobility, decreased earning capacity, asset loss, and loss of life. It is crucial to acknowledge and address these challenges to effectively plan and implement adaptation strategies. One starting point involves integrating gender equality concerns into key sectoral policies, particularly in areas like protected zones and regulations governing small craft businesses, where women are prominently involved. CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES In line with a knowledge, attitude, behaviours, and practices survey conducted by UN Women and IISD, stakeholders in national consultations emphasized the necessity of retraining government employees. This retraining is essential to anticipate technological shifts and the evolving needs of industries, with a specific focus on incorporating considerations related to gender and climate change. Additionally, there is a recognized need for further data collection on gender and social factors in the context of adaptation in Antigua and Barbuda. The findings suggested that any adverse effects of climate risks on women's livelihoods would have widespread consequences for both social and economic aspects. This is particularly notable because women often lead households and form the majority of the workforce in government and the tourism sector. Various coping mechanisms were identified in response to job losses stemming from hurricanes, storms, droughts, floods, flash floods, and the impacts of COVID-19, particularly in the protected areas, finance, and infrastructure sectors. In the aftermath of climate-related events and the ongoing effects of COVID-19, women are reportedly more likely to turn to microfinancing for income support. The study focused on livelihoods within the protected areas sector, including small craft/business operators, fisheries, and tourism. Identified gaps in access within the infrastructure sector, particularly in communications, health, transportation, and utilities, need attention to diminish the vulnerability of women post-climate events. Regarding health impacts associated with climate change, these can manifest as direct, indirect, or diffused effects. In the case of Antigua and Barbuda, direct health impacts are linked to extreme weather events. Indirect effects extend to repercussions in other sectors, such as the influence on water security and safety, leading to waterborne diseases. Diffused impacts encompass mental and psychosocial health issues as well as the prevalence of non-communicable diseases. 42 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Youth in the Context of Climate Change The consideration of youth in the context of climate change is of utmost importance, especially for those aged 10 to 24. Climate change, being a global issue, affects all people, irrespective of age. It has far-reaching consequences on health, income, security, education, and other vital aspects of individuals and families. As the youth confront climate change, they face the responsibility of contemplating the implications of environmental shifts and how it will shape their futures. Moreover, the youth are the ones who will inherit the consequences of current climate actions, making it essential to empower them with the knowledge, tools, and support to navigate these challenges effectively. One critical area affected is health, particularly during adolescence. However, climate change can exacerbate poverty and food scarcity, making it challenging for adolescents to access nutritious foods. This may lead to malnutrition, obesity, and related health issues like diabetes and high CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES blood pressure. Moreover, climate change-induced anxieties about the future and its impact on the world can significantly affect mental health, especially among young people. Learning about climate change and its far-reaching consequences can be anxiety-inducing, leading to stress, depression, and emotional distress. Family life is also affected. In Antigua and Barbuda, only 33% of adolescents had parents/guardians who understood their problems and worries, and 39% had parents/guardians who knew what they were doing with their free time, indicating potential challenges in communication, and understanding between parents and adolescents. The impact of climate change extends to education as well. Extreme weather events, such as floods, hurricanes, or prolonged droughts, can disrupt the accessibility of educational institutions, especially for students in vulnerable areas. Education could be impacted by climate change if certain regions of the nation face more adverse climate effects, hindering students' access to schools and educational opportunities. Children and Youth Vulnerability to Climate Change Children are generally exceptionally vulnerable to climate change due to their specific developmental needs and physiology (e.g., risk of injury and death during extreme weather events, heat stress, vector-borne diseases, air pollution). In the Eastern Caribbean, this vulnerability is exacerbated by the fact that children are disproportionally represented among the poor. In Antigua and Barbuda, 24.3% of them are estimated to live in poverty (Voluntary National Review, 2021), which has probably increased as an outcome of the COVID-19 pandemic. Likewise, young people face specific vulnerabilities. Youth (15-24) unemployment in Antigua and Barbuda is estimated at 25.7% (Ibid.). Young men are more likely to be unemployed than any other group. Faced with unemployment, climate change and now the pandemic and its myriad of impacts, 43 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan young people are also affected by mental health and behavioural issues. While these did not emerge solely because of the pandemic, a sharp increase has been observed since 2020. Obesity represents another growing source of concern for children and young people’s health and wellbeing. An estimated 19.1% of the adult population is affected (WHO/PAHO, 2020), which is linked to a high prevalence of diet-related non-communicable diseases (NCDs) such as diabetes. Climate change is likely to exacerbate the triple-burden of malnutrition, whereby undernutrition, micronutrient deficiencies and overweight/obesity exist simultaneously. It is expected to reduce short- and long-term food and nutrition security both directly, through its effects on agriculture and fisheries, and indirectly, by contributing to underlying risk factors such as water insecurity, dependency on imported foods, urbanization and migration, and health service disruptions. These risk factors are distributed unevenly, with some population groups (i.e., people living in poverty) experiencing greater vulnerability. As children and young people do not represent a homogeneous group, they experience climate CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES impacts differently. In addition to age, gender is one of the lenses through which to analyse the differentiated impacts that prevail. Globally, climate-related challenges facing women and girls can be worsened by overlapping issues of poverty, marginalization in decision-making, and control over land and resources. In Antigua and Barbuda, gender inequalities may be reinforced in subtle ways, such as a disproportionate representation of female employees in low-paying jobs. Similarly, women’s roles and activities in the fisheries sector tend to be in supporting low-paid onshore roles, such as fish processing, food preparation and service sector roles. Other Environmental Concerns The country’s acute vulnerability to climate-related pressures is exacerbated by locally driven environmental degradation and mismanagement of resources. Extensive development and increasing urbanization and industrialization, population growth, unsustainable agricultural practices, and the rapid growth of the tourism industry have led to significant environmental challenges, including: Water scarcity: The sustainability of safe water supplies is one of the most serious issues facing Antigua and Barbuda. With an increase in dry periods and increased demand, the country is facing regular water shortages and is now relying on desalination for freshwater. Antigua has five – soon seven - reverse osmosis (RO) plants and two water treatment plants. Barbuda has one desalination plant; however, most drinking water is shipped in through Antigua. During the drought of 2015, consumption of desalinated water reached more than 90%, compared with the normal 60%. In parallel, with sea level rise, the risk for saline intrusion has increased. Besides, due to the switch in dependence on desalinated water, metal piping systems are being corroded, resulting in significant water loss. Land degradation: Land degradation has long been a problem for Antigua and Barbuda, owing to inappropriate land use practices or the improper disposal of wastes that include wastewater and oily waste residues. 44 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Degradation of vital ecosystems: Both Antigua and Barbuda are home to extensive mangrove wetland ecosystems. In 2012, the 36 recognized wetland sites in Antigua were reported to cover 3% of the land, while the 9 mangrove wetland sites in Barbuda covered 22% of the land. Climate change is increasing their fragility, as illustrated by die-off of Hanson’s Bay wetlands on the West coast of Antigua, first observed in 2017, possibly due to hypersaline conditions (resulting from water evaporation). However, various human activities cause wetland degradation. These include deforestation (forest cover declined by 17% between 2015 and 2019) and infrastructure development. Of particular interest is the McKinnon’s Salt Pond, an ecological area that is located within proximity to farm holdings and tourism developments but however has been severely degraded by pollution influxes. In Barbuda, new tourism developments have come under considerable land use conflict given their location within or close to the Codrington Lagoon, which is a protected area and has become Antigua and Barbuda’s only Ramsar site since 2005. Loss of biodiversity: Biodiversity is an important catalyst for economic growth, through its CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES contribution to the attractiveness of Antigua and Barbuda as a tourism destination (e.g., Frigate Bird Sanctuary in Barbuda). Antigua and Barbuda’s offshore islands remain hubs for birds, lizards and four are home to the Antigua Racer snake, which is endemic to Antigua and Barbuda, and the most iconic reptile in the country. However, biodiversity has for long been impacted, historically by the sugar and cotton industries (which caused the introduction of rats and mongooses in the 19th century, leading to the extinction of various endemic species) and more recently by tourism (beachfront resorts, cruise ship and yachting industries, and new developments such as floating facilities). Extreme weather events and emerging threats from invasive species, such as the Lionfish and Giant African Snail, have also led to significant losses. Poor air quality: Rising levels of air pollution in the Eastern Caribbean are linked to increasing urbanization, polluting vehicles, and the burning of domestic waste. In Antigua and Barbuda, air quality monitoring may be undertaken at point locations, but there is no national air quality monitoring programme to provide baseline data. However, in April 2020, the World Health Organization (WHO) reported that air quality was considered moderately unsafe. The most recent data indicates an annual mean concentration of PM2.5 is 19 µg/m3, which exceeds the recommended maximum of 10 µg/m3. This is a concern as air pollutants, particularly from ozone and vehicle emissions, as well as mold and other allergens, have been recognized as important triggers for asthma. Asthma is endemic in the Caribbean, affecting almost one-third of the population in some countries. Solid waste management: Waste management is a particular challenge, due to limited land area available for disposal, lack of capacity to handle increasing volumes of waste, particularly from the tourism industry, high importation rates of food and other non-biodegradable goods, leading to a high level of waste per capita, and attitudes regarding disposal. Poor waste management is associated with air, water and soil pollution, and significantly exacerbates flooding when solid waste blocks drains. A specific challenge is illegal dumping and the unregulated disposal of hazardous wastes. There are also reports of sewage being used to put out fires at old dump sites. 45 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Sargassum seaweed: Antigua, Barbuda and Redonda have been affected by Sargassum seaweed since 2011. Sargassum blooms appear to originate off the coast of South America and have been affecting the Caribbean with varying ecological and socio-economic effects (impact on tourism). They biologically degrade upon contact with the shoreline, leading to negative impacts (while on the sea, they provide ecosystem services such as habitat for juvenile marine organisms including fish and turtles). Youth Engagement in Climate Action Antigua and Barbuda developed a Youth Engagement Strategy on Climate Action and Environmental Sustainability (YESCA) with an accompanying action plan. The YES-CA is structured based on three objectives and outcomes (transform education for sustainability; create training and employment opportunities; foster environmental stewardship); three strategic approaches CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES (institutionalizing youth participation; adopting inclusive approaches; using innovation and new technologies); and four conditions for an enabling environment (advancing policy; partnerships and resource mobilization; capacity-building; monitoring progress and evaluation). It is accompanied by an action plan and performance indicators for the period 2022- 2030, as summarized in the following graph: Figure 9: Strategy Overview of the YES-CA 46 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan The YES-CA is supported by (and supporting, complementing) a set of national policies, which identify youth engagement as key to achieving sustainable development and building Antigua and Barbuda’s resilience: Climate policies The Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs), revised in 2021, explicitly refer to the development of a Youth Engagement Strategy and Action Plan, in order to facilitate the involvement of children and youth, including the most vulnerable, and support the engagement of youth in adaptation and mitigation initiatives. A commitment from the NDCs is to expand training and skills development programmes to enable the creation of new jobs in the labour force, enhance youth employability and ensure their access to meaningful and decent work, in support of Antigua and Barbuda’s Just Transition Framework. CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES In 2016, the Government had already developed a Workforce Development Strategy, which serves to identify the enabling activities required to create a “sufficient and appropriately trained workforce” to support the implementation and achievement of the initial NDC targets. Antigua and Barbuda also committed to ensuring that Action for Climate Empowerment (ACE) becomes, as per Article 6 of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) and Article 12 of the Paris Agreement on climate change, a key cross-cutting instrument to involve all levels of society in climate action, in particular children and youth (as well as other vulnerable groups including women, the elderly and people living with disabilities) in support of all elements of adaptation. Youth Policies Antigua and Barbuda’s National Youth Policy 2021-2030 (launched in September 2021) was developed to guide the approaches that key stakeholders should adopt to enable youth development. One of the policy’s nine thematic focuses is environmental sustainability, covering the following: the Blue Economy, the Green Economy, and Climate Change Mitigation & Adaptation (climate action). The latter corresponds to eleven (11) strategies: The YES-CA is supported by (and supporting, complementing) a set of national policies, which identify youth engagement as key to achieving sustainable development and building Antigua and Barbuda’s resilience: 1) The Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs), revised in 2021, explicitly refer to the development of a Youth Engagement Strategy and Action Plan, in order to facilitate the involvement of children and youth, including the most vulnerable, and support the engagement of youth in adaptation and mitigation initiatives. A commitment from the NDCs is to expand training and skills development programmes to enable the creation of new jobs in the labour force, enhance youth employability and ensure their access to meaningful and decent work, in support of Antigua and Barbuda’s Just Transition 47 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Framework. The NDCs also include a commitment to promote environmental education to support the delivery of Antigua and Barbuda’s climate change ambitions. 2) The National Youth Policy 2021-2030, launched in September 2021, was developed to guide the approaches that key stakeholders should adopt to enable youth development. A comprehensive Action Plan, expected to be completed in 2022, will support its implementation. One of the policy’s nine thematic focuses is environmental sustainability, covering the following: the Blue Economy, the Green Economy and Climate Change Mitigation & Adaptation (climate action). Table 8: National Youth Policy's Strategies on Climate Change Mitigation and Adaptation National Youth Policy’s strategies on Climate Change Mitigation & Adaptation Strategy 1 Encourage young people to join environmental groups or organisations CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES Strategy 2 Boost climate change awareness among youth via social media Strategy 3 Integrate climate change adaptation into the school curricula Strategy 4 Mainstream climate change education into national policies and development plans Strategy 5 Offer more climate change scholarships and innovation grants to youth Strategy 6 Involve youth in the planning and implementation of environmental programmes Strategy 7 Provide arable land for more youth to engage in agricultural activities Strategy 8 Promote more tree-planting activities Strategy 9 Invest in schools’ agricultural programmes Strategy 10 Promote the 3Rs (Reduce, Re-use, Recycle) among youth Strategy 11 Create an enabling environment to bolster youth engagement in climate adaptation Education policies Neither the Education Act of 2008 nor the Draft Education Sector Plan 2013-2018 mention climate change or environmental sustainability. The only reference to the environment in the Act is the mandate given to the Ministry of Education to “increased awareness and appreciation of the natural environment of the state” in the education system. As a way of comparison, the 2021 NDCs are more specific, by including a commitment “to promote environmental education to support the delivery of Antigua and Barbuda’s climate change ambitions”. An important instrument is the 2020 National Safe School Policy, drafted as part of the Model Safe School Programme in the Caribbean, under the umbrella of the Caribbean Safe School Initiative (CSSI), initiated at a Regional Ministerial Forum in 2017 through the adoption of the Antigua and Barbuda Declaration on Safe Safety. The CSSI focuses on school safety in the context of natural disasters, including three pillars: infrastructure resilience, disaster management and resilience education (curriculum aspects). This is a priority in Antigua and Barbuda where many schools are located in hazard-prone areas. 48 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan The Elderly The elderly population in Antigua and Barbuda faces unique vulnerabilities in the context of climate change, particularly due to increasing temperatures and more frequent heatwaves. Older individuals are generally more susceptible to heat-related illnesses due to physiological changes associated with aging. For example, diminished sweat production and reduced ability to regulate body temperature make them prone to heat stress and dehydration. As temperatures rise, the risk of heat-related health issues such as heatstroke and heat exhaustion significantly increase among the elderly. Furthermore, extreme weather events, which are becoming more frequent and intense due to climate change, contribute to the disruption of the social fabric of communities. For the elderly, this disruption often translates into heightened social isolation. For instance, severe storms and flooding may damage infrastructure and transportation systems, making it challenging for older CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES individuals to access essential services and interact with their communities. Social isolation, in turn, is associated with adverse health outcomes, including mental health issues, and exacerbated chronic conditions. The intersection of health vulnerabilities and social challenges underscores the critical need to tailor climate adaptation and resilience strategies to address the specific needs of the elderly population in Antigua and Barbuda. This involves enhancing healthcare infrastructure to cope with the increased demand for medical services during climate-related health emergencies. Additionally, community support systems should be strengthened to ensure that older individuals have access to assistance, information, and social connections during and after extreme weather events. Moreover, strategies to mitigate the impacts of climate-induced social disruptions on the elderly, such as targeted outreach programs and communication networks, are essential to foster resilience and well-being within this vulnerable demographic. Persons with Disabilities (PWDs): Persons with disabilities (PWDs) in Antigua and Barbuda face a myriad of challenges, with the deleterious effects of climate change exacerbating their vulnerabilities. One prominent issue is the compromised state of existing infrastructure during extreme weather events, posing significant barriers to the evacuation and accessibility of emergency services. The implications of this are particularly dire for PWDs, who encounter substantial obstacles when attempting to navigate infrastructure that is either damaged or inadequately equipped. For instance, ramps, elevators, and other accessibility features may be rendered useless, hindering the mobility of individuals with disabilities during critical times. During climate-related events, the evacuation process becomes a formidable challenge for PWDs due to the compromised infrastructure. Safe relocation to designated areas is impeded, leaving this demographic at a heightened risk of harm. The urgency for inclusive disaster preparedness becomes glaringly evident in these circumstances. The lack of comprehensive measures 49 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan exacerbates the vulnerability of PWDs, emphasizing the need for proactive planning that takes into account the unique needs and challenges they face. Inclusive disaster preparedness involves not only accessible infrastructure but also clear communication strategies and targeted support mechanisms to ensure the safety of individuals with disabilities during crises. Furthermore, the impact of climate change extends beyond the immediate dangers posed during extreme weather events. Disruptions in healthcare services, both during and after such events, disproportionately affect PWDs, especially those with pre-existing health conditions. For example, individuals reliant on regular medical treatments or specialized care may find themselves in precarious situations when these services are interrupted. The consequences can be severe, ranging from exacerbated health conditions to life-threatening situations, underscoring the intricate relationship between climate change, healthcare access, and the well-being of persons with disabilities. CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES In conclusion, the intersection of disabilities and climate change in Antigua and Barbuda creates a complex web of challenges. From compromised infrastructure during extreme weather events to the lack of inclusive disaster preparedness and disruptions in healthcare services, PWDs bear a disproportionate burden. Addressing these issues requires a multifaceted approach that encompasses resilient infrastructure, inclusive disaster planning, and robust healthcare systems that prioritize the unique needs of individuals with disabilities. Only through such comprehensive measures can the adverse impacts of climate change on persons with disabilities be mitigated, ensuring their safety, well-being, and equal participation in society. Ethnic Communities The diverse ethnic communities in Antigua and Barbuda find themselves entwined in a complex tapestry of climate vulnerabilities, intricately connected to their cultural identity and geographical locations. One of the primary challenges faced by these communities is the imminent threat posed by rising sea levels and climate-induced changes. Coastal regions bear the brunt, leading to cultural displacement and the erosion of traditional practices that have been integral to the identity of these ethnic groups. The impact is not merely environmental but resonates deeply within the social and cultural spheres, creating a precarious balance between preservation and adaptation. Coastal ethnic communities in Antigua and Barbuda are particularly susceptible to heightened vulnerabilities arising from the twin challenges of rising sea levels and shifting climate patterns. These communities often rely profoundly on specific natural resources for their livelihoods, and any disruption in these resources due to climate-induced changes carries profound economic and cultural implications. For example, changes in fish migration patterns or the degradation of coastal ecosystems can disrupt longstanding fishing practices, impacting the economic sustenance and cultural traditions of these communities. 50 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan The intricate relationship between the environment and cultural heritage necessitates a nuanced strategy for safeguarding the identity of these ethnic communities. A comprehensive approach is required, seamlessly integrating climate adaptation measures with sustainable resource management and community resilience efforts. Such an approach acknowledges the interdependence of cultural practices, economic activities, and the natural environment. It involves not only adapting to the changing climate but also ensuring the sustainable use of natural resources, thereby safeguarding the cultural heritage that is deeply embedded in the relationship between these communities and their surroundings. Preserving the cultural fabric of these ethnic communities requires an understanding of the dynamic interplay between climate vulnerabilities and traditional practices. It involves empowering these communities with the knowledge and tools needed to adapt to changing environmental conditions while preserving their unique cultural identities. By fostering a balance between adaptation, sustainability, and resilience, Antigua and Barbuda can navigate the intricate CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES challenges posed by climate change and ensure that the rich tapestry of cultural diversity continues to thrive amid evolving environmental realities. Other Marginalized Groups: Low-income populations and residents of informal settlements in Antigua and Barbuda grapple with a complex array of vulnerabilities intricately intertwined with the impacts of climate change. The challenges faced by these individuals are multifaceted, arising from both their high dependence on climate-sensitive sectors and the limited resources available to them. This combination exacerbates the difficulty of adapting to the evolving environmental conditions, creating a layered vulnerability that requires careful consideration. Informal settlements, often characterized by a lack of proper infrastructure and situated in vulnerable locations, face heightened risks during climate-related events. These risks include flooding, resource scarcities, and inadequate access to emergency services, further amplifying the challenges faced by low-income populations. The vulnerability of these communities is not solely a result of environmental factors but is deeply rooted in socioeconomic disparities, making the need for targeted interventions even more pressing. Addressing the vulnerabilities of marginalized groups in Antigua and Barbuda demands a comprehensive and holistic approach. This includes the implementation of targeted economic policies to uplift low-income populations and reduce their dependence on climate-sensitive sectors. Community-driven adaptation strategies are crucial, as they empower residents to actively participate in the decision-making processes that affect their lives. Moreover, infrastructural improvements are essential to fortify resilience within informal settlements, ensuring that they can withstand the impacts of climate change and enhance their adaptive capacity. 51 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan A key element of this comprehensive approach is recognizing the interconnectedness of social, economic, and environmental factors. It is not enough to address climate vulnerabilities in isolation; instead, a holistic strategy must consider the broader context of poverty, inequality, and inadequate infrastructure. By doing so, Antigua and Barbuda can foster resilience within these marginalized communities, promoting an equitable response to the challenges posed by climate change. This approach not only mitigates the immediate impacts of environmental changes but also addresses the underlying factors that contribute to the vulnerability of low-income populations and informal settlements. CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES 52 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan 2.12.Local Areas Airport and Fitches Creek Area The Airport and Fitches Creek Local Areas in Antigua is situated along the northern coast of the island and is bordered by roads, communities, and wetlands. It is a flat region with some small hills scattered around. The area hosts various points of interest, including residential communities, educational institutions, the V.C. Bird International Airport, military facilities, restaurants, villas, and historic sites, making it a popular destination for tourists. The Fitches Creek watershed is one of the six major watersheds in Antigua. The coastal zone of the area is part of the Northeast Marine Management Area (NEMMA), a protected marine CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES environment known for its fringing reefs and seagrass beds, but erosion caused by oceanic conditions and hurricanes poses a threat to these ecosystems. The region is at risk of extreme weather events, with projected worsening impacts in the coming decades. The area has experienced severe flooding in the past, with hurricanes and tropical storms causing significant damage to inland areas like the Piggott’s community. Storm surge projections indicate the vulnerable areas at risk during such events. The area has also been affected by coastal and flash flooding, with flash floods occurring more frequently in response to heavy rainfall events. In the Airport/Fitches Creek area, there are challenges concerning water availability, primarily caused by frequent droughts. To address this issue, residents have taken measures such as installing personal water storage tanks and buying water delivered by trucks. It's important to note that the airport receives a higher priority in water supply because of its essential nature. The weak spots within the critical infrastructure sector of this area that cause this sector to be vulnerable include a lack of documentation of disaster plans and protocols. Many facilities, including piers and jetties, and roadways situated along the coastline are susceptible to flooding and damage from hurricanes/tropical storms and sea level rise. Sediment resuspension in seawater from hurricanes/tropical storms puts RO plants at risk, and the lack of climate-proofing measures in place at RO plants enhances this vulnerability. High amounts of rainfall cause low- lying roads to be susceptible to flooding and inadequate bridges and drains in this area are not equipped to handle stormwater from watercourses during extreme rainfalls well. High amounts of precipitation and high temperatures also increase the likelihood of vector-borne disease outbreaks putting increased pressure on medical facilities. On the other hand, extremely low amounts of precipitation also cause the critical infrastructure of the area to be vulnerable. High temperatures and low rainfall are a leading contribution to drought which results in weakening of the airport terminal tarmac, and as well as pavement cracking and splitting. Lack of rainfall also increases the cost of desalination to fulfil water requirements. This increases energy demand, but solar panels provide only partial relief for electricity demand. Increasing sea level rise makes critical infrastructure vulnerable in this area 53 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan because of beach erosion. It also causes underground metal pipes and other metallic installations to face a risk of corrosion. The effectiveness of drainage systems may diminish due to sea level rise, leading to more frequent flooding due to inundation. Elevated temperatures make critical infrastructure vulnerable because it increases the demand for cooling which increases the pressure on utilities, and it increases the dependency on RO facilities. High temperatures also make the critical infrastructure sector vulnerable because it creates added pressure on the water scarcity issue in Antigua and Barbuda which limits health facility functionality and increases the risk of educational institutions’ closure. Thus, the critical infrastructure sector of the Fitches Creek/Airport local area is vulnerable to hurricanes/tropical storms, rainfall extremes on both ends of the spectrum, sea level rise, and high temperatures. The residential sector of the Fitches Creek area is also vulnerable to the same climate change CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES impacts. Homes located in coastal areas and in flood prone zones are susceptible to damage, particularly homes near beaches with wooden structures such as piers. Homes that are not built with much resilience to hurricanes and flooding, for example, homes that are made of wood with zinc roofs or are not on raised stilts, are even more vulnerable. Extreme lack of rainfall and high temperatures makes the residential sector of this area vulnerable because it increases the water scarcity issue in homes and standpipes. Sea level rise impacts the residential sector by increasing beach loss and flooding, and it increases the amount of salt water that infiltrates fresh water which then increases water expenses. Higher temperatures also cause the sector to be more vulnerable because the severe water scarcity leads to water rationing. This is followed by impacts on the ability to implement household tasks, more effort being spent on storing water for future uses, increased expenses on drinking water, and the possibility of compromised hygiene which can, therefore, lead to diseases and outbreaks. Overall, the residential sector is affected by the impacts of climate change making it vulnerable to the changes. The natural resource sector of the local area is also impacted by the same indicators of climate change as the two sectors above. Solid waste pollution that can be picked up by hurricanes/tropical storms degrades wetlands. Degraded wetlands have a decreased ability to buffer the impact of storm surges. There is great biodiversity loss to coral reefs which decreases the reefs’ ability to break waves that come with storm surges. This puts the island at greater risk of storm surge. Mining activities degraded Piggotts Hill which increases the threat of overland flow and sedimented surface runoff that ends up in the sea during storms. Rainfall extremes cause coral reefs and other marine ecosystems by creating an increased amount of sedimentation. This puts ecosystems at risk. Sea level rise increases the amount of salt content on land, putting the quality of the soil at risk, and can change the chemistry of the ambient water. This then affects the biodiversity of the area. Increasing sea levels will also cause more inundation which can place terrestrial greenery at risk. Increasing temperatures cause the natural resources to be vulnerable because higher temperatures will allow for an influx of Sargassum. High concentrations of 54 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Sargassum create shading for coral reefs decreasing the amount of needed sun they receive. An increased amount of Sargassum also restricts water flow through mangroves. High temperatures exacerbate the limited water availability issue which thus causes a loss of flora and the migration of species. This decreases the overall biodiversity in the area. St. John’s Local Area The capital of Antigua and Barbuda, St. John's City, is located on Antigua's northwest coast and has a dense urban landscape. The city, which has a maximum elevation of 59 meters above sea level, is bounded to the west by St. John's Harbour, to the north by Dickenson Bay Street, and to the east and south by other streets. It is roughly 10 km2 in size. But because of the geography, clayey loam soil, and high-water table, there is significant surface runoff during rainfall events in addition to sporadic flooding brought on by poor drain design and upkeep. St. John's City is a CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES rather developed location, hence there isn't much marine or terrestrial vegetation there. Instead, trees and bushes are mostly found near roads and waterways. Over half of the country's population resides in the St. John's parish, making St. John's City the most densely populated area in the nation. Due to rising competition for urban property from commercial operations, the city has seen a movement in population from the center to the periphery, as seen by a 9% reduction in its percentage of the nation's population between 2001 and 2011. As the country's main commercial and financial center, St. John's City has several regional enterprises, grocery stores, dining establishments, and financial service providers, which considerably boosts the economy of the region. Workers in the secondary and tertiary sectors make up most of the city's labour force. St. John's City had difficulties despite being a thriving economic hub, including a higher unemployment rate. St. John's City, although being a bustling economic center, experienced issues, having a greater unemployment rate than other locations in Antigua. The city also has a sizable proportion of impoverished and vulnerable individuals. The city's unemployment rate fell in 2018, and labour force participation rates were higher than the national average. During the COVID-19 pandemic, however, unemployment rates rose across the country, impacting the service-oriented business in St. John's City and mirroring similar patterns found across the country. One of the primary hazards threatening livelihoods in the St. John's City local area is flooding, particularly flash flooding resulting from heavy rainfall. Stakeholders have indicated that flooding is more prevalent in coastal areas, along watercourses, and major drain systems further inland due to the topography of the city. The eastern sections of St. John's City are elevated and gently slope westward to St. John's Harbour, leading to a flat and low-lying coastal plain, making these areas susceptible to flooding during prolonged heavy rains. Past flood events have caused significant disruptions, such as restricting access to roadways and sidewalks, damaging buildings, and properties, disrupting vehicular traffic, and impacting the activities of both locals and tourists. Flash flooding occurs frequently in response to moderate to heavy rainfall, but the water typically drains directly into the sea within 1-3 hours after rainfall ceases. However, human-related factors 55 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan exacerbate the flooding impacts. The city has numerous open drains alongside the road networks, including the Tanner Street and Grays Farm gutters, designed to handle stormwater runoff. Unfortunately, these channels sometimes overflow due to solid waste accumulation, leading to overwhelming damage. Illegal waste dumping and backfilling in drains and watercourses have also contributed to increased instances of flooding, even in previously non-flood-prone areas. These practices create stagnant water, posing risks of vector-borne and water-related diseases lasting for days after heavy rainfall events. An example of the city's vulnerability to flooding occurred in November 2020 when heavy rainfall caused impassable roads, washed away cars and vending stalls, and caught many individuals off-guard. St. John's City is home to crucial facilities and infrastructure, including ports, piers, electrical poles, communication networks, roads, emergency response stations, health facilities, schools, and churches, which provide essential services but are vulnerable to wind damage, rising temperatures, and coastal flooding due to sea level rise and storm surges. Many critical facilities CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES near the coastline or flat flood-prone regions are at heightened risk. Older wooden buildings and supporting structures, like piers and boardwalks, are particularly susceptible to damage. Government institutions concentrated in the city, along with other critical infrastructure, face slow recovery times, leading to business losses and delays in repairs. The St. John's Harbour, a main deep-water port, is also sensitive to storm surges and sea level rise. Reclaimed lands in the harbour are at risk of subsidence and damage from storms. Water availability and access in the area are improved through desalination facilities, but water leakages and the high-water table remain challenges. Educational facilities and emergency services are at risk during floods, and the banking industry's online data systems are vulnerable to flooding and power disruptions. Pre-existing poor drainage facilities increase the vulnerability of coastal communities to flood events, impacting tourism and fisheries. Coastal lands may be lost to rising sea levels, requiring measures like flood defences, and retrofitting existing buildings to adapt to climate change. The city's capacity for climate change adaptation to rising sea levels is limited, necessitating considerations for protecting the coastline and constructing protective structures. St. John's City, with its commercial nature, has residential areas scattered throughout, mainly in pockets towards the north and south sections. Communities like Grays Farm, Green Bay, and Ottos to the south, and Villa and Pointe to the north of St. John's Harbour, form the main residential hubs. The prevalence of squatting resulting from rural-urban drift and economic migrants settling in the area adds to the sensitivity of these communities. Initiatives to increase resilience have been implemented, including building codes with resilient practices. However, limited technical and financial capacity remains a challenge to fully address the impacts of hurricanes, particularly on low-income community infrastructure. Heatwaves pose health risks to vulnerable subgroups, and demand for water increases during drought periods. While middle-income residents can afford water tanks and air conditioning, 56 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan lower-income residents benefit from government initiatives providing water tanks to indigent residents. Due to human activities and the geological makeup of the central plain, St. John's City lacks natural ecosystems and coastal protection. Mangroves and marine ecosystems have been removed for construction, making the area vulnerable to storms and flooding. Dredging has also removed seagrass beds, further increasing sensitivity. The harbour’s semi-enclosed nature hinders coral reef growth, leaving the city exposed to storm surges. There are no established forests, and the dense network of buildings increases flood risk. Restoring natural resources is challenging due to limited available areas in the city layout. Jolly Harbour to Johnson’s Point Local Area CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES The Darkwood Beach Local Area is a coastal community located within the Christian Valley Watershed located about 15 kilometres from the capital St. John’s City. It spans through a large area, stretching from Jolly Harbour to Turner’s Beach and Johnson’s Point community, and is bordered to the west by Lignumvitae Bay, Ffryes Bay, and Picarts Bay and to the east by Valley Road. The land consists of wetlands, swamp ponds, mangroves, and volcanic areas, and it has various uses such as agriculture, recreation, tourism, and so many more. It is located, at max, 92 m above sea level. The main climatic hazards in this area are hurricanes and storms, extreme rainfall, flash floods, and drought, which each bring vulnerability to various sectors, including critical infrastructure, residential, natural resources, tourism, agriculture, and fisheries. The southwestern stretch of the coastline, from Darkwood Beach to Ffryes Point, including Jolly Harbour to Johnson’s Point area, is highly vulnerable to the devasting impacts of hurricanes and extreme tropical storms. The southwestern stretch of the coastline, from Darkwood Beach to Ffryes Point, including Jolly Harbour to Johnson’s Point area, is highly vulnerable to the devasting impacts of hurricanes and extreme tropical storms. These weather events cause significant loss of seagrass beds and lead to damage to coastal infrastructures such as hotels, restaurants, and critical facilities like roads, marinas, water pipelines, and drainage infrastructure. Major hurricanes have resulted in substantial income loss for fisherfolk due to damage to boats, fishing equipment, fish pots, and poor visibility, making their recovery lengthy and challenging. Storm surges associated with hurricanes and intense storms further exacerbate the situation, causing significant damage to the coastal areas and critical facilities. Storms create vulnerability to critical infrastructure as the area has many old infrastructures, storm surges could cause damage to the main route and the reverse osmosis plant, and flooding could easily happen. Natural resources in the area are vulnerable to hurricanes because they aren’t protected from storm surges, seagrass is uprooted and cannot break waves offshore, and runoff can result in water changes that negatively impact seagrass growth. Tourism is affected by hurricanes as 57 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan accommodations would decrease during large storms due to cancellation, increased cost of insurance, increased coastal erosion, and coastline attractions and accommodations are prone to storm surges. The Jolly Harbour to Johnsons Point local area is prone to both coastal and flash flooding, primarily triggered by heavy continuous rainfall exceeding 3 inches. A significant portion of the area is susceptible to flooding, particularly along the coast due to its low-lying nature and limited drainage capacity. The construction of Valley Road has altered hydrological dynamics, leading to coastal flooding threats and fragmented wetlands during heavy rains. Rainfall extremes can cause flooding resulting in potholes, drains not fully draining, and increased pressure on healthcare facilities with increases in vector-borne diseases. Farmers have been affected by drought in the area, experiencing reduced crop production and irrigation water supply, requiring additional water sources like storage tanks and retention ponds. CHAPTER 2: IMPACTS AND VULNERABILITIES Critical infrastructure is vulnerable to increased pressure on utilities due to cooling demand, risk of limited water in healthcare facilities and schools, thermal expansion of piers, and compromise of road integrity due to cracking and splitting of pavement in high temperatures. The residential sector faces vulnerabilities such as increased expenses on drinking water, negative health impacts of heat waves, increased energy demand, and compromised hygiene due to disease outbreaks. Increased sea temperatures can cause vulnerabilities to natural resources through the loss of mangroves, flora, and seagrass, and the rising surface temperature of the water is difficult to adapt to, leaving no real solution. In the tourism sector, vulnerabilities due to increasing temperature include increased energy demand due to cooling, discomfort during outdoor activities, reduced productivity of staff, increased probability of wildfire, and increased pressure on resources at pools and beaches. Climate change projections for Antigua and Barbuda indicate sea level rise (SLR), posing significant threats to the low-lying Jolly Harbour to Johnsons Point local area. The rise in mean sea level could lead to severe damage to buildings, and critical infrastructure, and the loss of valuable coastal lands. Beach erosion compounds the risks, degrading sections along the southwest coastline and impacting the tourism industry. Rising sea levels cause vulnerabilities in the infrastructure sector through flooding close to the coastline where many buildings are located, flooding of the roads restricting movement of people, erosion of infrastructure due to higher tides, and drainage systems near Jolly Harbour becoming less effective. Rising sea levels create vulnerabilities in the residential sector due to homes in Jolly Harbour being more sensitive to sea level rise damage, low-lying communities are at risk of flooding, building foundations are at risk due to saltwater intrusion, and corrosion of appliances and other metal-based assets. Natural resources are vulnerable due to rising sea levels due to light limitation in deeper waters, changes in ambient water chemistry, and poor hydrology to wetlands cut off from the sea due to the road network. Agriculture and fisheries are negatively impacted by sea level rise due to saltwater intrusion into agricultural lands, the negative impact on food security, the increased demand without increased supply, and increased freshwater scarcity, which can be reduced through diversification of farming techniques and additional governmental support through the Ministry of Agriculture. 58 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION 59 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan 3. Adaptation Priorities for Combatting Adversities of Climate Change
3.1. Lessons Learned from Past Initiatives Since the inception of the National Adaptation Plan Project's formulation in Antigua and Barbuda, several lessons have been learned from the execution of various project initiatives30: Technical Capacity Enhancement: There is a critical need to enhance the technical capacity of local technocrats across various Ministries, Departments, and Agencies (MDAs). The successful implementation of climate adaptation strategies requires a robust understanding of complex scientific, engineering, and planning concepts. Investing in continuous training and skill development for local experts is essential to ensure effective decision-making, policy formulation, and project execution. CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION Stakeholder Engagement Lessons: Past initiatives have highlighted the significance of inclusive stakeholder engagement in climate adaptation efforts. Lessons have been learned regarding the importance of involving diverse stakeholders, including communities, civil society organizations, academia, and the private sector. Effective engagement fosters ownership, promotes collaboration, and ensures that the perspectives and needs of all stakeholders are integrated into adaptation strategies. However, it is crucial to manage stakeholder fatigue, which can result from overburdening stakeholders with multiple consultations. Careful scheduling, clear communication, and efficient feedback mechanisms can mitigate this challenge. Finance Challenges and Private Sector Engagement: There is limited availability of in-country finance to fund large-scale adaptation efforts. To overcome this, the engagement of the private sector has been identified as a key solution. Partnerships with private entities can unlock additional financial resources, technical expertise, and innovation. However, it's important to recognize that the cost of expertise required for climate adaptation projects can be substantial. Striking a balance between securing the necessary expertise and managing costs is essential for sustainable implementation. Addressing Data Gaps: Past initiatives have highlighted the existence of significant data gaps at the national level, which hinder informed decision-making for climate adaptation. While the NAP and Department of Environment (DOE) are expected to address some data gaps, resource limitations may prevent the comprehensive resolution of this issue. Strategic prioritization of data collection and analysis efforts is essential to focus on the most critical gaps that have the greatest impact on adaptation planning. Enhancing Institutional Coordination: Institutional coordination among key MDAs of the government has proven to be an area with room for improvement. Effective climate adaptation requires seamless collaboration among various departments and agencies to ensure a coherent 30 Constable, Ayesha. 2020. National Adaptation Plan Project: Status & Next Steps. 60 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan and integrated approach. Lessons from past initiatives emphasize the need for streamlined communication, shared responsibilities, and clearly defined roles to avoid duplication of efforts and maximize efficiency. Education and Awareness: The growing awareness of climate change and its impacts is a positive outcome of previous initiatives. However, more needs to be done to educate the public about actionable steps they can take to contribute to broad-scale behavioural change. Empowering individuals with the knowledge and skills to adapt to changing climate conditions is crucial for building resilience at the community level. Covid-19: The emergence of COVID-19 significantly disrupted the implementation of project activities, causing delays, resource reallocation, and shifts in priorities. Lockdowns, travel restrictions, and health concerns impeded fieldwork, stakeholder engagements, and timely decision-making. The pandemic also highlighted the need for enhanced resilience, adaptive strategies, and the integration of health considerations within the climate adaptation framework. CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION
3.2. Adaptation Needs for Antigua and Barbuda As a small island nation vulnerable to the impacts of climate change, Antigua and Barbuda possesses a range of adaptation needs that were identified by local stakeholders, and the National Adaptation Plan (NAP) Project is aimed at addressing adaptation priorities identified by stakeholders, which have been done within the six sectoral adaptation plans. Such adaptation needs include: Coastal Areas Strengthening: The coastal areas of Antigua and Barbuda are highly vulnerable to rising sea levels, increased storm surges, and coastal erosion due to climate change. According to the Caribbean Climate Online Risk and Adaptation Tool (CCORAL), the islands are projected to experience more frequent and intense hurricanes, leading to increased flooding and erosion of coastlines. Water Conservation: Water Scarcity is a growing concern for Antigua and Barbuda due to changing precipitation patterns and increased evaporation rates. With the opinions of the local stakeholders, the United Nations Development Programme highlights the need for innovative water conservation practices. Food, Water, and Energy Security: Climate Change can disrupt food and water supply chains, affecting the overall security of these resources. The Caribbean Community (CARICOM) emphasizes the importance of diversifying agricultural practices and promoting climate-resilient crop varieties to enhance food security. Additionally, adopting renewable energy sources such as solar and wind can reduce dependence on imported fossil fuels and enhance energy security. 61 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Populating Baseline Data: Collecting and analysing baseline data is essential for understanding the local context and assessing the potential impacts of climate change. Financial Resources: Securing financial resources for climate change adaptation is a significant challenge, particularly for small island developing states like Antigua and Barbuda. Adequate funding is essential to implement adaptation projects and initiatives effectively.
3.3. Adaptation Strategy, Pathways, and Barriers
3.3.1. Adaptation Strategy Antigua and Barbuda, situated in the Caribbean, confronts the vital importance for climate adaptation strategies in light of its susceptibility to hurricanes, rising sea levels, and other climate- related challenges. A crucial aspect of strengthening the islands capacity against such threats lies CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION in the development of climate-resilient infrastructure. This involves the establishment of robust building codes and the retrofitting of existing structures. By incorporating stringent standards for construction materials and design principles, the objective is to ensure that buildings can withstand extreme weather events, particularly the high-intensity hurricanes that frequently impact the region. Furthermore, an essential foundation of Antigua and Barbuda's adaptive approach is early warning systems. Utilizing advanced meteorological technologies, such as weather satellites and radars, the nation aims to enhance the accuracy and timeliness of weather forecasts. Moreover, involving local communities in the development and execution of community-based early warning systems is pivotal. This proactive engagement ensures that residents are not only informed but also well- prepared to respond to impending threats through drills and training sessions. Recognizing the significance of natural resources, the islands are diligently working towards integrated coastal zone management. This encompasses a comprehensive plan to balance developmental needs with the preservation of coastal ecosystems. Stricter regulations on coastal development, alongside protective measures for mangroves and coral reefs, are integral to mitigating the impact of storm surges and sustaining biodiversity. Diversification of the economy emerges as a strategic response to climate change facilitated by the twin island state. Antigua and Barbuda aim to reduce dependence on climate-sensitive sectors, such as tourism, by actively promoting investments in renewable energy projects and supporting the development of climate-resilient industries. This diversification strategy not only enhances economic sustainability but also contributes to the broader goal of reducing carbon footprints. Embedded within Antigua and Barbuda's initiatives to enhance resilience is the integral integration of community-based adaptation. Through workshops and consultations, involving communities 62 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan becomes a catalyst for their ability to formulate and execute climate action plans tailored to their specific circumstances. These plans may span a range of endeavours, including sustainable agriculture and measures for disaster preparedness, strategically addressing vulnerabilities and capitalizing on local strengths. Ecosystem-based adaptation is seamlessly integrated into the islands' tourism strategies, emphasizing sustainable and eco-friendly practices. Collaborative efforts to restore ecosystems, including reforestation and coral reef rehabilitation, underscore the commitment to preserving natural environments while fostering economic opportunities. Water management assumes a critical role, particularly in the face of changing precipitation patterns. Antigua and Barbuda promote rainwater harvesting systems at various levels, from households to commercial entities. Additionally, advocating for efficient irrigation practices in agriculture aligns with broader goals of water conservation and adaptation to evolving climate conditions. CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION Capacity building and education initiatives extend across formal education systems and emergency response teams. Integrating climate change education into school curricula ensures that the younger generation is equipped with the knowledge and awareness needed for sustainable practices. Simultaneously, regular training exercises for emergency responders enhance their readiness and adaptability in managing climate-related disasters. Insurance and risk transfer mechanisms are designed to provide financial resilience. By collaborating with international insurance agencies, Antigua and Barbuda explores parametric insurance schemes tailored to its specific climate risks. Rigorous risk assessments, encompassing sea-level rise, extreme weather events, and economic vulnerabilities, form the basis for these financial instruments, ensuring a swift and targeted response in the aftermath of climate-related events. Internationally, Antigua and Barbuda recognize the necessity of collaboration. Engaging in joint research initiatives and contributing local knowledge to global climate change databases strengthens the nation's position in the broader discourse. Regional alliances, particularly within the Caribbean community, provide a platform for shared resources, information, and collective strength in negotiating for international climate funding.
3.3.2. Adaptation Pathways Adapting to climate change is a critical for nations worldwide, and the integration of climate adaptation into national policies, plans, and development strategies is an essential pathway to address this global concern. By mainstreaming climate adaptation, a country like Antigua and Barbuda can ensure that climate considerations are central to decision-making processes across various sectors. This approach involves embedding climate resilience measures into the fabric of 63 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan governance, development planning, and policy implementation. Such a comprehensive strategy holds several potential benefits for Antigua and Barbuda. By integrating climate adaptation into national policies, Antigua and Barbuda can enhance its resilience to the impacts of climate change. Given the vulnerability of small island nations to extreme weather events, rising sea levels, and changing precipitation patterns, a proactive and integrated approach is crucial. Mainstreaming adaptation ensures that climate considerations are not treated as standalone issues but are woven into the very fabric of governance, thereby promoting a holistic and sustainable response to climate challenges. Integrating climate adaptation into development strategies allows for a more coherent and coordinated response. In a policy-integrated framework, various sectors, such as agriculture, infrastructure, and health, can work synergistically to address the multifaceted impacts of climate change. This avoids the siloed approach that may occur when climate considerations are treated separately, fostering a more effective and integrated response to the complex challenges posed CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION by a changing climate. Moreover, mainstreaming climate adaptation into national policies can contribute to the achievement of broader development goals. Climate-resilient strategies can enhance the overall sustainability and longevity of development initiatives, ensuring that investments made today are not compromised by future climate-related risks. This alignment between climate adaptation and national development objectives creates a mutually reinforcing relationship that promotes sustainable development in the face of climate uncertainty. Additionally, policy integration fosters inclusivity by ensuring that the impacts of climate change are considered across all segments of society. Vulnerable populations, such as those dependent on agriculture or living in coastal areas, can be better protected through policies that explicitly address their unique challenges. Mainstreaming adaptation thus becomes a tool for promoting social equity and reducing the disproportionate impacts of climate change on marginalized communities.
3.3.3. Adaptation Barriers Antigua and Barbuda, like many small island developing states (SIDS), faces a myriad of challenges in adapting to the impacts of climate change. These challenges are multifaceted, ranging from the economic dependence on climate-sensitive sectors to the geographical vulnerability of low-lying islands to rising sea levels and intense storms. One of the primary barriers lies in the limited resources of the nation. The islands are often confronted with insufficient financial, human, and technological resources, making it difficult to implement comprehensive adaptation measures. Moreover, the economic backbone of Antigua and Barbuda, heavily reliant on tourism and agriculture, is particularly susceptible to climate- 64 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan related disruptions, including hurricanes, changes in precipitation patterns, and rising temperatures. Water scarcity is another dire issue, exacerbated by changing precipitation patterns and increased evaporation. This poses a significant threat to agriculture, food security, and overall water availability. The islands' limited infrastructure, especially along coastlines, leaves the nation exposed to the impacts of sea-level rise and storm surges. Strengthening infrastructure for disaster preparedness, including early warning systems and evacuation routes, is imperative to mitigate these adverse impacts. Furthermore, governance and institutional capacity play a pivotal role in effective adaptation. Developing and implementing climate change policies require strong governance structures, and ensuring coordination among various government departments is crucial. Additionally, there's a need for technical expertise in climate science and adaptation strategies and other related expertise, necessitating investments in education and training programs. Moreover, Institutional CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION and government barriers, such as the need for improved governance frameworks and capacity gaps, underline the importance of institutional strengthening and policy integration. Aligning PPP processes with adaptation priorities requires strategic planning and transparent decision-making, while policy coherence ensures a coordinated approach across different sectors. On a socio-political front, social resistance, and a lack of political will impede progress. Public awareness and education initiatives are essential to overcome resistance, and civil society and NGOs can play a vital role in advocating for climate-resilient policies. Lack of political will can be addressed through international cooperation, highlighting the urgency and benefits of climate adaptation. Financial barriers, including the limited fiscal space of the government and financial restrictions in the private sector, pose substantial challenges. Exploring innovative financing mechanisms, such as green bonds and climate funds, can help mobilize resources. Involving the private sector through public-private partnerships (PPPs) and insurance schemes can contribute to climate resilience.
3.4. National Commitments Alignment The climate-related contributions of Antigua & Barbuda, encompassing both adaptation and mitigation measures, are delineated in the Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC). This commitment received the endorsement of the Cabinet of Antigua and Barbuda prior to its submission to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. The targets of the Nationally Determined Contributions (NDC) are based on the goal of limiting global temperature increase to 1.5°C and preparing for a 3.4°C rise in temperatures. These targets align with Antigua and Barbuda's aim to achieve net-zero emissions by 2040. These goals will be 65 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan achieved by using appropriate technologies and policies, such as better land use planning and updated building codes. Financial instruments like special insurance for extreme weather events will also be used. The achievement of these targets depends on various factors, including technology costs and transitional risks, which might make them conditional or unconditional. Considering the climate effects observed during the first five years of the previous climate plan (INDC), the coming decade could lead to over 0.5 billion dollars in climate-related damage in the country. As a result, there is a pressing need to swiftly build resilience to minimize these impacts and reduce the risks related to climate change. This updated NDC revises the 2015 INDC and doesn't replace the previous targets outlined in it. Instead, it keeps some unmet targets and raises the ambition level of certain goals. Since the INDC was meant to cover a decade and not all objectives were achieved, it remains relevant. The new NDC builds on the successes of the last five years and incorporates fresh data indicating decreased technology costs, enabling more ambitious targets. CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION This NDC's strategy aligns with the country's developmental priorities. It explores strategies like connecting the energy and agricultural sectors and enhancing energy resilience. The plan aims to reduce the cost of mitigation and adaptation projects while shifting away from fossil fuels towards abundant solar and wind energy resources. The strategy acknowledges the risks associated with making an inclusive energy transition, recognizing the varying roles and aspirations of different groups like men, women, and youth, ensuring that no one is left behind. The NDC is also considering the financial and transitional challenges that could arise during implementation. It emphasizes the need for gender-sensitive approaches and a fair workforce transition. While acknowledging significant challenges and uncertainties, the plan also envisions opportunities for new business ventures for the people of Antigua and Barbuda. The plan also looks at the financial challenges and risks that might come up during implementation. They're aware of the importance of gender equality and making sure the workforce transition is fair. They acknowledge that there are difficulties and uncertainties but also see opportunities for new businesses for the people of Antigua and Barbuda. The following are the National Adaptation goals of Antigua and Barbuda: 1. By the year 2025, seawater desalinacon capacity by 50% above the levels documented in 2015. 2. By the year 2030, enhance and forcfy all structures to effeccvely withstand extreme climacc occurrences, encompassing droughts, inundacons, and hurricanes. 3. By the year 2030, ensure that 100% of the electricity requisites within vital sectors such as water management and other essencal services encompassing healthcare, food preservacon, and emergency services, are sourced from off-grid renewable resources. 4. By the year 2030, implement comprehensive measures to safeguard all water bodies, micgacng flood hazards and associated health implicacons. 66 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan 5. By the year 2030, establish an affordable insurance framework to support farmers, fishermen, and proprietors of residencal and commercial properces in managing losses arising from climacc vagaries. The NAP is aimed to serve as a pivotal instrument in assisting the country in attaining its NDC objectives and fulfilling its obligations regarding reporting, transparency, and compliance within the Paris Agreement reporting. The NAP envisions itself as a practical document, supplying detailed climate forecasts, guidelines, and standards tailored to local contexts. This information will be utilized by engineers, community members, financial institutions, insurance providers, and other stakeholders, including politicians, to inform their initiatives and promote multi-sectoral advancements for the sake of achieving climate resilience.
3.5. Policies and regulations CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION Antigua and Barbuda's National Adaptation Plan (NAP) pursues enabling policies, regulations, and plans. These measures indicate the nation's commitment to climate change adaptation and its resilience-building efforts. The following are the key policies, regulations, and plans which provided the basis for the NAP: Government of Antigua and Barbuda (GOAB) Medium Term Development Strategy (2015): This strategic framework stands as the cornerstone of the NAP by setting forth a comprehensive national development vision. Its approval by the Cabinet lends the NAP a solid foundation, as it guides various sectors towards unified climate adaptation goals, ensuring that adaptation efforts are fully integrated into the country's overall development trajectory. National Physical Development Plan (SIRMZP 2012): The significance of this plan is twofold. Firstly, it identifies areas prone to environmental vulnerabilities, forming a basis for targeted adaptation strategies. Secondly, its sustainable development spatial plan aligns with the NAP's objectives, providing a blueprint for environmentally conscious growth and infrastructure development. Draft Building Code for the OECS: This forthcoming code plays a crucial role in the NAP by demanding resilient infrastructure. Its mandate for hurricane-resistant homes and drought- resistant features ensures that future constructions align with the nation's climate adaptation priorities, directly contributing to the enhancement of Antigua and Barbuda's resilience. Coastal Zone Management Plan (2016): Although faced with data gaps, this plan remains vital to the NAP. It aims to protect the nation's coastal areas, which are particularly vulnerable to climate impacts. By establishing appropriate coastal setbacks once data limitations are addressed, this plan will help safeguard coastal communities and ecosystems against sea-level rise and extreme weather events. 67 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Policy Framework for Integrated Adaptation Planning and Management (2002): This framework is pivotal in guiding the NAP's direction. By pinpointing priority sectors for adaptation, it enables Antigua and Barbuda to channel resources effectively and address vulnerabilities in a targeted manner, aligning adaptation actions with specific needs. National Comprehensive Disaster Management Policy and Strategy (2015–2017): The proposed modifications to the Disaster Management Act (2002) provide a legal basis for integrating various environmental policies. This legislative alignment reinforces the NAP's mission, promoting coordination and synergy among disaster management and environmental policies, thus enhancing the nation's adaptive capacity. Environmental Protection and Management Act (2015) and draft Paris Agreement Regulations: These legislative measures fortify the NAP by ensuring a robust legal framework for environmental commitments. By stipulating data collection, climate risk mapping, and Vulnerability Risk Assessment and Adaptation Plans, these regulations provide a systematic approach to climate CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION adaptation, embedding it firmly into the country's legal and policy landscape.
3.6. Institutional Arrangements and Coordination Antigua and Barbuda's NAP initiatives were carefully crafted to yield enduring, tangible results. These outcomes encompass tasks such as gathering and organizing data, establishing a legal framework for various sectors and businesses, conducting climate vulnerability assessments and crafting adaptation plans, formulating a sustainable financing strategy for NAP implementation, demonstrating practical applications, offering training and certification, and more. To facilitate this, the consultancies procured for services within this project are designed to be cost-effective, making use of local and regional expertise. This approach not only helps control costs but also aligns with the project's goals of capacity building. However, it is important to note that professional fees for qualified individuals and firms in the Caribbean region are comparably high in relation to other developing nations. 68 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION Figure 10: Institutional Arrangements to support climate change adaptation (ADCOM, 2022) Antigua and Barbuda’s national adaptation planning process was led by the UNFCCC Focal Point, the Department of Environment. The development process of the NAP document was supported by the Project Management Unit (PMU), which is the DOE’s implementing entity. The PMU oversaw the day-to-day management of the NAP Readiness project. Serving as the practical arm of the Department, the PMU consists of technical and administrative personnel, many holding master’s degrees in fields such as climate adaptation, marine biology, civil engineering, and project management. The PMU assists the DOE in fulfilling its responsibilities across projects, offering flexibility in staffing, secondments from the public sector, and promoting the sharing of expertise and ideas. This is particularly crucial for a small island nation with limited resources and human capital, where the government employs the country's most qualified experts. The PMU is made up of consultants supported by ad-hoc staff from various governmental departments and the private sector. It is a strategic component of the DOE, called upon to procure services like part- time and full-time consultants, project coordinators, technical experts, and technical coordinators. The PMU operates under the oversight of the DOE’s Director, the Project Management Committee (PMC) and its Audit Committee. Its structure aims to streamline management and implementation, covering numerous projects funded by various donors and the government itself. 69 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan It ensures effective coordination, especially when project activities overlap or depend on each other. As Antigua and Barbuda is a Small Island Developing State (SIDS) with limited technical capacity, the PMU acts as a measure to mitigate risks and enhance efficiency through experiential learning. The PMU handles day-to-day tasks of the NAP project, including the appointment of the NAP Coordinator and other part-time consultants and technical officers. This approach optimizes resource allocation and enables the NAP project to focus on results. Additionally, data collection, analysis and data management services are provided by the DOE’s Data Management Unit (DMU) and monitoring, evaluation, and learning (MEL) services by its MEL- Unit. In the development of the NAP, the Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) plays a pivotal role. This committee includes representatives from key government agencies, non-governmental organizations (NGOs), and private sector coalitions. It convenes monthly and provides technical guidance, policy suggestions, and facilitates communication among stakeholders throughout CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION project identification, development, and implementation. The TAC's involvement ensures the incorporation of socio-economic and environmental factors, broadens the dissemination of information, manages stakeholder expectations, and addresses challenges that may arise in executing activities within the Adaptation Work Programme. Additionally, the TAC enables these agencies to report on their actions related to climate change adaptation. When the National Adaptation Plan document is completed, the Cabinet of Antigua and Barbuda will be responsible for approving it. Once approved, the plan will be published in the gazette. Figure 11: Indicative process flow for Antigua and Barbuda’s National Adaptation planning process (Source: ADCOM, 2022) 70 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Project Management Committee (PMC) Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) Budget Office Rep. MOF Relevant expertise PS Environment Project Manager from Ministries and Department PS Energy Project Coordinator Barbuda Rep PS Agriculture Donor Representative NGOs Procurement Unit Private Sector Rep. Community Interests Audit Sub- Rep committee Technical Officers Project Assistants Data Managers CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION Data Officers Administrative Project Staff Management Unit Monitoring & Evaluation Staff Data Management Unit (DMU) Figure 12: The Department of Environment’s implementation arrangements for project management in Antigua and Barbuda
3.7. Sectoral Adaptation Six Sectoral Adaptation plans (SAP) were made for six different sectors in the Antigua and Barbuda economy. These plans were developed to support Antigua and Barbuda’s National Adaptation Plan Sub-programme, which aims at facilitating effective mid- and long-term climate change adaptation planning. The SAPs are aimed at addressing the numerous and interlinked vulnerabilities of Antigua and Barbuda’s main sectors to future climate change, as well as the impacts of major baseline challenges that jeopardize these sectors. These plans outline, in detail, specific vulnerabilities, establish cross cutting themes, and give direction toward specific initiatives and methods of monitoring and evaluation within each sector. The following section of the NAP will give a guideline of the results of each sector’s SAP including background and general implementation plans. The sectors that have an SAP written include: I. The Culture and Historical Sites II. Food Security III. Infrastructure and Housing IV. Tourism V. Finance 71 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan VI. Wholesale and Retail Cultural and Historical Sites Sector The objective of the Culture and Historical Sites Sector Adaptation Plan is to address the current and prospective impacts of climate change, disasters and any other factors that impact the cultural and historic sites sectors. Based on, but not limited to, the analysis of climate-related risks, the review of related policy and legislation, the review of previous national documents, and consultations with policymakers and other national stakeholders. The plan is envisioned to help the development of an effective adaptation strategy and action plan designed to reduce vulnerability and enhance the resilience of cultural and historical resources to climate change across the culture and historic sector of Antigua and Barbuda. This project will contribute by: 1. Reviewing and presenting a baseline/data of current climate and weather-related impacts and consequences for the sector, and stakeholder consultations. 2. Assessment of current climate trends, vulnerabilities, and priorities for the sector. CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION 3. Identifying the key risks to the sector. 4. Providing a list of adaptation actions with analysis of options and prioritized adaptation actions towards a sectoral plan. 5. Recommending indicators as part of monitoring and evaluation. This Plan provides strategic direction across organizations involved in the built cultural heritage and historic sites management, for integration of adaptation planning into the national development planning. Background Antigua and Barbuda are a nation steeped in history and culture yet carries the legacies of centuries of exploitation, poverty, lack of resources and adequate infrastructure, and others. There are about 180 prehistoric sites, over 170 sugar estates, 54 fortifications and an estimated 300 shipwrecks, and more. The economy is almost entirely dependent on tourism, which is largely a result of the rich natural and cultural heritage resources. However, the newly emerging threat that is beginning to impact the island is climate change with all its associated issues. These include, sea-level rise, increasing storm frequencies, the increasing power of hurricanes, storm surges, wind driven rain, all of which leads to coastal erosion, loss of beaches and coastal infrastructure, damage to the built cultural heritage, loss of archaeological sites, resulting in losses to the economy and heritage assets. Interestingly, archaeological research, which has been monitoring and documenting the cultural heritage and archaeological sites of Antigua and Barbuda is beginning to observe a sudden acceleration of negative impacts to the tangible cultural heritage assets far beyond the norm. This leads to great vulnerabilities within the cultural sector as described in section 3.4. 72 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Implementation Vulnerabilities can be reduced, and resilience can be enhanced within the culture and historical sites sector by creating a disaster management plan for cultural heritage sites. Disaster planning has two goals: the first is to develop a contingency plan, designed to take effect when an unforeseen event strikes or is imminent. The second goal is to ensure longer term mitigation actions are undertaken to minimize the impact of an anticipated event. Below is a list of steps to take to create a management plan for cultural heritage sites. DEVELOPING A DISASTER MANAGEMENT PLAN FOR CULTURAL HERITAGE SITES 1. Establish legal boundaries for sites. 2. Determine ownership/responsibilities. 3. Assess sites (financial value, structural integrity, vulnerability, replacement value). 4. Identify measures to prevent response to potential disasters. 5. Create funding mechanisms to support disaster management. CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION 6. Work on modalities for access to support for each site. 7. Plan for the worst. 8. Plan for all circumstances and types of disasters: fire, hurricane, earthquake. 9. Assume there will be no outside help or resources. 10. Plan for the aftermath: what to do immediately after to secure, evaluate, for safety. 11. Determine who can help and how. 12. Keep contact information on site managers and key persons on site, first responders, and essential services current and easily available. 13. Develop a list of essential workers with necessary skills/trades. 14. Plan to have an accessible stockpile of emergency items, first aid, tools, waterproof containers etc. 15. Training your first response team and have annual upgrading of skills. 16. Establish good maintenance practices. 17. Ensure your insurance policies for structures and contents are updated regularly. 18. Include staff and essential outside disaster management persons in your planning and drills. 19. Digitize and backup all computer data files, digital photographs, and plans of building records (documents) to an external provider. Below includes a list of actions that can be taken to reduce the vulnerabilities within the culture sector from the effects of climate change. IMPLEMENTATION PLAN 1. Continue Data Gathering and Research: This is essential to provide more information to facilitate planning and adaptation.: 73 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan 2. Capacity Building: Provide training in recognizing cultural heritage sites, particularly archaeological sites to persons involved in survey, development planning, environmental assessment teams. 3. Facilitate Cross-Sectoral Institutional Cooperation for site protection, reporting, protection, PDNA. 4. Encourage the gathering and use of qualitative data, such as, traffic flow, visitor numbers, site users to determine site use, infrastructure and staff requirements, potential income, and management needs. 5. Develop a program for vulnerability assessments at all listed sites. 6. Improve site survey documentation by seeking funding for improved survey resources and methodology to enable longer-term research. 7. Establish the formation of a Competent National Authority for management of cultural heritage sites. CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION 8. Begin the process of establishing a National Registry of Sites. 9. Lobby Government to support the CNA and National Registry. 10. Raise awareness with social media to get public support that will encourage Ministerial support. 11. Promote the inclusion of Cultural Heritage Impact Assessment surveys prior to construction and development. 12. Review and use UNESCO Cultural Conventions as Guidelines and Policies, increase contact with their technical field officers. 13. Review with intent to consider ratification of other UNESCO cultural conventions. 14. Encourage the bi-annual preparation and review of State of Conservation Reports from Cultural Heritage managers. 15. Develop rescue archaeological proposals for funding opportunities, (which will include analysis, conservation, reporting/publications, cataloguing, and storage). 16. Involve the community in research. 17. Review the 1990s studies for the development of heritage areas in St. John’s and Parham which are also coastal sites. More information can be found in the Culture Adaptation Plan. Food Security Sector The vision of the Food Security Adaptation sector is to increase access to affordable and nutritional food for residents and visitors to Antigua and Barbuda by increasing the resilience of the food system to climate change and variability. The strategic objective to achieving this vision is to directly respond to the multiple, interlinking challenges to the country’s food system and 74 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan strengthen the system’s robustness, redundancy, flexibility and adaptability to increase overall resilience (Section 4.1.1). A major element of this objective involves reducing the country’s reliance on food imports and concurrently making local food production — particularly agriculture and fisheries — processing and distribution more resilient to future climate change. Background Food security in the twin-island Caribbean state of Antigua and Barbuda is currently heavily reliant on imports and, to a lesser extent, local food production. These local production systems include the production of crops, livestock and bee products, as well as the harvesting of primarily reef- based fish. Both local food production and imports support other elements of the food system, including processing, distribution and consumption by residents and by tourists visiting the islands. Antigua and Barbuda’s food system, however, is impacted by a number of existing baseline challenges. These challenges primarily affect food production by i) limiting water availability; ii) reducing soil quality; iii) resulting in losses of agricultural and fisheries products through theft; iv) degrading ecosystems that support food production; v) limiting land availability for agriculture; vi) CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION limiting the availability of equipment and financing for producers; and vii) resulting in higher prices for consumers through increased production costs and a higher dependency on imported foods. In addition, there are insufficient food processing and storage facilities and capacities in the country, meaning that there are seasonal surpluses and scarcities in certain foods, and that the country is vulnerable to prolonged disruptions in food production or imports. Changing social preferences influenced by the high influx of tourists to the country also means that there is a transition away from demand for local foods and cuisines to imported alternatives that are often less nutritious. The impacts of the above challenges to the food system will be aggravated by projected changes in climate. These changes include rising temperatures, reductions in rainfall, more frequent and severe droughts, increasingly intense hurricanes, rising ocean temperatures and ocean acidification and sea level rise. Climate change hazards are expected to negatively impact food production in Antigua and Barbuda. For example, increasingly severe and frequent hurricanes and storm surges are expected to cause increased damages to infrastructure, equipment and produce, and worsening disruptions in the availability of imported food. The increased economic losses from damage to infrastructure and utilities will ultimately reduce the ability of consumers to afford sufficient and nutritious food. Other impacts include the erosion of coastal areas, saltwater intrusion into groundwater reserves and the degradation of both terrestrial and marine ecosystems. All of these hazards and impacts — combined with the existing baseline challenges — will contribute to increased food insecurity in the future. Implementation To achieve the above vision and objective, and to catalyse an impactful and sustainable shift towards climate change resilience across Antigua and Barbuda, a change in basic assumptions across the existing food system is required. According to the Green Climate Fund Sectoral Guide on Agriculture and Food Security, a transformation towards climate change resilient and low- emission agriculture and food systems can be reached through three paradigm-shifting 75 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan investment pathways. These pathways include: i) promoting resilient agroecology; ii) facilitating informed advisory and risk management services; and iii) reconfiguring food systems. The first of these pathways, namely promoting resilient agroecology, aims to support climate-resilient interventions to reduce the impacts of climate change on agricultural productivity while promoting low-emission synergies. Second, the paradigm shifting pathway on facilitating climate informed advisory and risk management services highlights the importance of climate information in mainstreaming climate considerations in agricultural management. Finally, the third pathway, namely reconfiguring food systems, promotes the transformation of the full food system towards one that uses resilient and low emission practices and technologies to feed the growing population. Key actions may be implemented across the above three paradigm-shifting pathways to assist in addressing these barriers. These actions are listed below. ● Alignment of incentive systems and policies at the national and sub-national levels through ● institutional and regulatory reforms aimed at fostering change. CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION ● Empowerment of communities and local leadership, combined with the use of traditional. ● knowledge and resources. ● Inclusion of women, youth and marginalized groups to enhance the ownership of improved. ● practices and increase productivity to attract the workforce towards the adoption of climate. ● resilient measures and technologies. ● Engagement with the private sector at all levels as both actors and innovators on investments and ● financing of businesses across all food system value chains. ● Evidence-based monitoring, evaluation and learning informed by science and data, along with ● knowledge management that links the three paradigm-shifting pathways. ● Capacity development of all stakeholder groups, targeting their specific requirements. A four-pronged approach to support the implementation of the above activities across the paradigm shifting pathways for adaptive agriculture and food security has been developed by the GCF. This four-pronged approach includes: i) transformational planning and programming; ii) catalysing climate innovation; iii) mobilization of finance at scale; and iv) coalitions and knowledge to scale up success. Based on stakeholder consultations and desktop research, specific adaptation options have been identified to increase the resilience of Antigua and Barbuda’s food system to climate change. These options all have the potential to align with and contribute to the above paradigm-shifting pathways and drivers. The relevance and urgency of identified adaptation options were assessed using a multi-criteria analysis (MCA). 76 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Based on the different identified adaptations’ alignments and MCA scorings, the identified adaptation options were structured around eight Investment Programmes (IPs) that reflect the strategic priorities for achieving a change in thinking towards a resilient food system. These Investment Programmes are listed below. Table 9: Investment Programmes (Ips) and activities for achieving a resilient food system. Investment Programme Activities 1 Enabling environment 1.1. Develop an updated national land use plan and local area strengthened to support plans that support the preservation of farmland and natural local food production ecosystems, and that promote agricultural production zoning. through legislation and
1.2. Support the development of improved legislation and task CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION plans. forces to address praedial larceny.
1.3. Draft policies that better regulate and promote sustainable tourism.
1.4. Update current food pricing legislation.
1.5. Improve standards and regulations for local food production and processing.
1.6. Increase the technical and human resource capacity of managing bodies and extension officers to support producers. 2 Governmental and civil 2.1. Strengthen cross-institutional coordination and policy coordination coherence to develop a regulatory system for food security. mechanisms enhanced.
2.2. Improve coordination between meteorological, hydrological and agricultural extension services to determine climate information needs for producers.
2.3. Promote the development of an overarching farmers’ cooperative.
2.4. Incentivize farmers to sell products to CMC as a central marketing hub. 3 Climate and food system 3.1. Improve data collection and research for agricultural data collection and production and consumer indicators that can be disseminated research supported to to end users across the food system. 77 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan inform the agricultural and fisheries sectors 4 Innovative technologies 4.1. Introduce hurricane-resilient equipment for fisherfolk. and practices mainstreamed to 4.2. Promote and upscale awareness-raising of environmental promote the climate- management and restoration practices within communities resilience of and fisheries. the fisheries sector.
4.3. Promote the restoration and maintenance of marine ecosystems to support fisherfolk.
4.4. Provide training for fisherfolk on sustainable practices, first aid, navigation, and mechanics to increase safety and efficiency. CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION 5 Innovative technologies 5.1. Upscale the natural resource management of watersheds. and practices mainstreamed to 5.2. Upscale sustainable and low-emission agricultural soil promote the climate- management practices. resilience of the agricultural sector. 5.3. Develop and promote value chains for the production of local organic fertilizers from disposed food and Sargassum seaweed.
5.4. Promote biological or non-chemical pest control. 6 Private investment and 6.1. Strengthen risk insurance and social safety net Public-Private mechanisms for farmers and fisherfolk. Partnerships (PPPs) promoted to encourage 6.2. Promote skills-based business models that support the sustainability of climate-resilient agricultural practices. climate-resilient
6.3. Introduce infrastructure and equipment to promote the interventions. diversification of local crop products. Antigua and Barbuda Food Security Sectoral Adaptation Plan 110 climate-resilient interventions.
6.4. Support PPPs to introduce low-emission agro-processing and food storage facilities to meet demand. 7 Training and awareness 7.1. Facilitate and promote international knowledge sharing raising facilitated to exchange programmes and learning opportunities for promote local producers. 78 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan production. 7.2 Provide business management training for farmers and fisherfolk.
7.3. Undertake awareness-raising campaigns that promote agriculture and fisheries as viable careers within schools.
7.4. Undertake an awareness-raising programme aimed at promoting backyard gardening and preserving natural ecosystems.
7.5. Undertake an awareness-raising programme to promote the purchase of locally produced food. 8 Funding mechanisms 8.1. Mobilize national and global funds to upscale training mobilized to finance food programmes and adaptation options. security resilience CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION interventions. 8.2. Establish or support micro-finance and loans for farmers and fisherfolk.
8.3. Promote the use of credit unions and village savings and loans associations (VSLAs) within producer cooperatives. Find descriptions and specific proposed actions for each investment programme in the Food Security Adaptation Plan. Infrastructure and Housing The goal of adapting the infrastructure and housing sector is to enhance climate resilience by proposing a range of adaptation measures that can be implemented over the course of the next decade to increase sectoral resilience to current and projected climate impacts and deliver broader social and environmental benefits to the residents of Antigua and Barbuda. Climate resilience can be defined as the ability of the infrastructure and housing sectors to withstand climate change impacts, both from extreme and slow-onset events, and to be able to maintain operations during such events to swiftly recover from associated impacts. Increasing infrastructure resilience may require both physical measures (e.g., engineering a drainage system to manage higher rates of runoff) and soft measures such as processes, procedures, and the institutional capacity to ensure proper planning and maintenance of infrastructure. Background Infrastructure is wide-ranging and multi-faceted by its functional and qualitative attributes, and its purpose. This section examines ‘hard’ (lifeline) infrastructure sectors (e.g., power, water, telecommunications, utilities, wastewater, roads, hospitals, shelters) as they are critically 79 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan vulnerable to the impacts of climate change and are central to the populations’ health, survival, and well-being. This section prioritizes four sectors within infrastructure and housing for analysis; housing, roads, wastewater, and energy, which were identified as both at-risk to future climate impacts and critical to the nation’s resilience through stakeholder engagement and a critical infrastructure assessment. Under a worst-case emissions scenario using the Representative Concentration Pathway (RCP), projections show that by 2030, Antigua and Barbuda’s building stock is expected to incur losses of up to US $451 million (EC $1218.9 million26) owing to the impacts associated with tropical cyclones (storm surge and high winds), sea level rise (SLR), and flooding, which could result in additional losses of US $108 million (EC $291.9 million). Gradual changes in precipitation and rising temperatures will accelerate the deterioration of energy infrastructure and road networks, increasing routine maintenance and repair costs, and disrupting the lives of citizens. Planning for climate change through appropriate adaptation measures can enable Antigua and Barbuda to ‘Build Back Better’, helping to reduce impacts to infrastructure assets, and allowing for a faster CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION recovery after extreme shocks. Both existing and new infrastructure assets must consider climate changes that are likely to occur over the asset’s lifetime, and potential adaptation measures, both physical and soft, that can strengthen resilience. Yet, as disaster-prone islands, the resilience of Antigua and Barbuda’s infrastructure and housing sectors are not only defined by the resilience of infrastructure assets alone, but also by the broader planning and development decisions, both past and future, that impact the resilience of the islands, and the role of natural ecosystems (e.g., sand dunes, beaches, sandbars, mangroves, wetlands) in protecting inland areas. All sectors have a goal based on the key climate risks that pose a threat to their resilience which can be found below. Table 10: Key goals for I&H subsectors based on key climate risks that pose a threat to their resilience. Sector Goal Road To ensure that roads and drainage systems can withstand the impacts of climate change, such as flooding, hurricanes, extreme heat and SLR Wastewater Protect public health and the environment by ensuring that wastewater treatment and disposal systems can withstand the impacts of climate change Housing To enhance the resilience of housing assets, homeowners, and the services that they depend on (e.g., water, electricity) to hurricanes, flooding, and drought Energy To enhance the resilience of Antigua and Barbuda’s domestic energy supply to 80 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan hurricane events, droughts, flooding, and rising temperatures. Implementation Given the above ultimate goals, the below tables based on sector detail all adaptation measures as well as their corresponding climate hazard, adaptation measure category, and location. The table also incorporates a results chain approach where the anticipated outcome (short- and medium-term) and anticipated impact(s), if successfully implemented, are denoted. Oftentimes, the long-term impacts of adaptation measures extend far beyond enhancing the resilience of the asset, or sector itself, and result in positive externalities to communities and ecosystems. More information on the financing, monitoring, and evaluation of these implementation plans can be found in the infrastructure and housing sectoral adaptation plan. CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION 81 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Table 11: Housing: Summary of prioritized adaptation measures Adaptation Location Category Associated Anticipated Anticipated impact Measures climate outcome (short & (long term) hazard(s) medium term) Obtain financing Barbuda Physical Flooding Homes are Adequate housing to complete the Hurricane protected against stock that is construclon flooding resilient to rainfall, (specifically flood, and plastering) of the hurricane events, 104 EU funded and does not homes, deteriorate as constructed post- quickly hurricane Irma to milgate flood water intrusion associated with heavy rainfall events CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION Provide Anlgua Financial Hurricane Increase Reduced impact to homeowners with and homeowners' the housing sector financial Barbuda accessibility to and households incenlves (e.g., finance dedicated to (e.g., physical tax breaks, build or retrofit damage and need credits, low hurricane resilient for shelters) interest loans) to homes associated with build or retrofit hurricanes homes so that they are hurricane-resilient (e.g., reinforce two rooms, one with plumbing and one to sleep in). Enhance Anlgua Informalonal Hurricane Enhanced Increased uptake awareness of and awareness and of insurance to insurance Barbuda understanding of protect eligibility, the benefits and homeowners policyholder terms of insurance against climate- responsibililes, among related risks terms of homeowners reference, and coverage Design of a pilot Anlgua Financial Hurricane Understand viability If successful, program of micro and of parametric addilonal financial parametric Barbuda insurance scheme resources are insurance for homeowners available to cover schemes for damages caused to homeowners. homes by climate- related hazards 82 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Develop a Barbuda Physical Hurricane Removal and Reduced loss and comprehensive disposal of derelict damages to community-led housing building stock from and community- derelict housing informed plan to and debris from restore and hurricanes condemn derelict and hurricane- damaged housing in Codrington, which includes cleaning up debris and adequately disposing of materials. Develop and Anlgua Informalonal Hurricane Up-to-date Priorilzalon of key maintain an up-to- database on derelict areas to condemn date inventory of homes available to or convert into CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION derelict housing in facilitate social housing to Anlgua (including condemnalon or reduce hurricane- localons and land conversion into induced damage to ltles) as a climate-resilient housing and precursor to plan social homes infrastructure and priorilze stock condemnalon of derelict homes (including the oplon to assess feasibility of converlng homes into social housing). Provide financial Anlgua Financial Hurricane Incenlves in place A higher incenlves for and Drought to make homes proporlon of new homeowners to Barbuda more hurricane - homes are build new homes resilient constructed with with cisterns, cisterns versus rain rather than rain barrels barrels which are vulnerable to hurricane impacts (flying away). Enforce coastal Anlgua Administralve SLR Future coastal Improved coastal development and , Policy, Flooding developments resilience which in setbacks for Barbuda capacity adhere to coastal turn safeguards beaches and setbacks the housing sector coastlines so that and other structures are not infrastructure built in assets from SLR ecologically and hurricane sensilve areas induced damage 83 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan that compromise resilience. Enhance Anlgua Capacity Hurricane Enhanced New housing enforcement SLR enforcement developments are capacity within Flooding capacity to ensure constructed and the DCA to that homes are sited as per the enforce the constructed in line building code, building code in with the building enhancing sector- Anlgua (e.g., to code wide resilience inspect each phase of housing development and properles for compliance, to enforce adequate setbacks both from roads and adjacent CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION structures in ciles and in coastal areas, to prohibit development on lands less than 0.13m above the SLR risk line, etc.) Re-instate the Barbuda Capacity SLR Re-instated Houses are built to Barbuda Planning Flooding Planning code, thereby Commission and Commission and increasing employ an Inspector resilience of the inspector (e.g., housing stock engineer, architect, or draqsman with in- depth knowledge of the building code) to enforce the building code. Create licensing Anlgua Administralve Hurricane Cerlfied New builds are and cerlficalon and , Policy, SLR contractors highly resilient to for contractors Barbuda Capacity Flooding equipped with the climate impacts, and builders to knowledge and skills minimizing overall build homes in to build climate- damage to the line with climate resilient housing as housing sector resilient building per the building Reduced praclces as per code requirements for the OECS Building sheltering and Code disaster assistance Reduce barriers to post- hurricane access by providing comprehensive educalon and 84 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan training for contractors to acquire the necessary skillset. Informalon Anlgua Informalonal Hurricane Up-to-date Increased number disseminalon to and SLR informalon of homes are homeowners on Barbuda Flooding available to constructed with climate resilient homeowners best praclces as housing and regarding best per the building construclon as praclces for code. outlined in the climate-resilient building code. houses and the (e.g., informalon construclon on how to hire a process contractor and draqsmen; DCA inspeclon process; setbacks CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION for seplc tank systems; material seleclon and other ways to enhance resilience if affordability is an issue (e.g., potenlal financial incenlves) Develop incenlve Anlgua Financial Drought Availability of Greater uptake of programs for and financial incenlves water efficient homeowners to Barbuda to purchase water- appliances increase water efficient appliances efficiency (e.g., through purchasing water- efficient appliances). Fund educalonal Anlgua Informalonal Drought Widespread Greater adoplon campaigns and/or and informalon of water programs to raise Barbuda targeted at conservalon awareness of households to praclces household water conserve water parlcularly during management and during drought drought periods praclces to implement, parlcularly during dry days / drought periods 85 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Table 12: Roads: Summary of prioritized adaptation measures Adaptation Location Category Associated Anticipated Anticipated impact Measures climate outcome (short & (long term) hazard(s) medium term) Develop a Barbuda Physical, Flooding Culverlng system is Reduced instances culverlng system administralve planned and of flooding in and an associated implemented in key roadways and management plan areas to reduce adjacent areas, and roadway flooding reduced maintenance and repair requirements Roulne clean-up Anlgua Maintenance Flooding Reduced liuer in Increased efficacy of liuer/debris and drains and culverts of drainage that clogs Barbuda systems to handle drainage systems rainfall flows, and a and culverts, consequent parlcularly in reduclon in CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION preparalon for an flooding and extreme rainfall recurrent event (e.g., maintenance tropical cyclone). expenditures and Removal of disruplons vegetalon that blocks culverts, and de-sillng of drainage systems. Undertake a Anlgua Administralve Flooding Idenlficalon of Priorilze, assess, comprehensive and areas where and undertake study to increase Barbuda inadequate drainage drainage capacity drainage exists in enhancement along roadways consideralon of (public works) in where inadequate present day and key areas resullng drainage exists, to future climate in reduced flooding account for change impacts projected water flows under future climate change. Increase capacity Anlgua Administralve Hurricane Increased capacity Future roadways of MWH to plan and SLR within MWH to plan are planned and and design climate Barbuda Flooding and design climate designed to be resilient roadways resilient roadways climate-resilient, in anlcipalon of reducing disruplon future climate and maintenance impacts and requirements enhance Improved cross coordinalon with agency other agencies coordinalon for (e.g., APUA) that public works. impact roadway 86 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan construclon and maintenance Ensure that future Anlgua Physical Flooding Future roadway Roads are road upgrades are and upgrades upgraded to be designed to Barbuda incorporate flood resilient account for hard projeclons on surface runoff in anlcipated hard development surface runoff projeclons Enact policies to Anlgua Administralve SLR Policies in place to Reduced risk of prohibit future and prohibit road and loss, damage, and road and public Barbuda infrastructure stranded assets infrastructure development in development in areas of projected areas of projected SLR SLR. Undertake a study Anlgua Administralve SLR Idenlfy coastal Planning and to idenlfy which and roadways implementalon of CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION segments of Barbuda vulnerable to SLR priorilzed coastal roadways and an assess adaptalon are at the greatest appropriate measures to risk of coastal adaptalon reduce roadway erosion and SLR. measures exposure to SLR. Define which adaptalon measures are most appropriate for at-risk road segments (e.g., relocate exislng roads, elevate roadways, coastal defenses green and gray) Ensure that the design of future coastal roadway accounts for SLR and coastal erosion in the design phase (and considers required maintenance works) Youth educalon Anlgua Informalonal Hurricane Increased Significant programs to and Flooding awareness among reduclon of waste reduce waste and Barbuda youth of waste in public spaces avoid liuering in reduclon and and enhanced roadway and adequate disposal funcloning of drainage systems. drainage systems 87 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Table 13: Wastewater: Summary of prioritized adaptation measures Adaptation Location Category Associated Anticipated Anticipated impact Measures climate outcome (short & (long term) hazard(s) medium term) Develop a nalonal Anlgua Administralve Flooding Climate-resilient Adequate wastewater and / Policy Hurricane nalonal wastewater regulatory management and Barbuda Drought management and framework to sanitalon policy sanitalon policy in support the policy. that integrates place climate change consideralons and local knowledge. Specifically, to reduce wastewater CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION spillage following heavy rainfall and flood events. Develop an Anlgua Administralve Flooding Implement aclons Eliminate associated and / Policy Hurricane detailed in the wastewater wastewater and Barbuda Drought nalonal wastewater spillage associated sanitalon aclon management with heavy rainfall plan and strategy events. ecologically Improved health of sustainable fisheries, and framework that marine ecosystems integrates climate (e.g., coral reefs, change adaptalon wetlands, planning seagrass), and a reduclon of eutrophicalon caused by algal blooms and red ldes. Promote Anlgua Financial Drought Increased Reduclon in water household and availability of usage, enhanced greywater reuse Barbuda financial incenlves water conservalon under hygienic for households to and safe install greywater condilons by treatment systems. educalng and incenlvizing homeowners (e.g., subsidies included in mortgages) to install low-cost and low- maintenance grey water treatment, 88 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan which can be used for irrigalon and/ or cleaning. Address Anlgua Physical Drought Increased uptake of Reduclon in water greywater and water efficient waste, enhanced reduclon at the Barbuda fixtures (versus water conservalon point of use by convenlonal) including water efficient fixtures in new residenlal development Centralized Anlgua Physical Flooding Planning, Eliminalon of sewage system in procurement, and wastewater St. John’s City that public works to overflow into St. collects both construct a sewage John’s city and sewage and grey system in St. John’s harbor, and a water to reduce consequent flood impacts in improvement in CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION St. John’s City. public health and the marine environment Upgrade exislng 2 Barbuda Physical Flooding Widespread chamber seplc adoplon of four tank systems to a chamber systems 4-chamber system leading to an with soak aways improvement in and drain fields, public health and including the marine managed wetland environment. systems. Adoplon and Anlgua Capacity Flooding Wastewater Reduclon in enforcement of and Hurricane treatment systems wastewater building and silng Barbuda (e.g., seplc tank overflow and guidelines that systems) are sited, consequent health specify the design constructed, and and environmental and maintenance maintained (CBH) consequences requirements for according to residenlal approved plans wastewater treatment systems DCA Building inspectors and Barbuda Planning Commission inspectors conduct site visits to ensure that seplc tank systems are sized and sited correctly (e.g., adherence 89 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan to setbacks as specified in the Building Code) and CBH capacity to ensure that systems are correctly maintained Table 14: Energy: Summary of prioritized adaptation measures Adaptation Location Category Associated Anticipated Anticipated impact Measures climate outcome (short & (long term) hazard(s) medium term) Decentralize Anlgua Administralve Flooding Reduclon of energy Greater energy energy and /Policy Hurricane supply disruplons independence, less distribulon Barbuda Physical Drought following extreme disruplon, and CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION through events. faster post-disaster microgrids and recovery (aided by renewable energy a more resilient technologies (e.g., and decentralized solar PV) energy system) Improved funcloning of the centralized grid, due to reduced users and demand Incenlve scheme Anlgua Financial Flooding Increased Greater energy for renewable and Hurricanes installalon of independence, less energy, Barbuda Drought renewable energy disruplon, and parlcularly for technologies, faster post-disaster installalons of parlcularly for recovery (aided by greater than 5KW users >5kwh a more resilient (e.g., through a and decentralized one-to-one buy energy system) and sell ralo) Improved funcloning of the centralized grid, due to reduced users and demand Adequate bauery Anlgua Physical Flooding Increased Greater proporlon storage for solar and Hurricanes performance of the of grid-energy is power plants to Barbuda Drought solar power plants fueled by ensure grid with respect to renewable power stabilizalon and installed capacity Greater energy energy storage and larger independence and contribulon of solar reduced reliance energy to the on imported fossil centralized grid fuels (diesel and natural gas) which are vulnerable to 90 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan climate change disruplon through transport (at sea) and storage, as facililes are exposed to climate risk Inveslgate Anlgua Informalonal Hurricanes Undertake wind If feasible, develop feasibility of wind and feasibility project proposal power (offshore Barbuda assessment and financing and land based), mechanisms that incorporates hurricane-resilient design (e.g., blades that can fold down) and silng consideralons CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION 91 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Tourism The tourism sector adaptation plan intends to create an adaptation baseline to then enhance adaptive capacity, strengthen resilience, and reduce vulnerability to the adverse effects of climate change in Antigua & Barbuda. It details specific vulnerabilities, priority areas, proposed activities, and methods to monitor and evaluate the progress of the proposed projects. This plan looks at all the subsections within the tourism sector of Antigua and Barbuda. The Plan was guided by the principles of climate change adaptation, diversification of tourism products, partnerships, social inclusion, protecting the sense of place and ecological sustainability. Background Antigua and Barbuda’s tourism service-based economy is heavily dependent on natural resources, low-lying coastal zones, and favourable climate conditions to support the sector. The tourism sector is also an economic driver, contributing 83.3% to the total economy and supporting 87.7% CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION of jobs in Antigua and Barbuda in 2019. However, Climate change is anticipated to result in an increase in temperature, increase in intensity and frequency of storms, sea level rise and changes in rainfall with a drying trend anticipated for Antigua and Barbuda. The tourism adaptation plan is therefore essential for building the resilience of the sector to climate change and its related hazards. Antigua and Barbuda heavily rely on the tourism sector. As a result of Antigua and Barbuda’s dependence on tourism, the country’s economy is sensitive to changes in the global economy as well as climate change. In 2017, Antigua and Barbuda’s economy contracted as a result of the passage of Hurricane Irma, where real GDP Growth in 2017 was 2.7% compared to 5.3% in 2016 (Caribbean Development Bank, 2018). Whereas in 2020, Antigua and Barbuda’s economy contracted by 16% due to the COVID-19 pandemic (Caribbean Development Bank, 2021). Peak tourism season occurs between December to April, when visitors escape cold winters and can experience the warm climate and enjoy festivals and events. The low season is the period with the least visitors and occurs between July to November, and the shoulder season is neither the high nor low season occurring from May to June. The three main types of tourism in Antigua and Barbuda include stay-over tourism, cruise tourism, and marine tourism (primarily consisting of yachting). However, Antigua and Barbuda is currently developing a homeporting facility that may result in the classification of excursionists. The main tourism markets for Antigua and Barbuda include the United States of America, Canada, Europe, and the Caribbean. Implementation This national adaptation plan for the tourism sector covers a 10-year strategic period 2023– 2033 and is not intended to function in isolation but strongly support sector strategies such as the Tourism Master Plan (2007) as well as the Tourism Strategic Policy and Plan (2005-2009). Of note 92 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan is that the Ministry is currently in the process of developing a National Sustainable Tourism Plan and Policy, which is intended to repeal the previously named outdated plan and policy. The development of the new policy and plan should ensure that there’s coherence and synergies with the tourism SAP. The Tourism SAP consists of 5 prioritized adaptation options, 5 outcomes and 13 outputs that are deemed critical to reduce the impacts of climate and disaster risks and strengthen the resilience of the sector. The overarching goal and outcomes of the TSAP were established based on the review of literature and discussion with stakeholders of the major adaptation needs. The following table outlines the 5 adaptation options, 5 outcomes, and 13 outputs. Further details on the specific activities that should be implemented within each output can be found in the full tourism sector adaptation plan. Table 15: Priority areas for the tourism sector and their strategic objective, outcomes, and outputs. Priority Area Strategic Objective Outcome Output Enhancing resilience of Increase the Implementation of Output 1.1 - Ecosystem CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION tourist facilities and adaptive capacity of climate resilient practices based Approaches (EbA) infrastructure including tourism sector in integrated in risk key support sectors and key support sectors response to a changing reduction and adaptation (agriculture, to climate climate water, energy) to the and disaster risks accelerated Output 1.2 – Reduced risk impacts of Climate at Change subsector level Output 1.3 – Sustainable Energy Water and Waste Management Practices Improve resilience of the All-inclusive Strengthened Output 2.1 – Private tourism sector through and participatory partnerships for resilience sector and civil collaborations and approach for building in society organizations are synergies with all building a sustainable and the tourism sector. fully engaged in CCA other sectors resilient planning and tourism sector in a implementation changing climate Output 2.2 – Public awareness and capacity building for tourism actors and stakeholders Improving evidence- Improve risk identification Evidence-based Output 3.1 – Multi-hazard based decision-making on and assessment and decision-making risk the planning and use of scientific models to enhanced assessments that management of disaster support risk informed through research and integrate climate and climate decision-making innovation projections conducted 93 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan related risks in the sector Output 3.2 – Sector/sub- sector specific analyses of climate impacts conducted Output 3.3 – Research and innovation in technologies for knowledge creation & resilience building Develop sustainable Establish a well-defined Sustainable financing Output 4.1 – Enhanced financing mechanisms for framework for DRR/CCA mechanism for resilience capacity to DRR/CCA actions for financing for resilience building in access funding for resilience building building in the tourism the tourism sector DRR/CCA CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION sector established and resourced. Output 4.2 –Economic analyses of specific tourism climate change adaptation actions evaluated Output 4.3 – Increased investments in and financing of CCA and livelihood protection insurance schemes Strengthening Strengthen the Enabling environment to Output 5.1 – National governance mechanism legal, policy and support disaster risk Sustainable Tourism Plan to sustain DRM/CCA institutional framework to management and Policy formulated and interventions in the facilitate climate change and climate change promulgated sector adaptation in the tourism adaptation sector strengthened Output 5.2 – Institutional and human capacity for the design, implementation, monitoring and evaluation of CCA projects in place Output 5.3 - Climate change issues incorporated in school curricula 94 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Wholesale and Retail Sector The Adaptation Plan for the Wholesale and Retail sector is designed to support the development and implementation of an effective sectoral adaptation strategy and action plan to form part of Antigua and Barbuda’s National Adaptation Plan (NAP), ultimately designed to reduce vulnerability and enhance the resilience of the Wholesale and Retail sector. The key objectives of this project were to conduct a situational analysis of the sector to include a review of key documents and policies; lead consultations with key stakeholders to map climate risks to the sector; to assess the vulnerability of the sector based on national, regional, and global trends in climate and current and projected economic variables; to identify entry points within institutional, policy, and legislative frameworks for prioritized adaptation actions; and to develop a Monitoring, Evaluation, and Learning (MEL) plan that outlines an approach to integrating adaptation options in sectoral policies and plans with related indicators for monitoring and evaluation. The outcomes of these tasks informed the creation of this adaptation plan. The plan is intended to support the DOE to prioritize adaptation actions that reduce vulnerability and enhance resilience of the sector. CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION Although the primary user for this plan is the DOE, the W&R sector have a role in leading some of the implementation actions. Background Generally, the wholesale and retail sector are defined as a two-distribution arrangement that constitutes a major part of the supply chain, meaning that when goods are manufactured, they are sold in large quantities (wholesale) to the wholesalers who further sells them to the retailers who finally sells them to the ultimate customers. The wholesale and retail sector therefore represents the critical link between manufacture and consumption. The wholesale and retail sector includes 136 establishments with a little over 90 per cent of these establishments being in retail with a little less than 10 per cent of the total being wholesale establishments. Of the 136 establishments, two operated both in wholesale and retail – one of these establishments is in the Dairy Product, Beverage Product and Manufacturing Industry and the other is in the Grocery Stores Industry. The sector is dominated by the grocery stores industry and the hardware, plumbing, building materials and supplies industry. The wholesale and retail trade sector contributed to approximately 12% of the GDP in 2021 The economy of Antigua and Barbuda is predominantly a service economy. According to the Labour Force Survey Report, two out of every three workers (66.9%) in Antigua and Barbuda worked in services industries in 2018. The hotel and restaurants industry were the largest employer with 17.4 percent of the employed population. Public administration and defence were the second largest, followed by wholesale and retail trade with 11.0 percent (Antigua and Barbuda Ministry of Finance and Corporate Governance, Statistics Division, 2020). It is important to recognize that these sectors do not stand alone but work together to create the overall economy. The Wholesale and Retail sector is vital to this system. As importers and sellers of necessary goods in the country, negative impacts it experiences will ripple through the other sectors as well. 95 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Approximately 5,517 people are employed in the wholesale and retail sector, representing about 16 percent of the employed force (UN Women). The sector employs the second largest number of workers, with the first being the hotels and restaurants sector which employs 17 percent of the labour force. In 2018, the number of men and women employed in the wholesale and retail sector was almost equal. In addition, wholesale and retail was one of the top two industries that female managers worked in (Antigua and Barbuda Ministry of Finance and Corporate Governance, Statistics Division, 2015). Implementation The adaptive technologies and strategies are designed to reduce vulnerability and enhance resilience of the wholesale and retail sector to climate change. Four key adaptation action areas were identified which are: ○ Physical adaptation and policy planning ○ Climate proofing wholesale and retail buildings CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION ○ Financing and financial instruments for adaptation ○ Training, capacity building, knowledge transfer for adaptation, and business continuity planning The first area, physical adaptation, and policy planning is focused on the built environment and improving its resilience and reducing its vulnerability. The goal of this area is to ensure that climate change impacts are considered when planning and designing infrastructure, deciding locations, and construction principles. They include structural and engineering options to harden infrastructure as well as urban planning instruments such as land-use planning and the development, application, and enforcement of building codes. The wholesale and retail sectoral adaptation plan lays out specific projects that would work towards building resilience, reducing vulnerabilities, and incorporating adaptive strategies in the building sector. The second area, climate proofing wholesale and retail buildings, focuses on adaptation actions to climate-proof buildings pertaining to the wholesale and retail sector. Actions are proposed to make buildings resilient to climate change effects such as heatwaves, coastal flooding, and hurricane wind and surge. The third category, financing and financial instruments for adaptation, considers finance and economic instruments for adaptation activities and disaster recovery from public, private, alternative, or blended sources. Access to finance and insurance cover is a major concern for Antigua and Barbuda businesses. There are several approaches being used currently in adaptation planning and implementation in different parts of the world. The government could offer financing instruments including loans, bonds, and seed capital. Insurance (micro, parametric) can be a cost- effective tool for adaptation planning and implementation. Several cases exist for insurance schemes in low income and developing countries which are a partnership project between private and public entities. 96 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan The fourth category, training, capacity building and knowledge transfer for climate adaptation and business continuity planning, highlights adaptation actions that strengthen the knowledge and capacity of the wholesale and retail sector to respond to and adapt to the effects of climate change. Such measures include knowledge transfer and training on how wholesale and retail businesses can structure their strategic plans to consider and include climate change adaptation practices and design effective business continuity plans that factor in climate change effects. Local Area Adaptation Plans (LAAP) The Local Area Adaptation Plans (LAAP) that have been developed for three areas in Antigua set a strategic framework for guiding and integrating the efforts of national and local government, local development corporations, civil society, businesses, and the international community in strengthening these areas’ capacities to adapt to climate change between 2023 and 2033. The three areas that have been considered are the Airport/Fitches Creek Local Area, St John's City, and the Jolly Harbour to Johnson's Point. These LAAPs provide sets of implementable actions identified CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION by multiple stakeholders as being key to reducing experienced and projected climate impacts in the most vulnerable portions of these areas. They also present combinations of cross-sectoral interventions to strengthen the capacity of the institutions that will play key roles in planning the adaptation actions and integrating these adaptation considerations into current and future development agendas, plans, programmes, and projects. These LAAPs serve as living documents that should undergo periodic revision and modification, where needed. The adaptation options and strategies included in these LAAPs identify indicative lead institutions. The period for implementing the measures, within the LAAP 2023-2033 cycle will be contingent on the availability of both the financial and technical resources required to implement and execute the actions outlined. LAAP Function and Audience The LAAPs have been formulated to: 1. Inform the process of planning, coordinating, and implementing actions urgently needed throughout the three local areas defined to prepare for, and cope with, the impacts of climate variability and change in the medium and long term and, when possible, tap into opportunities to address climate change. 2. Guide the integration of climate change adaptation considerations into ongoing, planned and emerging decision-making processes developed for the portions within each of the three areas that are deemed most vulnerable to climate impacts by stakeholders, i.e., critical infrastructure and facilities, the built environment and residential communities, natural ecosystems, tourism and local businesses. 3. Raise awareness on climate change projections, vulnerabilities, challenges and proposed solutions to promote action for the three defined areas, and encourage collaboration between, ministries, departments, parliamentary representatives and inter-ministerial committees to support the integration of climate change adaptation considerations in all 97 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan decisions made on ongoing and new development activities, programmes, projects and investments for these areas between 2023 and 2033. 4. Be an instrument for the mobilization of resources. The priority measures recommended can be included in projects to be presented to, and funded by, regional and/or international climate finance sources and can also be used by long-standing donor agencies to identify activities to support, based on their own funding priorities and preferences. It is also expected that, where possible, national resources will be allocated to adaptation as these considerations are increasingly included into national development policies, plans and programmes. Goal and Objectives The following adaptation goal and objectives help to provide a structure for the next steps, by clearly defining what the local area stakeholders would like to achieve through adaptation actions. The success of this LAAP will be reliant on the degree to which the overarching goal is CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION accomplished to yield actual climate impact risk reductions. To increase the technical and physical capacity of St. John's City, the Jolly Harbour to Johnson's Point local area, and Airport/Fitches Creek local area to prepare for the impacts of climate change as they seek to become climate-robust areas through effective and coordinated adaptation efforts. Guiding Principles and Cross-cutting Themes The LAAPs are aligned in particular with the National Communications (NCs) to the UNFCCC, and the guides and plans recently developed to advance the overall NAP process. As such, the development of these plans retained some of the same fundamental principles and cross-cutting themes of this NAP which includes: ➢ Ownership: LAAP should be integrated into sectoral policies and plans so that the entire government and key local stakeholders commit to and take ownership of climate-resilient development. ➢ Considerations on demography, gender and social inclusion: the LAAPs and the recommended actions will take into account the differentiated impacts of climate change on men, women, children, the indigent, the elderly, informal business operators, migrants and other potentially vulnerable groups. ➢ Climate measures that are suitable at the local level: The LAAPs will facilitate meeting urgent climate adaptation needs and advancing medium- and long-term adaptation and resilience-building measures so that they are adapted to local and national conditions and needs. ➢ The whole-of-government approach: The LAAPs will seek to benefit from financial climate change investment and sustainable resources to ensure optimal implementation of the priorities identified by the relevant stakeholders. 98 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan ➢ Integration of climate, resilience and livelihood approaches: The LAAPs will guide the implementation of climate change adaptation (CCA) measures within the areas in an integrated manner in order to promote the effectiveness and efficiency of the plans’ implementation. By integrating climate resilience into livelihoods, integrated interventions contribute to economic growth and environmental and socio-economic benefits. ➢ Climate-sensitive planning and budgeting: the LAAPs, through this NAP, will identify entry points and guide the integration of CCA considerations into sectoral planning and budgeting processes as part of the focus on mainstreaming CCA in day-to-day governance processes. ➢ Community stakeholder involvement: the LAAPs intend to identify and implement community centred and -led approaches whereby communities are empowered to strengthen their adaptive capacity and improve coping mechanisms for long-term climate resilience. CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION ➢ The ecosystem-based adaptation approach: the LAAPs identify implementation pathways that strengthen the resilience of biodiversity and ecosystem resources and take a systemic approach to adaptation with respect to natural capital. ➢ The adaptation approach to reinforce the resilience of local area communities to climate change: climate change can have negative impacts on infrastructure and access to services for a large percentage of the population. ➢ Innovation: The LAAPs will provide innovative tools and techniques to improve efficiency and implementation in order to maximize the impact of priority actions. Priority Adaptation Areas and Strategic Objectives Each of the following represents adaptation priorities that have been developed to address climate risk across Antigua, as outlined in the island’s GCF Country Programme: ➢ Improving water security. Antigua and Barbuda must approach 100% reverse osmosis as droughts are becoming more frequent and lasting longer. There is also a need for additional on-site water storage for community buildings (e.g., schools and clinics) to decentralize supply and build resilience when centralized supplies are disrupted by extreme climate events. ➢ Improving energy sector resilience. The country already has approximately 40% redundancy at the national level via back-up diesel generators. The backup energy is primarily in the business sector. One of the resilience targets is a 60–70% increase in renewable back-up energy systems in vulnerable homes and for community businesses 99 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan over a four-year period to build resilience, as the centralized power supply can be disrupted for weeks due to extreme climate events. ➢ Increasing flood and high-intensity hurricane resilience of the national grid infrastructure. ➢ Increasing resilience of buildings. The revised Building Codes for climate resilience will establish guidelines for the construction of new buildings or upgrading of existing buildings that can withstand Category 5 hurricanes. As a key area of concern for Antigua and Barbuda, financing should be secured for this response, particularly at reasonable rates for private homes and businesses. ➢ Improving the protection of coastal areas. The DOE has not yet conducted a significant assessment in this area. The overall NAP is intended to provide more details on the impacts of sea level rise as well as storm surge. ➢ Protecting watersheds and waterways to reduce flooding and control surges in vector populations (e.g., mosquitoes) CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION Based on consultations and a review of the risks across each local area, St. John's City, the Jolly Harbour to Johnson's Point local area, and Airport/Fitches Creek local area, the following strategies and techniques may be considered as a part of the efforts to climate-proof and build resilience for each area: ➢ Climate-proofing utilities ○ Elevating or relocating important electrical equipment to protect them from flooding. ○ Installing smart grid technologies and switches that can redirect power to undamaged sections of the powerline whilst isolating problem areas. Smart grids can also allow utilities that are faced with storm damage to use that data to successfully identify and quickly respond to problem areas in much quicker times. ○ Burying transmission and distribution lines, where feasible. ○ Reinforcing or replacing above-ground poles with more robust alternatives to reduce storm and heat damage. ○ Implementing ‘demand-response’ programs to help make the grid more flexible and resilient during heat waves and periods of high demand. ○ Improving grid reliability and efficiency by expanding transmission capacity, and integrating energy storage, particularly during periods of high usage. ○ Installing more efficient conductors to reduce ‘stress’ on adjacent sections of the grid to further improve overall grid efficiency during periods of demand. ➢ Climate-proofing roads (against flooding and high temperatures) ○ Build flood-barriers. 100 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan ○ Adjust the bituminous mixture design (consider the use of binders with higher softening point, including polymer modification of bitumen, and the selection of stronger aggregate skeleton) ○ Adjust the structural design of sidewalk pavements to make them flexible, semi- rigid and rigid/composite by design. ○ Greater use of concrete due to its higher temperature resistance and other advantages like its longer lifespan, possibility to bear an increased load, and lower need for maintenance. ○ Changing the design of concrete pavement mixtures to reduce the amount of water required. ○ Use of permeable pavements which allows water to be stored in the pavement structure and infiltrated into the soil or discharged by a drainage system. ○ Use of porous top layers that can facilitate the drainage of the water to the sides CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION of the road and prevent aquaplaning. ○ For concrete surfaces, consider using higher cement contents and lower water to cement ratios. ○ Consider the use of hydrophobic coatings suitable for use at the micro-mechanical and or pavement surfacing level. ○ Road maintenance must also be taken into account and should include all maintenance services, like cleaning and maintenance of drainage systems, removing of debris, cleaning of roads, and pruning of brushes. ➢ Increasing the capacity of ecosystems for protection ○ Mangrove wetland and seagrass rehabilitation for areas that have been degraded from anthropogenic activities to maintain ecosystem functioning. ○ Vegetation replanting along roads in flood-prone areas can help to minimize the impact by acting as buffers and also protect roads from direct sunlight. Vegetation should be planted at a sufficient distance from the road. ➢ Climate-proofing homes and businesses ○ Integrate the use of renewable energy to decrease the load demand for power from the grid. ○ Construct and renovate according to the revised national building code. ○ Diversify options for water supply and/or expand current sources to reduce the risk that water supply will fall below water demand. ○ Construct buildings in flood-prone areas on pillars/stilts or construct them within waterproof foundation systems. ➢ Climate proofing bridges ○ Consider the design, construction and management of bridge structures to withstand higher occurrences of flooding, erosion and temperature fluctuation. 101 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan ➢ Climate-proofing waterways, pipelines and drainage systems ○ Consider widening water-retaining structures. ○ The design for culverts should be adjusted to accommodate higher water volumes within a short period of time. ○ Consider the use of intensity-duration-frequency curves to define the capacity design of the drainage system, which takes into account the influence of climate change and future climate scenarios. ➢ Climate-proofing critical/emergency facilities ○ Diversify options for water supply and expand current sources to reduce the risk that water supply will fall below water demand. ○ Increase water storage capacity. ○ Plan and establish alternative or on-site power supply. ○ Install stormwater pumps for backflow prevention. CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION ○ Sea-level rise and coastal storm surges can cause wastewater outlets to backflow. To prevent this, stronger pumps may be necessary. ➢ Climate-proofing tourism assets ○ Diversify options for water supply and expand current sources to reduce the risk that water supply will fall below water demand. ○ Increase water storage capacity. ○ Finance and facilitate systems to recycle water. Greywater frees up more finished water for other uses, thus expanding the supply. ○ Consider installing renewable energy supply. ○ Install stormwater discharge trenches/channels and/or pipes. The following strategies may additionally be set in place for the St. John’s City area: ➢ Climate-proofing ports and piers ○ Install stormwater culverts/pipes to channel water away from assets. ○ Install stormwater pumps/pipes that pump water away to prevent flooding. Where there are already pumps, measures can be taken to increase the strength of these pumps for backflow prevention since sea-level rise and coastal storm surge can cause water outlets to backflow. ○ Install wave attenuators such as bulkheads and seawalls—to combat sea level rise, flooding, and increased wave action from extreme weather. ○ Develop site-specific plans that account for meteorological conditions, climatic hazards, orientation, coastline dynamics, bathymetry, and sediment regime. ○ Adopt a managed adaptive approach that acknowledges uncertainty and encourages appropriately managed flexible and adaptable designs. 102 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan ○ Adapt existing ports to the increases in sea level and wave height by either raising or upgrading the crest of breakwaters, the operating level of quay walls and the mooring facilities at quay walls. The following strategies may additionally be set in place for the Jolly Harbour to Johnson's Point local area: ➢ Resilient RO Plants ○ Reduce energy usage and the resultant carbon footprint of reverse osmosis plants by adopting renewable sources of energy to power both reverse osmosis plants. ○ Upgrading the membranes, pump and energy recovery technologies used. ○ Replacing most of the metal desalination plant equipment and piping with high- quality, non-corroding plastic equipment and piping, or with non-corrosive grade steel. CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION ○ Establish a plant-specific emergency action plan with protocols, particularly for hurricanes/storms, that includes a detailed list of physical preparations, timelines, and communication directives. Ensuring that operators have satellite phones to communicate if cell towers become unresponsive/damaged during an extreme event. ○ Long-term monitoring programs that characterize seawater quality should be conducted at the plant intake site(s). ○ RO plants can potentially prevent hydraulically irreversible fouling and continue operations during periods of high-density sargassum blooms by using techniques like reducing flux, recirculating flow, use of coagulation by either optimizing the dose or switching on coagulation in response to blooms, and decreasing backwashing intervals, among other techniques. ➢ Protecting heritage sites and ruins ○ Build flood barriers to protect infrastructure, like levees or seawalls. ➢ Increasing the capacity of ecosystems for protection ○ Mangrove wetland and seagrass rehabilitation for areas that have been degraded from anthropogenic activities to maintain ecosystem functioning. ○ Conduct a study to understand the hydrodynamics and response of nearby wetlands to storm surge event. ○ Vegetation replanting along roads in flood-prone areas can help to minimize the impact by acting as buffers and protect roads from direct sunlight. Vegetation should be planted at a sufficient distance from the road. ➢ Additional resiliency measures for the Airport ○ Diversify options for water supply and expand current sources to reduce the risk that water supply will fall below water demand. 103 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan ○ Increase water storage capacity. ○ Plan and establish alternative or on-site renewable energy power supply. ○ Maintain existing hurricane/storm proof measures that were considered during the construction of the new establishment. ➢ Climate-proofing Marinas ○ Install stormwater culverts/pipes to channel water away from assets. ○ Install stormwater pumps/pipes that pump water away to prevent flooding. Where there are already pumps, measures can be taken to increase the strength of these pumps for backflow prevention since sea-level rise and coastal storm surge can cause water outlets to backflow. ○ Install wave attenuators such as bulkheads and seawalls—to combat sea level rise, flooding, and increased wave action from extreme weather. ○ Develop site-specific plans that account for meteorological conditions, climatic CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION hazards, orientation, coastline dynamics, bathymetry, and sediment regime. ○ Adopt a managed adaptive approach that acknowledges uncertainty and encourages appropriately managed flexible and adaptable designs. ○ Adapt existing ports to the increases in sea level and wave height by either raising or upgrading the crest of breakwaters, the operating level of quay walls and the mooring facilities at quay walls. ➢ Climate-proofing the educational institutions ○ Install flood barriers to protect critical infrastructure. ○ Consider flood proofing critical equipment, placing important assets within waterproof containers. ○ Plan and establish an alternative power supply. ○ Install stormwater culverts/pipes to channel water away from assets. ○ Install stormwater pumps/pipes that pump water away to prevent flooding. ○ Rainwater harvesting and recharge systems that capture water on the roofs of buildings. ○ Create vegetation barrier. ➢ Other measures relevant to the Airport/Fitches Creek local area ○ Implement watershed management to include a range of policy and technical measures that focuses on preserving or restoring vegetated land cover in a watershed and managing stormwater runoff to help mimic natural watershed hydrology, increase groundwater recharge, reduce runoff, and improve the quality of runoff. ○ Implement saltwater intrusion barriers by injecting fresh water into aquifers to act as a barrier, while intrusion recharges groundwater resources. 104 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan ○ Ensuring the rehabilitation of mines/quarries by replanting vegetation limits sedimented runoff into watercourses and the sea. Based on these priority areas, the following strategic action plan, with four (4) strategic objectives, was developed: ➢ Strategic Objective 1: Building coastal resilience to hurricanes and tropical storm impacts through improved coastal zone management and climate adaptation action/measures. ➢ Strategic Objective 2: Eliminating future losses from flood hazards through strengthening critical infrastructure and building institutional capacity. ➢ Strategic Objective 3: Enhancing resilience to drought hazards and warmer temperatures. ➢ Strategic Objective 4: Mainstreaming considerations for future sea level rise CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION St John’s City Local Area Adaptation Plan St. John’s City is the capital of Antigua and Barbuda which is located on the northwest coast of Antigua, adjacent to a sheltered natural deep-water harbour. The demarcated area of focus is bordered by St. John’s Harbour to the west; Dickenson Bay Street to the north; Stapleton Lane, Independence Avenue and Camacho Avenue to the east; and the Grays Farm Main Road to the south. Surrounding St. John’s City is St. John’s Rural which makes up the remainder of the St. John’s parish. St. John's City is the most urban and developed area in the country and serves as the chief commercial centre and port of entry for Antigua. It is also the largest city in the country, being approximately 10 km2 in size, with a maximum elevation of 59 meters (194 feet) above mean sea level. One of the main hazards that threaten livelihoods in the St John’s City local area is flooding, particularly flash flooding following heavy rains. Stakeholders consulted have indicated that flooding is more prominent in areas near the coast, along watercourses, and major drain systems for areas further inland (Figure 3-3). This is linked to the topography of St. John’s City, as eastern sections are elevated and gently slope westward to St. John’s Harbour, ending in a coastal plain that is flat and low-lying. As a result, areas along the coastline are prone to flooding from heavy prolonged rainfall events. In the past, flood waters triggered by such events have resulted in surface water levels high enough to restrict access to roadways and sidewalks, damage low-lying building structures, flood homes, stores, stalls, and businesses, limit vehicular traffic flow and disrupt the activities of both local and tourist-based pedestrians and shoppers. 105 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION Figure 13: Stakeholder Perception Map of key Climatic and Non-Climatic Hazards affecting the St. John’s City Local Area St. John’s City has been impacted by the onset of hurricanes and tropical storms in the past. Despite past impacts, stakeholders have noted that the sheltered geography of the city has limited the extent of damage to the area. Nevertheless, the impact of the strong hurricane and storm- forced winds and storm surge from storms and hurricanes that have made landfall in Antigua i.e., Dorian (1971), Helena (1963), Luis (1995), Georges (1998), Jose (1999), and Gonzalo (2014) have resulted in widespread damage. The low-lying coastal nature of St. John’s City also puts coastal infrastructure and operations at risk from coastal inundation associated with rising sea levels. Several important sites in the city are already near mean sea level and are at risk of coastal inundation. The Antigua Distillery Limited Beverage Bottling Facility, James Service Station, the Fisheries Office, the cruise ports, and markets, for instance, are generally flat and lie at just over 10 feet above mean sea level. The low elevation also means that with future increases in mean sea level, existing groundwater resources are at risk of saline intrusion, underground fuel storage tanks are at risk of corroding, and other coastal structures will be more susceptible to flooding. Antigua and Barbuda rank as one of the most water-stressed countries in the Caribbean (United Nations, 2021). The country’s Voluntary National Review of SDGs, 2021 noted that “the demand for water has drastically exceeded the available supply from ground and surface water”. This demand, however, is a challenge, since rainfall has decreased in the Caribbean in the last century (as established under the Mainstreaming Adaptation to Climate Change (MACC) Project, 2010) with below-average rainfall being recorded across the Caribbean in 2015 (NOAA, 2015). 106 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan St. John’s Implementation Plans Based on the strategic objectives previously defined, there are corresponding cross-cutting outcomes aimed at establishing and managing activities geared towards addressing climate adaptation based on the main climatic hazards affecting the area (See appendix for the ten (10) outcomes and associated outputs for the St. John’s City LAAP 2023-2033). Darkwood Beach Local Area Adaptation Plan The designated Jolly Harbour to Johnsons Point local area is located along the southwestern coast of Antigua in the parish of St. Mary, about 15 km from the St. John’s City. The area stretches from Jolly Harbour to Turner’s Beach and the Johnsons Point community and is bordered to the west by Lignumvitae Bay, Ffryes Bay, and Picarts Bay. To the east, it is bordered by Valley Road and includes the adjacent swamp ponds, wetlands, and communities. Adjacent to this local area are the Bolans and Jennings communities as well as the higher-elevation areas of Crabb’s Hill. The CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION Parish of St. Mary’s is located in Antigua’s southwest volcanic region. The volcanic areas contain several small alluvial valleys rising to Boggy Peak at 402 meters above sea level. The Jolly Harbour to Johnsons Point local area is located within the Christian Valley Watershed and includes most of the developments along the southwestern coast. This watershed is 1,780 hectares with a ground water yield of 610,000 m3 /year. The watershed facilitates 3.7 hectares of storage for agricultural purposes and 67.2 hectares of municipal storage. The Bolans Watershed, which includes a section of the Christian Valley watershed, occupies about 19 km2 and is bounded by the southwest watershed. Uncontrolled and unregulated topsoil and sand mining in the Christian Valley watershed have affected agricultural fields and the erosive force of the heavy rains has had an impact on the overall ecosystems in the area. The Jolly Harbour to Johnsons Point local area is affected by both coastal and flash flooding. The impacts are often seen when there is heavy continuous rainfall that produces >3 inches of rainfall, meaning that intermittent rainfall does not typically result in any notable flooding. To identify the area’s most at risk of flooding and the extent of the potential impact, flood inundation maps were developed using locally available georeferenced data sets provided by the Department of Environment (Figure 3-4 and Figure 3-5). The maps depict flood inundation levels ranging from less than 0.5 meters to 4.5 meters overlaid against the natural and built environment in the area. The maps show that while flood risks are uneven and highly localized, a significant proportion of the Jolly Harbour to Johnsons Point Area is susceptible to flood inundation. 107 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION Figure 14: Coastal Inundation Scenarios for Jolly Harbour Figure 15: Coastal Inundation Scenarios for Ffryes Beach to Johnsons Point 108 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Hurricanes and extreme tropical storms have been reported to cause significant loss to seagrass beds as well as damage to coastal infrastructures such as hotels and restaurants that are located along the southwestern stretch of the coastline. Additionally, major hurricanes in the past have resulted in significant loss of income for fisherfolk due to the lengthy period it normally takes for them to recover after a hurricane as a result of damage to boats, poor visibility, excess debris, damage to fish pots, and drifting of fish pots. For example, during Hurricane Earl (2010), fisherfolk in Jolly Harbour expressed loss of fishing vessels and equipment damage. Further studies conducted following the hurricane estimated this cost to be approximately EC$352,730. Although not as densely populated as St. John’s City, the Jolly Harbour to Johnson’s Point local area has several established communities and tourism establishments. Whilst the replacement costs may not be as high for this local area when compared to St. John’s City, the cost implications are still very high. The total built infrastructure would cost an estimated US$244,750,875. Projections for more intense hurricanes thus suggest a continued and growing risk of storm surge impacts for the area. CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION Drought has become a recurrent hazard in Antigua which typically results in a severe reduction in water availability. Although some stakeholders indicated that the ongoing drought has not resulted in significant water shortages as is being experienced in other areas across Antigua, the hotels and surrounding health facilities that have a high-water demand, have indicated that they are feeling the effects through the consistently limited water availability. Similarly, farmers have also noted that drought conditions have been affecting their crop production and irrigation water supply. They have had to seek supplemental water supply with storage tanks and water retention ponds. Across the board, this has resulted in financial strain. Based on the climate change projections for the island, sea level rise is expected along the coastline of Antigua and Barbuda. Given the low-lying nature of the Jolly Harbour to Johnsons Point local area, any significant increase in mean sea level will threaten large tracts of land along the coast, with the potential to cause significant damage to buildings and key infrastructure and the permanent loss of valuable coastal lands. Figure 3-9 and Figure 3-10 show SLR projections for the Darkwood Beach local area for two scenarios (0.13m and 1.45m) based on the respective lower and upper values of mean SLR predictions for the Caribbean by 2100, i.e., end of century. The lower value of 0.13m SLR corresponds with the IPCC SRES B1 scenario and the upper value of 1.45m is based on research by Rahmstorf (2007) which suggests that future SLR might be in the order of twice the maximum level that the IPCC predicted for the worst case A2 scenario (Simpson et al, 2010). The dataset was created by JECO Caribbean for the OECS ICZM Policy Setback Guidelines, 2015. 109 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION Figure 16 : Sea Level Rise Perception for Jolly Harbour Figure 17: Sea Level Rise Perceptions for Jolly Harbour 110 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Darkwood Beach Implementation Plans Based on the strategic objectives previously defined, there are corresponding cross-cutting outcomes aimed at establishing and managing activities geared towards addressing climate adaptation based on the main climatic hazards affecting the area. (See appendix for the eleven (11) outcomes and associated outputs for the Darkwood Beach LAAP 2023-2033). Airport/Fitches Creek Local Area Adaptation Plan The Airport and Fitches Creek Local Area is located along the northern coast of Antigua in the parish of St. George. The area of focus is bordered by Jabberwock Road and Sir George Walter Highway to the west, Palmetto Drive, and the Piggott’s community to the south and the Fitches Creek Bay and wetlands to the east. The area is mainly flat with an undulating topography consisting of several small hills across the area. Notable points of interest within the area include the Fitches Creek and Piggott’s residential communities; the V.C. Bird International Airport; CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION educational institutions like the American University of Antigua, the Antigua and Barbuda Hospitality Training Institute, Antigua and Barbuda International Institute of Technology and the American International College of Arts and Sciences Antigua; the Camp Blizzard Military Base and the associated Reverse Osmosis Plant, the Shell Beach Reverse Osmosis Plant, restaurants and villas like the Dutchman’s Bay Cottages, Cecelia’s and The Anchor Bar and Restaurant; the Coolidge Cricket Grounds, and historic sites like the Nibbs Sugar Windmill Ruins, Barnacle Point, the St. George Anglican Church, the Antigua Sugar Mills and the Dungeon which are frequented by tourists. The property on which the Antigua Sugar Mills resided has been converted into an upscale housing development. Additionally, the Fitches Creek watershed is one of the six major watersheds in Antigua which has been recognized as critical based on their agro-ecological, hydrological, and socio-economic values. This watershed is 1,040 hectares in size with an existing 135.4 hectares of storage for agricultural purposes. The coastal zone of the Fitches Creek/Airport Local Area, i.e., Jabberwock Beach, Shoal Bay, Dutchman’s Bay, and the Fitches Creek Bay is also included as a part of the Northeast Marine Management Area (NEMMA), a large multi-use protected area located on the Northeast Coast of Antigua covering over 30 square miles. It includes a rich marine environment containing fringing reefs and seagrass beds. Beaches within the NEMMA are important as nesting habitats for marine turtles. Some of the beaches show erosion caused by oceanic conditions and hurricanes. Fitches Creek Bay and the Parham Harbour (located on the outskirts of the defined local area) are two large bays separated by Blackman’s Point which support an almost unbroken stretch of mangroves. At Fitches Creek Bay, a deep, mangrove-lined channel extends 1.5 km inland, and mangroves fringe the coast for ~1 km. This is a wetland site where the vulnerable West Indian Whistling-Duck is known to be found. Extreme weather events like hurricanes and tropical storms are expected to worsen in the coming decades under all emission scenarios. During the hurricane season, the area is at risk of being affected by strong winds and storm surges. In the past, inland areas like the Piggott’s community have been severely affected by hurricanes and tropical storms. In 1999, Hurricane Jose and 111 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Tropical Storm Lenny occurred within a month of each other. The events resulted in extensive flooding to the point where an estimated 62 residents from the Piggott’s community had to be rescued from rooftops in boats. A total of 98 homes in Piggott’s were affected, which amounted to 468 persons being impacted. Based on storm surge projections, the entire Jabberwock area, the coastline, and roadway along Winthorpes Bay (northwest of the V.C. Bird International Airport), St. Georges Drive, and the sections of the Fitches Creek wetlands are the main areas that are also at risk of exposure from as low as 1.2m storm surge associated with hurricanes and tropical storms. SLR projections for the Airport/Fitches Creek local area for two scenarios (0.13m and 1.45m) are based on the respective lower and upper values of mean SLR predictions for the Caribbean by 2100, i.e., end of century. The lower value of 0.13m SLR corresponds with IPCC SRES B1 scenario and the upper value of 1.45m is based on research by Rahmstorf (2007) which suggests that future SLR might be in the order of twice the maximum level that the IPCC predicted for the worst case A2 scenario (Simpson et al, 2010). The dataset was created by JECO Caribbean for the OECS ICZM Policy Setback Guidelines, 2015. CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION Antigua is affected by droughts every 3 to 5 years as drought has become a recurrent feature that typically results in a severe reduction in water availability. In the Airport/ Fitches Creek Area, water is supplied by the APUA. The effects of drought are being felt by both residents and business operators. The residents from the Fitches Creek community and resort owners have indicated that the APUA has consequently restricted access to piped water to 2-3 days per week. As such, there is inconsistent access to water. In response, residents in the community have retained their own water storage tanks and purchased trucked water. Since the nature of the airport services are deemed essential, priority is given for water supply. The Airport/Fitches Creek area has been affected by both coastal and flash flooding in the past. This type of hazard is projected to affect some sections of the local area in the future. Of the two, flash floods occur more frequently and are characterized by either rapid accumulation or runoff of surface water in response to heavy rainfall events. Airport/Fitches Creek Implementation Plan Based on the strategic objectives previously defined, there are corresponding cross-cutting outcomes aimed at establishing and managing activities geared towards addressing climate adaptation based on the main climatic hazards affecting the area. The twelve (12) outcomes and associated outputs for the Airport/Fitches Creek LAAP 2023-2033 are summarized below: Overall LAAP Implementation It is anticipated that the adaptation measures presented in the LAAP for St. John’s City will be implemented or at least initiated during the 2023-2033 period, according to their degree of urgency. However, their implementation will depend on funding, policy and other opportunities opening during this time, as it is expected that opportunities for implementation will be seized as 112 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan they arise. Although the plan focuses on a particular local area, given the cross-sectorial nature of the LAAP, it is to be expected that the execution of most of the specific measures may occur because of their inclusion in projects and programmes funded by both national and international sources. The LAAP includes indicative outputs to facilitate the planning and design of such projects and programmes. The execution of most activities included in the LAAP relies on the assumption that further to national budgetary efforts that are commensurate with national circumstances, the level of international support that Antigua and Barbuda has received for development and for climate change projects and programmes will be maintained and that additional climate finance for adaptation in the sectors will be attracted through entities like the Green Climate Fund (GCF), Adaptation Fund and multilateral and bilateral arrangements. It is also assumed that over time, adaptation will become immersed in all new development projects. In view of the above considerations, it is in the area’s best interest, in the coming years, and to the maximum extent possible, that elements of the LAAP be integrated into the existing and CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION proposed cooperation programmes of Antigua and Barbuda’s bilateral and multilateral partners. The LAAP should be shared and discussed with all relevant partner agencies and stakeholders to facilitate awareness raising of its objectives and planned activities and secure high-level buy-in that will enhance opportunities for the inclusion of the priorities in national and sectoral policy and budgets, as appropriate.
3.8. Communications Plan The National Adaptation Plan (NAP) necessitates the effective implementation of strategic communication practices to foster a comprehensive transformation on both sectoral and national fronts, addressing the challenges posed by climate change adaptation. A seamless integration of strategic communication throughout all phases of the NAP process—Planning, Implementation, and Evaluation—is essential to achieve these overarching objectives. In the Planning stage, the conduct of a comprehensive scoping exercise assumes critical importance. This exercise serves as a pivotal tool in assessing existing and projected climate conditions, facilitating the identification of potential challenges and opportunities that are integral to formulating effective adaptation strategies. Transitioning to the Implementation phase, a robust coordination mechanism among all pertinent stakeholders within the sector becomes paramount. Collaboration of this nature is central to the successful execution of the NAP and the realization of its intended objectives. In the Evaluation phase, the collation of relevant data takes precedence in order to gauge the extent of goal attainment. Valuable insights garnered from the evaluation process subsequently guide informed decisions, facilitating the refinement of adaptation strategies for future endeavours. 113 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan The underlying strategy seeks to highlight the pivotal role of strategic communications in support of the NAP’s success. The strategic objectives encompass building public awareness of environmental policies, clarifying actionable steps for individual contribution, advocating for a comprehensive governmental approach, highlighting the urgency of adaptation efforts, and enhancing global recognition of the NAP process. The Communication outreach targets both internal and external audiences. Internally, stakeholders directly involved in sectoral planning and other associated ministries are prioritized, while externally, the focus extends to encompass the public, media, private sector, NGOs, academia, and technical experts. Effective message delivery is done by employing relatable narratives, factsheets, statistics, and memorable phrases to engage a wide spectrum of demographics. Strategies for communication effectiveness include the development of a recognizable NAP logo CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION and slogan, the utilization of media formats such as animated and live-action videos, the engagement of influential figures as climate ambassadors, and the establishment of a structured dissemination schedule. Public engagement through workshops, consultations, and climate conversations facilitates informed dialogue and corrections of misinformation were also paramount. Moreover, much of the content produced was uploaded on the Department of Environment’s webpage and social media platforms for them to be easily accessed and viewed by the public. Furthermore, the integration of digital engagement through social media platforms ensures broader reach and stakeholder engagement. A comprehensive approach encompasses capacity- building initiatives, such as training programs and scholarships, reinforcing the knowledge and skills required for effective climate change adaptation.
3.9. Incorporation of Climate Change into Development Policies and Strategy (i.e., Mainstreaming Guidelines) Development Control Authority (DCA) The physical development process is fundamentally contained and guided by the Physical Planning Act (PPA) 2003. Physical development in Antigua and Barbuda is managed by (i) zoning and (ii) development control for specific activities. The primary agency responsible for the enforcement of provisions under the PPA is the Development Control Authority (DCA). Zoning The PPA allows the DCA to engage in a process of developing plans for large areas of land either covering the whole or part of Antigua and Barbuda. Zoning classifies land into groupings which ensures that the general land use follows the most suited development pathway as suggested by 114 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan the classification. An important part of this is recognizing the best available scientific and technical knowledge to achieve sustainability. As such, ecosystem function, vulnerability to environmental extremes, historical events, geology, hydrology, customary usage, and prospective for future economic activities all play important roles in developing effective zoning plans. In 2012, the government of Antigua and Barbuda completed a multi-year process in the development of a national physical development plan with the formal adoption by the Parliament of the Sustainable Island Resource Management Zoning Plan (SIRMZP). Funded through the GEF- sponsored SIRMM project, the SIRMZP specifically, “Vulnerability to external economic shocks and natural environmental events, such as economic recessions and hurricanes, and climate change;” as a major issue which the SIRMZP was intended to address. Development Control The Ministry of Housing, Lands, and Urban Renewal is responsible for Physical Planning in Antigua and Barbuda through its agency, the DCA. The DCA enforces control over development, and CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION prepares and enforces development plans and proposals, whereas zoning achieves overall general conformity and suitability of activities within an area, the Development Control Application and Approval process looks at the proposed activity from a more detailed human and environmental health and safety approach. Climate change is mainstreamed in several ways: ● Implementing and updating of building code ● Establishing Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) provisions within the PPA and the Environmental Protection and Management Act (EPMA) Updating the Building Code Given the latest climate science from the IPCC, the DoE in collaboration with the DCA has reviewed the OECS 2016 code as Antigua and Barbuda building code. The main aim of the revised code is to increase the resilience of the building sector standard in Antigua and Barbuda in keeping with Climate change science and which is underpinned by “Sustainable Development” & Health & Wellness”. It incorporates health and wellness dimensions of air quality, sound pollution, lighting & thermal comfort. With respect to sustainable development, the updated code will include standards for designing for Cat5 considerations, energy efficiency, updated water efficiency & storage, coastal setback, SLR, materials, resources inclusions & sustainable site, and zoning recommendation. Noted that with respect to storms, the minimum standard of the code is still for low cat 3, and high cat 4 winds, but it allows for voluntary compliance to higher cat-rated standards because of the economic implications. The code considers droughts and rainwater harvesting. Formalizing the EIA process Prior to the passage of the PPA in 2003, there was no legal requirement for an EIA in Antigua and Barbuda. 115 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan The preeminent legal guidance addressing the EIA process in Antigua and Barbuda can be found in the PPA 2003. Specifically, Section 23 (1), (2), and Schedule 3 of PPA, 2003 outline those activities that require an EIA. Additionally, the Director of the Department of Environment may also require, in consultation with the Chief Town and Country Planner that any matter that is likely to cause any serious social impact, or harm to the environment or to human health be subject to an environmental impact assessment. Section 23 (1), (2), and Schedule III of the PPA 2003, lists activities and undertakings that require an EIA. All projects undertaken for or on behalf of the DoE are subjected to a screening process, which will signal if an EIA is required. Within the DoE, the Biodiversity Ecosystem and Protected Areas Management (BEPAM) Unit is primarily responsible for oversight of EIA-related activities. Other Units within the DoE may be required to provide assistance as may be necessary based on needed skill sets. The inclusion of the SIRMZP, Building Code, and the EIA Process into the Development Control CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION Application and Approval system has allowed climate change to be considered at multiple stages. Table 16: EIA process and responsible parties. Development Application Climate Change Concerns Responsible Party Stage Pre-submission of application Is the area regularly subjected Developer to extreme climate events- flooding, high waves, drought, storms, heat? Submission of application Does it require EIA? DCA/DoE EIA Process Will the proposed EIA Consultant, DoE, other development be potentially relevant agencies disruptive to ecosystem services? What in-depth studies to examine climate change risks and propose mitigation measures need to be undertaken? Detailed drawings submitted- Does it meet building code Contractor, DCA Construction criteria for human and EIA Consultant, DOE environmental health and safety? Is it strong enough to withstand storms? The office of the BEPAM Unit works closely with the Office of the Director of Environment and has significant overlaps. This Unit has responsibility for: 116 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan 1. Environmental Policies and Plans (Part IV of the EPMA 2015) 2. Natural Resources Management (Part VII of the EPMA 2015) a. Watersheds and Wetlands b. Protected Areas c. Wildlife Protection and Trade 3. Access to Genetic Resources and the Sharing of Benefits (Part VIII of the EPMA 2015) 4. Implementation of Biodiversity Projects in Collaboration with the PMU. In the implementation of these aspects of the legislation the BPAM: ● Reviews DCA plan applications to identify potential environmental risks. ● Responds to requests for environmental advice from other units within the DoE, government agencies, the private sector, Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs), and the public. ● Receives and responds to environmental complaints and incident concerns. ● Provides recommendations for solving environmental incidents that could be reported CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION to or observed by the staff of the DoE. ● Implements those actions aimed at achieving conservation and management of selected natural resources. Within the scope of work in the unit, climate change and its impacts have been taken into consideration when reviewing DCA applications and environmental complaints. Screening and Scoping exercises for each application are carried out, as well as applying the Ccoral tool. Aspects such as SLR, Setbacks, Coastal Engineering Studies, protection for mature trees, replanting vegetation if removed, and protection of mangroves and other wetlands are also examined in the review process. The DoE has also been very vocal when it pertains to sand mining and the need to stop such activities. Various developments in Barbuda for example, the unit has received numerous applications along the more vulnerable sandbar and other sensitive areas of the coastline. Susceptible areas prone to flooding and storm surges in Antigua such as Cades Bay, Dickenson’s Bay, and McKinnon’s Pond, the unit requests the developers disclose the impacts the developments will have on adjacent properties and the financial costs they will incur. However, most of these applications would have been rejected or recommended that alternative sites be chosen considering impacts from climate change including storm surges from hurricanes and flooding from torrential rainfall. The Terms of Reference (ToR) provided by the unit to produce an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) contains a section that requests the developer to note the impacts of climate change. Given the nature of these proposed developments and the sensitive environment in which they are proposed to be located, the investment will likely be exposed to projected impacts of climate change, including, but not limited to increasing rainfall intensity, sea-level rise, decreasing average annual rainfall, and extreme temperatures. To ensure that the development is climate- resilient, potential impacts must be assessed and mitigation measures proposed in the planning and assessment stage. The unit includes the below table within the ToR. 117 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Impact Brief Description Risk Significance Mitigation High/Medium/Low Measures Extreme rainfall event Extreme drought Extreme atmospheric temperatures Hurricanes Sea Level Rise Other Table 17: Summary of risks associated with climate change impacts and mitigation measures The unit has also seen applications where developers intend to integrate renewable energy into the power supply. This was commendable and in line with the Greenhouse Gas reduction statements made by the government within its Intended Nationally Determined Contribution to CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION the Paris Climate Change Agreement. It should also be noted that Antigua and Barbuda has participated in the development and has adopted the regional (Renewable Energy) RE Building Code. Further, the government has waived taxes on RE and energy-efficient technologies. For development and subdivisions along waterways, the unit has included a caveat that encourages the DCA to have the relevant agencies implement protective borderline measures, such as boulders and signage informing developers of the imminent risk of development close to the waterway, as well as climate change impacts and its implication. Other Agencies who Contribute to the Physical Planning Aspect of Development NODS- Disaster Planning, Build Back Better, Climate Adaptation closely linked to Disaster mitigation. Fisheries Division – Marine Protected Areas, Coastal and marine resources APUA /PWD /CBH -Water courses Green Barbuda Project Antigua and Barbuda produced most of its emissions from the electricity sector, specifically the large diesel generators used in the generation process. By removing those generators and putting in renewable energy, as in the case of the Green Barbuda Power Plant, we are going to reduce our emissions a lot. In 2015, Antigua and Barbuda submitted its first NDC. The target is to phase out 90 percent of fossil fuels in the electricity sector by 203. As a result, therefore, the DoE would need to learn how to conduct and assess fossil fuels when processing development applications. In the end, the DoE 118 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan conducted a training field assessment during the period of July 27- 29, 2020, in Barbuda. The aim was to gather as much baseline data, to aid in the preparation of an Environment Impact Statement (EIS) for the project. This EIS practical field exercise served as a training opportunity, while also achieving ‘Output 5.1: Climate Change mainstreamed into the national development process,’ of the 4NC implementation plan. This will also build the DoE’s capacity for the inclusion of climate change impacts in the national development process. On completion of the field exercise, and preparation of the EIS, best practices and lessons learned were documented for future EIAs. Ministry of Finance The Ministry of Finance (MoF) with the support of the NDC Partnership has engaged a climate finance analyst and an economic advisor. Both consultants have started their work, and their CHAPTER 3: IMPLEMENTING ADAPTATION intended deliverables include incorporating the NDCs in the updated Medium Term Development Plan and the Macroeconomic framework. The Consultants were sourced through WRI, and they are funded by the United Kingdom and the World Bank. Similarly, the MoF is working with respect to Post Disaster Management. The ministry is currently undertaking a project with the World Bank and Canada to improve Post Disaster Procurement and Public Financial Management. The government launched a Climate Resilience Fund in the 2020 budget, however, due to COVID-19 this fund is now scheduled for roll out in 2021. The budget circular for 2020 and 2021 advised ministries of their need to identify climate risks as part of their budget estimates and planning and the MoF intends to further strengthen this integration in budget management going forward. 119 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan CHAPTER 4: FINANCING STRATEGY CHAPTER 4: FINANCING STRATEGY 120 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan 4. Financing Strategy Achieving ambitious adaptation actions requires adequate planning, analysis, and resource mobilization from a wide range of sources. Antigua and Barbuda’s NAP financing strategy includes an overview of actions, sources of funding, as well as some key stakeholders in the process. This draws from work previously undertaken by the government and creates synergies with previous efforts to ensure that the NAP builds on a robust and comprehensive framework. This section thus identifies relevant potential sources of finance, different streams of finance, and key stakeholders in the NAP financing process. Process for Sourcing Funding In the pursuit of funding for NAP implementation for Antigua and Barbuda, a systematic approach is essential to navigate the climate finance landscape. This section outlines a structured process for sourcing funding, beginning with the critical task of problem prioritization. By identifying and ranking environmental issues based on urgency and impact, stakeholders can lay the foundation for targeted interventions. The subsequent phases delve into the project idea conceptualization, CHAPTER 4: FINANCING STRATEGY engaging with diverse stakeholders, mapping potential funding sources, and project and proposal development. Together, these steps form a comprehensive guide for the process entailing securing access to climate finance for NAP implementation. Problem Prioritization This initial step involves identifying and prioritizing climate-related challenges that need to be addressed. It entails analysing the urgency, severity, and impact of these issues within a specific context or region, laying the groundwork for potential projects to tackle these problems. This step involves identifying prioritization criteria and corresponding indicators to capture the degree of strategic alignment with broader goals, feasibility of implementation, and outcomes of the activity. Problem prioritization is a key step that is essential to the appropriate channelling of finance and resources into projects and activities that have the greatest adaptation potential in alignment with the NAP’s priorities. Project Idea Conceptualization During this stage, the project features, objectives, goals, and expectations that are set to determine what the focus of the project will be, and basic information on the potential barriers and requirements for implementing the project are compiled. Here, brainstorming and developing innovative project ideas are required to adequately map the identified problems to their appropriate and viable solutions. It is also important for this stage to identify potential barriers, gaps and challenges that might arise during the project that will need addressing, including within institutional or financing arrangements. 121 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan
4.1. Stakeholder Engagement Engaging with various stakeholders such as local communities, NGOs, government agencies, and experts become crucial. This step involves garnering support, gathering insights, and involving key stakeholders in the project's design and development, ensuring a more comprehensive and inclusive approach. Stakeholder engagement is essential to improve data sharing for project criteria and indicators, as well as to increase buy-in in the project pipeline. Additionally, the Government of Antigua and Barbuda (GoAB) and the DOE have worked extensively with various policy planning support agencies that can also be considered key stakeholders for broader engagement in the NAP process. These agencies include the NDC Partnership, NAP Global Network, CCCCC, CDB, and Commonwealth Climate Finance. The Santiago Network on Loss and Damage can additionally provide technical assistance where appropriate. Mapping of potential funding sources Conducting research and mapping potential funding sources follows, involving identifying and CHAPTER 4: FINANCING STRATEGY assessing various funding options available — including public funds, private investors, grants, and specialized climate finance institutions that align with the project's objectives. This step enables the identification of potential sources of funding available, which will also further determine the proposal development phase of the project. In previous work undertaken to advance access to climate finance, implement NDCs, build capacity, and enhance institutional arrangements for climate in the country, the DOE has received funding from and partnered with various multilateral climate financing agencies, many of which have provided varied types of funding over the years. Some of these key funding sources are the Green Climate Fund (GCF), Adaptation Fund (AF), Global Environment Fund (GEF) and GEF Small Grants Programme (SGP), Climate Technology Centre and Network (CTCN), and the Caribbean Catastrophe Risk Insurance Facility (CCRIF). Project and proposal development Project and proposal development is the process of translating NAP priorities and investment needs into specific projects that are ready for financing and implementation. Using the identified priorities and matched potential source of funding from the previous steps, projects move from the idea stage to the proposal stage such that they can be submitted to the identified funder for implementation. The following requirements will likely be necessary when submitting a concept note or funding proposal to various funding sources: • Due diligence • Feasibility studies • Environmental impact assessments or compliance with environmental safeguards • Project budget and financing costs • Economic or financial analysis, including cost-benefit analysis. • Other funder-specific requirements 122 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan
4.2. Sustainable Financing Mechanisms The GoAB has a multi-faceted approach to secure funding and address pressing environmental challenges. This section provides an overview of some of these financing mechanisms to illustrate innovative climate financing mechanisms that already exist and could potentially support the NAP process. Sustainable Island Resource Framework (SIRF) Fund The GoAB has established the Sustainable Island Resource Framework Fund (SIRF Fund) as the central conduit for receiving environmental, climate mitigation, and adaptation financing from both international and domestic sources. The SIRF Fund was created as a Special Fund in accordance with the Finance Administration Act (2006). The SIRF Fund has the responsibility of facilitating funding access for the public sector, private sector, as well as non-governmental and community organizations within Antigua and Barbuda. Additionally, it has the capacity to assist in environmental management efforts across various CHAPTER 4: FINANCING STRATEGY islands within the Organization of Eastern Caribbean States (OECS). Income to the SIRF Fund is derived from a combination of domestic and international channels. Domestically, this includes revenue generated from Green Card Park visitation fees, pollution charges, carbon credits, taxes, levies, and any other fees specified by regulations. On the international front, the SIRF Fund functions as an executing body and a sustainable financing mechanism for bilateral and multilateral funding sources allocated for the objectives outlined in the Environmental Protection and Management Act (2019). The SIRF Fund continues to represent an opportunity for the Government and people of Antigua and Barbuda to attract substantial financing to support green growth, the Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs) targets and an overall sustainable development agenda for the country. Debt for Climate Swaps Despite achieving high per capita income and robust growth rates in 2019, Antigua and Barbuda's economy still maintains a relatively modest scale, marked by persistently elevated levels of public debt. While recent economic growth, diligent efforts at debt restructuring, and fiscal reforms have yielded some success in lessening the weight of public debt, the country faces significant challenges in servicing these debts. This challenge primarily arises from the escalating financial and economic toll of climate change, which has placed substantial constraints on the nation's fiscal capacity. To break free from this challenging financial situation, the GoAB has initiated discussions with both the GCF and their creditors who are part of the Paris Club. The objective is to establish a trilateral arrangement known as a Debt for Climate Swap. In this innovative arrangement, the GCF would provide financial support or partial financing to facilitate the repurposing of Antigua and Barbuda's 123 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan substantial debt, totalling around US$147 million. This redirected capital would be channelled into domestic initiatives focused on climate change projects within the country. GCF Readiness Programmes Antigua and Barbuda have harnessed the GCF Readiness Preparatory Support Programme to enhance its institutional and technical capabilities for securing and leveraging climate finance. A notable initiative is the introduction of the Multiyear Readiness (MYR) project, aimed at advancing the implementation of key concept notes that were earlier identified in the country's GCF country programme. Insurance prospective for farmers and fishers The likelihood of agricultural losses in Antigua and Barbuda is on the rise because of climate change, particularly concerning factors like droughts and strong winds. While farmers and fishers are implementing specific measures to mitigate these risks, there is a pressing need to improve and formalize the entire risk management system. A comprehensive approach to risk CHAPTER 4: FINANCING STRATEGY management should address the vulnerability of farmers and fishers to climate change impacts in Antigua and Barbuda. A study was conducted by the United Nations Development Program (UNDP) in collaboration with the Department of Environment (DOE) to report on the Insurance prospective for farmers and fishers in Antigua and Barbuda. One of the major findings in this study was that the agricultural insurance that would cover the production losses of farmers and fishers is not present yet in the country but is highly needed as a risk transfer instrument in the face of climate change. Subsequently, recommendations made by the UNDP included that Insurance companies join their efforts with the government in financial education of fishers and farmers: explaining which insurance products are already available and in which cases they bring the benefits. Additionally, two possible insurance types were suggested for Antigua and Barbuda – indemnity insurance and/or parametric insurance. Indemnity insurance can provide the coverage for all risk categories (climatic and man-made), whereas parametric insurance would only cover measurable climatic risks. All in all, further assessments along with these recommendations will help in insurance product development moving forward for the agricultural sector as well as other sectors that are highly impacted by climate change.
4.3. Key National Stakeholders Antigua and Barbuda collaborate with various local, regional, and international partners to address issues around climate change, disaster management, trade, and economic development. 124 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan The country has persistently leveraged technical support from a diverse range of partners, resulting in the reinforcement of essential institutional, policy, and regulatory structures, and the enhancement of capabilities to facilitate better access to climate finance. Accreditation of the NDA The country through its National Designated Authority (NDA), is accredited to the GCF and the AF. This accreditation allowed the country to propose and implement adaptation projects that address climate change impacts. The NDA serves as the country's official contact point with the GCF and AF to facilitate the submission and approval of funding proposals. Funding through the country’s NDA can also be accessed from the GEF to support projects and initiatives aimed at addressing global environmental challenges, including biodiversity conservation, climate change, and land degradation. Accreditation to these international finance mechanisms is a significant step for Antigua and Barbuda in securing the necessary resources to address climate change and environmental challenges. It allows the government to access funding, technical expertise, and capacity-building CHAPTER 4: FINANCING STRATEGY support to implement projects and programmes that support climate resilience and sustainability goals. Private Sector Many private sector organizations, particularly small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), face difficulties in accessing affordable financing for climate projects. Banks and financial institutions may be reluctant to provide loans or capital for projects perceived as high-risk or unfamiliar. However, financing through the SIRF Fund is available to the private sector in the form of grants, loans, and equity. SIRF Fund Revolving Loan Programme The SIRF Fund Revolving Loan Programme (RLP) in Antigua and Barbuda has made significant progress in enhancing climate change resilience for households and private businesses. The RLP provides low-cost loans for households and businesses to adapt to climate change impacts. The programme offers a wide range of adaptation measures to include hurricane shutters, roof reinforcement, water harvesting systems, energy efficient appliances, renewable energy systems and vector control measures. SIRF Fund Blended Finance Programme for SMEs Funds from the GEF has enabled the SIRF Fund to initiate a blended finance programme as part of the PATH to 2020 Project. This pioneering programme combines various financial instruments, 125 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan including grant-based technical assistance, loans, and equity investments. Specifically, it incorporates equity investments to inject capital into renewable energy (RE) and climate-smart technology businesses. This novel approach will contribute to a more resilient and sustainable future for SMEs. This ground-breaking initiative seeks to revolutionize the financial landscape in Antigua and Barbuda by piloting support systems for sustainable livelihoods. The programme aims to establish innovative financial mechanisms that open new opportunities for residents to pursue viable livelihoods while discouraging environmentally harmful practices.
4.4. NAP Synergies with NDC Implementation Especially given the Antigua and Barbuda’s NDC and NDC Implementation Plan distinctively identify the importance of adaptation as well as key adaptation priorities, ensuring that the NAP complements NDC implementation is crucial for fostering effective and coherent climate action. The NAP and NDC together are integral components of the country’s strategy to address climate CHAPTER 4: FINANCING STRATEGY change, and ensuring synergies between the two allows for integrated planning, streamlined resilience-building and efficient resource allocation. This section highlights significant existing and potential future opportunities for NAP-NDC synergies. NDC Financing Strategy The GoAB, continuing in its collaborations with the NDC Partnership, has developed a NDC Financing Strategy. The Strategy reviews the country’s capacity to access climate finance, clarify roles of key institutions, and establish approaches to key actions including stakeholder engagement and finance monitoring system. The strategy also explores investment needs for achieving the NDC, identifies gaps and explores a prioritisation process to secure investments. Finally, the Strategy determines barriers to financing climate action, potential policy interventions to overcome them, and identifies potential sources of finance and a pipeline of climate investments to achieve Antigua and Barbuda’s NDC. Given the country’s focus on both mitigation and adaptation in the NDC, the Strategy follows suit to explore opportunities for adaptation investments. Water, AFOLU, Buildings and Infrastructure, Just Transition, Gender, Children and Youth, Finance and Regional Engagement are all identified as key sectors for adaptation actions within the NDC. The total amount of financing required to implement the adaptation specific NDC measures was estimated at USD 469.9 million, with a current financing gap of USD332 million that still needs to be procured for the full implementation of the adaptation targets. The Strategy includes a prioritization of adaptation outputs based on timeline, financing gap, impact potential and alignment with national priorities, as well as provides matching sources of finance for the adaptation outputs. Altogether, the NDC Financing Strategy, given its overlap in adaptation focus with the NAP, creates an opportunity for effective mobilisation of resources. 126 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Private Sector Engagement Strategy for NDC Antigua and Barbuda’s Private Sector Engagement Strategy establishes a systematic approach for the public sector to collaborate with private sector entities to align action and mobilise resources to achieve the country’s NDC targets and commitments. The strategy focuses on supporting country efforts to reduce emissions to support the NDC implementation, while facilitating a clean energy and sustainable transition. Private sector engagement is a key element to achieving the country’s NDC due to the private sector’s contribution by adopting greener policies and practices and undertaking the transformation towards a more sustainable and circular supply chain. The strategy lays out a four-phased approach to ensure meaningful and effective collaboration and progress. Phase 1 establishes the initiation of engagement to lay a foundation for long-lasting collaboration through the entire implementation process. This is followed by Phase 2 on providing stakeholders with necessary information to make informed decisions. Phase 3 involves the formalization of engagement and decision-making of collaboration mechanisms into institutional structures. Finally, Phase 4 establishes an iterative process to the strategy to reflect feedback, reflections, CHAPTER 4: FINANCING STRATEGY and revisions to the process to ensure that the strategy evolves with changes in the NDC implementation landscape. This entire strategy is important to the NAP process given how NDC implementation also includes adaptation priorities and objectives. The PSES similarly can also be adopted for NAP implementation with revisions made where necessary for appropriate stakeholder engagement and institutional arrangements. Given the goal of the PSES is to leverage and enhance public-private collaboration, engagement and resources, there are many synergies that can be optimized within NDC and NAP implementation using this strategy.
4.5. NAP Costs and Prioritisation The NAP includes a set of complementary Sectoral and Local Adaptation Plans (SAPs and LAPs, respectively), which outline a series of additional activities, outcomes and objectives aimed at improving the adaptability and resilience of the country. For the SAPs and LAPs, a preliminary costing exercise was conducted to provide initial guidance on the amount of finance required to implement the activities outlined in the SAPs and LAPs as outlined below: • Sectoral Adaptacon Plans: 1. Wholesale and Retail 2. Infrastructure and Housing 3. Food Security 4. Tourism • Culture and Historical Sites Local Adaptacon Plans 1. St. Johns City Local Area Adaptacon Plan 2023-2033 2. Jolly Harbour to Johnsons Point Local Area Adaptacon Plan 2023-2033 3. Airport/Fitches Creek Local Area Adaptacon Plan 2023-2033 127 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan After costing the SAPs and LAPs, a prioritization exercise with the same methodology as the one used for the development of the NDC Financing Strategy and Action Plan was conducted. Costing for the NAP complimentary SAPs and LAPs Table 18 shows the total number of activities per output and the estimated costs from the sectoral and local adaptation plan outputs considered in the costing exercise. The estimated total amount for the implementation of the five (5) SAPs and three (3) LAPs is USD 500 million. However, it should be noted that these are just preliminary costs, and a detailed cost analysis would be performed before implementing any of the SAPs or LAPs. Additionally, some of the costs from the SAPs or LAPs might have already been identified in the NDC Financing Strategy and Action Plan, taking as basis the NDC implementation Plan 2021-2030, but it falls outside the scope of this costing exercise to determine the amount of financing already procured for the SAPs and LAPs, or even if some of the activities have already been implemented as part of the climate finance support received to date for A&B. CHAPTER 4: FINANCING STRATEGY Table 18: Costing Estimates for SAPs and LAPs (in USD million) No. of Est. Cost Thematic Area Output Activities (USD million) WR.1 Physical Adaptation and Policy Planning for 6 31.3 Wholesale & Retail WR.2 Climate-proofing Wholesale & Retail 8 24.0 Buildings Wholesale and WR.3 Financing and Financial Instruments for Retail SAP 8 1.4 Adaptation WR.4 Training, Capacity Building and Knowledge Transfer for Climate Adaptation and Business 8 6.8 Continuity Planning IH.1 Housing adaptation measures: To enhance the resilience of housing assets, homeowners, 14 95.5 and the services that they depend on (e.g., water, electricity) to hurricanes, flooding, and drought. Infrastructure IH.2 Roads adaptation measures: To ensure that and Housing SAP roads and drainage systems can withstand future 8 1.3 impacts associated with flooding, hurricanes, extreme heat, and SLR IH.3 Wastewater adaptation measures: Protect 7 56.6 public health and the environment by ensuring 128 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan No. of Est. Cost Thematic Area Output Activities (USD million) adequate wastewater treatment and disposal systems that can withstand future flood impacts. IH.4 Energy adaptation measures: To enhance the resilience of Antigua and Barbuda’s domestic 4 4.1 energy supply to hurricane events, droughts, flooding, and rising temperatures. FD.1 Enabling environment strengthened to support local food production through legislation 6 2.2 and plans. FD.2 Governmental and civil coordination 4 2.4 mechanisms enhanced. FD.3 Climate and food system data collection and research supported to inform the agricultural and 1 0.2 fisheries sectors CHAPTER 4: FINANCING STRATEGY FD.4 Innovative technologies and practices mainstreamed to promote the climate-resilience 4 9.5 Food Security of the fisheries sector. SAP FD.5 Innovative technologies and practices mainstreamed to promote the climate-resilience 9 19.2 of the agricultural sector. FD.6 Private investment and Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs) promoted to encourage the 4 14.7 sustainability of climate-resilient interventions. FD.7 Training and awareness-raising facilitated to 5 1.1 promote local production. FD.8 Funding mechanisms mobilized to finance 3 3.9 food security resilience interventions. T.1 Implementation of climate-resilient measures 12 16.9 in response to a changing climate enhanced T.2 Strengthened Partnerships for Resilience 4 1.1 Building in the Tourism Sector T.3 Evidence-based decision-making enhanced 12 16.8 through innovation Tourism SAP T.4 Sustainable financing mechanism for resilience building in the tourism sector 8 3.5 established and resourced. T.5 Enabling environment to support disaster risk management and climate change adaptation 9 2.2 strengthened 129 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan No. of Est. Cost Thematic Area Output Activities (USD million) C.1 Cultural Heritage and Historical Sites Sectoral Culture SAP Adaptation Plan 13 9.0 LAPSJ.1 Improved protection from wind damage and impacts from storm surges along the St. 3 0.7 John’s Harbour through the implementation of offshore and nearshore protective infrastructure. LAPSJ.2 Enhanced and rehabilitated marine ecosystems that provide greater coastal 3 1.2 protection from storm surge and wave erosion. LAPSJ.3 Improved critical infrastructure and buildings with reduced susceptibility to impacts 7 14.3 from hurricanes and storm surges. LAPSJ.4 Increased uptake of climate/ hurricane CHAPTER 4: FINANCING STRATEGY risk insurance schemes by local farmers and 3 0.8 fishers, and businesses LAPSJ.5 Increased capacity of drainage St. John LAP infrastructure to better channel stormwater, 21 48.2 improve solid waste management and reduce the incidence of localized flooding LAPSJ.6 Improved solid waste management 3 0.6 practices within at-risk communities LAPSJ.7 Expanded water storage capacity 11 19.6 LAPSJ.8 Increased uptake of renewable energy 7 1.4 technologies by businesses and households LAPSJ.9 Improved critical infrastructure and buildings with reduced susceptibility to impacts 11 16.4 from higher mean sea levels LAPSJ.10 Established enabling environment for the expansion of and investment in the Blue 4 0.8 Economy Sector in St. John City LAPJH1 Improved protection from wind damage and impacts from storm surges through the 3 2.0 implementation of offshore and nearshore protective infrastructure. Jolly Harbour LAP LAPJH.2 Enhanced and rehabilitated marine ecosystems that provide greater coastal 7 1.0 protection from storm surge and wave erosion. LAPJH.3 Improved critical infrastructure and 7 1.0 buildings with reduced susceptibility to impacts 130 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan No. of Est. Cost Thematic Area Output Activities (USD million) from hurricanes and storm surges in coastal communities such as Jolly Harbour, Bolans and Johnson’s Point. LAPJH.4 Increased uptake of climate/ hurricane risk insurance schemes by local farmers and 3 0.4 fishers, and businesses LAPJH.5 Increased capacity of drainage infrastructure within Jolly Harbour, and along Valley Road to better channel stormwater, 6 0.8 improve solid waste management and reduce the incidence of localized flooding LAPJH.6 Improved solid waste management practices within at-risk communities in Jolly 3 0.4 Harbour, Bolands, Jennings, and Johnsons Point. CHAPTER 4: FINANCING STRATEGY LAPJH.7 Expanded water storage capacity 9 1.2 LAPJB.8 Increased uptake of drought risk 2 0.5 insurance schemes by local farmers LAPJH.9 Increased uptake of renewable energy and climate-smart technologies by businesses 5 1.2 and households in the Jolly Harbour to Johnsons Point area. LAPJH.10 Improved critical infrastructure and buildings with reduced susceptibility to impacts 8 7.8 from higher mean sea levels LAPJH.11 Established enabling environment for the expansion of and investment in the Blue 4 0.6 Economy Sector in the Jolly Harbour to Johnsons Point Area LAPAF.1 Improved protection from wind damage and impacts from storm surges through ecosystem maintenance and the implementation 8 14.2 of offshore and nearshore protective infrastructure Airport/Fitches LAPAF.2 Improved critical infrastructure and Creek LAP buildings with reduced susceptibility to impacts 8 1.0 from hurricanes and storm surges. LAPAF.3 Reduced interruption of essential services through alternative energy and water 5 1.0 supply 131 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan No. of Est. Cost Thematic Area Output Activities (USD million) LAPAF.4 Increased capacity of drainage infrastructure to better channel stormwater, 7 1.0 improve solid waste management and reduce incidence of localized flooding LAPAF.5 Increased capacity to handle extreme precipitation events through nature-based 2 0.3 solutions LAPAF.6 Improved solid waste management 2 0.3 practices within at-risk communities LAPAF.7 Expanded water storage capacity 5 5.7 LAPAF.8 Reduced damage to coastal critical 2 13.3 infrastructure LAPAF.9 Increased uptake of renewable energy 2 0.6 technologies by small businesses and households CHAPTER 4: FINANCING STRATEGY LAPAF.10 Improved critical infrastructure and buildings with reduced susceptibility to impacts 5 13.6 from higher mean sea levels LAPAF.11 Decreased building damage and losses 4 0.7 from rising sea levels LAPAF.12 Established enabling environment for the expansion of and investment in the Blue 4 1.2 Economy Sector Total 341 497.3
4.6. NAP Prioritization of SAPs and LAPs The methodology prioritizing the outputs is based on four criteria (implementation timeline, financing amount, impact potential, and alignment with national priorities). To reflect the importance of each indicator, outputs are first prioritized or filtered based on their timing for implementation, then the financing gap, then their impact potential and finally, their alignment with national priorities. The evaluation criteria are as follows: 1) Timeline: The outputs are evaluated based on the number of years needed for their implementacon from all their individual accvices or measures and based on the earliest start date and the latest end date for each output based on the best available escmates. This defines a cme window during which each output needs to be executed. Longer cmelines rank higher in the list, while shorter cmelines rank lower. For example, if an output has a cmeline of five 132 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan years versus a seven-year output, the one with the longest cmeline is chosen first, then the one with the shortest cmeline. 2) Financing gap: For this criterion, the outputs are evaluated against the escmated amount of financing needed in USD million. 3) Impact potencal: The outputs are assessed based on their potencal to make a significant contribucon to a share of the total A&B populacon using the number of potencal beneficiaries. Outputs with higher impact potencal receive higher scores, and those with limited impact get lower scores. 4) Alignment with Naconal Priorices: The outputs are analysed to determine how well they align with the country's strategic objeccves and priorices; the score can range from one (1) to five (4) with four being the highest alignment with naconal priorices. Outputs that closely align with naconal goals receive higher scores, while those that are less relevant get lower scores. Once the evaluations are complete, the final list of prioritized outputs is created based on the results from the different evaluation criteria scores and using the custom sorting function built in Microsoft Excel. CHAPTER 4: FINANCING STRATEGY Table 19 shows the ranking for all the fifty-five (55) outputs from the SAPs and LAPs and based on the four criteria as explained above. The top three outputs based on the prioritization are: 1. IH.1 Housing adaptacon measures: To enhance the resilience of housing assets, homeowners, and the services that they depend on (e.g., water, electricity) to hurricanes, flooding, and drought. 2. IH.4 Energy adaptacon measures: To enhance the resilience of Ancgua and Barbuda’s domescc energy supply to hurricane events, droughts, flooding, and rising temperatures. 3. FD.5 Innovacve technologies and praccces mainstreamed to promote the climate- resilience of the agricultural sector. Table 19: SAPs and LAPs Prioritization of Outputs Priority Thematic Area Output Rank WR.1 Physical Adaptation and Policy Planning for Wholesale & 9 Retail Wholesale and WR.2 Climate-proofing Wholesale & Retail Buildings 47 Retail SAP WR.3 Financing and Financial Instruments for Adaptation 45 WR.4 Training, Capacity Building and Knowledge Transfer for 52 Climate Adaptation and Business Continuity Planning IH.1 Housing adaptation measures: To enhance the resilience of housing assets, homeowners, and the services that they 1 depend on (e.g., water, electricity) to hurricanes, flooding, Infrastructure and and drought. Housing SAP IH.2 Roads adaptation measures: To ensure that roads and drainage systems can withstand future impacts associated 55 with flooding, hurricanes, extreme heat, and SLR 133 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Priority Thematic Area Output Rank IH.3 Wastewater adaptation measures: Protect public health and the environment by ensuring adequate wastewater 7 treatment and disposal systems that can withstand future flood impacts. IH.4 Energy adaptation measures: To enhance the resilience of Antigua and Barbuda’s domestic energy supply to hurricane 2 events, droughts, flooding, and rising temperatures. FD.1 Enabling environment strengthened to support local 54 food production through legislation and plans. FD.2 Governmental and civil coordination mechanisms 5 enhanced. FD.3 Climate and food system data collection and research 44 supported to inform the agricultural and fisheries sectors FD.4 Innovative technologies and practices mainstreamed to 4 promote the climate-resilience of the fisheries sector. CHAPTER 4: FINANCING STRATEGY Food Security SAP FD.5 Innovative technologies and practices mainstreamed to 3 promote the climate-resilience of the agricultural sector. FD.6 Private investment and Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs) promoted to encourage the sustainability of climate- 46 resilient interventions. FD.7 Training and awareness-raising facilitated to promote 6 local production. FD.8 Funding mechanisms mobilized to finance food security 53 resilience interventions. T.1 Implementation of climate-resilient measures in response 11 to a changing climate enhanced T.2 Strengthened Partnerships for Resilience Building in the 50 Tourism Sector T.3 Evidence-based decision-making enhanced through Tourism SAP 48 innovation T.4 Sustainable financing mechanism for resilience building in 49 the tourism sector established and resourced. T.5 Enabling environment to support disaster risk 51 management and climate change adaptation strengthened C.1 Cultural Heritage and Historical Sites Sectoral Adaptation Culture SAP Plan 17 LAPS.1 Improved protection from wind damage and impacts from storm surges along the St. John’s Harbour through the St. John LAP 35 implementation of offshore and nearshore protective infrastructure. 134 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Priority Thematic Area Output Rank LAPS.2 Enhanced and rehabilitated marine ecosystems that provide greater coastal protection from storm surge and wave 23 erosion. LAPS.3 Improved critical infrastructure and buildings with reduced susceptibility to impacts from hurricanes and storm 13 surges. LAPS.4 Increased uptake of climate/ hurricane risk insurance 33 schemes by local farmers and fishers, and businesses LAPS.5 Increased capacity of drainage infrastructure to better channel stormwater, improve solid waste management and 8 reduce the incidence of localized flooding LAPS.6 Improved solid waste management practices within at- 35 risk communities LAPS.7 Expanded water storage capacity 10 LAPS.8 Increased uptake of renewable energy technologies by CHAPTER 4: FINANCING STRATEGY 21 businesses and households LAPS.9 Improved critical infrastructure and buildings with 12 reduced susceptibility to impacts from higher mean sea levels LAPS.10 Established enabling environment for the expansion 32 of and investment in the Blue Economy Sector in St. John City LAPJB.1 Improved protection from wind damage and impacts from storm surges through the implementation of offshore 20 and nearshore protective infrastructure. LAPJB.2 Enhanced and rehabilitated marine ecosystems that provide greater coastal protection from storm surge and wave 30 erosion. LAPJB.3 Improved critical infrastructure and buildings with reduced susceptibility to impacts from hurricanes and storm 28 surges in coastal communities such as Jolly Harbour, Bolans and Johnson’s Point. Jolly Harbour LAP LAPJB.4 Increased uptake of climate/ hurricane risk insurance 40 schemes by local farmers and fishers, and businesses LAPJB.5 Increased capacity of drainage infrastructure within Jolly Harbour, and along Valley Road to better channel 31 stormwater, improve solid waste management and reduce the incidence of localized flooding LAPJB.6 Improved solid waste management practices within at-risk communities in Jolly Harbour, Bolands, Jennings, and 41 Johnsons Point. LAPJB.7 Expanded water storage capacity 22 135 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Priority Thematic Area Output Rank LAPJB.8 Increased uptake of drought risk insurance schemes 39 by local farmers LAPJB.9 Increased uptake of renewable energy and climate- smart technologies by businesses and households in the Jolly 24 Harbour to Johnsons Point area. LAPJB.10 Improved critical infrastructure and buildings with 18 reduced susceptibility to impacts from higher mean sea levels LAPJB.11 Established enabling environment for the expansion of and investment in the Blue Economy Sector in the Jolly 38 Harbour to Johnsons Point Area LAPAF.1 Improved protection from wind damage and impacts from storm surges through ecosystem maintenance and the 14 implementation of offshore and nearshore protective infrastructure LAPAF.2 Improved critical infrastructure and buildings with CHAPTER 4: FINANCING STRATEGY reduced susceptibility to impacts from hurricanes and storm 26 surges. LAPAF.3 Reduced interruption of essential services through 27 alternative energy and water supply LAPAF.4 Increased capacity of drainage infrastructure to better channel stormwater, improve solid waste management 29 and reduce incidence of localized flooding Airport/Fitches LAPAF.5 Increased capacity to handle extreme precipitation 43 Creek LAP events through nature-based solutions LAPAF.6 Improved solid waste management practices within 42 at-risk communities LAPAF.7 Expanded water storage capacity 19 LAPAF.8 Reduced damage to coastal critical infrastructure 16 LAPAF.9 Increased uptake of renewable energy technologies 37 by small businesses and households LAPAF.10 Improved critical infrastructure and buildings with 15 reduced susceptibility to impacts from higher mean sea levels LAPAF.11 Decreased building damage and losses from rising 34 sea levels LAPAF.12 Established enabling environment for the expansion 25 of and investment in the Blue Economy Sector 136 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan CHAPTER 5: MONITORING, EVALUATION AND LEARNING FOR ADAPTATION CHAPTER 5: MONITORING, EVALUATION AND LEARNING FOR ADAPTATION 138 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan 5. Overview of Monitoring & Evaluation The NAP’s Monitoring, Evaluation, Learning (MEL) Framework takes into consideration the individual adaptation actions prioritized through the NAP preparation process and is based on the NAP technical guidelines:31 1. Monitoring of adaptacon accons in Ancgua and Barbuda, 2. Reviewing the NAP process to assess progress, effeccveness, and gaps, 3. Iteracvely updacng the naconal adaptacon plan, 4. Promocng outreach on the NAP process, and CHAPTER 5: MONITORING, EVALUATION AND LEARNING FOR ADAPTATION 5. Reporcng on progress and effeccveness The MEL Framework incorporates the process of collecting, analysing, and using data for the purpose of measuring whether adaptation actions are being implemented according to plan (monitoring). Monitoring of adaptation is an ongoing process of collecting data and documenting information to determine progress made against stated plans. Monitoring should reveal whether activities lead to the achievement of outputs and planned targets. Monitoring is, therefore, useful for identifying issues during implementation to provide feedback needed by decision-makers. It looks at measurable changes linked to inputs, processes, and outputs. The processes of review, assessment, and learning is key to monitoring. The Framework links the monitoring process with that of evaluation. Evaluation of adaptation should further assess the management and impact of adaptation actions to determine if they are having the desired results. The Framework promotes reporting of findings to multiple stakeholders. To uphold the principles of transparency and accountability, it promotes the sharing of lessons, knowledge, and best practices (learning) for continuous improvement of adaptation efforts. Learning will be generated from implementation experiences and inform decision-making, ongoing adaptation, and future planning efforts. Monitoring and evaluation are distinguished mainly in terms of their purpose, the time periods when they are done, why they are done, what they measure and who is involved. Monitoring is conducted continuously to gather information on implementation status at a given time, or over time. It involves identifying data needs, collecting, and analysing data, and using that data in relation to activities, processes, outputs, and progress towards meeting outcomes. Based on the information gathered, the results are used for decision-making, to solve implementation problems and to make corrective changes. Contrastingly, the focus of evaluation is on assessing design of policies, strategies, plans and interventions; as well as the implementation process, outputs, outcomes, and impacts achieved. At its core, evaluation provides insight on what works well, what has not worked, what needs to change, and gives structured insight into the overall performance. Evaluation provides needed evidence to allow for corrective actions to be taken when needed. Both processes, however, do allow for the modification of existing plans based on lessons learned. 31 https://unfccc.int/files/adaptation/cancun_adaptation_framework/application/pdf/naptechguidelines_eng_high__res.pdf 139 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan
5.1. National Adaptation Plan Monitoring, Evaluation and Learning Framework Antigua and Barbuda has in place a Nationally Determined Contributions (NDC) Implementation Plan with identified adaptation indicators and a Monitoring, Reporting and Verification (MRV) System for assessing climate adaptation actions and interventions. This presented an opportunity to align the Monitoring, Evaluation, Learning (MEL) Framework for the NAP with the adaptation CHAPTER 5: MONITORING, EVALUATION AND LEARNING FOR ADAPTATION actions and indicators of the NDC Implementation Plan and the MRV System as well as the climate relevant indicators listed in Antigua and Barbuda’s 2021 Voluntary National Review (VNR) for the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). This effort will support building adaptive capacity and resilience as well as integrating climate change into national policies, strategies, and planning. The objectives of the NAP MEL Framework are to: i. measure the effeccveness of adaptacon policies, plans, and intervencons in a changing climate, ii. idencfy how adaptacon intervencons reduce vulnerability and improve Ancgua and Barbuda’ ability to prepare and respond to climate change at the naconal, sectoral, and local levels, iii. Generate knowledge, lessons, and best praccces to inform future policy making, iv. Enable the integracon of MEL into naconal, sectoral, and local adaptacon planning processes, and v. Fulfil reporting obligations of the Government of Antigua and Barbuda in line with international reporting commitment and processes, particularly Nationally Determined Contributions, National Communications, Adaptation Communications, Biennial Transparency Reports and Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Institutional Arrangements The DOE is primarily responsible for coordinating the implementation of the National Adaptation Plan. The DOE is an accredited National Implementing Entity to the Adaptation Fund (AF) and a direct access Accredited Entity (AE) to the Global Environment Facility (GEF), and therefore is in a position to coordinate the implementation of multilateral environmental agreements (MEAs) in the country as well as climate finance. These agreements pertain to inter alia climate change, biodiversity, and land degradation. Antigua and Barbuda’s context as a small island developing state (SIDS) necessitates streamlining of its institutional structures. The government, therefore, aims to strategically build capacity for MEAs in one agency (i.e., the DoE) to provide enhanced accountability and coordination across all agencies and stakeholders. In accordance with its mandate, the DOE coordinates multistakeholder technical and oversight committees. A key coordination committee is the country’s Technical Advisory Committee (TAC). The TAC currently consists of over 15 members from Government, as well as NGO and private sector representatives. The Project Management Committee (PMC) is a high-level oversight 140 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan committee based within the DOE that is appointed by the Cabinet of Antigua and Barbuda. This committee was primarily established to provide financial, policy and administrative oversight. The PMC facilitates interagency coordination and monitoring of national-level activities. This management structure has a long-lasting impact on the institutionalization of the national climate change adaptation and mitigation process as well as building capacity. The DOE’s Project Management Unit (PMU) and the Monitoring Evaluation and Data Management unit (DMU) also have critical roles to play in tracking and assessing adaptation progress. Various government ministries and agencies also have responsibility for the implementation and CHAPTER 5: MONITORING, EVALUATION AND LEARNING FOR ADAPTATION monitoring and evaluation of the NAP within their respective ministries and agencies and in the context of national development. • Ancgua and Barbuda’s Ministry of Finance (MOF) also serve as the Naconal Designated Authority (NDA) to the Green Climate Fund, while the DOE serves as a co-signatory for the GCF’s No-Objeccon Procedure. The MOF is responsible for: (i) verifying whether adaptacon policies and proposed accons are aligned to naconal priorices, (ii) idencfying potencal financial risks associated with climate change projects; ii) designing financial risk assessment criteria; and iii) ensuring that climate change projects progressing to the implementacon phase are approved according to the specified criteria and that the relevant consultacons have been undertaken. • The Ministry of Foreign Affairs chairs the Naconal Coordinacng Mechanism (NCM), which provides a forum for the policcal coordinacon of the country’s engagement with mulclateral funds. Ancgua and Barbuda’s Ambassador for Climate Change presents annual reports on both past and future engagements to the Minister of Foreign Affairs. • The Government’s main insctuconal mechanism for overseeing the implementacon of the 2030 Agenda is the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Addiconally, all government ministries and agencies are responsible for the alignment of government policies and key programmes with the global agenda to facilitate not only implementacon but also more effeccve monitoring and evaluacon. • The Sta_s_cs Division, as the country’s Naconal Stacsccs Office is the agency responsible for the compilacon of Official Stacsccs, which some of the SDG indicators fall under. As repository of official stacsccs, the Division plays a vital role in the coordinacon and generacon of these stacsccs in accordance with internaconal standards that govern official stacsccs and guidelines for the compilacon of SDG indicators. Currently, the country’s Stacsccal Office is leading the process of creacng mechanisms for data mining for the SDG indicators deemed applicable to the country’s monitoring and evaluacon framework for SDG implementacon. • Cabinet established a na_onal SDG Commijee whose membership is representacve of the three pillars of sustainable development and is chaired by the Director of Internaconal 141 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Trade who in turn reports to a Cabinet Subcommitee on the Sustainable Development Goals which is chaired by the Minister of Foreign Affairs. The Commitee guides Ancgua and Barbuda’s advancement of the SDGs. The SDG Commitee has also been tasked with developing and implemencng a comprehensive communicacons and stakeholder engagement strategy for advancing a more inclusive and parccipatory pathway to the nacon’s development. This institutional structure will support the MEL system in monitoring and assessing national and sectoral climate change adaptation actions in a more strategic way. The NAP prioritizes monitoring CHAPTER 5: MONITORING, EVALUATION AND LEARNING FOR ADAPTATION at the national and sectoral level. Its design is based on identifying the priority adaptation actions from within the produced adaptation plans and selection of indicators. These indicators are linked to the six priority NAP sectors. The identified adaptation indicators and associated actions will be useful for: • Assessing impacts, vulnerability, risks, and resilience (people, communices, sector, infrastructure, among others) • Assessing adaptacon policy and strategic frameworks • Informing the design for adaptacon intervencons • Assessing maladaptacon and bad praccces • Informing decision-making and future adaptacon policies and plans • Mainstreaming adaptacon planning in development processes • Tracking adaptacon achievements • Communicacng adaptacon progress • Informing internaconal climate change negocacons • Monitoring and evaluacng funding for adaptacon funding.
5.2. Norms and Standards of the NAP M&E System The NAP MEL System is designed to meet the following norms and standards: 1. Transparency and Accountability—Improve responsiveness and reporcng on progress and/or results to mulcple stakeholders, including but not limited to other public sector agencies, ciczens, the private sector, non-governmental organizacons, civil society, partner organizacons, donors, and beneficiaries of intervencons. 2. Track and Improve Performance— Tracking progress in adaptacon planning against plans and recommend accons to improve performance for the effeccve delivery of results. Performance informacon is key to learning if country policies, strategies and accons are on track or at risk; invescgate the reasons why performance has lagged and to explain the causes of any deviacon during implementacon. 3. Learning—contribute to learning at mulc-levels through the sharing of lessons learned, best praccces and knowledge. Lessons learnt on what works and what does not work can be valuable. Feeding informacon back into naconal systems and agencies and to the 142 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan adaptacon cycle to avert mistakes and idencfy successful strategies for replicacon. These lessons can inform decisions on operacons, policy, or strategy. 4. Communica_on—promote effeccve communicacon among different stakeholders thus facilitacng a beter understanding of the project design, implementacon, and challenges. The data and informacon gained from M&E provides evidence to demonstrate results reporcng that highlights achievements on various levels. Informacon and analysis of findings are useful for ploughing informacon back into regular planning, scaling up of intervencons, resource allocacon, and budgecng. CHAPTER 5: MONITORING, EVALUATION AND LEARNING FOR ADAPTATION 5. Empowerment of Stakeholders— A strong parccipatory approach for adaptacon helps to develop and strengthen the MEL system. It also enhances capacity of stakeholders and oversight processes. Arccle 7.5 of the Paris Agreement, speaks to Parces acknowledging “that adaptacon accon should follow a country-driven, gender-responsive, parccipatory and fully transparent approach, taking into consideracon vulnerable groups, communices and ecosystems, and should be based on and guided by the best available science and, as appropriate, tradiconal knowledge, knowledge of indigenous peoples and local knowledge systems, with a view to integracng adaptacon into relevant socioeconomic and environmental policies and accons, where appropriate”. The MEL system for adaptacon will create opportunices that (i) encourage stakeholder buy-in; (ii) increase the level of meaningful stakeholder parccipacon in tracking adaptacon progress and commitments; (iii) facilitate access to data and informacon; (iv) promote opportunices for stakeholders to enhance their skills for planning and implemencng future climate accons; (v) improve the sustainability of intervencons; (vi) facilitate sharing of local and sciencfic knowledge sharing relevant for adaptacon; (vii) uptake and replicacon of lessons learned; (viii) strengthen development; and (viii) enhance implementacon of adaptacon solucons to problems faced on the ground. 6. Gender Integra_on–Within the MEL Framework gender will be addressed in a measurable way. It will provide valuable insight on the effeccveness of adaptacon accon and support. Focus will also be placed on understanding inequalices, power dynamics and gender and social relacons. The Framework will consider the impact of gender on target populacons and interseccons with gender relacons and gender equality. It integrates gender into the conceptual framework, logic model, indicators, and data gathering, analysis and use. This is in keeping with the country’s commitment to achieving Sustainable Development Goal 5: Gender Equality by promocng contribucons by men and women to climate change adaptacon to ensure they are recognized and valued; and assessing efforts to reduce gender inequalices and promote opportunices for effeccve empowerment for women. As part of gender-sensicve monitoring, gender relaconships will be acknowledged at mulcple levels and seek to reduce and eliminate, rather than exacerbate or intensify gender inequalices. It, therefore, must not look at just the roles and funccons of women 143 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan within the context of any intervencons, but also examine how the roles of women and men determine the relaconships between men and women, and the impacts of such relaconships on social, economic, and environmental sustainability. Gender sensicve monitoring will also consider gender specific outputs, progress on gender specific elements, disaggregated data colleccon, and colleccon of data on a„tudes and behaviours that reflect gender norms. For evaluacon, the MEL system will promote a gender sensicve approach in measuring the impact of outcomes that relate to gender specific programming, idencfying elements that CHAPTER 5: MONITORING, EVALUATION AND LEARNING FOR ADAPTATION address gender inequalices, using data to demonstrate progress and impact, and using gender disaggregated data to understand the gender-differencated impacts of climate change and adaptacon efforts. To have an effeccve gender-sensicve MEL system both qualitacve and quanctacve data will be used to measure the impact on gender relacons, address the different needs of men and women, and assess impacts on their well-being. The system will also consider differencal access and control over resources, role of women in decision-making, gender differences in vulnerability and coping strategies.
5.3. Data, Information, and Knowledge Management Adaptation planning in Antigua and Barbuda has suffered from inadequate data – data that is outdated, inaccurate, or poor in quality, which results in high uncertainty in the adaptation solutions proposed to date. Despite constraints, Antigua and Barbuda continues to make strides towards enhancing its data repository and institutional systems needed for climate action. The M&E system will drive the process of collecting, analysing, and using data to measure whether climate change adaptation responses are implemented according to plan (monitoring) and are yielding the intended results (evaluation) in accordance with national and sectoral priorities. Timely and reliable M&E provides information needed for upholding principles of good governance, accountability, and transparency and ensures compliance with established laws, regulations, standards, and obligations. To determine if the country is reducing its adaptation gap32, critical data is and further will be collected across sectors, analysed, and reported on. The national and sectoral level indicators identified in the NAP will be used to track the country’s climate change response, inclusive of its adaptation policies, strategies, and actions. Measurement of these indicators will be instructive for answering questions on: 32 IPCC defines the adaptation gap as “the difference between actually implemented adaptation and a societally set goal, determined largely by preferences related to tolerated climate change impacts and reflecting resource limitations and competing priorities. 144 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan • What accons have been taken to help the country, its people, and communices adapt to climate change? • How have adaptacon accons led to a reduccon in climate risks? • Will adaptacon efforts likely decrease future climate risks? • How effeccve has adaptacon planning been mainstreamed into naconal policies, strategies, and plans and development processes? • Has loss and damage associated with climate change impacts been averted, minimized, and addressed? • Does the enabling environment support naconal adaptacon planning as well as sound CHAPTER 5: MONITORING, EVALUATION AND LEARNING FOR ADAPTATION environmental governance (access to informacon, access to public parccipacon and access to juscce)? There are diverse methods that will be used to collect data to enable MEL for adaptation. These include but are not limited to surveys, questionnaires, stakeholder interviews, expert observation, focus group discussions, field visits, testimonials, scorecards, review of records, documents, and reports. These data collection methods can range from formal, structured methods to informal, less structured methods. Formal and more structured methods include questionnaires and surveys. Informal, less structured methods include interviews, focus group discussions, and observations. The choice of approach used will influence the results yielded. A key component of the national M&E system for adaptation includes the Environment Registry. The registry was created as a mandate under Part X: Section 87 of the Environmental Protection and Management Act (EPMA), 2019. It is managed by the Department of Environment and will assist support the monitoring, compliance, reporting, and notification requirements under the multilateral environmental agreements (MEAs) to which Antigua and Barbuda is a party; depositing information related to climate change, biodiversity, land management, pollution, and any other purpose in accordance with the requirements of the EPMA, 2019. The Registry will contain the EPMA Information System (a document management system whereby various reports will be uploaded), Monitoring Reporting and Verification (MRV) System and a place for rosters and notices. The Environment Registry will be used to monitor and report on mitigation and adaptation actions, support received as well as GHG emissions by sector. 145 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan CHAPTER 5: MONITORING, EVALUATION AND LEARNING FOR ADAPTATION Figure 18: Conceptual Model of the Environment Registry
5.4. National Monitoring, Reporting and Verification System The UNFCCC Enhanced Transparency Framework demands substantial and immediate progress in the countries’ domestic MRV systems and strategic decarbonization planning. This entails moving from often disintegrated and often different methodological approaches in data management to an integrated and robust system. The success of the Paris Agreement hinges on enhanced transparency of action and support, as a critical foundation to making its bottom-up, country-led approach work, as well as building mutual trust and confidence amongst Parties. GEF-CBIT is supporting Antigua and Barbuda in establishing an overarching structure across all sectors that will ensure high quality in its transparency instruments; and create the capacities to respond to UNFCCC's reporting requirements. CBIT’s most important contribution will occur by building capacity and setting up systems to collect data and track NDC implementation. Through the Department of Environment (DOE)—the country’s national UNFCCC focal point— Antigua and Barbuda designed a MRV mechanism for the NAP process and related adaptation actions. The components of the MRV system include the methods used to track specific activities and impacts; transparently communicate selected information to national stakeholders and/or the international community; and measures to ensure that selected reported information is accurate and complete as it relates to the MEAs. The climate change MRV system focuses on three main areas: 1. MRV of Adaptation (to include loss and damage tracking and reporting) 2. MRV of Mitigation Actions (to include GHG emissions) 3. MRV of Climate Support (to include climate finance, technology transfers, capacity building) 146 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Table 20: Key components of a national MRV system for Antigua and Barbuda and their relevance to NDC implementation. Adapted from GGGIb, 2020 MRV Component Relevance to Adaptation Climate Data and Collate, manage and disseminate data and information related to climate Information trends, vulnerabilities, impacts, GHG emissions and progress of climate actions. Mitigation To assess the progress in reducing GHG emissions and expected future reductions at national and sectoral levels. CHAPTER 5: MONITORING, EVALUATION AND LEARNING FOR ADAPTATION To also track implementation and effectiveness of mitigation actions to meet NDC targets and capture lessons learned to inform refinement and design of future NDCs and climate actions. Support and To track support including finance and resource allocation and flows, Finance technology transfer and capacity building for NDC implementation. This includes tracking of international climate finance, national budgets, private sector climate finance etc. to improve the overall transparency of climate finance flows, and to assess if the financing needs are being met and identify new financing requirements. The country has developed an initial fit-for-purpose methodology for tracking domestic and international climate finance flows in Antigua and Barbuda under a UNFCCC Needs Based Financing Project. Adaptation To track implementation effectiveness of adaptation actions taken to build climate resilience at the national and sectoral levels. This includes responses to loss and damage. To also track implementation and effectiveness of adaptation actions to meet NDC targets and capture lessons learned to inform refinement and design of future NDCs and climate actions. Wider Impacts To track co-benefits of NDC implementation activities e.g., contributions to Sustainable Development Goals, national development priorities, other multilateral environmental agreements (MEAs) The MRV System is responsive to the 2019 EPMA, including Part VI – Environmental Management and Monitoring and Part X, sections 85–87. In this regard, it supports not only the implementation of climate change action, but also environmental management in general and the tracking of indicators for multilateral environmental agreements (MEAs). Regulations to support an MRV Framework are included as part of the 2021 Paris Agreement Regulations to the 2019 EPMA, at Part V paragraphs 49–53. The system pulls together various elements of MEA reporting and access to information requirements. 147 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan The national MRV System will track the progress of achieving Antigua and Barbuda’s national adaptation goals and outcomes. It is expected that the MRV system will enhance Antigua and Barbuda’s capability to collect, analyse, and report on data that is key to decision making processes. This MRV system will also ensure that data is collected periodically and is easily accessible when reports to international conventions need to be produced. Furthermore, the existence of this system will allow Antigua and Barbuda to easily compare data across a time series, and to accurately track adaptation indicators as well as on the NDC targets and other national objectives. CHAPTER 5: MONITORING, EVALUATION AND LEARNING FOR ADAPTATION The Paris Agreement established universal and harmonised MRV requirements for tracking progress and effectiveness of implementation of climate actions, including mitigation, adaptation, and support (e.g., finance and resources) utilised by countries to meet their NDC targets. The system will enable the country to meet the Paris Agreement requirements on transparency and reporting. It includes coverage of MRV of Adaptation (as well as loss and damage tracking and reporting), MRV of Climate Support (to include climate finance, technology transfer and capacity building). The MRV system supports Antigua and Barbuda’s efforts towards the Global Goal Adaptation (GGA) by tracking outcomes related to various strategies and plans, including33: i. Outcomes that formed the focus for the 2015 Intended Naconally Determined Contribucon (iNDC 2015), ii. The updated 2021 NDC and associated emission reduccon strategies, iii. The NAP, iv. Ancgua and Barbuda’s Climate Finance Strategy developed from the report on the Assessment and Overview of Climate Finance Flows: Anegua and Barbuda 2014- 2017, and v. Associated strategies around the transicon of the workforce from fossil fuel-based energy systems to renewable energy systems.
5.5. Measuring Progress on Implementation of Adaptation Actions Measuring and monitoring adaptation progress are integral processes of the MEL system. The M&E system for adaptation will monitor and analyse climate change adaptation responses to determine if commitments are being met. It will also seek to enhance transparency and accountability— which are two key elements of good governance. Transparency is important for measuring, reporting and verification of climate change actions. Given that the climate crisis has a wide reach and affects multiple groups of stakeholders in varying ways, there is a need to ensure accountability for commitments and actions. Without measuring and monitoring of adaptation progress, it would be difficult to improve our climate change response. Adaptation tracking in the MEL system will involve measuring and monitoring adaptation in political systems, socioeconomic and environmental policies, and actions. There will also be a focus on feedback and learning. 33 Goodwin, Justin. GGGI. 2021. Antigua and Barbuda Climate Change Monitoring Reporting and Verification (MRV) system framework 148 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan The Biennial Transparency Report (BTR) will provide support in developing and implementing a monitoring and evaluation plan for adaptation actions building on findings from the previous outputs and on the NDC outcomes. It will also capture information related to averting, minimizing, and addressing loss and damage associated with climate change impacts. Given the importance of knowledge management, the cooperation, good practice, experience, and lessons learned from this process will be documented. CHAPTER 5: MONITORING, EVALUATION AND LEARNING FOR ADAPTATION
5.6. NAP Theory of Change The theory of change (TOC) of adaptation maps is a set of interrelated adaptation pathways with each pathway showing the required results in a logical relationship with a hierarchical order.34 The performance of adaptation will be tracked at the national level and for sectors highlighted in the NAP and SAPs and other priority sectors within the NDCs and the country’s GCF Country Programme. Figure 19: NAP Theory of Change 34 Global Environmental Facility Medium Term Review Guidelines 149 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan
5.7. Evaluation of Adaptation Actions Within the MEL Framework, evaluation serves as a systematic and objective assessment of the effectiveness of the NAP process and its implementation in reducing the country’s vulnerability and building national resilience. Evaluation for adaptation can provide critical information on the country’s climate change adaptation policies, strategies programmes and projects. It will also be instructive in determining whether adaptation efforts have increased rather than reduce both current and future vulnerability to natural hazards. Thus, leaving marginalised and vulnerable CHAPTER 5: MONITORING, EVALUATION AND LEARNING FOR ADAPTATION groups, communities, sectors, and ecosystems worse off. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change’s (IPCC) Third Assessment Report defines maladaptation as “an adaptation that does not succeed in reducing vulnerability but increases it instead” (McCarthy et al., 2001: 990). Maladaptive Actions/Maladaptation Actions that may lead to increased risk of adverse climate-related outcomes, including via increased greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, increased or shifted vulnerability to climate change, more inequitable outcomes, or diminished welfare, now or in the future. Most often, maladaptation is an unintended consequence. - Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change in its Sith Assessment Report, 2023 Evaluation findings then can guide planning and decision-making. Evaluation assesses achievements on a specific criterion, which includes a determination of the relevance, efficiency, effectiveness, impact, and sustainability of results. A key feature of evaluation is the inclusion of before—and—after comparisons. It is conducted at key points in the implementation phase (e.g., mid-term and terminal) to enable an in-depth analysis of whether ongoing or completed activities achieved planned results.
5.8. Framing of the Evaluation Scope Evaluation of the NAP process is a key phase of the adaptation cycle. This type of assessment can help in understanding support received for the development of the NAP, data or information gaps, stakeholder involvement in the development processes, and capture data and evidence generated to inform future adaptation policies and practices. The table below outlines an evaluation criterion with key evaluation questions for the NAP process. 150 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Table 21: Evaluation criteria and questions relevant to the implementation process Adaptation Plan Evaluation Evaluation Indicative Questions Criteria Evaluation criteria and questions relevant to the implementation process Country capacity • Is accurate and detailed data and scienPfic informaPon available to strengthening inform naPonal adaptaPon planning? • Have data been collected and compiled to support adaptaPon planning and response at sectoral scales? CHAPTER 5: MONITORING, EVALUATION AND LEARNING FOR ADAPTATION • Have adaptaPon data been integrated into enhanced naPonal decision-making databases and reporPng to the UNFCCC as per the Paris Agreement? Engagement of • Have sectors and stakeholders been involved in adaptaPon planning Stakeholders in and how have they implemented acPons? consultative • Have approved legislaPon, regulaPons and procedures enabled adaptation private sector and civil society to meaningfully parPcipate in planning processes environmental decision-making and in implemenPng climate acPons? • How has knowledge, lessons learned, and best pracPces been transferred and used for the benefit of the OECS sub-region, CARICOM region, and internaPonally? Sectoral adaptation • Have sectors improved their level of resilience and are beUer able priorities to respond effecPvely to climate change risks? Mobilization of • How have resources been mobilized to support adaptaPon Private sector in planning? adaptation • How involved is the private sector in sustainable financing and planning making investments for adaptaPon? • How has human capital been enhanced to implement adaptaPon through cerPficaPon and qualificaPons? The evaluation of whether the NAP responds to the relevant impacts, risks, vulnerabilities, and resilience needs will be guided by a list of six evaluation criteria from the Development Assistance Committee (DAC) of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. This criterion can be adapted to include additional criteria for assessment. An evaluation criterion supports consistent, high-quality evaluation within a common framework, and is a standard used as the basis for evaluation judgement. This criterion provides a normative framework with which to assess a specific intervention. Each of the six international evaluation criteria stated in the table below is summarised by a broad evaluation question, which illustrates its overall meaning. 151 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Table 22: Evaluation criteria and questions relevant to Adaptation Plan Effectiveness Adaptation Plan Evaluation Evaluation Indicative Questions Criteria Evaluation Criteria and Questions Relevant to Adaptation Plan Effectiveness Relevance • Is the intervenPon consistent with country needs, global prioriPes, and donors’ policies? • How well is country ownership reflected in the governance, coordinaPon, and consultaPon mechanisms? CHAPTER 5: MONITORING, EVALUATION AND LEARNING FOR ADAPTATION Coherence • How well does the intervenPon fit? • To what extent does the intervenPon compliment other on-going iniPaPves (by stakeholders, donors, governments) on climate change adaptaPon efforts? Efficiency • How well are resources being used? A measure of how economically resources/inputs (funds, experPse, Pme, equipment, etc.) are converted into results. Effectiveness • Is the intervenPon achieving its objecPves? • How effecPve has the country been in establishing financial mechanisms to advance its adaptaPon prioriPes. Impact • What posiPve and negaPve primary and secondary long-term effects are produced, whether directly or indirectly, intended or unintended? • How do intended and/or unintended effects contribute to overall adaptaPon? Sustainability • Can the results conPnue a\er the project ends? • What is the likely impact? • How does the NAP contribute to building resilience to climate change impacts? • Will the benefits last? The evaluation criteria may also include the following: Equity • To what degree has the intervenPon reduced or perpetuated inequaliPes, and how equitably benefits were accrued to vulnerable groups? • Have vulnerable groups such as women, youth, persons with disability, minoriPes, and other potenPally marginalized groups or locaPons been included during implementaPon? Adaptive • To what extent has the intervenPon supported the use, Management development, or diffusion of innovaPve pracPces, tools, or technologies to improve or accelerate climate change adaptaPon? • Have the project’s intervenPons been innovaPve to unlock addiPonal financing? 152 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Scalability • How can climate change adaptaPon intervenPon be increased or replicated at a broader scale, as well as in other contexts? • What contribuPon was made to build resilience to climate change impacts and AnPgua and Barbuda’s disaster risk reducPon response in the face of climate variability? • What are the key challenges for replicability and scalability?
5.9. Reporting on Climate Change Adaptation CHAPTER 5: MONITORING, EVALUATION AND LEARNING FOR ADAPTATION Different stakeholders and sectors in Antigua and Barbuda will need to understand the magnitude and frequency of climate impacts, to conduct climate vulnerability and risk assessments, identify and fund adaptation priorities, enhance systems and processes, as well as to inform future adaptation implementation and decision making. MEL for adaptation involves the synthesizing of data and generation of information that is relevant and accessible to a variety of stakeholders – from policy makers, business owners, communities, to technicians. Antigua and Barbuda will primarily be utilizing the following vehicles for reporting and learning on support for adaptation, adaptation progress and other related actions: • Na_onal Adapta_on Plan – The Naconal Adaptacon Plan will assist the country to meet its commitments to the Paris Agreements reporcng, transparency, and compliance requirements. It will contribute adaptacon informacon relevant to the global goal on adaptacon in the Paris Agreement – to enhance adapcve capacity, strengthen resilience and reduce vulnerability to climate change (Arccle 7.1.). o Progress Report on the NAP—provides informacon on Ancgua and Barbuda’s progress toward adaptacon to diverse stakeholders. • Adapta_on Communica_ons (ADCOMs)—form part of the suite of adaptacon reporcng to the UNFCCC. Ancgua and Barbuda’s first ADCOM captured informacon on the key climacc drivers and their impacts on the country; naconal adaptacon responses, both planned and ongoing; the adaptacon framework in which these responses are situated; and the needs and challenges to be addressed. Guidance on ADCOMs is presented in UNFCCC Decision 9/CMA13.35 Its purpose is to: o Increase the visibility and profile of adaptacon and its balance with micgacon. o Strengthen adaptacon accon and support for developing countries. o Provide input to the global stock take. o Enhance learning and understanding of adaptacon needs and accons. 35 UNFCCC. 2020. FCCC/PA/CMA/2018/3/Add.1. Decision 9/CMA.1 Further guidance in relation to the adaptation communication, including, inter alia, as a component of nationally determined contributions, referred to in Article 7, paragraphs 10 and 11 of the Paris Agreement. https://unfccc.int/sites/default/files/resource/9-CMA.1_English.pdf 153 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan The ADCOM as a reporting instrument stems from the Paris Agreement’s36 (PA) Article 7 at paragraphs 10 and 11. ADCOMs feature as part of the Enhanced Transparency Framework (ETF) for action and support, elaborated in Article 13 of the PA, and will inform the Global Stocktake (GS). The GS will track progress towards the Global Goal on Adaptation (GGA), which is “to enhance adaptive capacity and resilience; to reduce vulnerability with a view towards contributing towards sustainable development and ensuring an adaptation response in the context of the goal of holding average global warming well below 2o C and pursuing efforts to hold it below 1.5oC.”2 The information presented in the ADCOM also supports reporting for the National Communication and the CHAPTER 5: MONITORING, EVALUATION AND LEARNING FOR ADAPTATION country’s NAP. • Na_onally Determined Contribu_ons. Ancgua and Barbuda, as one of the most vulnerable countries to the negacve impacts of climate change, recognizes the importance of strengthening the global climate change response by enhancing the adapcve capacity and resiliency, and reducing vulnerability. As a result, adaptacon informacon will be reported on in its NDCs. The country as a Party to the Paris Agreement, is expected to submit a Naconally Determined Contribucon and revise it every five years. Ancgua and Barbuda submited its first Intended Naconally Determined Contribucons (INDCs) in 2015 and communicated its updated NDCs to the UNFCCC in 2021. In the context of the ETF, countries are expected to track and report progress towards achieving their NDCs, and communicate adaptacon accons, including good praccces, priorices, needs and gaps, to inform the global stock take under Arccle 14 of the Agreement. • Biennial Transparency Report (BTR)— Ancgua and Barbuda is in the process of preparing its first BTR that will comply with the United Nacons Framework Convencon on Climate Change (UNFCCC) and Paris Agreement reporcng requirements while responding to naconal development goals. As a signatory to the Paris Agreement, it is expected to submit a BTR including a Naconal Inventory Report every two years starcng from December 2024, thus replacing the Biennial Update Reports (BURs). The BTR will highlight efforts by Ancgua and Barbuda to strengthen the mainstreaming and integracon of climate change into country and sectoral development goals and to enable the country to respond to internaconal environmental obligacons by building insctuconal and technical capacity of government agencies, NGOs, and the private sector. o NDC Tracking Reports— These reports will be prepared in a common tabular format with informacon on tracking progress made in implemencng and achieving NDC. Preparacon of these reports are a requirement of the BTR. As Ancgua and Barbuda’s NDC features adaptacon, the progress update on achievements in adaptacon will also be a focus. The data and informacon compiled in the NDC tracking report will be derived from the Environment Registry plasorm. Data will be reviewed and validated. 36 United Nations. 2015. Paris Agreement 154 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan o Climate Change Impacts and Adapta_on Report— This report will be produced as part of implementacon of the BTR. Data and informacon contained in the report will be reported from the Environment Registry plasorm. The report will be validated by the Technical Advisory Commitee (TAC) and other relevant stakeholders. The DOE will manage the process of preparing informacon related to climate change impacts and adaptacon. • Na_onal Communica_ons: The Guidelines on Naconal Communicacons for Non-Annex I Parces “encourage” the provision of “informacon on and, to the extent possible, an CHAPTER 5: MONITORING, EVALUATION AND LEARNING FOR ADAPTATION evaluacon of, strategies and measures for adapcng to climate change, in key areas, including those which are of the highest priority.” (Paragraph 35 in UNFCCC, 2002). Ancgua and Barbuda presented three Naconal Communicacons, in 2001, 2011 and 2015 respeccvely, with the 4th Naconal Communicacon being prepared for submission to the Conference of the Parces to the UNFCCC in fulfilment of its obligacons to the Convencon under Decision 17 / CP. 8, and other related guidance. The country is obligated to submit its Naconal Communicacons (NCs) every four years. The 4th Naconal Communicacons will elaborate in detail the impact of climate change on weather and climate-sensicve sectors. It will also address efforts by Ancgua and Barbuda to deepen the mainstreaming and integracon of climate change into country and sectoral development goals and to enable the country to respond to internaconal environmental obligacons by strengthening the insctuconal and technical capacity of government agencies, NGOs and the private sector. • Voluntary Na_onal Reviews – This report provides criccal data and informacon on progress towards the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. The VNR serves as a plasorm to review new and emerging challenges such as climate change and efforts to strengthen resilience. The VNR is evidence – and data-based and structured to be analyccal. • The State of Environment (SOE) Report – Antigua and Barbuda through its Department of Environment is mandated to release a SOE Report every two years under its Environmental Protection and Management Act, 2019 under Part X, Section 89. This report provides information about environmental and social conditions, trends and pressures for the country, and the surrounding seas. The SOE reporting process is useful for effective environmental and sustainable development planning by examining the current condition of environmental indicators influenced by national, regional, and global pressures. The SOE report can be used in the following ways: o National Environment Sector Planning: Integrate findings into National Environmental Management Strategies (NEMS) and National Sustainable Development Plans (NSDPs). The SOE Report identifies gaps and priorities that can be included into National Environmental Management Strategies (NEMS) and National Sustainable Development Plans (NSDPs). o Multilateral Environmental Agreement Reporting: Report international obligations under the United Nations environmental conventions. 155 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan o Project Identification: Serve as a foundation for project development using gaps identified. o Cross-Sector Collaboration: Identify opportunities for interagency collaboration. o Sustainable Development Goals Reporting: Serve as an information source in national reporting by different interest groups.
5.10. Feedback and Learning on Adaptation CHAPTER 5: MONITORING, EVALUATION AND LEARNING FOR ADAPTATION There is a connection between effective adaptation and ongoing reflection and learning. Promoting feedback and learning on adaptation involves analysing M&E data to learn from implementation experiences and informing decision-making, ongoing adaptation, and planning for future initiatives. Learning is a critical and continuous process that occurs throughout this cycle of planning, implementation, monitoring and evaluation, all of which contribute to knowledge creation. An effective M&E system of adaptation facilitates learning and accountability, which are essential elements of results-based management. Antigua and Barbuda will provide dedicated resources to transfer knowledge and lessons learned on national adaptation planning. To do so the country will: • Synthesize experiences, best praccces and lessons learned and incorporate these into Naconal Communicacons, the Adaptacon Communicacons and policies, plans, strategies and key reports. • promote the use of the sub-regional OECS climate resilient Building Code and include findings from the NAP process in the updated Building Code. • Provide outcomes of naconal adaptacon planning to the Finance Sector (banks and insurance) in the sub-region and via the Eastern Caribbean Central Bank (ECCB) to allow them to make climate resilient financial decisions and where appropriate, provide detailed risk informacon to the Caribbean Catastrophe Risk Insurance Facility (CCRIF); and • Share knowledge, lessons learned and best praccces at the Conference of Parces, regional exchanges; workshops and expert meecngs; training accvices.
5.12. Conclusion As the climate crisis escalates, the Government of Antigua and Barbuda has been bearing the costs of adaptation – recovering from hurricanes, making improvements to infrastructure, adapting to saltwater intrusion, installing desalination and water storage, among other actions. This effort is not unique to Antigua and Barbuda. Climate expenses and recovery activities borne by the Government tend to delay the implementation of developmental priorities. In addition to the Government, the private sector and other stakeholder groups have also had to invest in adaptation planning. 156 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan This makes tracking national adaptation planning progress even more crucial. An integral part of monitoring and measuring progress is having quality data. The MEL system will integrate adaptation data generated by the NAP into the national repositories to support adaptation mainstreaming into national development processes. Importantly, it will also synthesize data and information generated making it accessible to a variety of stakeholders – from government agencies, policy makers, business owners, communities, technicians to civil society. Evaluative evidence can also provide valuable information on what works well or does not work during NAP implementation and provide an assessment of the impact of adaptation actions on CHAPTER 5: MONITORING, EVALUATION AND LEARNING FOR ADAPTATION sectors, local communities, and ecosystems. Reporting on adaptation progress will be a key feature of the system, so that there is: (i) enhancement of the effectiveness and transparency of the enabling environment for adaptation; and (ii) improvement in planning, decision making, accountability, and communication. Feedback and learning from planning, implementation, monitoring and evaluation processes can help in lowering the risk of maladaptation. In the long- term, effective adaptation approaches can enhance adaptive capacity, strengthen resilience, and reduce vulnerability to climate change (Article 7.1.). 157 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Appendix
Appendix 1: National Adaptation Plan Project Results Tracker Component Outcome Deliverable Indicator Country capacity 1.1. Accurate and detailed 1.1.1 Preliminary data 1.1. Data compiled every strengthened data and scienlfic compiled (delivery: every 6 six months informalon is months and final at 18 available to inform months) nalonal adaptalon planning 1.2. Country capacity is 1.2.1. Guidelines, including 1.2. Number of people strengthened in instructional videos, for trained in climate change adaptalon planning conducting climate adaptation planning in methodologies assessments the private and public sector. Guidelines, including instructional videos, for conducting climate assessments and SIAs produced 1.3. Informalon is 1.3.1. NAP Chapter 1 1.3 NAP Chapter 1 (GIS APPENDIX accessible via a baseline assessment) countrywide climate including a Climate change risk and Change Risk and vulnerability map Vulnerability MAP 1.3 Adaptalon data is 1.4.1.A: Report on 1.4. Report on integrated into adaptation data in multi- Adaptation data in Multi- enhanced nalonal agency information system Agency Information decision-making accessible to the public System accessible to the databases and public reporlng to the 1.4.1.B: Information and UNFCCC as per the data for the transparency Information and data for Paris Agreement mechanism of the Paris the transparency Agreement is peer reviewed mechanism of the Paris and information is provided Agreement is peer for the National reviewed and Communication Biennial information is provided Update Reports (BUR), for the National Adaptation Communication Communication, Biennial and general compliance Update reports (BUR), reporting under the Adaptation Convention Communication general reporting under the Convention. Component 2: 2.1. Stakeholders are 2.1.1. Approved regulations 2.1. Approved Stakeholder engaged in engaged in consultative and procedures for the regulations and Access to Justice procedures for the 158 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan consultative adaptation adaptation planning programme and public links Access to Justice planning processes processes to information programmed and public links to information 2.2. Adaptation priorities 2.2.1.A: Endorsed National 2.2. Endorsed National are developed and Adaption Plan for Antigua Adaptation Plan for continuously updated and Barbuda Antigua and Barbuda 2.2.1.B: Draft Adaptation Draft Adaptation Communication to the Communication to the UNFCCC UNFCCC 2.3. Knowledge and 2.3.1. Report on the 2.3. Report on the lessons learned are transfer of national transfer of national transferred regionally and adaptation planning lessons adaptation planning internationally learned in the OECS sub- lessons learned in the region and globally. OECS sub-region and globally Component 3: Sectoral 3.1. Enabling legal 3.1.1.A: Enactment of EPMA 3.1. Enactment of EPMA adaptation priorities environment for multi- Regulations providing Regulations providing sector adaptation enabling legal environment enabling legal planning for national adaptation environment for national planning adaptation planning 3.1.1.B: Operational and Operational and technical procedures for the technical procedures for implementation of the the implementation of regulations included in the the regulations included APPENDIX SIRF Fund procedures in the SIRF Fund procedures 3.2. Adaptation Plans for 3.2.1. 3 Sector Vulnerability 3.2. 3 Sector three sectors Risk Assessment and Vulnerability Risk Adaptation Plans, including Assessment and marketing material for Adaptation Plans, popularizing the plans including marketing material for popularizing the plans 3.3. NGOs and private 3.3.1. Up to 6 Vulnerability 3.3. Up to 6 Vulnerability sector Adaptation Plans Risk Assessment and Risk Assessment and Adaptation Plans (NGO and Adaptation Plans (NGO private sector) and private sector) 3.4. NAP Strategic Impact 3.4.1. 18-22 Strategic 3.4. The Strategic Impact Assessments fulfil legal, Impact Assessments meet Assessment Framework financial and planning national legal requirements was completed. requirements for the NAP and produce localized resilience action plans and investment strategies across assets, sectors, gender, and social impacts Component 4: Private 4.1. Private sector 4.1.1.A: NAP chapter on 4.1. NAP chapter on sector mobilization resources are mobilized sustainable financing for sustainable financing for to support NAP adaptation adaptation implementation 159 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan 4.1.1.B: Private sector Private sector funding funding proposal, including proposal, including SIAs, SIAs to implement to implement adaptation adaptation priorities priorities 4.2. Enhanced human 4.2.1. Over 50 public and 4.2. Over 50 public and capital to implement private sector professionals private sector adaptation through (50% female) are trained professionals (50% certification and from short term to medium female) are trained from qualifications (certificates) and long term short term to medium (master’s level) (certificates) and long term (master’s level) APPENDIX 160 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan
Appendix 2: Preliminary Stakeholder Consultation Stakeholder List No. Name of Organizations and Agencies 1. Antigua and Barbuda Association of Persons with Disabilities 2. Antigua and Barbuda Investment Authority 3. Antigua and Barbuda Transport Board 4. Antigua Public Utilities Authority 5. BAU Panel 6. Barbuda Council 7. Barbuda Go 8. Bureau of Standards 9. Caribbean Water Treatment 10. Carisun Renewable Energy 11. Central Board of Health 12. Central Housing and Planning Authority 13. Community Development Division 14. Contractor’s Association 15. CSO (Civil Society Organization) 16. Development Control Authority 17. Environmental Awareness Group 18. Fisheries Division 19. Forestry Division 20. GEF/SGP (Global Environment Facility/ Small Grants Programme 21. APPENDIX Gilbert Agricultural and Rural Development Center 22. Invasive Alien Species Project Coordinator 23. MEPA Trust (Zero Waste Antigua Barbuda and MEPA Trust) 24. MET Office 25. Ministry of Finance 26. Ministry of Health, Wellness, and the Environment 27. Ministry of Housing and Lands 28. Ministry of Public Works 29. Ministry of Tourism 30. Ministry of Works and Housing 31. National Housing and Urban Renewal Authority 32. National Office of Disaster Services 33. National Parks Authority 34. National Solid Waste Management Authority 35. Plant Protection Unit 36. St. John’s Development Corporation 37. Statistics Division 38. The Be Foundation 39. The Coco Point Fund 40. Transport Board 41. UNOPS (United Nations Office for Project Services) 42. Water-Energy-Food Nex 43. West Indies Oil Company (WIOC) 161 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Annex A – Prioritisation scores for each output Implementation Impact Alignment timeline (Years) Cost potential (No. with Thematic Area Output (USD of priorities ((1 million) Beneficiaries) – Highest/ 4 – Lowest) WR.1 10 31.3 15,666 2 Wholesale and WR.2 6 24.0 15,666 2 Retail SAP WR.3 8 1.4 15,666 2 WR.4 4 6.8 15,666 3 IH.1 12 95.5 24,174 1 Infrastructure IH.2 4 1.3 93,763 2 and Housing IH.3 10 56.6 93,763 1 SAP IH.4 12 4.1 93,763 2 FD.1 4 2.2 93,763 3 FD.2 11 2.4 93,763 3 FD.3 10 0.2 93,763 3 APPENDIX Food Security FD.4 11 9.5 93,763 2 SAP FD.5 11 19.2 93,763 2 FD.6 7 14.7 93,763 2 FD.7 11 1.1 93,763 3 FD.8 4 3.9 93,763 1 T.1 10 16.9 24,750 1 T.2 6 1.1 24,750 1 Tourism SAP T.3 6 16.8 24,750 3 T.4 6 3.5 24,750 2 T.5 5 2.2 24,750 2 Culture SAP C.1 10 9.0 93,763 2 LAPSJ.1 10 0.7 54,655 1 LAPSJ.2 10 1.2 54,655 2 LAPSJ.3 10 14.3 54,655 1 LAPSJ.4 10 0.8 54,655 2 LAPSJ.5 10 48.2 54,655 1 St. John LAP LAPSJ.6 10 0.6 54,655 2 LAPSJ.7 10 19.6 54,655 1 LAPSJ.8 10 1.4 54,655 2 LAPSJ.9 10 16.4 54,655 1 LAPSJ.10 10 0.8 54,655 3 162 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Implementation Impact Alignment timeline (Years) Cost potential (No. with Thematic Area Output (USD of priorities ((1 million) Beneficiaries) – Highest/ 4 – Lowest) LAPJH.1 10 2.0 862 1 LAPJH.2 10 1.0 862 2 LAPJH.3 10 1.0 862 1 LAPJH.4 10 0.4 862 2 LAPJH.5 10 0.8 862 1 Jolly Harbour LAPJH.6 10 0.4 862 2 LAP LAPJH.7 10 1.2 862 1 LAPJH.8 10 0.5 862 2 LAPJH.9 10 1.2 862 2 LAPJH.10 10 7.8 862 1 LAPJH.11 10 0.6 1,815 3 LAPAF.1 10 14.2 1,815 2 LAPAF.2 10 1.0 1,815 1 LAPAF.3 10 1.0 1,815 1 LAPAF.4 10 1.0 1,815 1 LAPAF.5 10 0.3 1,815 3 APPENDIX Airport/Fitches LAPAF.6 10 0.3 1,815 2 Creek LAP LAPAF.7 10 5.7 1,815 2 LAPAF.8 10 13.3 1,815 2 LAPAF.9 10 0.6 1,815 2 LAPAF.10 10 13.6 1,815 1 LAPAF.11 10 0.7 1,815 3 LAPAF.12 10 1.2 1,815 3 163 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan
Appendix 3: Snapshots from Stakeholder Engagement Activities Geographic Information Systems (GIS) Training APPENDIX Truck load of mosquito traps for distribution to local communities Department of Environment Stakeholder Engagement and mosquito trap distribution 164 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan
Appendix 4: Implementation Plans for the three (3) Local Area Plans Table 21: The ten (10) outcomes and associated outputs for the St. John’s City LAAP 2023-2033 Output Activities Description Deliverables Outcome 1 Improved protection from wind damage and impacts from storm surges along the St. John’s Harbour through the implementation of offshore and nearshore protective infrastructure Activity 1.1.1 Conduct a coastal engineering study to determine the feasibility of different coastal and 1. Technical reports offshore protection This initiative will involve the from coastal Output 1.1 Coastal measures for the St. John’s development of an engineering study engineering study waterfront area spans the implementation plan and 2. Workshop notes and to evaluate and Antigua and Barbuda Port strategy document for an reports recommend the Authority, Heritage Quay integrated coastal protection 3. Approved contracts most feasible Complex and the Antigua program for Saint John’s City. and TORs coastal and Cruise Port. These protection measures will 4. Establishment of APPENDIX offshore Activity 1.1.2 Consult with aid in reducing exposure to coastal zone protection stakeholders to get wave erosion and mitigating management and measures feedback and buy-in for impacts from storm surges and planning processes commissioned the project. coastal inundation. that build climate Activity 1.1.3 Develop resilience action/implementation plan and strategy document based on final recommendations Outcome 2 Enhanced and rehabilitated marine ecosystems that provide greater coastal protection from storm surge and wave erosion Activity 2.1.1 Mapping and 1. Baseline study and remote sensing of existing rehabilitation plan for seagrass bed noting critical seagrass bed and This initiative will involve ecological features. accompanying TOR understanding the benthic Activity 2.1.2 Conduct 2. Technical reports Output 2.1 environment off the coast of St. marine assessment and from mapping and Restoration of John’s City to determine the feasibility study to remote sensing seagrass bed viability for replanting of the determine viability for exercise seagrass bed in the outer seagrass replanting. 3. Establishment of harbour regions of St. John’s. Activity 2.1.3 Commission coastal zone replanting of seagrass bed management and at approved sites in the St. planning processes 165 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan John’s Harbour in that build climate collaboration with local resilience stakeholder organizations Outcome 3 Improved critical infrastructure and buildings with reduced susceptibility to impacts from hurricanes and storm surges Activity 3.1.1 Obtain final governmental approval of the revised building codes. Activity 3.1.2 Output 3.1 Revisions/strengthening of This initiative is already Approval of the existing legislation (EPMA, underway and involves the revised building the Physical Planning Act approval of the revised national code which 2003) and the National building code for Antigua and accounts for the Physical Development Plan Barbuda to accommodate for 1. Approved national growing threats (NPDP) to ensure the use more extreme climate events. It building code posed by of the revised codes is also involves legally mandating hurricanes, mandated by law in new its use and strengthening the increased flood developments. capacity to enforce its use in risks, and drought Activity 3.1.3 Identify and new developments. resilience procure resources and training needed to implement and enforce the use of the updated APPENDIX building code Output 3.2 Renovation of existing critical facilities such as emergency shelters, schools, Activity 3.2.1 Develop an health and 1. Relevant policy inventory of existing transport facilities documents, MOUs facilities and identify that are at risk This initiative will build on etc. facilities that require from wind damage existing activities to identify and 2. Implementation plan renovation along the and coastal renovate existing critical and guidelines for waterfront. flooding. Special facilities in St. John’s City to upgrading existing Activity 3.2.2 Renovate attention to build resilience to hurricane and facilities. selected facilities in line establishments storm impacts. 3. Inventory of all critical with revised national and infrastructure facilities and their building code located in the resource needs requirements coastal zone including major harbourfront complexes such as Heritage Quay, Redcliffe Quay, 166 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Point Wharf and the Markets Output 3.3 Power lines and communication networks in at-risk low-lying locations 1. Flood and hurricane (namely, Greys hazard maps for road Farm, Pointe, and Activity 3.3.1 Mapping and communication Green Bay) locations of most infrastructure relocated vulnerable powerlines and This initiative is intended to 2. Detail road and underground to related communication build resilience in the energy communications protect against infrastructure to wind and telecommunication sectors network wind and flood damage by placing power lines and infrastructure map damage. Also Activity 3.3.2 Consult with communication infrastructure and implementation applies to localized Public Works and APUA on underground where they are plan sections of the city options to protect this less exposed to climatic risks. 3. Financial reports and and commercial infrastructure when audits district including placing underground 4. MOUs and other Church Street, policy documents Dickenson Bay Street, Market Street, Newgate APPENDIX Street and South Street Outcome 4 Increased uptake of climate/ hurricane risk insurance schemes by local farmers and fishers, and businesses This initiative is aimed at building resilience in the local farming, fishing, hotel and small Output 4.1 Activity 4.1.1 Conduct a business sectors through the 1. Completed feasibility Feasibility feasibility study with local provision of a suitable climate study. Assessment for the stakeholders. risk insurance mechanism. This 2. Tailored parametric- establishment of a Activity 4.1.2 Develop a risk-transfer mechanism will based climate climate risk parametric-based climate provide tailored financial insurance instruments insurance scheme risk insurance scheme assistance to those in key vulnerable sectors in the event of a natural disaster. Output 4.2 This initiative is aimed at Sensitization on sensitizing local stakeholders 1. Sensitization strategy the new climate or Activity 4.2.1 Plan and about the benefits of the document hurricane risk execute sensitization insurance scheme with the 2. Workshop notes and insurance scheme sessions/workshops hope of gaining useful feedback reports that fosters the and buy-in. uptake for the 167 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan farming, fisheries, resort and local business sectors Outcome 5 Increased capacity of drainage infrastructure to better channel stormwater, improve solid waste management and reduce the incidence of localized flooding Activity 5.1.1 Conduct a study to determine the volume and peak rate of runoff. Activity 5.1.2 Conduct a study to determine how 1. Technical reports Output 5.1 wide drains, canals and 2. Completed and signed Expanded and waterways can be contracts and TORs This initiative will involve the improved network expanded within their 3. Improved stormwater identification and expansion of of drains, canals, existing location. infrastructure that is existing drains, canals, and and waterways Activity 5.1.3 Develop climate resilient waterways throughout the city. throughout St. terms of reference for a 4. Financial reports and John’s City competitive bidding audits process. 5. M&E reports Activity 5.1.4 Contract local construction/engineering company to expand drains, APPENDIX canals and waterways Activity 5.2.1 Conduct a study to determine the required capacity of the sewer system. 1. Technical reports Activity 5.2.2 Develop This initiative will entail the 2. Completed and signed Output 5.2 terms of reference for a design and construction of a contracts and TORs Construction of a competitive bidding central sewer system for St. 3. Final design drawing central sewerage process. John’s City. Currently, the area of sewerage system system to better Activity 5.2.3 Contract a does not have a central sewer 4. Construction of manage sewage local engineering company system which often leads to central sewer system waste throughout to design the system for sewage ending up in drains and 5. Financial reports and the city the City. ultimately the sea. audits Activity 5.2.4 Contract 6. M&E reports construction entity to construct a central sewer system for the St. John’s City local area Output 5.3 Activity 5.3.1 Survey This initiative will involve the 1. A technical report Retrofitting the existing roads for evidence construction of drains and documenting high-risk existing coastal of deterioration and/or culverts at certain sections of sections of the road network damage and identify roads the roadway to channel and roadway. 168 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan spanning Villa, that typically flood during divert flood waters away from 2. Road rehabilitation Perry Bay and rainfall events. the road infrastructure. plan and guidelines Grey’s Farm, to Activity 5.3.2 Evaluate and document protect against test different erosion- 3. Financial reports and future flood control techniques such as audits impacts. Attention embankments that resist should be given to washing out, rubber liners key transport and reduced slopes infrastructure as well, such as the West Bus Station Terminal Activity 5.4.1 Conduct a Output 5.4 This initiative will focus on needs assessment of the Improving the strengthening the capacity of Ministry of Public Works to capacity of the the Ministry of Public Works to 1. Needs Assessment identify resource needs Ministry of Public carry out regular clean-up and report and resource and other gaps. Works to rehabilitation work throughout mobilization plan. Activity 5.4.2 Use results undertake regular the city. This will entail the 2. Maintenance plan for from needs assessment to clean-up and drain provision of more equipment drainage clearing develop a resource rehabilitation work and personnel to conduct these mobilization plan for the in the city activities. Ministry 1. Technical reports APPENDIX 2. Completed and signed Output 5.5 Activity 5.5.1 Assessment contracts and TORs Installation of These activities are aimed at or audit of existing 3. Assessment/Audit drain covers and preventing the build-up of solid drainage network Results of existing metal barrier for waste material in the existing Activity 5.5.2 Installation drainage network existing drainage drainage network. of drain covers 4. Project Reports network 5. Financial reports and audits Output 5.6 Activity 5.6.1 Conduct a Strategy study to determine the developed to feasibility of the proposed establish an action and make site- 1. Technical reports underground specific recommendations. 2. Completed and signed This initiative will entail the drainage network Activity 5.6.2 Develop contracts and TORs construction of an underground in flood-prone terms of reference for a 3. Construction of drainage system for St. John’s sections of the city competitive bidding underground City to reduce the risk of water such as Gray’s process. drainage system overflowing drains and causing Farm, the Point Activity 5.6.3 Contract 4. Financial reports and flooding of roads. Community, the local construction/ audits Lower North engineering company to 5. M&E reports Street area, Green design and construct an Bay, the Perry Bay underground drainage Main Road, and system for the St. John’s 169 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan the Lower Market City local area on a phased Street area basis prioritizing at-risk location Activity 5.7.1 Research and Output 5.7 procure the most suitable Implemented a system to monitor and computer evaluate drainage issues. 1. Implementation plan database system Activity 5.7.2 Conduct This activity will provide a digital 2. Installation of IT that monitors and training led by the system that will monitor and infrastructure forming evaluates drainage technology provider to evaluate drainage issues like coordination between issues, including learn about the system and leakages. It will include building different Ministry of leaks to manage how to use its features. a database that can be used to Works personnel for their status in real- Activity 5.7.3 Implement a collect, manage, and monitor documentation and time and used system and develop a drainage systems across St. recording of drainage across various database to manage data. John’s City. issues governmental Activity 5.7.3 Design on- entities to manage site data collection infrastructure procedures for regular field site visits Outcome 6 Improved solid waste management practices within at-risk communities 1. Media campaign APPENDIX strategy document and plan (media This initiative will entail a series Output 6.1 PR coverage of activities) of PR campaigns (television, campaign around 2. Education toolkit radio, and other media) to best practices for Activity 6.1.1 Develop a (school field trips, educate and sensitize the household solid communication strategy primary and general public about the waste secondary school importance of solid waste management demonstrations) management. 3. Electronic news bulletin to highlight local action Activity 6.2.1 Consult with waste facilities and the Output 6.2 City- Ministry of Health, wide recycling Wellness and the services are 1. MOUs and other Environment (DoE, provided for This activity will develop a relevant policy National Solid Waste businesses and framework for expanding documents Authority) about residences to recycling services in the St. 2. Recycling system that establishing acceptance collect plastics, John’s City local area. provides waste criteria for plastics, metals metals, and other disposal services materials and other forms forms of solid of solid waste. waste Activity 6.2.2 Explore options for partnering with 170 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan private sector partners to develop recycling services for the area Outcome 7 Expanded water storage capacity Activity 7.1.1 Conduct a study to determine the This activity is intended to Output 7.1 remaining water demand increase the water production Construction of at needs for St. Johns City and capacity for the area through 1. Technical reports least one surrounding areas. the commissioning and 2. Financial reports and additional Activity 7.1.2 Use the construction of at least one audits desalination/RO results from the study to additional RO plant or plant determine the number increasing the capacity of the and/or increase in capacity existing plant. of RO plants needed Output 7.2 Develop measures to encourage local Activity 7.2.1 Provide tax businesses and and customs duty relief to This initiative is intended to hotels to invest in 1. Technical reports and incentivize local businesses facilitate the decentralization of micro-scale relevant policy and hotels to invest in water production to reduce the desalination documents APPENDIX microscale desalination pressure at the municipal level. technologies to technologies reduce the pressure at the municipal level Activity 7.3.1 Conduct a survey to identify areas that require intervention. This activity will primarily entail 1. Technical reports Output 7.3 Put Activity 7.3.2 Develop a the replacement of old 2. Rehabilitation and measures in place rehabilitation and upgrade degraded pipelines with new upgrade plan for the to reduce non- plan for the water sector. ones to reduce leakage. This will water sector revenue water Activity 7.3.3 Commission also involve the installation of 3. Implementation of losses from the rehabilitation work on smart metering systems that pilot projects for the existing water existing water pipes can better account for water smart metering piping network Activity 7.3.4 Explore distribution within the water system options for piloting the piping network. 4. M&E reports smart metering system in the area Output 7.4 Activity 7.4.1 Conduct 1. Sensitization strategy Implementation of sensitization campaign to This activity will promote the document new initiatives to educate the public on the storage and use of grey water to 2. MOUs and increase the use of benefits of greywater aid in water conservation. partnership greywater, usage. agreements especially in the Activity 7.4.2 Explore 171 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan commercial and potential partnerships with tourism sectors regional organizations such as the Caribbean Water and Wastewater Association (CWWA) and Global Water Partnership Caribbean (GWPC) to pilot greywater use Activity 7.5.1 Survey at-risk Output 7.5 communities to determine Provision of water and map households that storage facilities to need water storage Water storage devices will be 1. Community residents in systems. provided to the most vulnerable household survey and vulnerable Activity 7.5.2 Provide households in at-risk inventory document households in at- water storage devices to communities to improve their 2. Project risk communities the most vulnerable ability to store water for implementation such as Grey’s households identified from household consumption. document Farm and Pointe to the community water increase resilience survey and inventory to drought hazards exercise Outcome 8 Increased uptake of renewable energy technologies by businesses and households APPENDIX Activity 8.1.1 Survey 1. A survey report and homeowners/tourists and feasibility study local businesses on Output 8.1 This initiative will develop 2. Incentives program willingness to install solar Incentivize the incentive packages to designed and energy systems. uptake of solar encourage persons to install implemented under Activity 8.1.2 Evaluate energy solar systems at the local scale. the coordination of affordability and financing relevant Government options for different solar agencies energy technologies Activity 8.2.1 Survey homes, buildings, and other properties to determine the potential for This initiative will seek to 1. A survey report and Output 8.2 installing green roofs, rain promote urban greening and feasibility study Establishing urban gardens, and infiltration sustainability projects such as 2. Incentives program greening projects basins. green roofs and tree planting designed and aimed at Activity 8.2.2 Identify activities to reduce the urban implemented under regulating local locations that can be used heat island effect and increase the coordination of urban as green areas. surfaces for infiltration across relevant Government microclimates Activity 8.2.3 Mandate the the city. agencies use of green infrastructure in new developments (e.g., use of grasscrete in parking spaces and hedges instead 172 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan of concrete walls etc.) Activity 8.2.4 Promote ongoing tree planting initiative. Activity 8.2.5 Conduct an assessment to determine fossil fuel usage in the city Outcome 9 Improved critical infrastructure and buildings with reduced susceptibility to impacts from higher mean sea levels Activity 9.1.1 Conduct a comprehensive coastal Output 9.1 Expand assessment of the port and 1. Coastal assessment and elevate the surrounding areas. reports for the port port to reduce the Activity 9.1.2 Use results 2. Technical reports and risk of coastal to develop a proposal for This activity will involve raising plans inundation and addressing any climate- the current level of the St. 3. Completed and signed loss of prime related risks identified. John’s City port facility to contracts and TORs coastal lands. Activity 9.1.3 Share accommodate projected 4. Stakeholder Should include the proposals with key increases in mean sea level. consultation notes following facilities: stakeholders to get 5. Financial reports and Heritage Quay, feedback and buy-in audits Redcliffe Quay and Activity 9.1.4 Mobilize 6. M&E reports Point Wharf resources for executing the APPENDIX project Activity 9.2.1 Develop a stormwater master plan for the area. 1. Stormwater master Activity 9.2.2 Commission plan and Output 9.2 This activity will involve a series the construction of a accompanying reports Establishing a of infrastructure projects stormwater pumping 2. Completed and signed stormwater designed to remove floodwaters system for the St. John city contracts and TORs pumping system from low-lying sections of the local area comprising 3. Financial reports and for the coast city. stormwater pumping audits stations, injection wells 4. M&E reports and other supporting infrastructure Output 9.3 Activity 9.3.1 Perform desk 1. Desk study Planned coastal review of relevant 2. Workshop reports This initiative will entail the retreat (where documents to understand and notes development of a managed feasible) for common themes in 3. Assessment of the coastal retreat plan for certain certain key managed coastal retreat feasibility and sectors, communities and key infrastructure and programs in other parts of implications of infrastructures that are located assets. This may the world. managed retreat in high-risk zones. include facilities Activity 9.3.2 Perform strategies for like the Barnes stakeholder validation vulnerable coastal 173 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Funeral Home or workshops to evaluate areas of St. John’s City sewage plants that lessons learned and may pose acute managed retreat scenarios health risks to the with (residents, tourism general population and local businesses) Activity 9.4.1 Identify areas within the city that 1. List of no-build zones Output 9.4 are at risk and designate 2. List of available land Promoting future them as no-build zones. This activity will entail the that can housing and Activity 9.4.2 Identify development of a master plan accommodate the business areas inland that are not at to manage future coastal development. developments risk where future development and encourage 3. Development of further inland to developments can occur. inland developments for the policies and incentive reduce exposure Activity 9.4.3 Produce city. mechanisms to build to projected SLR planning guidance and further inland (e.g., expansion restrictions for tax credits, subsidies) coastal zone developments Outcome 10 Increased enabling environment for the expansion of and investment in the Blue Economy Sector in St. John City Activity 10.1.1 Survey local fishermen, tourism and businesses in the area to APPENDIX identify daily activities, and major issues or challenges. Activity 10.1.2 Consult with statutory bodies 1. Surveys and other within the Ministry of technical reports Output 10.1 Blue Tourism, Investment and 2. Training manuals and economy jobs Economic Development guidelines This activity will entail setting promoted where (Antigua and Barbuda 3. Pilot projects based up the foundation for the feasible to explore Tourism Authority, Antigua around blue economy development of a viable blue benefits from a and Barbuda Investment initiatives. economy for the area. growing marine Authority) to determine 4. Economic evaluation resource base the strategy for capitalizing report on the Blue Economy 5. List of potential Activity 10.1.3 Perform investors economic valuation of the St. John’s city local area. Activity 10.1.4 Explore investment opportunities that can help to grow the Blue Economy 174 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Table 22: The eleven (11) outcomes and associated outputs for the Darkwood Beach LAAP 2023-2033 Output Activities Description Deliverables Outcome 1 Improved protection from wind damage and impacts from storm surges through the implementation of offshore and nearshore protective infrastructure Activity 1.1.1 Conduct a 5. Technical reports from coastal engineering study coastal engineering study (inclusive of a bathymetry (inclusive of feasibility study) to determine the and bathymetric studies) feasibility of different coastal 6. Workshop notes and and offshore protection reports measures for the Jolly This initiative will involve the Output 1.1 Coastal 7. Approved contracts and Harbour to Johnsons Point feasibility and design study engineering study to TORs local area. as well as the construction of evaluate and 8. Several newly the recommended coastal recommend the constructed Activity 1.1.2 Consult with works (e.g., offshore most feasible recommended coastal stakeholders to get feedback breakwater structures to coastal and offshore protective measures and buy-in for the project. assist in reducing wave protection measure (e.g., offshore erosion and mitigating commissioned breakwaters) Activity 1.1.3 Mobilize impacts from storm surges). 9. Financial reports and resources for the project audits design and commission of 10. Establishment of coastal the construction for the APPENDIX zone management and recommended coastal works planning processes that (e.g., offshore breakwater build climate resilience system) Outcome 2 Enhanced and rehabilitated marine ecosystems that provide greater coastal protection from storm surge and wave erosion Activity 2.1.1 Mapping and remote sensing of mangrove/wetland identifying areas of These activities will degradation. characterize the wetland/ 4. Technical report outlining Output 2.1 Activity 2.1.2 Conduct mangrove ecosystem and its results of the mapping Restoration of hydrological assessment for hydrology within the Jolly exercise and hydrological degraded wetlands wetland/ mangrove Harbour to Johnsons Point assessment. /mangroves in the ecosystems in the area local area to guide the 5. M&E Plan/Framework for vicinities of Activity 2.1.3 Initiate project appropriate restoration evaluating biodiversity Darkwood Beach, to replant mangroves guided activities. These will be and carbon Turner’s Beach and by previous studies. supported by protection sequestration. the Valley Church Activity 2.1.4 Establish measures to assist in 6. Mangrove/Wetland Bay areas baselines and monitoring rehabilitating the degraded Rehabilitation Plan and evaluation plan for mangroves/wetlands. biodiversity and carbon sequestration in mangroves and wetlands 175 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Output Activities Description Deliverables Activity 2.2.1 Mapping and remote sensing of existing 1. Baseline study and seagrass bed noting critical rehabilitation plan for ecological features. Output 2.2 This initiative will involve seagrass bed and Activity 2.2.2 Conduct Restoration of understanding the benthic accompanying TOR marine assessment and seagrass bed in the environment off the coast of 2. Technical reports from feasibility study to nearshore zone Jolly Harbour to Johnsons mapping and remote determine viability for along Jolly Harbour, Point to determine the sensing exercise seagrass replanting. Ffryes Beach to Fort viability for replanting of the 3. Establishment of coastal Activity 2.2.3 Commission Johnston’s Point seagrass beds. zone management and replanting of seagrass bed at planning processes that approved sites in build climate resilience collaboration with local stakeholder organization Outcome 3 Improved critical infrastructure and buildings with reduced susceptibility to impacts from hurricanes and storm surges in coastal communities such as Jolly Harbour, Bolans and Johnson’s Point Activity 3.1.1 Obtain final governmental approval of the revised building codes. Activity 3.1.2 Revisions/strengthening of This initiative is already APPENDIX Output 3.1 Approval existing legislation (EPMA, underway and involves the of the revised the Physical Planning Act approval of the revised building code which 2003) and the National national building code for accounts for the Physical Development Plan Antigua and Barbuda to 2. Approved national growing threats (NPDP) to ensure the use of accommodate more extreme building code posed by hurricanes, the revised codes is climate events. It also increased flood mandated by law in new involves legally mandating risks, and drought developments. its use and strengthening the resilience. Activity 3.1.3 Identify and capacity to enforce its use in procure resources and new developments. training needed to implement and enforce the use of the updated building code Output 3.2 Activity 3.2.1 Develop an 4. Inventory of all critical Renovation of This initiative will build on inventory of existing facilities facilities and their existing critical existing activities to identify and identify facilities that resource needs facilities such as and renovate existing critical require renovation. 5. Relevant policy emergency shelters, facilities in Jolly Harbour to Activity 3.2.2 Renovate documents, MOUs etc. schools and health Johnsons Point to build selected facilities in line with 6. Implementation plan and facilities that are at resilience to hurricane and revised national building guidelines for upgrading risk from wind storm impacts. code requirements existing facilities damage and coastal 176 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Output Activities Description Deliverables flooding (include health centers in Bolans and Johnson’s Point, the Ffryes Beach RO Plant, Jolly Harbour Gas Station, St. Mary School and Valley Church). Activity 3.3.1 Mapping 5. Flood and hurricane Output 3.3 Power locations of most vulnerable hazard maps for road and This initiative is intended to lines and power lines and related communication build resilience in the energy communication communication infrastructure and telecommunication network along infrastructure to wind 6. Detail road and sectors by placing Valley Road and in damage and storm surge communications network powerlines and Jolly Harbour and impact infrastructure map and communication Bolans relocated Activity 3.3.2 Consult with implementation plan infrastructure underground underground to Public Works and APUA on 7. Financial reports and where they are less exposed protect against wind options to protect this audits to climatic risks. and flood damage infrastructure when placing 8. MOUs and other policy underground documents APPENDIX Outcome 4 Increased uptake of climate/ hurricane risk insurance schemes by local farmers and fishers, and businesses This initiative is aimed at building resilience in the local farming, fishing, hotel Output 4.1 Activity 4.1.1 Conduct a and small business sectors 3. Completed feasibility Feasibility feasibility study with local through the provision of a study Assessment for the stakeholders. suitable climate risk 4. Tailored parametric- establishment of a Activity 4.1.2 Develop a insurance mechanism. This based climate insurance climate risk parametric-based climate risk-transfer mechanism will instruments insurance scheme risk insurance scheme provide tailored financial assistance to those in key vulnerable sectors in the event of a natural disaster. Output 4.2 Sensitization on the This initiative is aimed at new climate or sensitizing local stakeholders 3. Sensitization strategy hurricane risk Activity 4.2.1 Plan and about the benefits of the document insurance scheme execute in insurance scheme with the 4. Workshop notes and that fosters the sessions/workshops hope of gaining useful reports uptake for the feedback and buy-in. farming, fisheries, resort and local 177 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Output Activities Description Deliverables business sectors Outcome 5 Increased capacity of drainage infrastructure within Jolly Harbour, and along Valley Road to better channel stormwater, improve solid waste management and reduce the incidence of localized flooding Activity 5.1.1 Conduct a study to determine the volume and peak rate of runoff. 6. Technical reports Output 5.1 Activity 5.1.2 Conduct a 7. Completed and signed Expanded and study to determine how This initiative will involve the contracts and TORs improved network wide drains, canals and identification and expansion 8. Improved stormwater of drains, canals, waterways can be expanded of existing drains, canals, infrastructure that is and waterways within their existing location. and waterways throughout climate resilient throughout Jolly Activity 5.1.3 Develop terms the local area. 9. Financial reports and Harbour to Johnsons of reference for a audits Point competitive bidding process. 10. M&E reports Activity 5.1.4 Contract local construction/engineering company to expand drains, canals and waterways Activity 5.2.1 Survey existing APPENDIX Output 5.2 roads for evidence of Retrofitting at-risk deterioration and/or 7. Technical report sections of Valley damage and identify roads This initiative will involve the documenting high-risk Road (e.g., the that typically flood during construction of drains and sections of the roadway. segment in the rainfall events. culverts at certain sections 8. Road rehabilitation plan vicinity of the Activity 5.2.2 Evaluate and of the roadway to channel and guidelines document Darkwood Pond) to test different erosion-control and divert flood waters away 9. Financial reports and protect against techniques such as from the road infrastructure. audits future flood impacts embankments that resist and coastal erosion washing out, rubber liners and reduced slopes Outcome 6 Improved solid waste management practices within at-risk communities in Jolly Harbour, Bolans, Jennings, and Johnsons Point 4. Media campaign strategy Output 6.1 PR document and plan This initiative will entail a campaign around (media coverage of series of PR campaigns best practices for activities) (television, radio, and other household solid Activity 6.1.1 Develop a 5. Education toolkit (school media) to educate and waste management communication strategy field trips, primary and sensitize the general public in Jolly Harbour, secondary school about the importance of Bolans, Jennings, demonstrations) solid waste management. and Johnsons Point 6. Electronic news bulletin to highlight local action 178 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Output Activities Description Deliverables Activity 6.2.1 Consult with waste facilities and the Ministry of Health, Wellness and the Environment (DoE, Output 6.2 National Solid Waste Recycling services Authority) about establishing This activity will develop a 3. MOUs and other relevant are provided for acceptance criteria for framework for expanding policy documents businesses and plastics, metals materials recycling services in the Jolly 4. Recycling system that residences to collect and other forms of solid Harbour to Johnsons Point provides waste disposal plastics, metals, and waste. local area. services other forms of solid Activity 6.2.2 Explore waste options for partnering with private sector partners to develop recycling services for the area Outcome 7 Expanded water storage capacity Output 7.1 Develop measures like tax incentives to encourage local APPENDIX Activity 7.1.1 Provide tax This initiative is intended to businesses and and customs duty relief to facilitate the resorts to invest in 3. Technical reports and incentivize local businesses decentralization of water micro-scale relevant policy and hotels to invest in production to reduce the desalination documents microscale desalination pressure at the parish and technologies to technologies national levels. reduce the pressure of other desalination plants in the area Activity 7.2.1 Conduct a survey to identify areas that This activity will primarily require intervention. entail the replacement of old 2. Technical reports Activity 7.2.2 Develop a Output 7.2 Put degraded pipelines with new 3. Rehabilitation and rehabilitation and upgrade measures in place to ones to reduce leakage. This upgrade plan for the plan for the water sector. reduce non-revenue will also involve the water sector Activity 7.2.3 Commission water losses from installation of smart 4. Implementation of pilot rehabilitation work on the existing water metering systems that can projects for the smart existing water pipes piping network better account for water metering system Activity 7.2.4 Explore distribution within the water 5. M&E reports options for piloting the piping network. smart metering system in the area Output 7.3 Activity 7.3.1 Conduct a This activity will promote the 5. Sensitization strategy 179 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Output Activities Description Deliverables Implementation of sensitization campaign to storage and use of grey document new initiatives to educate the public on the water to aid in water 6. MOUs and partnership increase the use of benefits of greywater usage. conservation. agreements greywater in Activity 7.3.2 Explore business and tourist potential partnerships with establishments regional organizations such along the local area as the Caribbean Water and Wastewater Association (CWWA) and Global Water Partnership Caribbean (GWPC) to pilot greywater use. Activity 7.4.1 Survey at-risk Output 7.4 Provision communities to determine of water storage and map households that Water storage devices will system to residents 3. Community household need water storage systems. be provided to the most in vulnerable survey and inventory Activity 7.4.2 Provide water vulnerable households in at- households in document storage devices to the most risk communities to improve Bolans, Jennings, 4. Project implementation vulnerable households their ability to store water and Johnsons Point document identified from the for household consumption. to assist during community water survey and times of drought inventory exercise Outcome 8 Increased uptake of drought risk insurance schemes by local farmers APPENDIX Activity 8.1.1 Explore options with private sector partners to set up a tailored This initiative is aimed at drought risk insurance building resilience in the Output 8.1 Setting scheme. local farming sector through up a climate or Activity 8.1.2 Conduct a the provision of a drought 3. Completed feasibility drought risk feasibility study with local risk insurance mechanism. study. insurance scheme farmers to determine their This risk-transfer mechanism 4. Tailored drought risk tailored for local willingness to participate in will provide much-needed insurance instruments farmers the program (this should be financial assistance to the done in tandem with a sector during periods of sensitization campaign on prolonged drought. the benefits of a risk insurance scheme) Outcome 9 Increased uptake of renewable energy and climate-smart technologies by businesses and households in the Jolly Harbour to Johnsons Point area Output 9.1 Activity 9.1.1 Survey This initiative will develop 7. Survey report and Incentivize the homeowners/tourists and incentive packages to feasibility study uptake of solar local businesses on encourage persons to install 8. Incentives program 180 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Output Activities Description Deliverables energy willingness to install solar solar systems at the local designed and energy systems. scale. implemented under the Activity 9.1.2 Evaluate coordination of relevant affordability and financing Government agencies options for different solar energy technologies Activity 9.2.1 Agricultural Output 9.2 survey in the area to identify Implementation of resource and technology projects to facilitate needs. This activity will facilitate technology transfer Activity 9.2.2 Training and farmer training in climate- in the agriculture capacity building initiatives 5. Agricultural survey smart agricultural practices sector to build around climate-smart 6. Training manuals and the transfer or piloting resilience to drought agricultural practices 7. Project implementation of various technologies and and heat impacts Activity 9.2.3 Pilot projects plans and M&E reports innovations to build climate (e.g., water storage, aimed at demonstrating the resilience in the sector. hydroponics and usefulness of different forms drought-resistant of technology e.g., rainwater crops) harvesting, drought tolerant crops etc. Outcome 10 Improved critical infrastructure and buildings with reduced susceptibility to impacts from higher mean sea APPENDIX levels Activity 10.1.1 Conduct a comprehensive coastal assessment of the coastline within the local area (can be This activity will entail split into sections to focus on understanding the coastal Output 10.1 Expand, 6. Coastal inundation the various issues like dynamics of the coastal zone reinforce and/or hazard maps coastal erosion, beach within the area and using elevate the road 7. Feasibility study erosion, and coastal flooding the information to guide network to reduce 8. Completed and signed in various areas within the works along Valley Road to the risk of coastal contracts and TORs local area) address existing coastal inundation and loss 9. Financial reports and Activity 10.1.2 Use issues and future challenges of prime coastal audits recommendations from the that may be caused by the lands 10. M&E reports studies to develop targeted projected increases in mean projects. sea level. Activity 10.1.3 Mobilize resources for executing these projects Output 10.2 Coastal Activity 10.2.1 Conduct This initiative will involve the 1. Technical reports from engineering study feasibility and bathymetric construction of the feasibility and that evaluated and study to determine the appropriate coastal works bathymetric studies recommended the appropriate for the area which might 2. Workshop notes and most feasible recommendation for coastal include sea walls and dykes reports 181 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Output Activities Description Deliverables coastal and offshore protection works and designed to prevent coastal 3. Approved contracts and protection measure placement and design of inundation from rising sea TORs commissioned these (e.g., sea walls and levels. 4. Several newly followed by dykes) constructed coastal implementation Activity 10.2.2 Consult with protective works (e.g., stakeholders to get feedback sea wall defences and and buy-in for the project. dykes) along the Activity 10.2.3 Mobilize coastline resources for the project and 5. Financial reports and commission the construction audits of protective coastal works (e.g., sea walls and dykes) Activity 10.3.1 Perform desk review of relevant 1. Desk study documents to understand 2. Workshop reports and common themes in managed This initiative will entail the Output 10.3 notes coastal retreat programs in development of a managed Planned coastal 3. Assessment of the other parts of the world. coastal retreat plan for retreat for certain feasibility and Activity 10.3.2 Perform certain sectors, communities key infrastructure implications of managed stakeholder validation and key infrastructure that and assets where retreat strategies for workshops to evaluate are located in high-risk feasible vulnerable coastal areas lessons learned and zones. APPENDIX of Jolly Harbour to managed retreat scenarios Johnsons Point with (residents, tourism and local businesses) Outcome 11 Established enabling environment for the expansion of and investment in the Blue Economy Sector in the Jolly Harbour to Johnsons Point Area Activity 11.1.1 Survey local fishermen, tourism and businesses in the area to identify daily activities, and 1. Surveys and other major issues or challenges. technical reports Output 11.1 Blue Activity 11.1.2 Consult with 2. Training manuals and economy jobs statutory bodies within the This activity will entail guidelines promoted where Ministry of Tourism, setting up the foundation for 3. Pilot projects based feasible to explore Investment and Economic the development of a viable around blue economy benefits from a Development (Antigua and blue economy for the area. initiatives. growing marine Barbuda Tourism Authority, 4. Economic evaluation resource base Antigua and Barbuda report Investment Authority) to 5. List of potential investors determine the strategy for capitalizing on the Blue Economy Activity 11.1.3 Perform 182 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Output Activities Description Deliverables economic valuation of the Jolly Harbour to Johnsons Point local area. Activity 11.1.4 Explore investment opportunities that can help to grow the Blue Economy APPENDIX 183 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Table 23: The twelve (12) outcomes and associated outputs for the St. John’s City LAAP 2023-2033 Output Activities Description Deliverables Outcome 1 Improved protection from wind damage and impacts from storm surges through ecosystem maintenance and the implementation of offshore and nearshore protective infrastructure. Output 1.1: The use of enforcement officers to deter Activity 1.1.1 Perform illegal dumping Create monitoring surveillance activities to 11. Enhanced institutional within the NEMMA protocols that strengthen protect capacity for to preserve the the sustainable mangroves/wetlands and surveillance and storm surge management of the maintain stream channel enforcement barrier functions NEMMA. integrity of the mangroves and wetlands along Fitches Creek Bay Output 1.2 Maintenance cleaning programme for the APPENDIX Activity 1.2.1 NEMMA Create waste disposal 1. A comprehensive Establishment of waste established to quality standards for management plan for management standards for reduce garbage household disposal of mangrove/wetland proper disposal of that is affecting garbage. monitoring household garbage the storm surge barrier integrity of mangroves along Fitches Creek Bay Activity 1.3.1 Maintain a Perform spatial analysis to database of vulnerable evaluate the number of buildings and critical buildings and critical infrastructure where the infrastructure exposed to impacts of sea level rise are different SLR scenarios. Output 1.3 being observed. Installation of weather 1. Establishment of Enforced coastal gauge stations to create coastal zone setback Activity 1.3.2 Installing local records that measure management and recommendations weather gauge station to weather and climatic planning processes that along Shoal Bay monitor rainfall, wind conditions to guide coastal build climate resilience and Dutchman Bay speed, and sea level rise. setback recommendations. Revisions to legislation and Activity 1.3.3 Revisions to guiding planning EPMA and Physical documents provide the Planning Act, and National requirements for building Physical Development plan behind the coastal setback 184 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Output Activities Description Deliverables to include coastal setback line recommendations Activity 1.4.1 Mapping and remote sensing of mangrove/wetland extend noting critical ecological 1. Strengthened features. Identify the cause of Output 1.4 awareness of the value mangrove/wetland Restoration of and importance of Activity 1.4.2 Rehabilitate degradation and determine degraded mangroves in the degraded stream channels. solutions to ensure areas mangroves/wetlan Fitches Creek Bay area can provide ecosystem ds along Fitches 2. Rehabilitation plan for Activity 1.4.3 Establish services under changing Creek Bay mangroves affected by baselines and monitoring climate. illegal dumping and evaluation plan for biodiversity and carbon sequestration in the mangrove areas Outcome 2: Improved critical infrastructure and buildings with reduced susceptibility to impacts from hurricanes and storm surges. Perform spatial analysis to APPENDIX evaluate the number of buildings and critical infrastructure exposed to different storm surge scenarios. Discussions (interviews) Activity 2.1.1 Consult with with stakeholders involved Output 2.1 Storm RO operators, APUA and in power supply to proofing power Ministry of Works on understand what is grid (e.g., installing already-existing efforts to currently being done to flood barriers) for 7. Flood barrier systems storm proof power grids. protect power grids from Camp Blizzard installed and used to Activity 2.1.2 Perform hurricanes and tropical Reverse Osmosis protect key vulnerable feasibility study for storms. Plant, and the critical infrastructure regional grid stations. Preliminary exploration of Shell Beach Activity 2.1.3 Retrofit installing isolated electric Reverse Osmosis existing or constructing power systems that do not Plant new flood barriers have to connect to the national grid. Fix existing flood barrier systems if damaged or deteriorating. Install new flood barriers for vulnerable critical infrastructure that need 185 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Output Activities Description Deliverables protection but do not have it. Activity 2.2.1 Identification Understand already- of hurricane building existing efforts to retrofit retrofitting measures. buildings for hurricane Output 2.2 Activity 2.2.2 damage. Approval of the Revisions/strengthening of Improve building code to revised building existing legislation (EPMA, create buildings that are code which the Physical Planning Act resilient to hurricane wind accounts for the 4. Capacity to implement 2003), National Physical damage. growing threats hurricane-proof Development Plan (NPDP) Identify financial and posed by building code and newly proposed OECS material resources to hurricanes, building code (2020) implement different increased flood Activity 2.2.3 Identify and hurricane building code risks, and drought procure resources, and measures. Train existing resilience training needs to and hire new personnel to implement updated install and enforce building code measures Activity 2.3.1 Maintain a database of locations Perform spatial analysis to where power lines and evaluate the number of APPENDIX communication power lines and related infrastructure have been communication Output 2.3 Secure affected by infrastructure exposed to 1. A select number of power lines and hurricane/storm related different wind speed power lines and communication wind damage. scenarios. communication network to protect Activity 2.3.2 Consult with Consult with relevant systems that are wind against wind and Public Works and APUA on stakeholders to determine and flood proof flood damage options to protect this the benefits and challenges infrastructure when placing of placing power lines and underground is not an communication network option due to high flood underground risk Outcome 3 Reduced interruption of essential services through alternative energy and water supply Activity 3.1.1 An analysis of An analysis that assesses to Output 3.1 socio-economic conditions, what extent renewable Decentralized willingness-to-pay and energy and rainwater- power and water 3. Implementation plan affordability of based water collection can supplies to reduce and guidelines for decentralized water and be implemented across operational stabling decentralized power supplies. households. reliance on interventions Activity 3.1.2 Estimate costs of centralized power Documentation and implementing a system and water systems description of costs and that generates water 186 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Output Activities Description Deliverables benefits for solar-energy desalination and electricity efficient electricity and production using solar freshwater cogeneration energy. system (e.g., costs of Count the number of batteries, green roofs) persons/households that Activity 3.1.3 Survey of have cisterns and solar persons with cisterns and panels already installed at solar panels their residence Output 3.2 Activity 3.2.1 Mapping Create a map that Disaster risk locations of all essential delineates locations of all management plan services (emergency essential services and formulated shelters, fire department, measuring the distance to 7. Draft disaster plan to detailing police department, such services. reduce risk across mitigation, hospitals/health centres, In discussion with local different sectors from preparedness, power stations) disaster coordinators and extreme weather response and Activity 3.2.2 Consult with APUA, determine current events recovery to build local disaster coordinators disaster planning efforts resilience to and APUA to identify issues and issues for creating a essential services and challenges coordinated disaster plan. Outcome 4 Increased capacity of drainage infrastructure to better channel stormwater, improve solid waste management and reduce incidence of localized flooding APPENDIX Perform spatial analysis to Activity 4.1.1 Consult with evaluate inland flooding Outcome 4.1 residents and local risk across Piggott’s and Drainage clearing businesses in area to Fitches Creek. programs with identify common areas of Discussions with residents expanded and flooding and observations and local businesses to improved network of clogged drains. understand their 5. Maintenance plan for of drains, canals Activity 4.1.2 Consult with experiences with inland drainage clearing and waterways Solid Waste Management flooding and what they throughout Authority, Department of think the cause is. Airport/Fitches Environment, and Ministry Discussions with Creek area of Works to assess needs stakeholders involved in including Piggotts and financial costs to clear drainage maintenance to drainage points develop a clearing strategy. Output 4.2 Activity 4.2.1 Survey Site visits to vulnerable Retrofitting the existing roads for evidence roads to observe and existing road of deterioration and/or document cracks, washed 5. Engineering methods network damage out sections, erosion, and that protect existing particularly along Activity 4.2.2 Evaluate and assess asphalt durability roads when they are St. George’s Drive, test different erosion- and strength. flooded Burma Rd, and control techniques such as Install and experiment with Jabberwock Rd to embankments that resist different erosion-control protect against washing out, rubber liners techniques for roads that 187 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Output Activities Description Deliverables future flood and reduced slopes cannot be elevated. impacts Activity 4.3.1 Survey Output 4.3 number and types of Create a document that Implemented computers, internet provides an overview of computer routers, software, cable existing IT infrastructure. database system 1. Installation of IT systems and wireless Discuss with relevant IT that monitors and infrastructure forming networks and road maintenance evaluates drainage coordination between Activity 4.3.2 Consult with stakeholders about issues, including different Ministry of APUA and IT persons at installing and coordinating leaks to manage Works personnel for ministries (Public works) a centralized database their status in real- documentation and about major challenges system. time and used recording of drainage and issues Develop data collection across various issues Activity 4.3.3 Design on- procedures that can be governmental site data collection entered and recorded into entities to manage procedures for regular field a database system. infrastructure site visits Outcome 5 Increased capacity to handle extreme precipitation events through nature-based solutions Evaluate how different Activity 5.1.1 Survey APPENDIX green infrastructure 11. Incentives program homes/buildings/propertie Output 5.1 Expand measures can be designed designed and s to determine potential green and implemented. implemented under the for installing green roofs, infrastructure such Encourage the installation coordination of rain gardens, and as rain gardens, of green infrastructure relevant Government infiltration basins. tree lines, green through offering grants, agencies (Department Activity 5.1.2 Promote roofs, infiltration development incentives, of Environment, installation of green basins rebates and installation Development Control infrastructure through financing and utility fee Authority) incentives discounts. Outcome 6 Improved solid waste management practices within at-risk communities 7. Media campaign (media coverage of Output 6.1 PR Enhance public awareness activities) campaign around and influence behaviour 8. Education toolkit best practices for Activity 6.1.1 Develop change on disposing of (school field trips, household solid communication strategy waste so that it does not primary and secondary waste negatively affect drainage. school demonstrations) management 9. Electronic news bulletin to highlight local action Output 6.2 Activity 6.2.1 Consult with Identify options for 5. Recycling system that 188 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Output Activities Description Deliverables Provision of waste facilities and recycling and composting provides waste disposal recycling services Ministry of Health, for different materials and services provided for Wellness, and the waste. businesses and Environment (DoE, residences to National Solid Waste collect plastics, Authority) about metals, and other establishing acceptance forms of solid criteria for plastics, metals wastes materials and other forms of solid waste Outcome 7 Expanded water storage capacity Activity 7.1.1 Consult with farmers about local water Interview farmers to harvesting and major Output 7.1 gather details about challenges. Expanded rainwater harvesting Activity 7.1.2 Identify and rainwater practices. survey old, broken or 4. Increase farmer access harvesting and Determine rainwater damaged rainwater to rainwater harvesting water catchment/ harvesting systems that harvesting systems. systems storage systems need repair or Activity 7.1.3 Install storm- APPENDIX for farmers and replacement. proof rain, grey water and residents Assist farmers in protecting wastewater harvesting water harvesting systems. systems for small-scale farmers Assess capacity and Output 7.2 materials to pilot Develop measures Activity 7.2.1 Select small/community scale to encourage local technologies that can be water supply systems, businesses and used to pilot small-scale specifically evaluate hotels across the water supply system. building materials needed 6. Produce small- local area to invest Activity 7.2.2 Identify and and potential to treat scale/community-based in micro-scale select areas within water contaminants. water supply system desalination Piggott’s/Fitches Creek Survey land/and or technologies to where small-scale system facilities not in use where reduce the facilities can be built and small/community scale pressure at the operated water systems can be municipal level installed. Outcome 8 Reduced damage to coastal critical infrastructure Output 8.1 Activity 8.1.1 Conduct Determine the extent in 5. Management plan for Monitoring assessments of sargassum which sargassum reaches regularly clearing programs to influx near both reverse the properties of RO sargassum nearby 189 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Output Activities Description Deliverables remove sargassum osmosis plants plants. critical coastal from reverse Activity 8.1.2 Consult with Conduct interviews to infrastructure osmosis plant RO operators, APUA, and understand RO stakeholder properties Ministry Works on current experiences with sargassum clearing efforts sargassum management and evaluate opportunities and evaluate measures to and challenges in maintain clearance. implementing regular clearing measures Outcome 9 Increased uptake of renewable energy technologies by small businesses and households Determine area stakeholder inclination to install solar energy, Activity 9.1.1 Survey specifically determining homeowners/tourist and what factors are 9. Incentive scheme that local businesses on Output 9.1 influencing stakeholders’ promotes increased willingness to install solar Incentivized disinterest in adopting energy efficiency and energy measures. uptake of solar such measures. introduction of solar Activity 9.1.2 Evaluate energy Document and explore energy usage on affordability and financing how much solar smaller scale APPENDIX options for different solar technologies would cost energy technologies household versus tourist property versus local business. Outcome 10 Improved critical infrastructure and buildings with reduced susceptibility to impacts from higher mean sea levels Perform spatial analysis to evaluate the number of Output 10.1 roads exposed to flood Elevate the road inundation. network and Activity 10.1.1 Conduct Assess which roads will be install coastal feasibility study for road able to be elevated barriers to elevation (e.g., make sure without causing negative 11. Elevated roads in areas accommodate raising road does not feedback such as that will not cause some degree of create backwater flooding) backwater flooding which adverse effects such as inundation Activity 10.1.2 Consult is upstream flooding upstream flooding particularly along with Public Works and local caused by downstream St. George’s Drive, contractors to evaluate conditions such as a Burma Road, and different design options roadway with a bridge in a Jabberwock Road floodplain. and AUA campus Use feasibility study to discuss design options for road elevation. 190 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Output Activities Description Deliverables Surveillance of sensitive areas that prevent storm Activity 10.2.1 Monitoring surge such as wetland and evaluation of coastal ecosystems. land development, water Legislation and policies Output 10.2 quality, and wetlands that delineate protection Decrease Activity 10.2.2 Regulation of habitats within NEMMA corrosion of water of habitat preservation to preserve the integrity of 6. Adaptation strategies pipes from within NEMMA wetland ecosystems to for saltwater intrusion saltwater intrusion Activity 10.2.3 Engineering control flooding. along Burma Road structures for increasing Explore and implement drainage for better flushing hard or soft shoreline of salts from ground maintenance interventions surface as allowed within the NEMMA to lessen saltwater intrusion. Outcome 11 Decreased building damage and losses from rising sea levels Desk review will produce Activity 11.1.1 Perform scenario profiles most desk review of relevant found across review of APPENDIX documents to understand plans from across the 6. Assessment of the Output 11.1 Plans common themes in world. feasibility and for managed managed retreat programs Workshop will host implications of retreat/relocation in other parts of the world. speakers from similar managed retreat of vulnerable Activity 11.1.2 Perform circumstances to discuss strategies for buildings and stakeholder validation lessons learned in vulnerable coastal infrastructure workshop with to evaluate managing retreat. areas of the along the coastline lessons learned and It will also be a forum for airport/Fitches Creek managed retreat scenarios stakeholders to provide area with (residents, tourism, feedback on willingness to and local businesses) relocate and various scenarios. Activity 11.2.1 Consult Discuss and evaluate ways with DCA to determine future development can be Output 11.2 how future developments discouraged from the coast 1. Development of Promoting future can be encouraged further and be encouraged more policies and incentive developments inland. inland. mechanisms to build further inland to Activity 11.2.2 Produce Enforceable policy further inland (e.g., tax reduce exposure planning guidance for the guidelines that create credits, subsidies) to projected SLR coastal zones of the coastal zones where airport/fitches creek area setbacks must be followed. Outcome 12 Established enabling environment for the expansion of and investment in the Blue Economy Sector 191 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Output Activities Description Deliverables Qualitatively assess the ways various stakeholders utilize the NEMMA for Activity 12.1.1 Survey local livelihoods. fishermen, tourism and Discuss with various businesses in area to government entities whose identify daily activities, and job is to inform national major issues or challenges. development and Activity 12.1.2 Consult economic decisions, to with statutory bodies establish local goods and within Ministry of Tourism, services that can increase Outcome 12.1 Investment and Economic sustainable livelihoods for Expanded Development (Antigua and residents depending on the opportunities for Barbuda Tourism ecosystem within the 1. Identifying and testing tourism, local Authority, Antigua and NEMMA. new sustainable businesses and Barbuda Investment Evaluate the potential livelihood options fishermen within Authority) economic gains/value- NEMMA for blue Activity 12.1.3 Perform added to the economy economy activities economic valuation of from LAAP area goods and Airport/Fitches Creeks services that fall within areas that falls within NEMMA boundary. NEMMA boundary. Work with local Activity 12.1.4 Perform APPENDIX environmental groups and assessment of local Government to assess the habitats with state of habitat for LAAP Environmental Awareness area falling within NEMMA Group (EAG) and DoE to determine the sustainability of the Blue Economy. 192 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan References Adaptation Committee. 2023. Monitoring and evaluation of adaptation at the national and subnational levels: Technical paper by the Adaptation Committee. Bonn: UNFCCC. Available at https://unfccc.int/sites/default/files/resource/AC_TechnicalPaper_AdaptationMandE_2023.pdf. Adaptation Committee. 2021. Approaches to reviewing the overall progress made in achieving the global goal on adaptation. Bonn: UNFCCC. Available at https://unfccc.int/documents/309030. Adaptation Communication Antigua and Barbuda’s Submission to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. (202 C.E.). 16. https://unfccc.int/sites/default/files/ACR/2022-07/ATG%20- %20UNFCCC%20Adaptation%20Communication%20-%202022-06-29%20-%20Final.pdf Antigua & Barbuda Coral Reef Report Card. (2016). https://www.agrra.org/wp- content/uploads/2016/06/ATG-Report-Card_2016_WebLowRes.pdf Antigua and Barbuda Forest Information and Data. (2010). Rainforests.mongabay.com. REFERENCES https://rainforests.mongabay.com/deforestation/2000/Antigua_and_Barbuda.htm Antigua and Barbuda’s First National Report to the Convention on Biological Diversity Office of the Prime Minister Prepared under UNDP Project ANT/97/G31/1G Biodiversity Enabling Activity Project. (2001). https://www.cbd.int/doc/world/ag/ag-nr-01-en.pdf ANTIGUA AND BARBUDA THIRD NATIONAL COMMUNICATION. (2015). https://unfccc.int/sites/default/files/resource/atgnc3.pdf Caribbean Marine Climate Change Report Card 2017 Commonwealth Marine Economies Programme. (2017). https://unfccc.int/sites/default/files/resource/83_caribbean-marine- climate-change-report-card-2017.pdf Caribsave. (2012). The Caribsave Climate Change Risk Atlas (CCCRA). Caribbeanclimate.bz. http://dms.caribbeanclimate.bz/M-Files/openfile.aspx?objtype=0&docid=5031 Convention on Biological Diversity. (n.d.). Status and trends of biodiversity, including benefits from biodiversity and ecosystem services. Www.cbd.int. https://www.cbd.int/countries/profile/?country=ag Defra. (2010). Measuring Adaptation to Climate Change – A Proposed Approach. http://archive.defra.gov.uk/environment/climate/ documents/100219-measuring-adapt.pdf 193 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Glavovic, B. (n.d.). Contribution of Working Group II to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Oceans and Coastal Ecosystems and Their Services. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781009325844.005 Government of Antigua and Barbuda. (n.d.). Antigua and Barbuda National Strategic Plan (pp. 3– 4). Retrieved July 5, 2023, from https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/1436antigua.pdf Government of Antigua and Barbuda. (n.d.). Antigua and Barbuda National Strategic Plan (pp. 3– 4). Retrieved July 5, 2023, from https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/1436antigua.pdf Green Climate Fund. (2017, November 1). National Adaptation Planning support for Antigua and Barbuda through Ministry of Health and Environment. Green Climate Fund. https://www.greenclimate.fund/document/national-adaptation-planning-support-antigua-and- barbuda-through-ministry-health-and Health & Climate Change Country Profile 2020 Small Island Developing States Initiative Contents. (2020). ImageCat Inc. (2023). Antigua and Barbuda’s Adaptation Plan for the Wholesale and Retail REFERENCES Sector. IPCC. (2023). Annex I: Glossary [Reisinger, A., D. Cammarano, A. Fischlin, J.S. Fuglestvedt, G. Hansen, Y. Jung, C. Ludden, V. Masson-Delmotte, R. Matthews, J.B.K Mintenbeck, D.J. Orendain, A. Pirani, E. Poloczanskaa, and J. Romero (eds.)]. In: Climate Change 2023: Synthesis Report. Contribution of Working Groups I, II and III to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change [Core Writing Team, H. Lee and J. Romero (eds.)]. IPCC, Geneva, Switzerland, pp. 119-130, doi: 10.59327/IPCC/AR6-9789291691647.002. Lewis, A., Nicholas, N., Simmon, I., Hill, A., Nicholson, L., & Rose Needham, E. (2015). Antigua & Barbuda’s 2015-2020 National Action Plan: Combatting desertification, Land Degradation & Drought. https://info.undp.org/docs/pdc/Documents/ATG/NAP%202015-20%20ANU.pdf Magnan, A. (2014). Avoiding maladaptation to climate change: towards guiding principles”, S.A.P.I.EN. S [Online], 7.1 | 2014, Online since 17 September 2014, connection on 20 March 2024. URL: http://journals.openedition.org/sapiens/1680 Murphy, Dr. R. (2023). Sectoral Adaptation Plan Culture. The Royal Society. (2022). Why Is Biodiversity important? Royalsociety.org. https://royalsociety.org/topics- policy/projects/biodiversity/why-is-biodiversity- important/#:~:text=Biodiversity%20is%20essential%20for%20the 194 Ancgua and Barbuda Naconal Adaptacon Plan Price-Kelly, H., Hammill, A., and Dekens, J., Leiter,T., Olivier J., (2015). Developing national adaptation monitoring and evaluation systems: A guidebook. GIZ, https://www.adaptationcommunity.net/download/uploads/giz2015_Developing_national_adap tation_M&E_systems_-_A_guidebook.pdf Pringle P. 2011. AdaptME: Adaptation Monitoring and Evaluation. Oxford: UKCIP. Available at https://www.ukcip.org.uk/wp-content/PDFs/UKCIP-AdaptME.pdf Rai, N., Brooks, N., & Nash, E. (2015). Tracking Adaptation and Measuring Development: a manual for national governments. International Institute for Environment and Development. https://www.iied.org/sites/default/files/pdfs/migrate/10134IIED.pdf UKCIP, 2005. Principles of good adaptation. UKCIP Guidance Note, UKCIP, Oxford. http://www.ukcip.org.uk//essentials/adaptation/goodadaptation/ UNEP-IOC-ASPEI-IUCN Global Task Team. (n.d.). Global Climate Change and Coral Reefs: Implications for People and Reefs Report of the UN EP-IOC-ASPEI-UCN Global Task Team on the Implications of Climate Change on Coral Reefs. Retrieved July 13, 2023, from https://www.iucn.org/sites/default/files/import/downloads/climchng.pdf REFERENCES United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. Lease developed countries. Technical guidelines for the national adaptation plan process LDC Expert Group, December 2012. https://unfccc.int/files/adaptation/cancun_adaptation_framework/national_adaptation_plans/a pplication/pdf/naptechguidelines_eng_low_res.pdf Wood, H. L., Spicer, J. I., & Widdicombe, S. (2008). Ocean acidification may increase calcification rates, but at a cost. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 275(1644), 1767– 1773. https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2008.0343 195